![]() |
|
Labour = Tory - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Labour = Tory (/showthread.php?tid=37593) |
RE: Labour = Tory - Derek Hardballs - 05-07-2025 Meanwhile… yet another pesky study debunking the PIP myths that are peddled by the government and those on here, who will defend absolutely anything this Tory government do… Article here “Meanwhile, 16 major charities - including the Trussell Trust, Scope, and Mind - have penned a letter to the government warning that benefit cuts would have a “catastrophic impact on disabled people up and down the country”. No doubt Centrist Dad’s will declare all these organisations as ‘screaming’ ‘scaremongering’, ‘whining’. RE: Labour = Tory - CarlosCorbewrong - 05-07-2025 Now the DWP admit that the cuts to disability benefits will affect 700,000 people who are already in poverty. Waiting for the lycra clad lads to get off their 24 mile Wednesday nighter to hear the defence. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2025/may/07/disability-benefit-cuts-to-hit-700000-families-already-in-poverty-dwp-forecasts-show RE: Labour = Tory - Derek Hardballs - 05-07-2025 (05-07-2025, 07:23 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Now the DWP admit that the cuts to disability benefits will affect 700,000 people who are already in poverty. They will be ‘entirely comfortable’ with this, as is befitting of the Tories they have become, or perhaps they always were. RE: Labour = Tory - tHEgLASSdOORS - 05-07-2025 (05-07-2025, 05:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Aside from the fact that most of this relates to the changes in UC and work related benefits you’re spot on Derk RE: Labour = Tory - Derek Hardballs - 05-07-2025 (05-07-2025, 07:38 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:(05-07-2025, 05:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: “The PM’s move to slash welfare spending by £5bn through cuts to personal independence payments (PIP) was based on claims the system is too lenient. In a policy paper explaining the cuts, the government cited a 34 per cent jump in the number of disabled working-age people in England and Wales claiming incapacity or disability benefits between 2020 and 2024. This was double the 17 per cent rise in the number of disabled working-age people overall over the same period, the government said.” Sir Keir used the figures to claim the current welfare system is “morally and economically indefensible”. But an analysis from think tank the New Economics Foundation (NEF), shared with The Independent, shows the rate of successful claims for PIP, the main disability benefit, had remained steady at 50 per cent since before the pandemic. Meanwhile, 46 per cent of disabled people claim PIP, compared with 40 per cent before the pandemic, which NEF said showed that the rise in claims is due to an increase in people applying for benefits they are already entitled to. “This suggests that the disability benefits bill has risen due to two factors: a rise in the number of disabled people eligible for state support, and a rise in deprivation, meaning that disabled people previously not claiming support are now looking for additional financial help from the government,” the think tank added. Under the changes, someone someone who needs assistance washing below their waist, uses an aid to use the toilet or deal with incontinence, needs assistance dressing their lower body or needs an aid to to speak or hear would no longer be eligible for PIP. NEF senior economist Max Mosley said: “Our analysis suggests that PIP is going to exactly the sort of people it is intended to support, but that higher rates of disability and financial hardship are driving more people to claim. “The government's plans to restrict access to PIP will lead to hundreds of thousands of disabled people missing out on support they very much need. This could well prove to be as politically toxic for the government as cutting the winter fuel payment.” Sir Keir has already faced a fierce backlash over the planned cuts, with left-wingers vowing to vote against the changes when they are put before parliament. Research has shown that nearly 100 Labour MPs have a majority smaller than the number of disabled people who face losing their benefits in their constituencies, adding to the intensity of the rebellion. Outspoken Labour MP Rachael Maskell has said there is “deep, deep concern” among colleagues in the Commons. Meanwhile, 16 major charities - including the Trussell Trust, Scope, and Mind - have penned a letter to the government warning that benefit cuts would have a “catastrophic impact on disabled people up and down the country”. How was the bike ride? RE: Labour = Tory - CarlosCorbewrong - 05-09-2025 Today's Sensible Dad news: "Unthinkable" cuts to NHS https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cgle2xkg3wpo RE: Labour = Tory - baggy1 - 05-09-2025 (05-09-2025, 10:28 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Today's Sensible Dad news: "Unthinkable" cuts to NHS Saw that CC and why do you think that is? After increasing the funding by £22Bn over two years the NHS is still targeted to overspend by another £7Bn. What do you think is the option here? Just give more money or try to work on where costs aren't needed or being duplicated. RE: Labour = Tory - CarlosCorbewrong - 05-09-2025 (05-09-2025, 10:35 AM)baggy1 Wrote:(05-09-2025, 10:28 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Today's Sensible Dad news: "Unthinkable" cuts to NHS There is little doubt in most peoples' minds that the level of growth to funding for health and social care is unsustainable internationally. The government, by shunting the affordability gap problem to quasi autonomous (and hugely variable) organisations (ie Trusts and ICBs) - with huge variation in funding due to an imperfect funding formula and model - is avoiding the difficult decisions they need to make. They do this whilst pushing responsibility to organisations who are not empowered to make those decisions, are not necessarily competent to do so fairly and further widen healthcare inequalities, particularly for those with the greatest need - impoverished communities and individuals. Those local Trusts will also be hung out to dry as soon as any kind of localised political backlash is felt by vote-conscious politicians. Meanwhile, we'll wait years for the government review into social care which will tell everyone what everyone (in the game) already knows. It's an avoidance of responsibility and not what should be expected of a government of grown-ups. RE: Labour = Tory - baggy1 - 05-09-2025 So that’s what they shouldn’t do - what should they do? RE: Labour = Tory - CarlosCorbewrong - 05-09-2025 (05-09-2025, 11:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So that’s what they shouldn’t do - what should they do? A personal opinion: Healthcare systems management doesn't lend itself to ill thought out whimsical decision making in silos. We could scream 'sack managers' or 'stop gender reassignment' or 'no surgery for smokers' but the consequences of those decisions are felt elsewhere and, taken in an uncoordinated approach. often result in unintended consequences. The examples of uncoordinated, reactionary cuts given in the BBC article have consequences. If you poorly manage paediatric diabetes you risk increased admissions and early kidney failure in adulthood. If you stop talking therapies then you probably increase unemployment and physical health problems. If you reduce the amount of doctors and nurses you restrict access to services full stop. There needs to be a programme of work, with academic rigour, which looks at the compounding problems faced, considers options and acknowledges that not everyone will be happy with the solutions offered. Then there needs to be the political will to see it through. Talk seriously - invoking cross party talks - about what it takes to sustain a health and social care system for the 21st century. At the very least, produce an impact assessment, of planned cuts so they know what they have as a baseline. Rules and principles for engagement would need to be established with constraints being understood upfront. The following are unavoidable factors: An ageing population A reluctance to pay more tax Increasing expectation from patients and public linked to better education and development of innovative treatment The increased cost of worklessness A falling birth rate creating workforce problems in an anti immigration world Competition at a departmental level for funding Shunting the problem to local managers is not going to result in difficult decisions being made well. The response to these factors are POLITICAL decisions, not healthcare decisions. I hold a personal view that a fundamental rethink of what the NHS provides is needed. I'm saying that the government needs to lead those discussions, as painful as they may be. Should Streeting be expected to have done that in 12 months? No. Should he have said it's needed - 100% yes. It's not a problem of Labour's doing, but a failure to respond properly to these very well understood factors, will be. |