RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Derek Hardballs - 04-18-2025
(04-18-2025, 05:57 PM)Jerry Wrote: (04-18-2025, 03:44 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: That's the most damaging impact of Mowbray's tenure here.
I'm not overly bothered by not making the play-offs. Even with CC as manager I couldn't see us winning them. But having someone come in and tear up all the organisation and everything that made us difficult to beat and a damn good side is soul destroying.
The management decided that we would move from a defensive very structured approach to a more open, football style. They did not choose CC but kept him in place until HE left. The new man (TM but could have been someone else) came in half way through and tried to change the style which was not working under CC. TM tried to bits of CC structure but it didn’t work with the other parts of TM method and the players were not quite suited to the new style. Add into that injuries, players seeing contracts out and it was always a stretch for it to work. Now we wait and hope for next season.
TM is an average Champ manager, he’s failed to get any team up since he had the biggest budget and the best squad in the Championship over a decade ago. His teams on the whole flatter to deceive for a few months then simply fade away.
CC’s football was pragmatic, each player knew their job and despite drawing a lot of games we were still a far better managed team than we have been for years. If CC was failing then I’d love to know what you think TM is currently achieving.
Mowbray will create a team that, will become easy to play against, obsessed with possession and treat it as some kind of moral victory. Whilst the opposition help themselves to the points.
We will waste at least another half a season languishing in midtable obscurity at best until the inevitable will happen and he will leave.
Even if it i give your argument any credence at all, i ask the question what is the point in a manager if its not to get the best results all the time? You can’t suddenly change the way we play and ignore the players we have strengths and weakness’s because that not how you want to play. I genuinely don’t know what you see in his managerial record to suggest he is the right manager for us and should be afforded more time.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Stillclem4england - 04-18-2025
Good post. There is no identity. 16 games in and I can honestly say I have no idea.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Birdman1811 - 04-18-2025
It is very obvious Sunderland was an outlier and exception to the rule for Mowbray, circumstances made him play differently and use different types of players to his usual.
He needs to go, he's not had any positive impact, all the players are out of form and looking like shadows of themselves as time goes on, his dropping of Fellows and seeming obsession to play someone instead of him is baffling, and that's just one of many decisions he's made that makes no sense at all.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - DemonicBaggie - 04-18-2025
The lack of communication between players was noticeable.
We looked deadbeat from the off - no energy, no will to win, no clear plan.
Truly one of the most abject displays I can recall from an Albion team.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Tom Joad - 04-18-2025
(04-18-2025, 06:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-18-2025, 05:57 PM)Jerry Wrote: (04-18-2025, 03:44 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: That's the most damaging impact of Mowbray's tenure here.
I'm not overly bothered by not making the play-offs. Even with CC as manager I couldn't see us winning them. But having someone come in and tear up all the organisation and everything that made us difficult to beat and a damn good side is soul destroying.
The management decided that we would move from a defensive very structured approach to a more open, football style. They did not choose CC but kept him in place until HE left. The new man (TM but could have been someone else) came in half way through and tried to change the style which was not working under CC. TM tried to bits of CC structure but it didn’t work with the other parts of TM method and the players were not quite suited to the new style. Add into that injuries, players seeing contracts out and it was always a stretch for it to work. Now we wait and hope for next season.
TM is an average Champ manager, he’s failed to get any team up since he had the biggest budget and the best squad in the Championship over a decade ago. His teams on the whole flatter to deceive for a few months then simply fade away.
CC’s football was pragmatic, each player knew their job and despite drawing a lot of games we were still a far better managed team than we have been for years. If CC was failing then I’d love to know what you think TM is currently achieving.
Mowbray will create a team that, will become easy to play against, obsessed with possession and treat it as some kind of moral victory. Whilst the opposition help themselves to the points.
We will waste at least another half a season languishing in midtable obscurity at best until the inevitable will happen and he will leave.
Even if it i give your argument any credence at all, i ask the question what is the point in a manager if its not to get the best results all the time? You can’t suddenly change the way we play and ignore the players we have strengths and weakness’s because that not how you want to play. I genuinely don’t know what you see in his managerial record to suggest he is the right manager for us and should be afforded more time. Well put Derek. The difference being CC watched EVERY Albion game from the period before he was appointed. Mowbray comes in and thinks Jed and Swift are still the best players in the division. I know he was ill but with all due respect to him, do some fucking catching up before you take on the Albion job.
I wasn't a TM fan 1st time round. I thought he should have taken us up 1st time, I thought he got lucky 2nd time, I thought he was arrogant in the Prem. I didn't like the way he demanded loyalty from our relegated players then fucked off to Celtic. Now I don't like the way he's the only person in the West Midlands to not know Grant isn't a no.9, that Diakite should be a mainstay of our midfield. I'm not falling for the "nice guy" thing, this is our club, if you can't be bothered Tone, just go.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Jack Halford - 04-18-2025
(04-18-2025, 05:57 PM)Jerry Wrote: (04-18-2025, 03:44 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: That's the most damaging impact of Mowbray's tenure here.
I'm not overly bothered by not making the play-offs. Even with CC as manager I couldn't see us winning them. But having someone come in and tear up all the organisation and everything that made us difficult to beat and a damn good side is soul destroying.
The management decided that we would move from a defensive very structured approach to a more open, football style. They did not choose CC but kept him in place until HE left. The new man (TM but could have been someone else) came in half way through and tried to change the style which was not working under CC. TM tried to bits of CC structure but it didn’t work with the other parts of TM method and the players were not quite suited to the new style. Add into that injuries, players seeing contracts out and it was always a stretch for it to work. Now we wait and hope for next season.
Jerry, the most sensible post I have read today.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Sliced - 04-18-2025
“Falling back in love with football” seems to mean being undisciplined and just letting them do what they want. As soon as Mowbray comes in Jed Wallace comes out and does an interview saying CC was too strict, well maybe that’s what’s needed because every time we get someone in who’s less authoritarian we turn to shit. It was the same with Pardew and Bruce.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Derek Hardballs - 04-18-2025
(04-18-2025, 08:24 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-18-2025, 05:57 PM)Jerry Wrote: (04-18-2025, 03:44 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: That's the most damaging impact of Mowbray's tenure here.
I'm not overly bothered by not making the play-offs. Even with CC as manager I couldn't see us winning them. But having someone come in and tear up all the organisation and everything that made us difficult to beat and a damn good side is soul destroying.
The management decided that we would move from a defensive very structured approach to a more open, football style. They did not choose CC but kept him in place until HE left. The new man (TM but could have been someone else) came in half way through and tried to change the style which was not working under CC. TM tried to bits of CC structure but it didn’t work with the other parts of TM method and the players were not quite suited to the new style. Add into that injuries, players seeing contracts out and it was always a stretch for it to work. Now we wait and hope for next season.
Jerry, the most sensible post I have read today.
Arf, Jerry is talking nonsense and you haven’t given a proper answer to what TM has achieved that makes him a manager that can and will get us promoted. Explain where this belief is coming from because at the moment it looks like blind belief or sycophancy.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Tiptonmon - 04-18-2025
(04-18-2025, 07:27 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (04-18-2025, 06:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-18-2025, 05:57 PM)Jerry Wrote: (04-18-2025, 03:44 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: That's the most damaging impact of Mowbray's tenure here.
I'm not overly bothered by not making the play-offs. Even with CC as manager I couldn't see us winning them. But having someone come in and tear up all the organisation and everything that made us difficult to beat and a damn good side is soul destroying.
The management decided that we would move from a defensive very structured approach to a more open, football style. They did not choose CC but kept him in place until HE left. The new man (TM but could have been someone else) came in half way through and tried to change the style which was not working under CC. TM tried to bits of CC structure but it didn’t work with the other parts of TM method and the players were not quite suited to the new style. Add into that injuries, players seeing contracts out and it was always a stretch for it to work. Now we wait and hope for next season.
TM is an average Champ manager, he’s failed to get any team up since he had the biggest budget and the best squad in the Championship over a decade ago. His teams on the whole flatter to deceive for a few months then simply fade away.
CC’s football was pragmatic, each player knew their job and despite drawing a lot of games we were still a far better managed team than we have been for years. If CC was failing then I’d love to know what you think TM is currently achieving.
Mowbray will create a team that, will become easy to play against, obsessed with possession and treat it as some kind of moral victory. Whilst the opposition help themselves to the points.
We will waste at least another half a season languishing in midtable obscurity at best until the inevitable will happen and he will leave.
Even if it i give your argument any credence at all, i ask the question what is the point in a manager if its not to get the best results all the time? You can’t suddenly change the way we play and ignore the players we have strengths and weakness’s because that not how you want to play. I genuinely don’t know what you see in his managerial record to suggest he is the right manager for us and should be afforded more time. Well put Derek. The difference being CC watched EVERY Albion game from the period before he was appointed. Mowbray comes in and thinks Jed and Swift are still the best players in the division. I know he was ill but with all due respect to him, do some fucking catching up before you take on the Albion job.
I wasn't a TM fan 1st time round. I thought he should have taken us up 1st time, I thought he got lucky 2nd time, I thought he was arrogant in the Prem. I didn't like the way he demanded loyalty from our relegated players then fucked off to Celtic. Now I don't like the way he's the only person in the West Midlands to not know Grant isn't a no.9, that Diakite should be a mainstay of our midfield. I'm not falling for the "nice guy" thing, this is our club, if you can't be bothered Tone, just go. Nailed it, mate. It's just so effing obvious that any supporter with an average knowledge of the game could have told him this, yet he's the professional, earning thousands of pounds per week, who can't seem to work it out.
RE: Losing our identity and becoming easy to play against and beat. - Stillclem4england - 04-18-2025
(04-18-2025, 08:31 PM)Sliced Wrote: “Falling back in love with football” seems to mean being undisciplined and just letting them do what they want. As soon as Mowbray comes in Jed Wallace comes out and does an interview saying CC was too strict, well maybe that’s what’s needed because every time we get someone in who’s less authoritarian we turn to shit. It was the same with Pardew and Bruce. Absolutely 100%.
|