RE: Tranny Banny - MrFizz - 07-04-2025
(07-04-2025, 03:39 PM)Jacko Wrote: (07-04-2025, 03:31 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-04-2025, 02:40 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Whatever happened to the parents saying "Put that back, i don't want you reading it".?
You may not agree with that parents stance, but its their right as a parent to decide what their child can or cannot read.
Banning books rarely ends well. What is this? Nazi Germany or Taliban Afghanistan?
I agree.
It's up to parents, I may disagree with parents views vehemently, which is common, I wasn't told what I could read, watch, listen to, or play much as a kid, and I haven't with my son, I turned into me, pretty damn close to perfection (I joke obviously). My son is top of the class in almost everything, considered the example for other kids at school behaviour wise, while kids with over protective parents are still needing help reading to a teenage level in secondary school, some even still believe in Santa FFS, couldn't believe that when my son told me.
Knowledge is never bad, ignorance is never better. What's important is being shown and taught right and wrong, being supported to make good choices and encouraged to actually think things through.
It is absolutely not the governments job to ban media from anyone, especially when we do actually have a robust, strong age rating system for a lot of media.
I'll get off my soapbox now
What's this about Santa?
He ay cummin.
RE: Tranny Banny - Squid - 07-04-2025
IME some of these supposedly "pro-trans" books contain gender stereotypes which hark back to the 1950s. Stating that if you are a girl who doesn't like "girly" things you are really a boy and vice versa is a really negative message to send to young children.
However, more important is actually keeping libraries open. For any in and around the Birmingham, please get involved in the campaign to save Birmingham's libraries https://www.birminghamloveslibraries.org/
RE: Tranny Banny - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-04-2025
(07-04-2025, 02:33 PM)Tokyo Baggie Wrote: (07-04-2025, 01:36 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Banning books has never been by the ones on the right side of history.
I'll never, ever be supportive of a book ban at any level.
I agree to both statements in essence, BUT... society is changing. Authoritarianism and all it entails is rising.
Say, for an extreme example, there was a book targetted at children that had an underlying theme promoting eugenics. I'm 100% sure I wouldn't want my kids reading it, and I would not put up an argument against anyone that wanted it banned.
As for pro-trans children's book, I'm ambivalent. I wonder how many of those books are actually selected from libraies and enjoyed by kids? It seems to me that its more about the authors trying to make kids aware of something they feel is important. In my mind it's like me trying to sway my kids into listening to <HOG - some of you know what I mean > techno because I like it, despite the fact they have no interest in it whatsoever. However, I feel that the books in question should be available to kids who have a genuine interest in them. It's a tough one, but banning seems wrong to me in this case.
My kids don’t get a choice about listening to HOG techno!
|