WBAUnofficial
State pension age - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: State pension age (/showthread.php?tid=38115)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: State pension age - Protheroe - 07-22-2025

It's not moot to me or anyone else who has been saving for that entire period. If you remove £5bn a year + the amount reinvested it has a huge cumulative impact on how much we're saving. I'm sorry if that's not clear to you.

I think your diagnosis of the "actual problem" is incorrect. It's multifaceted. Private Sector Final Salary Pensions for instance closed their doors to new staff at the fastest rate on record with the advent of quantitative easing. In 2005 43% of Private Sector DB schemes were still open to new starters, by 2012 that was just 13%. Another chilling effect of Brown's (and Osbornes) response to the GFC - low gilt yields = much higher liabilities.

I agree with you that young people renting or saving for a home see a pension as a low priority. Why wouldn't they? Particularly as they're now being taxed at a much higher marginal rate than I ever was at their age. People starting pension savings in the last 5 years will also have seen inflation eat 25% of its spending power already - so you can forgive them for having little incentive to save.

This is a timebomb waiting to explode. You may have a point that squandering North Sea Oil revenue on tax cuts rather than renewal was short-sighted - but I didn't hear many people complaining at the time. But there's no doubt that governments since have compounded the problem; the Triple Lock simply has to go, yet review of it is absent from the Pensions Commission's terms of reference - riddle me that?

Reeves' IHT tax grab on DC pensions has led to me and many other people I know who have paid themselves in employer contributions for years ceasing to put anything at all into a pension in favour of alternatives (largely offshore). I will take my pension as soon as I can, and drain it as fast as I tax efficiently can to keep it out of the estate.

And we all know the fundamental reason why auto-enrolment was brought in and why Kendall is so keen to get younger people to save more; the eventual means testing of the State Pension. Auto enrolment will end up being the biggest misselling scandal of my lifetime - brought to you by HMG.


RE: State pension age - Ted Maul - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 09:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You all might care very much in thirty years time when you realise everything you've saved will be taxed and means tested to the limit. Those who've never saved will need to be looked after by the state (taxpayers like you). Others will benefit from an unfunded public sector pension (£2.5 Trillion and counting).

If you think intergenerational inequality is a problem now, just wait for Pensions Apartheid.

I think the whole point of what SW and I were saying is that you can means test and tax it as much as you like, as we've put private provision in place to ensure we'll be OK compared to many others. Isn't that the point of society? Ensure there is enough to go around and look after those who can't look after themselves.

My first post in this thread stated that I'm already resigned to never receiving a penny of state pension and I'm OK with that, providing the money I've paid in goes toward helping someone who really needs it.


RE: State pension age - Borin' Baggie - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 09:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote: It's not moot to me or anyone else who has been saving for that entire period. If you remove £5bn a year + the amount reinvested it has a huge cumulative impact on how much we're saving. I'm sorry if that's not clear to you.

I think your diagnosis of the "actual problem" is incorrect. It's multifaceted. Private Sector Final Salary Pensions for instance closed their doors to new staff at the fastest rate on record with the advent of quantitative easing. In 2005 43% of Private Sector DB schemes were still open to new starters, by 2012 that was just 13%. Another chilling effect of Brown's (and Osbornes) response to the GFC - low gilt yields = much higher liabilities.

I agree with you that young people renting or saving for a home see a pension as a low priority. Why wouldn't they? Particularly as they're now being taxed at a much higher marginal rate than I ever was at their age. People starting pension savings in the last 5 years will also have seen inflation eat 25% of its spending power already - so you can forgive them for having little incentive to save.

This is a timebomb waiting to explode. You may have a point that squandering North Sea Oil revenue on tax cuts rather than renewal was short-sighted - but I didn't hear many people complaining at the time. But there's no doubt that governments since have compounded the problem; the Triple Lock simply has to go, yet review of it is absent from the Pensions Commission's terms of reference - riddle me that? 

Reeves' IHT tax grab on DC pensions has led to me and many other people I know who have paid themselves in employer contributions for years ceasing to put anything at all into a pension in favour of alternatives (largely offshore). I will take my pension as soon as I can, and drain it as fast as I tax efficiently can to keep it out of the estate.

And we all know the fundamental reason why auto-enrolment was brought in and why Kendall is so keen to get younger people to save more; the eventual means testing of the State Pension. Auto enrolment will end up being the biggest misselling scandal of my lifetime - brought to you by HMG.

There are people who have been saving for that entire time period who are now retired and they are the current pensioners, that's literally why it's a moot point. You can't compare two groups affected by the same thing and act like it only affects one group because that makes no sense. The current pensioners - the group that are on track to be better off - are equally affected by that than my generation so trying to blame that is nonsensical.

And your third paragraph is my point, there aren't many defined benefit pensions anymore as they've been replaced by defined contribution pensions and you need to pay into those as much as you can as early as you can to realise the benefits of compounded returns. People aren't putting money into them because they can't afford to with the median income for people in their 20s and 30s being below £35k and needing to balance the costs associated with infrastructure deficiencies (housing, energy, water) which take precedence. That is the problem and if we'd not wasted the boom in the 1980s and actually planned for infrastructure renewal and development under Thatcher and realised it under Major and Blair there would be more disposable income to put towards pension contributions today for young people.

The thing that is holding back future retirees is their capacity to save for retirement in their 20s, 30s and early 40s. The primary driver of that isn't tax fudges but the effects of a higher cost of living for younger generations caused by massive infrastructure deficiencies in this country pushing up rent, house prices and utility bills. There is a reason pension contributions increase as income increases for young people but unfortunately not a lot of people are on £65k a year or more in their 30s.

And why would the government put the triple lock under review when they have fuck all political capital? As unaffordable as it is there would be a huge backbench rebellion and likely a cabinet one as it would all but guarantee loads of MPs lose their incomes in 4 years time, not helped by a charlatan leading in the polls promising the land of milk and honey being backed by a stupid voting system that amplifies the damage he can inflict on this country.


RE: State pension age - Protheroe - 07-22-2025

I confess I don't understand how you interpret anything I've posted in your first para whatsoever (or indeed some of the syntax). I'm not suggesting at all that pensioners and pension savers aren't both affected, they are - but those who started saving after the reforms are affected more.

As for DB & DC pensions the question is "Why?" - the answer is, largely, QE.

(07-22-2025, 10:15 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I think the whole point of what SW and I were saying is that you can means test and tax it as much as you like, as we've put private provision in place to ensure we'll be OK compared to many others. Isn't that the point of society? Ensure there is enough to go around and look after those who can't look after themselves.

My first post in this thread stated that I'm already resigned to never receiving a penny of state pension and I'm OK with that, providing the money I've paid in goes toward helping someone who really needs it.

It's a nice thought, but the state won't give you any credit for it. They'll tax you instead.

As an example, just look at the vicious tax treatment of individual landlordism, or Brown changing the rules around multipliers for commercial property purchases in SIPPS & SASS. It's abundantly clear the state will do whatever it can to extract as much as it can as often as it can.

If nearly half of all people of working age aren't saving for a pension at all, then don't be surprised when the government come knocking your door. 

I really don't think that pensions are an entirely wise investment for those that can afford to contribute these days.


RE: State pension age - HugeHons - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 06:05 AM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 05:51 PM)HugeHons Wrote: Talking to a mate at work who will receive his State Pension from October. He’s worked full-time since 16 ( 50 years). He’s been told he won’t get a full state pension because he was ‘contracted out’ for a few years. He can’t afford to retire for another 5 or so years as his Private Pensions are not worth much ( despite him contracting out), admittedly he doesn’t know much about pensions. My lazy brother, on the other hand, is 54, probably worked 6 years full time since he left school, hasn’t worked at all for the last 7 years and he will receive a full state pension. His partner and he claim for everything going with no intention of working.

Your brother is a massive part of the problem.

Exactly.


RE: State pension age - SW4Baggie - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 11:18 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I confess I don't understand how you interpret anything I've posted in your first para whatsoever (or indeed some of the syntax). I'm not suggesting at all that pensioners and pension savers aren't both affected, they are - but those who started saving after the reforms are affected more.

As for DB & DC pensions the question is "Why?" - the answer is, largely, QE.

(07-22-2025, 10:15 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I think the whole point of what SW and I were saying is that you can means test and tax it as much as you like, as we've put private provision in place to ensure we'll be OK compared to many others. Isn't that the point of society? Ensure there is enough to go around and look after those who can't look after themselves.

My first post in this thread stated that I'm already resigned to never receiving a penny of state pension and I'm OK with that, providing the money I've paid in goes toward helping someone who really needs it.

It's a nice thought, but the state won't give you any credit for it. They'll tax you instead.

As an example, just look at the vicious tax treatment of individual landlordism, or Brown changing the rules around multipliers for commercial property purchases in SIPPS & SASS. It's abundantly clear the state will do whatever it can to extract as much as it can as often as it can.

If nearly half of all people of working age aren't saving for a pension at all, then don't be surprised when the government come knocking your door. 

I really don't think that pensions are an entirely wise investment for those that can afford to contribute these days.

But this is where our view points differ Proth, and there's no right or wrong answer, it's just how you view things, and in many ways, generational. I do not mind paying tax, I think in the UK we ought to pay more, and I'd be happy to do so if it led to public services on a par with other European nations. Governments on both sides have wasted huge amounts of money and have made terrible fiscal decisions, but I'm sure many other countries will say the same.

Ultimately the UK is hugely dependent on tax revenue to function thanks to some shocking historic decisions by both Tories and Labour, and successive governments have danced around the issue - essentially we wither pay more, or receive less. I would rather the former, but appreciate there are arguments for the latter too.


RE: State pension age - Borin' Baggie - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 11:18 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I confess I don't understand how you interpret anything I've posted in your first para whatsoever (or indeed some of the syntax). I'm not suggesting at all that pensioners and pension savers aren't both affected, they are - but those who started saving after the reforms are affected more.

As for DB & DC pensions the question is "Why?" - the answer is, largely, QE.

There are people who would have only started saving after 1997 who are retired now, and there are people who would have had the bulk of their savings after the change. It was 27 years ago. The variance from that compared to future retirees of my generation - the ones projected to be worse off - are minimal if not nil.

And the process of replacing DB pensions with DC pensions began in the 1990s, even at large privately owned utilities like National Grid they were wound down well before the GFC.

The fundamental issue here affecting retirement is savings, particularly early career where you have the chance to compound returns to the greatest extent and that's being affected by the cost of living deterring contributions.


RE: State pension age - Protheroe - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 11:57 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:  essentially we either pay more, or receive less.

I fear the answer is that we'll pay more and receive less. That's what debt interest and inflation do to an economy I'm afraid.

(07-22-2025, 12:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:  It was 27 years ago. 

I fail to see how that doesn't matter, but what went on longer ago does matter. What an odd line of argument.


RE: State pension age - Borin' Baggie - 07-22-2025

When you are comparing current with future then pointing out that something that was so far in the past that affects both current and future is functionally irrelevant to the issue at hand is a perfectly valid line of argument.

I repeat, the fundamental issue is not tax. The fundamental issue is younger people in work do not feel they can put more money into their pensions earlier in their careers because of the cost of living.


RE: State pension age - SW4Baggie - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 12:32 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-22-2025, 11:57 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:  essentially we either pay more, or receive less.

I fear the answer is that we'll pay more and receive less. That's what debt interest and inflation do to an economy I'm afraid.

(07-22-2025, 12:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:  It was 27 years ago. 

I fail to see how that doesn't matter, but what went on longer ago does matter. What an odd line of argument.

I suspect you’re right,  but in the long list of problems caused by the last couple generation’s greed that us millennials and GenZ will have to fix, it’s a long way down!