WBAUnofficial
"He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" (/showthread.php?tid=35604)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Lurker#3 - 11-10-2024

(11-10-2024, 07:47 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(11-09-2024, 01:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I see this argument quite a lot, not just by our fans, but across the footballing community. In all leagues and at most levels. 

Not sure why, though, we changed shape at least twice on Thursday night in that game alone. 

We started with a 433 with 2 wide men high and wide trying to get in behind, with Swift playing that deeper role that he did so well the first few games. Then when Luton starting dropping deeper we moved to a a 442/352 type shape when we made the subs with KG going high and narrow as an almost wide forward and MJ going narrow on the left. 

We then went 3421 when Grady and MJ played as 2 #10s behind Maja/Cole for the last 10/15 mins. 

I know people want to see the sub board go up and a clear and almost telegraphed change of shape with 2 strikers coming on for a midfielder and fullback. But i don't think that really happens untill the final frows of a game as all team structure and tactical work out in goes out the window. Not there's not a time for chucking the kitchen white good at a game of course. 

I've seen it on a post on another Fred today and it is bob on. We are still short of different options. We lack a CM who is a goal threat/runner and we lack a CF option. That does hamstring a coach somewhat, but the job of restructuring the squad was a tough one. Let's hope Cole is finding his fitness and starting to earn CCs trust a little more as a second CF option is vital.
Not taking the piss here Lurker or having a go, but how on earth can you deduce that from TV? If I’m in the stadium I can unless low down but on TV?

Quite easily, seeing where players are taking up positions when we have good possession, seeing the positions we take up out of possession. I have always found it easier to watch football on the telle to be honest.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - SW4Baggie - 11-10-2024

Formations as fans know them have been going out of fashion for quite some time, and most top managers now regularly change shape and formation several times in a game. With the advent of data analysts the level of preparation that goes into matches means that more and more games are becoming like chess matches with managers finding solutions and preventions throughout the match, and this is something that Carlos generally excels at.

For me, the real sign of a very good manager is how well set up teams are. A lot has been said about how well we’re defending with a makeshift back 4, but this is no accident. This is where Carlos absolutely excels. Just think how quickly we were rigid and solid from when Bruce left and the chaos that he put created back there.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-11-2024

I’ve given him plenty of stick over recent days/weeks not just for the poor form (it happens) but for what he’s been trying to do arrest this; and of course what else he expected to happen going into another season with only one recognised and fit centre-forward. But to be quite fair he changed it about, it just about worked; and although I remain a little unconvinced about the performance and decisions (Hull really aren’t all that and it could quite easily have been a draw), credit where it is due.

Defensively we are pretty threadbare, but in front of that I think perhaps he’s been guilty of trying to keep everyone happy opposed to selecting the best team. So while one swallow does not a summer make, well done to him for finally arresting the slide - particularly on the road.


RE: "He doesn't change the shape" / "there's no plan b" - Bob Fossil - 11-11-2024

(11-11-2024, 01:58 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I’ve given him plenty of stick over recent days/weeks not just for the poor form (it happens) but for what he’s been trying to do arrest this; and of course what else he expected to happen going into another season with only one recognised and fit centre-forward. But to be quite fair he changed it about, it just about worked; and although I remain a little unconvinced about the performance and decisions (Hull really aren’t all that and it could quite easily have been a draw), credit where it is due.

Defensively we are pretty threadbare, but in front of that I think perhaps he’s been guilty of trying to keep everyone happy opposed to selecting the best team. So while one swallow does not a summer make, well done to him for finally arresting the slide - particularly on the road.
Went earlier than usual with his first subs yesterday on 54 mins, so obviously wasn't happy with the response from his half time chat. 
Maja didn't look happy to come off, again, but not sure if that was a knock. Chucked his gloves either way. Can see why CC is protective though, with Cole seemingly bought in solely to cut the oranges at half time.