WBAUnofficial
Stoke City - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Stoke City (/showthread.php?tid=36774)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Stoke City - Birdman1811 - 02-26-2025

It is crazy how Stoke haven't seemed to even do anything right at all, even by accident by now, when we were shit we had the likes of Bob Taylor, Andy Hunt, Lee Hughes, Richard Sneekes that at least gave hope we could get it right, Stoke seem to do everything wrong and it somehow goes even worse after.


RE: Stoke City - Bob Fossil - 02-26-2025

I was talking to family this weekend and they reel off 4 or 5 players that they rate, they don't think they are that bad, they just can't get them playing together. They are all as bemused as DK as to what the root of the problem is.


RE: Stoke City - SW4Baggie - 02-26-2025

(02-26-2025, 11:41 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 11:20 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 10:21 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 09:51 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 09:42 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Pick a reason, any reason. Literally everything we try ends up in disaster. There'll be logical reasons for it all, but for now I'm going with the 'cursed' option.

I didn't go last night. A painfully gammy foot meant I really didn't fancy the mile walk to the ground from where we park (or the usually even more dispiriting walk back). I dare say if we were on a 10-game winning streak, my enthusiastic spirit might have overcome any weakness of the flesh, but we're not, so it didn't.

The general concencus on the Oatcake is that this time we really are going down. Only the utter shitness of teams below us could possibly save us, but the last two performances have shown a worrying decline in performance.

When we played you at our place earlier in the season, it was noticable how we were physically bullied. This has kept happening, and is a big part of this season's problems. My view is that we're a team full of players who could be really good in a really good side. In short, we have no leaders. No glue. 

In answer to your question, Peachy, yes Coates is still bankrolling us. Yes he does seem willing to spend what it takes. But thanks to us buying a new squad, new managers and new backroom staff every year, we're still hampered by FFP from spending proper money on key players.

Seriously, I could write pages, and it still wouldn't touch the sides of all the problems we have. But this post will probably be a threadender anyway, so I'll leave it at that for now. 
Should they stick by Robins? Seems you need some continuity at some point. Is he the one that gets time?
A lot of us were not against him rocking up here when CC left.
Problem is, Bob, whichever way the question gets answered, it turns out to be the wrong answer. 

Obviously it's way too soon to be pulling the trigger on Robins, but our recent performances suggest his methods aren't having any positive impact. 

We've backed ourselves into such a shit situation that for everyone's sanity, I think we have to stand by him and give him the best part of next season at least, even if we end up relegated at the end of this one.

Has Viveash come with him? Think they fell out at Cov, and that was always the reservation I had with us appointing him post CC. Viveash was considered to be the man who made what Robins wanted to do work day to day.

Sorry to drag up old memories DK, but what went wrong with Pelach?

Also, of all the managers you’ve had since you came down, who do you think was the most successful?

The last question is piss-easy. Michael O'Neil was head and shoulders above anyone else. Had no money to spend. Took over when we were somehow in a worse position than we are now, and had us looking like an actual football team for a while.

The best guess with Pelach, apart from him being totally out of his depth and inexperienced, is that he tried to over-complicate matters. I'd listen to his after-match summaries and couldn't work out what the hell he was on about for the most part. 

Shawcross came in for two games and we looked a completely different team, free of the shackles. Strangely, the deterioration in our performances under Robins after just a few matches is very much following the same route as under Pelach. 

With regards to your first point, this won't be the first time we've appointed someone, then rapidly been made to ponder whether we've appointed a low-grade version of Clough without Taylor.

Interesting DK - Pelach was always Corberan’s #1 target to join his coaching team so would make sense that he took that level of detail in approach. Think he started out as an analyst with Bielsa so…

It would be a very Stoke thing to appoint Robins without Viveash or without the due diligence, sack him after 9 months, only to see them reunite and have success elsewhere.

I genuinely thought with another year under their belt, Jun-ho and Burger would really push on this year but they both seem to have caught the Stoke bug and dropped off into obscurity. Even Tryese Campbell looks decent for Sheff Utd!


RE: Stoke City - Dreamkiller - 02-26-2025

(02-26-2025, 12:24 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It is crazy how Stoke haven't seemed to even do anything right at all, even by accident by now, when we were shit we had the likes of Bob Taylor, Andy Hunt, Lee Hughes, Richard Sneekes that at least gave hope we could get it right, Stoke seem to do everything wrong and it somehow goes even worse after.

This is the thing. Even the most inept owners, and John Coates is definitely that, will, at some point strike it lucky. 

I've said before on here, since relegation, the managers we've appointed haven't been world-beaters, but nor have they been as apparently clueless anywhere else. They've all, with the possible exception of Pelach, had a selling point that you could see what had attracted the club to them.

Anyone who's been to a meet the manager event, which Coates, for reasons best known to himself, always shoehorns himself into, can't fail to be horrified or at least bemused by his awkward/ nervy/ bonkers mannerisms. But even so, it's hard to believe that this is so overriding that it permeates every part of the club.

Yet, here we are.


RE: Stoke City - MGalea - 02-26-2025

Have they tried pissing on the corner flags yet?


RE: Stoke City - ColliersWoodBaggie - 02-27-2025

They’ve circled the plug hole for many a season.


RE: Stoke City - tHEgLASSdOORS - 02-27-2025

When you look at some of the clubs beneath and around them starting to pick up - eg Plymouth, Hull & Derby likely to do so with Eustace in charge - they could be in some real bother


RE: Stoke City - aj21 - 02-27-2025

It would be better for Stoke to get relegated - Coates could just spend money he can clearly afford and not be tied by FFP. Birmingham will clearly have an excellent chance of back to back promotions.


RE: Stoke City - CarlosCorbewrong - 02-27-2025

Given that Mrs Coates paid herself a salary of £221m for running B365 I don't think buying some 3rd division cloggers is going to bankrupt him anytime soon.

Edit: Misread your post.


RE: Stoke City - Dreamkiller - 02-27-2025

(02-27-2025, 10:55 AM)aj21 Wrote: It would be better for Stoke to get relegated - Coates could just spend money he can clearly afford and not be tied by FFP. Birmingham will clearly have an excellent chance of back to back promotions.

There are dark rumblings that they're going to be changing the rules on FFP in the 3rd tier to make them more in line with the Championship. It would be very Stoke City for us to be the first to fall foul of that.

Then again, we spent money like it was going out of fashion when we were relegated, and we still only just managed to avoid a further drop.

Cursed, I tell thee.