WBAUnofficial
xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? (/showthread.php?tid=35493)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Shabby Russian - 10-29-2024

(10-29-2024, 12:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 11:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 11:15 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like all stats, it's useful when used with other stats properly to build up a picture, on its own it's not worth a lot.

This.

Although I disagree when people completely dismiss it as nonsense.

Be interesting to know what the combined xg for our first 6 games was and that fir the following 6.

Were we just on a hot streak in the first 6 games taking every chance and scoring goals with low xg, or have our xg for goals scored fallen.

Suspect it's more the former than latter.

First 6 - We had 14 chances above 0.2xG and scored 11 goals. Total xG - 10.4

Following 6 - We had 4 chances above 0.2xg and scored 3 goals. Total xG - 5.8

Not really Shabby - In fact we probably missed a few good chances in the first few games according to the xG ratings for each shot. But by and large we were about on the mark. 

Our average xG/goal this year is 0.28.

Slightly surprised by those numbers. 

But this is where stats can help, it shows that our results have deteriorated because we are creating less chances, rather than we were on a hot streak of scoring difficult chances.


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Lurker#3 - 10-29-2024

(10-29-2024, 01:24 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Slightly surprised by those numbers. 

But this is where stats can help, it shows that our results have deteriorated because we are creating less chances, rather than we were on a hot streak of scoring difficult chances.

Absolutely, pal. That's why I haven't really stressed about the form in the short term.

As I allude to above in my reply to DH. It was clear CC went back to basics to end our run of 2 defeats, and after 2 solid but unspectacular games we improved v Blackburn and then we improved massively against Cardiff.


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Tom Joad - 10-29-2024

TBH, it really throws me. For example, on that chart our lowest XG is vs Blackburn where both Furlong and Heggem had one on ones with the keeper and missed. Yet Millwall really parked the bus, barely gave us a sniff and we had a higher XG? Also, the games we scored 3 goals don't figure in our highest XGs? I know it is my ignorance preventing me understanding it, but it is further proof that on its own, the stat is of little use. Who decides whether it's a sitter or a snapshot. I watched the Championship highlights of the weekend and noticed how many shots ended in goals whether "worldys" (Sunderland's 2) or deflected, bundled over the line or follow ups? If the guy doesn't follow up or the deflection doesn't go the favourable way, is that no longer an XG?


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Lurker#3 - 10-29-2024

(10-29-2024, 02:11 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: TBH, it really throws me. For example, on that chart our lowest XG is vs Blackburn where both Furlong and Heggem had one on ones with the keeper and missed. Yet Millwall really parked the bus, barely gave us a sniff and we had a higher XG? Also, the games we scored 3 goals don't figure in our highest XGs?  I know it is my ignorance preventing me understanding it, but it is further proof that on its own, the stat is of little use. Who decides whether it's a sitter or a snapshot. I watched the Championship highlights of the weekend and noticed how many shots ended in goals whether "worldys" (Sunderland's 2) or deflected, bundled over the line or follow ups? If the guy doesn't follow up or the deflection doesn't go the favourable way, is that no longer an XG?

Which goals are you thinking about, let me have a look at them and their xG score. 

https://www.sportperformanceanalysis.com/article/what-are-expected-goals-xg

This is a good read, mate.


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - TartanRug - 10-29-2024

(10-29-2024, 02:11 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: TBH, it really throws me. For example, on that chart our lowest XG is vs Blackburn where both Furlong and Heggem had one on ones with the keeper and missed. Yet Millwall really parked the bus, barely gave us a sniff and we had a higher XG? Also, the games we scored 3 goals don't figure in our highest XGs?  I know it is my ignorance preventing me understanding it, but it is further proof that on its own, the stat is of little use. Who decides whether it's a sitter or a snapshot. I watched the Championship highlights of the weekend and noticed how many shots ended in goals whether "worldys" (Sunderland's 2) or deflected, bundled over the line or follow ups? If the guy doesn't follow up or the deflection doesn't go the favourable way, is that no longer an XG?

As far as I know the xg amount for a chance is based on previous data for similar type chances. So if looking at past data over loads of matches, a shot from 10 yards out in the centre of the goal with several defenders between the attacker and the goal might result in 10 goals from 100 attempts so this gives the chance an xg of 10% or 0.1. So if your player has a similar type chance then 0.1 will be added to the xg for the team, whether it results in a goal or not.

As for the deflection example, the original shot will have a certain xg (again whether it ends up in a goal or not) and if noone follows up on the deflection or the deflection doesn't go the favourable way then no more xg will be added (but you'll still keep the original shot xg whatever happens next)

Hope that makes sense  Big Grin


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Tom Joad - 10-29-2024

(10-29-2024, 02:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 02:11 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: TBH, it really throws me. For example, on that chart our lowest XG is vs Blackburn where both Furlong and Heggem had one on ones with the keeper and missed. Yet Millwall really parked the bus, barely gave us a sniff and we had a higher XG? Also, the games we scored 3 goals don't figure in our highest XGs?  I know it is my ignorance preventing me understanding it, but it is further proof that on its own, the stat is of little use. Who decides whether it's a sitter or a snapshot. I watched the Championship highlights of the weekend and noticed how many shots ended in goals whether "worldys" (Sunderland's 2) or deflected, bundled over the line or follow ups? If the guy doesn't follow up or the deflection doesn't go the favourable way, is that no longer an XG?

Which goals are you thinking about, let me have a look at them and their xG score. 

https://www.sportperformanceanalysis.com/article/what-are-expected-goals-xg

This is a good read, mate.

OK, well I binge watched the league highlights but the Sunderland 2nd goal was just a wonder strike when probably not even a worthy chance. As I say, watching the rest I was struck by the fact many were just hopeful hits that got deflected to someone else or followed up. If the bouce doesn't go your way or no one follows up, then the chance doesn't exist - yet a goal happened anyway.
I'll read your link later on, I'm meant to be working up a tree right now and probably shouldn't be attempting to understand xG!


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Slowpoke Gonzalez - 10-29-2024

(10-29-2024, 10:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Seems to be a hotly contested matter amongst football fans, coaches and pundits at the moment. 

What do we all think? 

I think it's a really good barometer of the standard of chances a team are creating generally. 

For reference I have attached a screenshot which shows our form is pretty much directly correlated with our xG this year. 

I think it's maligned because it's misunderstood. It shouldn't be called expected goals, because it gives the wrong impression. It's a way of measuring the quality of chances a team has. It's a statistic and should be read as such. It's very helpful in giving a better impression of a game that you haven't seen. It should be called chance quality.


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Tom Joad - 10-29-2024

(10-29-2024, 02:24 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 02:11 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: TBH, it really throws me. For example, on that chart our lowest XG is vs Blackburn where both Furlong and Heggem had one on ones with the keeper and missed. Yet Millwall really parked the bus, barely gave us a sniff and we had a higher XG? Also, the games we scored 3 goals don't figure in our highest XGs?  I know it is my ignorance preventing me understanding it, but it is further proof that on its own, the stat is of little use. Who decides whether it's a sitter or a snapshot. I watched the Championship highlights of the weekend and noticed how many shots ended in goals whether "worldys" (Sunderland's 2) or deflected, bundled over the line or follow ups? If the guy doesn't follow up or the deflection doesn't go the favourable way, is that no longer an XG?

As far as I know the xg amount for a chance is based on previous data for similar type chances. So if looking at past data over loads of matches, a shot from 10 yards out in the centre of the goal with several defenders between the attacker and the goal might result in 10 goals from 100 attempts so this gives the chance an xg of 10% or 0.1. So if your player has a similar type chance then 0.1 will be added to the xg for the team, whether it results in a goal or not.

As for the deflection example, the original shot will have a certain xg (again whether it ends up in a goal or not) and if noone follows up on the deflection or the deflection doesn't go the favourable way then no more xg will be added (but you'll still keep the original shot xg whatever happens next)

Hope that makes sense  Big Grin

Yes! Cheers for that.


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - Hughie Reed 31 - 10-29-2024

A load of bollocks only stat that matters is the result
Fed up of modern football trying to jazz everything up


RE: xG - Meaningful or Meaningless? - MrBater - 10-29-2024

Pointless. The only stat that matters is goals scored.