WBAUnofficial
Ben Doak - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ben Doak (/showthread.php?tid=36143)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Ben Doak - Gzbaggy - 01-05-2025

Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.


RE: Ben Doak - Duffers - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 11:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.

What’s wrong with Wildsmith? Was brought in as a reserve keeper and a reserve keeper he has been.


RE: Ben Doak - Shabby Russian - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 11:11 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: What I would say about Liverpool is that they are fantastically coached and brilliantly run from a football side. Their system is so meticulously planned that any player that comes into it can perform well above their individual ability. Look at how many kids came into Klopp’s side and performed well, I’m sure one had previously been on loan in the Conference with Kiddy Harriers before suddenly finding himself at CB for Liverpool. This then allows them to sell squad or bit part players for inflated sums.

Brighton dedicate a huge amount of resource to individual coaching. There’s a lot of attention to one on one time and preparing a player to come into their first team. Yes their scouting is generally excellent but they also put the hard work into making sure players are fully ready to come into their system. 

The final part is playing attacking football. Players that score goals attract a premium price, so if your style allows you to score more goals you sell for a bigger price, this is something Norwich did to great effect during their yo-yo years. 

My biggest frustration with Lai and co was the lack of implementing a very simple plan upon relegation to maximise this. I said when we appointed Val, the strategy had to be to reduce the age of the squad, invest our parachute payments into players with a sell-on value and to play football on the front foot. You need to set arbitrary rules such as not spending more than a nominal fee on players over 25, having 2-3 large earning experienced players on 1-2year deals at best, and not to make any loan signings that cost a fee without their being a pre-agreed permanent price. Yes we’d miss out on a few players but the long term sustainability was the most important factor given our chronic lack of external investment.

Agree with most of that.


RE: Ben Doak - B68Baggy - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 11:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.

Reach and Kelly were from previous regime.  Cole was bought in as third choice striker who had netted 16 goals last season with no fee and low wages, but we then spent the 2nd choice money on MJ.   Still think he should have had more minutes but CC just not a fan.

On the whole recruitment under the new regime has been low cost, low risk and decent.    Real wins with Heggem, Syles and I think Diakite has something about him.

During the Dashworth yo-yo years we made some proper dosh out of some pretty average players. Buy low, sell high. We also signed a few duds, you really can't win them all shopping from the bottom shelf.


RE: Ben Doak - Tom Joad - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 12:41 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 11:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.

Reach and Kelly were from previous regime.  Cole was bought in as third choice striker who had netted 16 goals last season with no fee and low wages, but we then spent the 2nd choice money on MJ.   Still think he should have had more minutes but CC just not a fan.

On the whole recruitment under the new regime has been low cost, low risk and decent.    Real wins with Heggem, Syles and I think Diakite has something about him.

During the Dashworth yo-yo years we made some proper dosh out of some pretty average players.  Buy low, sell high.  We also signed a few duds, you really can't win them all shopping from the bottom shelf.
Aye. I am still of the opinion Cole was signed early doors to fill a shirt as we slashed costs. Then there was a shift in our state of finances freeing up some more funds which has left him rightfully down the pecking order. None of us like Maja being subbed every 80th minute but if it keeps him available and not in the hydropool for months then I suppose it has to be reluctantly accepted until we find an alternative. That alternative is a priority for me and the difference between 7th and possibly 4th position.


RE: Ben Doak - B68Baggy - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 01:01 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 12:41 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 11:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.

Reach and Kelly were from previous regime.  Cole was bought in as third choice striker who had netted 16 goals last season with no fee and low wages, but we then spent the 2nd choice money on MJ.   Still think he should have had more minutes but CC just not a fan.

On the whole recruitment under the new regime has been low cost, low risk and decent.    Real wins with Heggem, Syles and I think Diakite has something about him.

During the Dashworth yo-yo years we made some proper dosh out of some pretty average players.  Buy low, sell high.  We also signed a few duds, you really can't win them all shopping from the bottom shelf.
Aye. I am still of the opinion Cole was signed early doors to fill a shirt as we slashed costs. Then there was a shift in our state of finances freeing up some more funds which has left him rightfully down the pecking order. None of us like Maja being subbed every 80th minute but if it keeps him available and not in the hydropool for months then I suppose it has to be reluctantly accepted until we find an alternative. That alternative is a priority for me and the difference between 7th and possibly 4th position.

Yep, totally agree.  We need to presume that poor Dike's career in this country is done and recruit accordingly.  Not easy, and my expectation would be a loan but one with a sizeable budget attached for fee and wages and potentially an inflated fee should we go up.  We need to learn from bringing in Marshal last year who looked totally unready for this level but I'm pretty sure would have been on chip money comparatively.


RE: Ben Doak - Peachy - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 01:09 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 01:01 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 12:41 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 11:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.

Reach and Kelly were from previous regime.  Cole was bought in as third choice striker who had netted 16 goals last season with no fee and low wages, but we then spent the 2nd choice money on MJ.   Still think he should have had more minutes but CC just not a fan.

On the whole recruitment under the new regime has been low cost, low risk and decent.    Real wins with Heggem, Syles and I think Diakite has something about him.

During the Dashworth yo-yo years we made some proper dosh out of some pretty average players.  Buy low, sell high.  We also signed a few duds, you really can't win them all shopping from the bottom shelf.
Aye. I am still of the opinion Cole was signed early doors to fill a shirt as we slashed costs. Then there was a shift in our state of finances freeing up some more funds which has left him rightfully down the pecking order. None of us like Maja being subbed every 80th minute but if it keeps him available and not in the hydropool for months then I suppose it has to be reluctantly accepted until we find an alternative. That alternative is a priority for me and the difference between 7th and possibly 4th position.

Yep, totally agree.  We need to presume that poor Dike's career in this country is done and recruit accordingly.  Not easy, and my expectation would be a loan but one with a sizeable budget attached for fee and wages and potentially an inflated fee should we go up.  We need to learn from bringing in Marshal last year who looked totally unready for this level but I'm pretty sure would have been on chip money comparatively.

The Bobbins loan would suggest we didn't learn a single thing from the Marshall loan. Marshall looked so lightweight. Nowhere near ready for Championship football and I'd argue we would have benefitted more from recalling Mo Faal and giving him the bench spot. He was at least battled hardened from his loan and physically on another level to Marshall.

Bobbins loan was a joke imo. It was fairly common knowledge that his was a hoax transfer between two clubs to circumnavigate FFP. The lad had played a season for Derby and hardly kicked a ball for Everton with 1 start in his 15 games I believe. It was also in a position where we had plenty of numbers. I do wonder who scouted him and quite exactly what they saw to think he'd add something better than we currently had? Villa must have been pissing themselves.....


RE: Ben Doak - SW4Baggie - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 01:21 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 01:09 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 01:01 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 12:41 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 11:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.

Reach and Kelly were from previous regime.  Cole was bought in as third choice striker who had netted 16 goals last season with no fee and low wages, but we then spent the 2nd choice money on MJ.   Still think he should have had more minutes but CC just not a fan.

On the whole recruitment under the new regime has been low cost, low risk and decent.    Real wins with Heggem, Syles and I think Diakite has something about him.

During the Dashworth yo-yo years we made some proper dosh out of some pretty average players.  Buy low, sell high.  We also signed a few duds, you really can't win them all shopping from the bottom shelf.
Aye. I am still of the opinion Cole was signed early doors to fill a shirt as we slashed costs. Then there was a shift in our state of finances freeing up some more funds which has left him rightfully down the pecking order. None of us like Maja being subbed every 80th minute but if it keeps him available and not in the hydropool for months then I suppose it has to be reluctantly accepted until we find an alternative. That alternative is a priority for me and the difference between 7th and possibly 4th position.

Yep, totally agree.  We need to presume that poor Dike's career in this country is done and recruit accordingly.  Not easy, and my expectation would be a loan but one with a sizeable budget attached for fee and wages and potentially an inflated fee should we go up.  We need to learn from bringing in Marshal last year who looked totally unready for this level but I'm pretty sure would have been on chip money comparatively.

The Bobbins loan would suggest we didn't learn a single thing from the Marshall loan. Marshall looked so lightweight. Nowhere near ready for Championship football and I'd argue we would have benefitted more from recalling Mo Faal and giving him the bench spot. He was at least battled hardened from his loan and physically on another level to Marshall.

Bobbins loan was a joke imo. It was fairly common knowledge that his was a hoax transfer between two clubs to circumnavigate FFP. The lad had played a season for Derby and hardly kicked a ball for Everton with 1 start in his 15 games I believe. It was also in a position where we had plenty of numbers. I do wonder who scouted him and quite exactly what they saw to think he'd add something better than we currently had? Villa must have been pissing themselves.....

Just took a quick look on the Norwich board and they seem to have been quite impressed with his debut!


RE: Ben Doak - B68Baggy - 01-05-2025

(01-05-2025, 01:21 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 01:09 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 01:01 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 12:41 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-05-2025, 11:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Agree on your last paragraph. Unfortunately, our recruitment will not listen to people like you and we recruit the likes of Reach, Cole, Kelly and Wildsmith.

Reach and Kelly were from previous regime.  Cole was bought in as third choice striker who had netted 16 goals last season with no fee and low wages, but we then spent the 2nd choice money on MJ.   Still think he should have had more minutes but CC just not a fan.

On the whole recruitment under the new regime has been low cost, low risk and decent.    Real wins with Heggem, Syles and I think Diakite has something about him.

During the Dashworth yo-yo years we made some proper dosh out of some pretty average players.  Buy low, sell high.  We also signed a few duds, you really can't win them all shopping from the bottom shelf.
Aye. I am still of the opinion Cole was signed early doors to fill a shirt as we slashed costs. Then there was a shift in our state of finances freeing up some more funds which has left him rightfully down the pecking order. None of us like Maja being subbed every 80th minute but if it keeps him available and not in the hydropool for months then I suppose it has to be reluctantly accepted until we find an alternative. That alternative is a priority for me and the difference between 7th and possibly 4th position.

Yep, totally agree.  We need to presume that poor Dike's career in this country is done and recruit accordingly.  Not easy, and my expectation would be a loan but one with a sizeable budget attached for fee and wages and potentially an inflated fee should we go up.  We need to learn from bringing in Marshal last year who looked totally unready for this level but I'm pretty sure would have been on chip money comparatively.

The Bobbins loan would suggest we didn't learn a single thing from the Marshall loan. Marshall looked so lightweight. Nowhere near ready for Championship football and I'd argue we would have benefitted more from recalling Mo Faal and giving him the bench spot. He was at least battled hardened from his loan and physically on another level to Marshall.

Bobbins loan was a joke imo. It was fairly common knowledge that his was a hoax transfer between two clubs to circumnavigate FFP. The lad had played a season for Derby and hardly kicked a ball for Everton with 1 start in his 15 games I believe. It was also in a position where we had plenty of numbers. I do wonder who scouted him and quite exactly what they saw to think he'd add something better than we currently had? Villa must have been pissing themselves.....

Dobbins was bought in before the MJ deal was on the table and with nobody expecting GrantMk2 to appear.  So he would have been competing with Fellows, Jed and Grady? at that point.  No doubt he would have had a lot more minutes and he did show glimpses how he could carry the ball at pace.  

Marshall just looked like a 14 year old asked to play mens Sunday league because the normal bloke playing up front had a shitty hangover. Not seen a more inappropriate loan for a particular moment in my life.