WBAUnofficial
Man City punishment - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Man City punishment (/showthread.php?tid=35069)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Man City punishment - Berthe of a Nation - 09-13-2024

(09-13-2024, 08:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 07:30 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 06:07 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 06:00 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 05:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: They are successful because of clever marketing… we literally heard it here first!
I must be the only one who has any sympathy with their predicament.

They were joke relying on Dickov goals in the thurd tier.

Now the envy of the "old money clubs" don't like the competition and want FFP so they aren't allowed to do what they did for decades with impunity.

So friggin what. Plenty of clubs have had their rough times. They won the League Cup in 76, got to the Cup Final in 81, have had decent seasons.
Newcastle, Sunderland, Sheff Wed, us etc, etc have had heaps of shite.
Does that mean we too can break all rules for success.
They’ve made the Prem a bore fest.
They’ll just string this through the courts for years as well. Oil money buys the best lawyers too.

(09-13-2024, 06:36 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 06:25 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote: I bet you'd think differently if it was us being fucked by the pull up the draw-bridge mentality.

Why didn't FFP matter when the Moores pools money financing Livafool to rule over all.

If you can't see what this is doing for competition, I can't explain it any further.

They are well run and have probably spent less recently than Man United and their Maguire and Antony fuck ups.

You are basically saying know your station and don't dare challenge the status quo.

Furthermore, I don't care who wins the premier league unless it is us, so fuck em all in that regard, so 4 in row I don't give shit about.

I doubt I’d be comfortable if it was us in that situation. It was probably great for them a decade ago, but really?

The set up is such that they stop making football competitive.

I actually like football as well as Albion and watch the Prem. 

As for Liverpool, it was a time when clubs like us and Forest could compete and gate receipts shared. Liverpool were great but never had that much of a competitive advantage. They went to shit in the early 90s too long before the Arabs arrived.

You sound like someone with values very different from mine.
Funnily enough I like football too, and have been to every WC since 1998 except the last death factory one.

Tell me how many times a Direby (you  forgot about them) or a Forest won the league when Livafool won multiple titles in the 80's financed by pools money and Chelsea won it with gas money in the 2000's?

Don't think because I love the Albion I don't love football in general having been to over a hundred grounds around the world and some the most fiercely fought derbies out there. 

I live and breathe football, and don't give a fuck about other sports, so before you spout your patronising bollox about the premier league think twice.

In no other sector in business (yes football is unfortunately is a business now) is such restraint on trade trying to stifle competition in this way, and it all designed so nobody can challenge the likes of the top 6.

So when you spout shit about forest and my values try to remember how long ago those days were, and ask yourself can they do it again under FFP without spending like the top six clubs who are trying to protect their status.

The fact that FFP doesn't apply to thurd tier clubs says it all about who it is designed to protect.

None of the arguments you put forward are to do with clever marketing, they are simply down to Man City being able to spend billions on the best business people in the game, the best medical staff, ground, players, youth development, wages and training facilities and erm marketing. They have bought success and everything they’ve achieved since the billionaire owners arrived is down to their money. It has absolutely nothing to do with marketing whether clever or not. 

I cannot admire a club that simply went out and bought the best talent from around the world on and off the pitch. You can argue Man Utd and others have done this and football has never been a real meritocracy arguably since it became professional, but the bottomless pit of money they have has driven the need to have billionaire owners. It’s driven the divide beyond imagination for most clubs and Man City are at the epicentre of this anti-competitive and completely lopsided culture in the Prem. If there were no safeguards in terms of FFP they would still be in a position to buy success and make the competition a victory parade for an entire season. 

I don’t follow football beyond where we are, and a major reason for that is the the money in the game at the top level is ludicrous as is the horrible culture that surrounds the game. Again Man City are at the epicentre of this. 

Marketing my arse!

Who the fuck said anything about marketing.

I said the current ffp rules are designed to protect the status quo.

If they really wanted to protect the existence of defunct clubs like Bury they would apply to all tiers of football, but as blose spending has shown it does not.

Man city were up and down and then they got investement and a plan to develop the local area that was deprived and no we are now supposed to hate them for being aspirational and for having ideas above their station.

Fucking bollox.

The day a fan can stop dreaming about getting to where they are is day football really dies.

The fact they were thurd tier also rans to champions of Europe should give us all hope, but if you want to view it in a different way and prefer cunty Chelski or Man United winning loads of titles in the 90's and 2000's because of their dominant position then go for it.

 There is no absolutely no difference to what they did to what City are doing, especially when it comes to Chelski.


RE: Man City punishment - Derek Hardballs - 09-13-2024

(09-13-2024, 08:24 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 07:30 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 06:07 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 06:00 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote: I must be the only one who has any sympathy with their predicament.

They were joke relying on Dickov goals in the thurd tier.

Now the envy of the "old money clubs" don't like the competition and want FFP so they aren't allowed to do what they did for decades with impunity.

So friggin what. Plenty of clubs have had their rough times. They won the League Cup in 76, got to the Cup Final in 81, have had decent seasons.
Newcastle, Sunderland, Sheff Wed, us etc, etc have had heaps of shite.
Does that mean we too can break all rules for success.
They’ve made the Prem a bore fest.
They’ll just string this through the courts for years as well. Oil money buys the best lawyers too.

(09-13-2024, 06:36 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 06:25 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote: I bet you'd think differently if it was us being fucked by the pull up the draw-bridge mentality.

Why didn't FFP matter when the Moores pools money financing Livafool to rule over all.

If you can't see what this is doing for competition, I can't explain it any further.

They are well run and have probably spent less recently than Man United and their Maguire and Antony fuck ups.

You are basically saying know your station and don't dare challenge the status quo.

Furthermore, I don't care who wins the premier league unless it is us, so fuck em all in that regard, so 4 in row I don't give shit about.

I doubt I’d be comfortable if it was us in that situation. It was probably great for them a decade ago, but really?

The set up is such that they stop making football competitive.

I actually like football as well as Albion and watch the Prem. 

As for Liverpool, it was a time when clubs like us and Forest could compete and gate receipts shared. Liverpool were great but never had that much of a competitive advantage. They went to shit in the early 90s too long before the Arabs arrived.

You sound like someone with values very different from mine.
Funnily enough I like football too, and have been to every WC since 1998 except the last death factory one.

Tell me how many times a Direby (you  forgot about them) or a Forest won the league when Livafool won multiple titles in the 80's financed by pools money and Chelsea won it with gas money in the 2000's?

Don't think because I love the Albion I don't love football in general having been to over a hundred grounds around the world and some the most fiercely fought derbies out there. 

I live and breathe football, and don't give a fuck about other sports, so before you spout your patronising bollox about the premier league think twice.

In no other sector in business (yes football is unfortunately is a business now) is such restraint on trade trying to stifle competition in this way, and it all designed so nobody can challenge the likes of the top 6.

So when you spout shit about forest and my values try to remember how long ago those days were, and ask yourself can they do it again under FFP without spending like the top six clubs who are trying to protect their status.

The fact that FFP doesn't apply to thurd tier clubs says it all about who it is designed to protect.

None of the arguments you put forward are to do with clever marketing, they are simply down to Man City being able to spend billions on the best business people in the game, the best medical staff, ground, players, youth development, wages and training facilities and erm marketing. They have bought success and everything they’ve achieved since the billionaire owners arrived is down to their money. It has absolutely nothing to do with marketing whether clever or not. 

I cannot admire a club that simply went out and bought the best talent from around the world on and off the pitch. You can argue Man Utd and others have done this and football has never been a real meritocracy arguably since it became professional, but the bottomless pit of money they have has driven the need to have billionaire owners. It’s driven the divide beyond imagination for most clubs and Man City are at the epicentre of this anti-competitive and completely lopsided culture in the Prem. If there were no safeguards in terms of FFP they would still be in a position to buy success and make the competition a victory parade for an entire season. 

I don’t follow football beyond where we are, and a major reason for that is the the money in the game at the top level is ludicrous as is the horrible culture that surrounds the game. Again Man City are at the epicentre of this. 

Marketing my arse!

Who the fuck said anything about marketing.

I said the current ffp rules are designed to protect the status quo.

If they really wanted to protect the existence of defunct clubs like Bury they would apply to all tiers of football, but as blose spending has shown it does not.

Man city were up and down and then they got investement and a plan to develop the local area  that was deprived and no we are now supposed to hate them for being aspirational and for having ideas above their station.

Fucking bollox.

The day a fan can stop dreaming about getting to where they are is day football really dies.

The fact they were thurd tier also rans to champions of Europe should give us all hope, but if you want to view it in a different way and prefer cunty Chelski or Man United winning loads of titles in the 90's and 2000's because of their dominant position then go for it.

 There is no absolutely  no difference to what they did to what City are doing, especially when it comes to Chelski.

I had zero respect for Chelsea’s success either.

Sorry but I’m not seeing the free market beauty of billionaire oil money buying the Prem title.


RE: Man City punishment - Tom Joad - 09-13-2024

I see little difference between City or Chelsea and would like to see them both chucked out of the league. It isn't jealousy or a desire to see Albion do something similar, it is just that they have killed interest in top tier football for me. These days I can;t wait to see the Albion take the field, I am the most enthusiastic I've been for years, yet I rarely find time to bother with the Prem. All I see is City bogging this down in a solicitor's bunfight.


RE: Man City punishment - Berthe of a Nation - 09-13-2024

(09-13-2024, 08:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I see little difference between City or Chelsea and would like to see them both chucked out of the league. It isn't jealousy or a desire to see Albion do something similar, it is just that they have killed interest in top tier football for me. These days I can;t wait to see the Albion take the field, I am the most enthusiastic I've been for years, yet I rarely find time to bother with the Prem. All I see is City bogging this down in a solicitor's bunfight.
Pray tell what is the difference between those clubs you despise and the Livafool Moores pools millions or the Louis Edwards butcher business that funded Man United and paid players with rotten meat as long it lined his pockets?

Anyone who thinks FFP is there to protect football clubs from going bankrupt and therefore in the best interests of fans are truly mistaken imo.


RE: Man City punishment - Tom Joad - 09-13-2024

(09-13-2024, 08:59 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I see little difference between City or Chelsea and would like to see them both chucked out of the league. It isn't jealousy or a desire to see Albion do something similar, it is just that they have killed interest in top tier football for me. These days I can;t wait to see the Albion take the field, I am the most enthusiastic I've been for years, yet I rarely find time to bother with the Prem. All I see is City bogging this down in a solicitor's bunfight.
Pray tell what is the difference between those clubs you despise and the Livafool Moores pools millions or the Louis Edwards butcher business that funded Man United and paid players with rotten meat as long it lined his pockets?

Anyone who thinks FFP is there to protect football clubs from going bankrupt and therefore in the best interests of fans are truly mistaken imo.
Firstly, although I can barely muster enthusiasm for any defence, Liverpool had a dynasty of managers from Shankly through to Fagin and a clear identity. They were an evolution not an instant success. Winning trophies in the 60s, 70s and 80s but still having stiff competition.  Man Utd just had a great manager that saw off all competition, they also had a great youth development system. Neither dominated to the same extent.
Second, I completely agree with you about FFP. Jeremy Peace pointed it out at the time and he knew a thing or two about pulling up drawbridges.


RE: Man City punishment - Berthe of a Nation - 09-13-2024

(09-13-2024, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:59 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I see little difference between City or Chelsea and would like to see them both chucked out of the league. It isn't jealousy or a desire to see Albion do something similar, it is just that they have killed interest in top tier football for me. These days I can;t wait to see the Albion take the field, I am the most enthusiastic I've been for years, yet I rarely find time to bother with the Prem. All I see is City bogging this down in a solicitor's bunfight.
Pray tell what is the difference between those clubs you despise and the Livafool Moores pools millions or the Louis Edwards butcher business that funded Man United and paid players with rotten meat as long it lined his pockets?

Anyone who thinks FFP is there to protect football clubs from going bankrupt and therefore in the best interests of fans are truly mistaken imo.
Firstly, although I can barely muster enthusiasm for any defence, Liverpool had a dynasty of managers from Shankly through to Fagin and a clear identity. They were an evolution not an instant success. Winning trophies in the 60s, 70s and 80s but still having stiff competition.  Man Utd just had a great manager that saw off all competition, they also had a great youth development system. Neither dominated to the same extent.
Second, I completely agree with you about FFP. Jeremy Peace pointed it out at the time and he knew a thing or two about pulling up drawbridges.

Read the books mate they bought the best players for the highest transfer fees and wages.

They got Shankly by paying him more than Huddersfield did.

Just like Arsenal took Chapman from the terriers decades earlier.

I have no love for any of them, and just recognise it has always been the same. A businessmam comes in and thinks he can make more money by out spending others to get success and therefore bigger gates.

Forest did it by breaking records when getting the likes of TF .

Great manager, but also a great budget.

Now we are expected to despise it as it oil money, well bollox to that as those with slightest knowledge of football know what FFP is designed to do, and it isn't to protect to the likes of Bury.


RE: Man City punishment - Tom Joad - 09-13-2024

(09-13-2024, 09:34 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:59 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I see little difference between City or Chelsea and would like to see them both chucked out of the league. It isn't jealousy or a desire to see Albion do something similar, it is just that they have killed interest in top tier football for me. These days I can;t wait to see the Albion take the field, I am the most enthusiastic I've been for years, yet I rarely find time to bother with the Prem. All I see is City bogging this down in a solicitor's bunfight.
Pray tell what is the difference between those clubs you despise and the Livafool Moores pools millions or the Louis Edwards butcher business that funded Man United and paid players with rotten meat as long it lined his pockets?

Anyone who thinks FFP is there to protect football clubs from going bankrupt and therefore in the best interests of fans are truly mistaken imo.
Firstly, although I can barely muster enthusiasm for any defence, Liverpool had a dynasty of managers from Shankly through to Fagin and a clear identity. They were an evolution not an instant success. Winning trophies in the 60s, 70s and 80s but still having stiff competition.  Man Utd just had a great manager that saw off all competition, they also had a great youth development system. Neither dominated to the same extent.
Second, I completely agree with you about FFP. Jeremy Peace pointed it out at the time and he knew a thing or two about pulling up drawbridges.

Read the books mate they bought the best players for the highest transfer fees and wages.

They got Shankly by paying him more than Huddersfield did.

Just like Arsenal took Chapman from the terriers decades earlier.

I have no love for any of them, and just recognise it has always been the same. A businessmam comes in and thinks he can make more money by out spending others to get success and therefore bigger gates.

Forest did it by breaking records when getting the likes of TF .

Great manager, but also a great budget.

Now we are expected to despise it as it oil money, well bollox to that as those with slightest knowledge of football know what FFP is designed to do, and it isn't to protect to the likes of Bury.
I don't need to read the books, I saw much of that with my own eyes.
Shankly bought Ron Yeats and Ian St John for a pittance and played them with Roger Hunt and local lads, Thompson, Lawler, Smith and Callaghan. It isn't the same.
Clough bought John O'Hare, Alan Hinton, Archie Gemmil, Frank Clark, Kenny Burns and various other journeymen players and won the league. 
There has always been a degree of the bigger (or wealthier) clubs winning things when they manage to click into gear. The issue with Man City is they throw so much money at it, it cannot fail. FWIW, I can't really be bothered with it as it is less like sport and more like business.


RE: Man City punishment - Berthe of a Nation - 09-13-2024

(09-13-2024, 09:51 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 09:34 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:59 PM)Berthe of a Nation Wrote:
(09-13-2024, 08:43 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I see little difference between City or Chelsea and would like to see them both chucked out of the league. It isn't jealousy or a desire to see Albion do something similar, it is just that they have killed interest in top tier football for me. These days I can;t wait to see the Albion take the field, I am the most enthusiastic I've been for years, yet I rarely find time to bother with the Prem. All I see is City bogging this down in a solicitor's bunfight.
Pray tell what is the difference between those clubs you despise and the Livafool Moores pools millions or the Louis Edwards butcher business that funded Man United and paid players with rotten meat as long it lined his pockets?

Anyone who thinks FFP is there to protect football clubs from going bankrupt and therefore in the best interests of fans are truly mistaken imo.
Firstly, although I can barely muster enthusiasm for any defence, Liverpool had a dynasty of managers from Shankly through to Fagin and a clear identity. They were an evolution not an instant success. Winning trophies in the 60s, 70s and 80s but still having stiff competition.  Man Utd just had a great manager that saw off all competition, they also had a great youth development system. Neither dominated to the same extent.
Second, I completely agree with you about FFP. Jeremy Peace pointed it out at the time and he knew a thing or two about pulling up drawbridges.

Read the books mate they bought the best players for the highest transfer fees and wages.

They got Shankly by paying him more than Huddersfield did.

Just like Arsenal took Chapman from the terriers decades earlier.

I have no love for any of them, and just recognise it has always been the same. A businessmam comes in and thinks he can make more money by out spending others to get success and therefore bigger gates.

Forest did it by breaking records when getting the likes of TF .

Great manager, but also a great budget.

Now we are expected to despise it as it oil money, well bollox to that as those with slightest knowledge of football know what FFP is designed to do, and it isn't to protect to the likes of Bury.
I don't need to read the books, I saw much of that with my own eyes.
Shankly bought Ron Yeats and Ian St John for a pittance and played them with Roger Hunt and local lads, Thompson, Lawler, Smith and Callaghan. It isn't the same.
Clough bought John O'Hare, Alan Hinton, Archie Gemmil, Frank Clark, Kenny Burns and various other journeymen players and won the league. 
There has always been a degree of the bigger (or wealthier) clubs winning things when they manage to click into gear. The issue with Man City is they throw so much money at it, it cannot fail. FWIW, I can't really be bothered with it as it is less like sport and more like business.
I again repeat the fucking stupid money the likes of money man United waste on Martial, McGuire, and Antony.

I haven't got the time nor the inclination to work out the budgetary difference between the 2 Manchester clubs since city started winning stuff and became a threat to the top table.

However, I bet the difference wouldn't be that different.

And btw fuck Jeremy the cunt peace and the name check you gave that greedy mother fucking sewer rat bastard cunt wanker, because everyone with any common sense knew what FFP was designed to do, which was to give the yank controlled clubs what they wanted, no competition and no relegation if they had their way.


RE: Man City punishment - ColliersWoodBaggie - 09-13-2024

Not one team one a League title 8 out of 9 seasons.


RE: Man City punishment - CaptainFantastico - 09-13-2024

Should they be allowed straight into the championship? Yay or nay?