RE: IPPR - Tom Joad - 01-07-2025
(01-03-2025, 08:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Populist politicians appeal to people who are dissatisfied and disaffected with their lives. They offer simple solutions to complex problems. Those people are usually not as well educated, have less money and less agency in their lives. If you want to address the dangers of snake oil salesmen selling false medicine for the ills of society the mainstream parties should hold themselves to higher standards and address those areas with short, medium and long term solutions. Sadly they haven’t, you have Johnson, Truss and now Badenoch doing piss poor impressions of Trumpism and Labour are now using the same rhetoric and tactics of othering groups be they migrants or the disabled as both Reform and Tories whilst adding their very own condescending we know what’s best for you attitude.
Almost every government policy for the last 15 years has punished disproportionately the poorer in society and it shows no sign of changing to Labours shame. Be that placing migrants in poorer areas regardless of community cohesion, telling communities they should just accept decisions made on high about who and what can be placed in their area, lack of community policing to crack down on antisocial behaviour and crime, closing down youth clubs, community centres, selling sports fields off, poorer schools, doctors, lack of dentists the list is long and shameful. Telling them they should accept being poorer for the good of the country whilst the top 1-10% have made feck all sacrifices and only get disproportionately richer.
These pressures on those communities rarely happen in leafy mcw areas and yet we have to have a report to understand why people from less well educated backgrounds, living in working class areas are now turning their back on the two and a half main parties and looking for easy/quick solutions. Those areas don’t have the luxury of time to improve, to feel like ‘we are all in this together’ when clearly we aren’t and that leads to frustration and anger.
Farage age co would gain no traction if we lived in a fairer and more equal society, and as much as some in those communities should take more responsibility for getting a decent education etc, not making their areas worse through crime etc, the three main parties have enabled professional bullshitters and grifters to offer unworkable and vindictive solutions and gain political momentum.
If Labour want to defeat popularism then they have to remember to make society fairer not simply stick to the same policies as the Tories… but with a twist of condescension and a complete mixed bag of messaging. One minute they are using the language of Farage the next they are condemning similar language used by erm Farage and his supporters.
Popularism isn’t the answer to anything but Labour are currently all over the shop not knowing who and what they stand for, trying to appease potential Reform and Tory voters through rhetoric whilst telling Labour supporters to just accept watered down Tory policies that have failed the working class areas for 15 years! Who exactly does Labour speak for now? I suggest they no longer know the answer to this themselves and given what’s happened at a local level in Broxtowe this week I think they need to figure out this fundamental question pretty darn quickly, Great post DH. For now I'm just grateful the new government have stopped things falling off a cliff. At some point soon they need to start making a visible improvement. Start by getting some better P.R. and pointing out what the plan is and why things need to change. Start by listening to local communities.
RE: IPPR - Protheroe - 01-07-2025
Who aren't Labour listening to Dekka, in your opinion?
|