WBAUnofficial
Well Done Labour - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Well Done Labour (/showthread.php?tid=36772)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: Well Done Labour - Derek Hardballs - 03-09-2025

(02-25-2025, 07:14 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: For maybe the third time today I find myself agreeing with Proth.

It’s a very tough but necessary pragmatic decision. And that’s the type of leadership we have badly lacked.

I don’t like it but it’s a necessity.

Im off for a lie down

I think like a lot of Labour centrists your centre may have moved closer to Proth Politics than you realise. I considered myself a centrist but the actions of Labour since they have taken power are simply Tory policies that if announced by Sunak, Johnson etc would be criticised by most on here.


RE: Well Done Labour - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-09-2025

I’m realistic about a number of things Derek. The size of the task rebuilding education, health, police, courts, youth services, welfare, housing to name a few. All, to one extent or another, left in a far worse state than they were inherited. It would be hard enough in a positive economic and global political context, and we have neither.

I’m also realistic that you have to actually be in power to begin to effect change. Labour have never won an election from the left of centre in my lifetime. However, when they have been in power, they have effected society far more positively than the alternative periods.

I’m pragmatic because until circumstances lend themselves to being otherwise, we need a government that is pragmatic too. The circus of instability in leadership could not continue. Starmer is more perfunctory to me than anything much more, but that’s exactly what we needed for now. And if anything, I’m even more happy I leant Labour my vote this time than I was to do so at the time.

As for Proth, there’s are lots of things in the UK, at least, that I at least have a shared sense of what he sees as desired outcomes. We just usually differ on the approach and the lense through which it’s viewed. Like you, I’ve been arguing with him on here for donkeys years, usually disagreeing, but happy to say otherwise when I don’t.


RE: Well Done Labour - Derek Hardballs - 03-09-2025

(03-09-2025, 09:28 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m realistic about a number of things Derek. The size of the task rebuilding education, health, police, courts, youth services, welfare, housing to name a few. All, to one extent or another, left in a far worse state than they were inherited. It would be hard enough in a positive economic and global political context, and we have neither.

I’m also realistic that you have to actually be in power to begin to effect change. Labour have never won an election from the left of centre in my lifetime. However, when they have been in power, they have effected society far more positively than the alternative periods.

I’m pragmatic because until circumstances lend themselves to being otherwise, we need a government that is pragmatic too. The circus of instability in leadership could not continue. Starmer is more perfunctory to me than anything much more, but that’s exactly what we needed for now. And if anything, I’m even more happy I leant Labour my vote this time than I was to do so at the time.

As for Proth, there’s are lots of things in the UK, at least, that I at least have a shared sense of what he sees as desired outcomes. We just usually differ on the approach and the lense through which it’s viewed. Like you, I’ve been arguing with him on here for donkeys years, usually disagreeing, but happy to say otherwise when I don’t.

It’s a funny coincidence that all these ‘difficult and pragmatic’ decisions seem to be falling on those with the least agency to fight back… I mean they could for example go after tax evasion, or like other countries take a risk on a wealth tax on the super rich to recoup billions in (lost) tax or they could pick on John the 50 year old disabled bloke from Bilston with severe learning difficulties and multiple physical problems by ‘freezing his PIP’. 

If that’s the ‘positive change you’re arguing this current government is making I’d argue you’re talking bollocks.


RE: Well Done Labour - baggy1 - 03-09-2025

There appears to be the misunderstanding that Labour could come in and had room for manoeuvre to make big changes and solve all the problems. Dekka - you appear to be very critical without stating what you are criticising, given the finances that have been left, i.e. fuck all, this government is not able to make big decisions and is having to make the financial headroom first. As Proth asked, what are you actually upset with and what did you expect them to do?

I don’t think anyone is getting carried away with where we are, but I am comfortable that Labour have brought a stability to the table that has been missing for a very long time. At last we are talking about the decisions and not the decision makers. One thing that stability will bring is investment, when big corporations see what is going on in the US they will get nervous and move their funds, they will need somewhere safe to move them and the UK will be on that list.

The decision on funding our own security is paramount at this point, it is unfortunate that we need to use the international aid budget to do that but where else are we going to get the funds from?

Some decisions I don’t agree with but can see why they have been made and by the time we get round to the next big budget statement at the end of the year I’m hoping there will start to be better news.


RE: Well Done Labour - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-09-2025

(03-09-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-25-2025, 07:14 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: For maybe the third time today I find myself agreeing with Proth.

It’s a very tough but necessary pragmatic decision. And that’s the type of leadership we have badly lacked.

I don’t like it but it’s a necessity.

Im off for a lie down

I think like a lot of Labour centrists your centre may have moved closer to Proth Politics than you realise. I considered myself a centrist but the actions of Labour since they have taken power are simply Tory policies that if announced by Sunak, Johnson etc would be criticised by most on here. It’s a funny coincidence that all these ‘difficult and pragmatic’ decisions seem to be falling on those with the least agency to fight back… I mean they could for example go after tax evasion, or like other countries take a risk on a wealth tax on the super rich to recoup billions in (lost) tax or they could pick on John the 50 year old disabled bloke from Bilston with severe learning difficulties and multiple physical problems by ‘freezing his PIP’. 

It’s kind of like Labour are bullies…

Regards PIP, the problem isn’t the claimants, the whole thing needs totally redesigning. It’s a points based system that ends up treating physical and mental health in more or less the same assessment process which is absolute madness. It’s also very open to manipulation and if anything is harder for the genuine claimants to attain than those that just watch a tik tok video on how the scoring system works. I know Proth said the welfare issue began with Blair and Brown but PIP was designed and implemented by the Tories and whatever problems there were before had a nuke lobbed underneath them. It wasn’t a continuation of the issues, it was the creation of a turbo charged white elephant that no one knows what to do with

(03-09-2025, 09:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 09:28 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m realistic about a number of things Derek. The size of the task rebuilding education, health, police, courts, youth services, welfare, housing to name a few. All, to one extent or another, left in a far worse state than they were inherited. It would be hard enough in a positive economic and global political context, and we have neither.

I’m also realistic that you have to actually be in power to begin to effect change. Labour have never won an election from the left of centre in my lifetime. However, when they have been in power, they have effected society far more positively than the alternative periods.

I’m pragmatic because until circumstances lend themselves to being otherwise, we need a government that is pragmatic too. The circus of instability in leadership could not continue. Starmer is more perfunctory to me than anything much more, but that’s exactly what we needed for now. And if anything, I’m even more happy I leant Labour my vote this time than I was to do so at the time.

As for Proth, there’s are lots of things in the UK, at least, that I at least have a shared sense of what he sees as desired outcomes. We just usually differ on the approach and the lense through which it’s viewed. Like you, I’ve been arguing with him on here for donkeys years, usually disagreeing, but happy to say otherwise when I don’t.

It’s a funny coincidence that all these ‘difficult and pragmatic’ decisions seem to be falling on those with the least agency to fight back… I mean they could for example go after tax evasion, or like other countries take a risk on a wealth tax on the super rich to recoup billions in (lost) tax or they could pick on John the 50 year old disabled bloke from Bilston with severe learning difficulties and multiple physical problems by ‘freezing his PIP’. 

If that’s the ‘positive change you’re arguing this current government is making I’d argue you’re talking bollocks.

Specific positives

Regulations for working people including redesign of sick pay

More teachers

Clearing court backlog

Clearing NHS backlog

Intent on housing

Reverting to community led policing

Focus on bringing back the successes we were having around 2010 reducing knife crime

I expect none of these to be judged as a success or failure yet becomes to do so would be ridiculous. At the moment, the intent is something the left leaning part of me is happy with.

Also no need to get aggressive Derk, it’s a good debate so let’s keep it that way

Oh and very clear intent and progress on beginning to deal with domestic abuse and issues such as spiking


RE: Well Done Labour - Derek Hardballs - 03-09-2025

(03-09-2025, 09:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-25-2025, 07:14 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: For maybe the third time today I find myself agreeing with Proth.

It’s a very tough but necessary pragmatic decision. And that’s the type of leadership we have badly lacked.

I don’t like it but it’s a necessity.

Im off for a lie down

I think like a lot of Labour centrists your centre may have moved closer to Proth Politics than you realise. I considered myself a centrist but the actions of Labour since they have taken power are simply Tory policies that if announced by Sunak, Johnson etc would be criticised by most on here. It’s a funny coincidence that all these ‘difficult and pragmatic’ decisions seem to be falling on those with the least agency to fight back… I mean they could for example go after tax evasion, or like other countries take a risk on a wealth tax on the super rich to recoup billions in (lost) tax or they could pick on John the 50 year old disabled bloke from Bilston with severe learning difficulties and multiple physical problems by ‘freezing his PIP’. 

It’s kind of like Labour are bullies…

Regards PIP, the problem isn’t the claimants, the whole thing needs totally redesigning. It’s a points based system that ends up treating physical and mental health in more or less the same assessment process which is absolute madness. It’s also very open to manipulation and if anything is harder for the genuine claimants to attain than those that just watch a tik tok video on how the scoring system works. I know Proth said the welfare issue began with Blair and Brown but PIP was designed and implemented by the Tories and whatever problems there were before had a nuke lobbed underneath them. It wasn’t a continuation of the issues, it was the creation of a turbo charged white elephant that no one knows what to do with

(03-09-2025, 09:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 09:28 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m realistic about a number of things Derek. The size of the task rebuilding education, health, police, courts, youth services, welfare, housing to name a few. All, to one extent or another, left in a far worse state than they were inherited. It would be hard enough in a positive economic and global political context, and we have neither.

I’m also realistic that you have to actually be in power to begin to effect change. Labour have never won an election from the left of centre in my lifetime. However, when they have been in power, they have effected society far more positively than the alternative periods.

I’m pragmatic because until circumstances lend themselves to being otherwise, we need a government that is pragmatic too. The circus of instability in leadership could not continue. Starmer is more perfunctory to me than anything much more, but that’s exactly what we needed for now. And if anything, I’m even more happy I leant Labour my vote this time than I was to do so at the time.

As for Proth, there’s are lots of things in the UK, at least, that I at least have a shared sense of what he sees as desired outcomes. We just usually differ on the approach and the lense through which it’s viewed. Like you, I’ve been arguing with him on here for donkeys years, usually disagreeing, but happy to say otherwise when I don’t.

It’s a funny coincidence that all these ‘difficult and pragmatic’ decisions seem to be falling on those with the least agency to fight back… I mean they could for example go after tax evasion, or like other countries take a risk on a wealth tax on the super rich to recoup billions in (lost) tax or they could pick on John the 50 year old disabled bloke from Bilston with severe learning difficulties and multiple physical problems by ‘freezing his PIP’. 

If that’s the ‘positive change you’re arguing this current government is making I’d argue you’re talking bollocks.

Specific positives

Regulations for working people including redesign of sick pay

More teachers

Clearing court backlog

Clearing NHS backlog

Intent on housing

Reverting to community led policing

Focus on bringing back the successes we were having around 2010 reducing knife crime

I expect none of these to be judged as a success or failure yet becomes to do so would be ridiculous. At the moment, the intent is something the left leaning part of me is happy with.

Also no need to get aggressive Derk, it’s a good debate so let’s keep it that way

Oh and very clear intent and progress on beginning to deal with domestic abuse and issues such as spiking

Sorry TGD, my problem with Labour is they are taking easy options when it comes to cutting budgets by picking on and using the same rhetoric as the Tories. If the leaked planned cuts to the welfare budget for the disabled are true, then it penalises not only those who are genuinely fiddling the system but also those who no matter what ‘incentives’ are offered are incapable of work. Now of course the leaked planned cuts may be to soften up the electorate and then suddenly declare they aren’t going to do that but the fact it’s even mooted that to save money you go after the most vulnerable people in society and those that care for them as a political choice, rather than say go after those avoiding paying tax is wrong on every level. The disabled community and the organisations that support them feel like they are being victimised and bullied by a Labour government who are not making ‘difficult or pragmatic’ choices, they are making lazy and blunderbust choices because those they effect cannot fight back.


RE: Well Done Labour - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-09-2025

Let’s wait and see what it actually brings. Both UC and PIP need reform. That is very clear. If the way they go about that matches it your concerns I’ll be the first to say it. Sunak was advised to means test pip but feared the response it would evoke. I’d say it is quite a reasonable step personally, even if the test were set at a relatively high bar before before implementation


RE: Well Done Labour - Derek Hardballs - 03-09-2025

(03-09-2025, 10:30 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Let’s wait and see what it actually brings. Both UC and PIP need reform. That is very clear. If the way they go about that matches it your concerns I’ll be the first to say it. Sunak was advised to means test pip but feared the response it would evoke. I’d say it is quite a reasonable step personally, even if the test were set at a relatively high bar before before implementation

They aren’t planning to means test it, it’s apparently if ITV leaks are to be believed blanket freezes. That would be a disgrace and I’d call out anybody or party who supports it.


RE: Well Done Labour - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-09-2025

It was always my guess that freezing uprating was the likeliest blunt tool.

I’d means test freeze personally and make sure the less well off are still uprated.

Even with focus and competence it’ll take at least 3 years for them to drag the whole backlog to a level field

I don’t think when the NI contributions have been foisted specifically on to big business you can say it is only certain groups taking the hit. It clearly isnt


RE: Well Done Labour - Protheroe - 03-09-2025

(03-09-2025, 09:35 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s a funny coincidence that all these ‘difficult and pragmatic’ decisions seem to be falling on those with the least agency to fight back… I mean they could for example go after tax evasion, or like other countries take a risk on a wealth tax on the super rich to recoup billions in (lost) tax or they could pick on John the 50 year old disabled bloke from Bilston with severe learning difficulties and multiple physical problems by ‘freezing his PIP’. 

If that’s the ‘positive change you’re arguing this current government is making I’d argue you’re talking bollocks.

But that's not a Labour government decision. 

That's the indefensible decision of some civil servant. It's why the civil service needs root and branch reform, and why both the tax and benefits systems need simplification.

(03-09-2025, 10:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry TGD, my problem with Labour is they are taking easy options when it comes to cutting budgets by picking on and using the same rhetoric as the Tories. If the leaked planned cuts to the welfare budget for the disabled are true, then it penalises not only those who are genuinely fiddling the system but also those who no matter what ‘incentives’ are offered are incapable of work. Now of course the leaked planned cuts may be to soften up the electorate and then suddenly declare they aren’t going to do that but the fact it’s even mooted that to save money you go after the most vulnerable people in society and those that care for them as a political choice, rather than say go after those avoiding paying tax is wrong on every level. The disabled community and the organisations that support them feel like they are being victimised and bullied by a Labour government who are not making ‘difficult or pragmatic’ choices, they are making lazy and blunderbust choices because those they effect cannot fight back.

I agree with you on that, though the means testing of the WFA wasn't easy - though completely right in economic and moral terms.

I you believe the Tory propaganda on housing allocations being taken out of local hands then that's also a difficult decision - though completely right in economic and moral terms.

I'll believe Labour is serious about welfare reform when they ditch the triple lock and apply NI to pension income over the State Pension.