WBAUnofficial
Well done Mark Carney - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Well done Mark Carney (/showthread.php?tid=36901)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-16-2025

What groupthink? He literally responded to the GFC in Canada exactly how you wanted us to respond. You are so blinkered here that you're attributing the decisions made under Mervyn King to him, it's pathetic. You are still at it, what the hell was he supposed to do about asset price inflation when there was already a £375bn increase in the money supply before he got off the plane?

It's quite clear that he's an easy scapegoat for you which is why you're continually ignoring the facts about who was in charge of the BoE when the decisions were made (Mervyn King) and that the BoE was boxed in by disastrous (Tory) fiscal policy that meant there was zero room for substantive rate rises or QT.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - man in the corner shop - 03-16-2025

Blinkered? Proth? About anything?
Nah!
About everything !


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-16-2025

(03-16-2025, 08:07 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What groupthink? He literally responded to the GFC in Canada exactly how you wanted us to respond. You are so blinkered here that you're attributing the decisions made under Mervyn King to him, it's pathetic. You are still at it, what the hell was he supposed to do about asset price inflation when there was already a £375bn increase in the money supply before he got off the plane?

It's quite clear that he's an easy scapegoat for you which is why you're continually ignoring the facts about who was in charge of the BoE when the decisions were made (Mervyn King) and that the BoE was boxed in by disastrous (Tory) fiscal policy that meant there was zero room for substantive rate rises or QT.

Like I said, I don't agree. The suppressed interest rates he oversaw for his entire tenure were a disaster for this country, as anyone without a home of their own will attest.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-16-2025

The interest rates were low because for almost his entire fucking tenure inflation was below target and the period that is wasn't was when the bank had to price in higher inflation targets to manage Brexit uncertainty which was then scuppered by oil prices dropping sharply which limited the amount rates could bloody rise by. Extremely conservative fiscal policy that actively suppressed inflation with low public investment - that you voted for - is why rates couldn't bloody rise. Do you think risking deflation is a good thing for a central bank or something?

And I don't give a shit if you agree with the facts or not, but the facts are that he literally resisted rates cuts after the GFC in Canada and was the first central bank chair to raise rates coupled with resisting QE. His time as BoC governor is literally what you wanted us to do, but because he called out Brexit you are physically unable to accept that fact while you blame him for the shit decisions made under Mervyn King when Carney was at the BoC.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-16-2025

There was absolutely no need to lower rates after the Brexit vote, just as there was no need to lower rates during Covid. By your logic we ought to be increasing rates now given inflation expectations. Why aren't we? Because the BoE isn't really independent.

What is worse? Mild deflation or rampant asset price inflation? I know what's better for me - but that doesn't make it the correct policy.

I agree that Carney should never have been in the position he was placed in by King, but it's not like he did anything about it but makes things even worse for the young and asset poor.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-16-2025

Deflation is worse than every form of inflation, it creates doom loops by withdrawal of investment, that would have been disastrous for the UK given our stagnant growth.

There was also a need to lower rates post-Brexit for that exact reason above - there was extreme uncertainty and that risked collapsing investment and there needed to be a stimulation package to prevent that. You're arguing from a position that there would be no negative consequences from the vote to leave when the reason there was limited fallout is because of the monetary response, 2016 and 2017 growth rates were hardly good so can you imagine how bad it would have been if they had collapsed due to investment dropping?

And Carney had his hands tied by stupid fiscal policy, if Osborne wasn't such a peanut and relaxed public investment restrictions into infrastructure then inflation would have risen and that would have given room for rate rises but that did not happen. Over his entire tenure at the BoE inflation averaged at 1.4% per year which is comfortably below the target of 2% - and that factors in the time period covering the post-Brexit vote spike and temporarily higher target inflation rate. The very fact that Carney was agitating publicly about wanting to raise rates should growth be sufficient to enable rate rises and the very fact he did raise rates before anyone else when at the BoC which was extremely successful spells out that he is not dovish on raising interest rates.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - man in the corner shop - 03-17-2025

"You're arguing from a position that there would be no negative consequences from the vote to leave when the reason there was limited fallout is because of the monetary response, 2016 and 2017 growth rates were hardly good so can you imagine how bad it would have been if they had collapsed due to investment dropping?"

Wrong sort of Brexit. We had all the cards.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-18-2025

(03-16-2025, 10:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: There was also a need to lower rates post-Brexit for that exact reason above - there was extreme uncertainty and that risked collapsing investment and there needed to be a stimulation package to prevent that. 

I don't agree with that either. And if a 0.25% rate cut and a little more QE dealt with it then it can't have been that extreme.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-18-2025

(03-18-2025, 12:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-16-2025, 10:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: There was also a need to lower rates post-Brexit for that exact reason above - there was extreme uncertainty and that risked collapsing investment and there needed to be a stimulation package to prevent that. 

I don't agree with that either. And if a 0.25% rate cut and a little more QE dealt with it then it can't have been that extreme.

Chart 4.8

And that flat line is with a modest bump of QE and an interest rate cut. The evidence does not support your opinion I'm afraid, businesses hate uncertainty and they reduce investment in times of uncertainty, Brexit caused a material amount of uncertainty.


RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-18-2025

Don't agree. And the modest policy prescription doesn't support your contention.