WBAUnofficial
Council By Elections - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Council By Elections (/showthread.php?tid=35965)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024

The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.

The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.

We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.


RE: Council By Elections - tHEgLASSdOORS - 12-23-2024

Stop being a pinko self hater Baggy1 and give up on the hand wringing

That’s my grown up contribution


RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024

Luckily I'm insulated from those insults gd, although I'm concerned that my offspring aren't as self hating as me.


RE: Council By Elections - tHEgLASSdOORS - 12-23-2024

I’d imagine there’s a lot of upset in the core voter base of this tirade


RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024

The metropolitan elite, as we like to call ourselves, are concerned but only whilst discussing these optics over our socialist champagne. I'm probably looking to move out to the shires in the near future so I'll probably join the countryside alliance at that point and airbrush this part of my history.


RE: Council By Elections - Derek Hardballs - 12-23-2024

Meanwhile in the real world people are getting penalised for trying to save for disability equipment under the unbelievably poor UC system (well it was developed by IBS so it should be a given it doesn’t work properly and punishes the most vulnerable) sadly but increasingly unsurprisingly Labour show absolutely no signs to make things fairer.

Instead they like to indulge in Mel Stride like rhetoric. For all the piss taking by comfortably well off middle class professionals on here… this is the reality of where this country is… the disabled and their carers getting financially punished for trying to save for medical equipment and adaptions to their homes. 

So whilst we pontificate about about politics on here like a sixth form debating society, the above is just one example of reality for the poorest in society. I am watching the Labour administration morph from a party wanting fairness and a better society for all to a pretty nasty, dictatorial impersonation of Cameron’s Tory Party.


RE: Council By Elections - Protheroe - 12-23-2024

(12-23-2024, 09:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.

The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.

We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.

My confirmation bias? You don't agree with it so you think it's flawed.

Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.


RE: Council By Elections - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-23-2024

(12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-23-2024, 09:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.

The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.

We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.

My confirmation bias? You don't agree with it so you think it's flawed.

Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.

These are the majority of people that have not witnessed a Labour shit show. They are now, and they are changing their opinions in the masses.

It's a shame that it takes a once in a generation event for the idealists to be welcomed to the real world, which is happening now.

Stagflation, coming to the UK in 2025. A electoral mandate based on economic growth? My arse. FGK & Thieves kill the economy.


RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024

Here's the problem Dekka, you throw insults around about being insulated from problems without knowing the status and motivation of people so expect some piss taking back. Likening the current government speakers to Mel 'they left a note' Stride is just simply bullshit. Comparing someone who used a moment of dark humour to the current situation of highlighting how shit things really are is daft.

The reality is that because of the state of the country there are steps to take to get us back on track and solving all of the solutions at once isn't viable. On one hand you've spent the last few years arguing against populist politicians offering sunlit uplands and cake with every serving, rightly btw, but when you get politicians that are trying to deal with the shit you moan they are not offering enough cake.

You might not agree but we are better off simply by having a stable party in place taking the problems seriously rather than the last mob who were more focussed on flawed ideology and self promotion. There are some serious tasks ahead but talk of a failed government and Starmer being replaced are both far from the truth and wildy misunderstanding of how the Labour party works.

(12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-23-2024, 09:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.

The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.

We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.

My confirmation bias? You don't agree with it so you think it's flawed.

Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.

The article you linked was based on exit polls not facts, it was also clearly comparing a high point in the younger vote which will skew any results.. You'll need to engage with BB on why he considers that is true.


RE: Council By Elections - Borin' Baggie - 12-23-2024

(12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.

That's not what I said