WBAUnofficial
Just back (ratings) - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Just back (ratings) (/showthread.php?tid=36969)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Just back (ratings) - Sandking - 03-15-2025

(03-15-2025, 06:01 PM)Majas magic Wrote:
(03-15-2025, 05:44 PM)The Price is Right Wrote:
(03-15-2025, 05:35 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wildsmith did nothing wrong today and saved out bacon at the end. Some of you are pathetic.

He was at fault for the goal.

The double save needn’t have been so if he’d dealt with initial shot properly instead of parrying it out to a striker.
T
The one on one at the end was down to a poor striker not good goalkeeping.

He’s shit - deal with it.

Wow that’s some take. 

If I had to rate anyone today I would give the crowd a Two, we are in a race for the playoffs offs & it’s quiet & takes a sending off to wake anyone up.  Bet it’s far livelier at Coventry & Bristol.

Yep, piss poor support.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Vinebaggie - 03-15-2025

I’m back bit pissef Mowbray fuck all


RE: Just back (ratings) - Peachy - 03-15-2025

I've watched their equaliser back a dozen times. Wildsmith is hesitant and is rooted to his line. Was it his fault no. Could he have done better..yes.

And this is my issue with Wildsmith. I firmly believe the defence don't have confidence in him. He's not a commanding keeper who takes care of business. He flaps, drops bollocks and then makes the occasional decent stop. He looks every inch a bang average keeper to me.

Today was far from his fault but he played a part in that goal. You can see he starts to come and then stops. Just more indecision.

I'm not spacegoating him. I just really don't rate him and I think he makes our defence weaker by not being commanding.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Stillclem4england - 03-15-2025

(03-15-2025, 08:58 PM)Peachy Wrote: I've watched their equaliser back a dozen times. Wildsmith is hesitant and is rooted to his line. Was it his fault no. Could he have done better..yes.

And this is my issue with Wildsmith. I firmly believe the defence don't have confidence in him. He's not a commanding keeper who takes care of business. He flaps, drops bollocks and then makes the occasional decent stop. He looks every inch a bang average keeper to me.

Today was far from his fault but he played a part in that goal. You can see he starts to come and then stops. Just more indecision.

I'm not spacegoating him. I just really don't rate him and I think he makes our defence weaker by not being commanding.
Spot on this.

I would say the dithering and being rooted to his line is more of an issue than the mistakes.


RE: Just back (ratings) - wba13 - 03-15-2025

(03-15-2025, 05:34 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(03-15-2025, 05:26 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: All I'd say there Josh is that Johnston's twinkly feet but total absence of end product don't get him a 7.

I'll be interested to see what others say. I thought he had a good game! Provided width and creativity. A lot of chances and good periods of play came from our left hand side where MJ was involved.

Well I thought when I saw Fellows coming on of goes Johnston who for me was awful falling over and gesturing, I would have subbed him at halftime.
I might be being hard on Wildsmith but I thought he was culpable for there goal, ball in 6 yard box and then he palms it into the net.
Should have won and didn’t also what is Armstrong offering.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Lurker#3 - 03-15-2025

Wildsmith - 6 - 2 good stops, some decent distribution
Didn't cover himself in glory for the goal and has very little command of his defence or area.

Price - 8 - Thought he was superb throughout, considering he was banging out of position. Tackled, recovered the ball, drove forward, passed progressively, scored. But loses a mark for perhaps getting caught under the ball for their goal. But considering he should be tracking midfielders not challenging aerially on crosses I'll cut him some slack. Some player we have. MOTM.

Holgate - 6 - Competent for the most part, but did his bets to let them through 1v1, and at times got dragged too wide when we made the three.

Bartley - 6 - Played really well for 35 mins. Game caught up with him after that and didn't look fully fit.

Heggem - 6 - Plodded through the game. Defended well 1v1. Looked like a CB at LB now.

Molumby - 6 - Usual graft, usual lack of discipline, usual inconsistencies in possession. Not helped being asked to play right midfield though. Battled away.

Mowatt - 7 - As you would expect. Kept us ticking. Won plenty of challenges and seemed to make plenty of ball recoveries.

Swift - 7 - Thought he was running the game on our transition. Linked up really well with Price on a number of occasions. Legs let him down second half. MOTM contender till then.

MJ - 6 - Huffed and puffed. Showed his class, but nobody got close enough to him as KG was miles off it and Heggem is a CB. He can't beat 3 blokes overtime. Help him out FFS sake.

Armstrong - 5 - Last chance saloon as a starter for me at the moment. Anonymous.

kG - 5 - Grafted, but zero involvement. Really held us back when ever we did attack, bar one good shuffle and take in first half down the right.

Subs:
Dike - 6 - Keep getting the minutes in big guy. What a player he could be if he stays healthy.
Lankshear - 6 - But himself about and think there's potential there. Wouldn't be sad if we signed him permanently.
Grady - 6 - Got in the half turn a few times. But was isolated as we had dropped so deep and lost all structure and movement. Then the game had gone when he played CDM.
Fellows - 6 - 2 good crosses, a few awful passes, added some width but again let down by the lack of structure at the time.


ToMo - 10 - As not to upset anybody.


RE: Just back (ratings) - SussexBaggie - 03-15-2025

Points for the fans? 2
Poor and generally quiet & complacent again (exemptions to some in the Smethwick tbf)

What do you want, lions & gladiators & loads of blood before we do our bit for the team?


RE: Just back (ratings) - Sliced - 03-15-2025

(03-15-2025, 09:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: ToMo - 10 - As not to upset anybody.

Big Grin


RE: Just back (ratings) - man in the corner shop - 03-15-2025

(03-15-2025, 10:02 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-15-2025, 09:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: ToMo - 10 - As not to upset anybody.

Big Grin

How fucking rude Lurker. The respectful thing to do would to have at least given him an 11.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Spandaubaggie - 03-16-2025

(03-15-2025, 08:58 PM)Peachy Wrote: I've watched their equaliser back a dozen times. Wildsmith is hesitant and is rooted to his line. Was it his fault no. Could he have done better..yes.

And this is my issue with Wildsmith. I firmly believe the defence don't have confidence in him. He's not a commanding keeper who takes care of business. He flaps, drops bollocks and then makes the occasional decent stop. He looks every inch a bang average keeper to me.

Today was far from his fault but he played a part in that goal. You can see he starts to come and then stops. Just more indecision.

I'm not spacegoating him. I just really don't rate him and I think he makes our defence weaker by not being commanding.
And that’s a relatively fair assessment.

He was competent today but he’s a significant downgrade to Palmer. 

I think if you’re on the shorter side of a modern keeper you need to be exceptional like Raya or Pickford in distribution and commandeering the defence. 

Problem now for a 6ft keeper is several players from the opposition are at least your height for set pieces. 
The goal is the same size as 40 years ago but you’re not the imposing giant of a man circa 1990.

Wildsmith did very decently today but the feeling that we have a better player in his position will not go until we have a good spell with Griffiths.

That does not excuse icastigating him for a decent performance today.