WBAUnofficial
Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF (/showthread.php?tid=34752)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-15-2024

(08-15-2024, 05:19 PM)Jacko Wrote: Yep now the appointment has been ratified by the legal eagles, he needs to get his ducks in row before Carlos goes completely cuckoo.

Won't believe it until I read it on Twitter though.


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - WorcsWBA - 08-15-2024

Andrew Nestor: "Our aim is to transition the club through its past financial troubles, building around a consistent game model and strategy. We are implementing effective trading policies, recruitment practices and building resources to support Ian Pearce and our football senior management as we invest in and develop the core of our men’s first team. We also look forward to extending these resources and best practices into our academy and newly integrated women’s first team.

We have been fully aware of the challenges and opportunities that we have in front of us here. We must operate within certain PSR constraints due to the Club’s past financial losses and decisions, but it should not be daunting to any of us. We continue to work through the current transfer window with a view to strengthening the club for the present and the long-term.”

His past history shows that he knows what he's doing, so I'm excited about the structure we now have in place. We really could be properly on the up here, finally, and I look forward to seeing what changes are made along the way to achieve this. Excellent stuff!


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - PatelsPlatoon - 08-15-2024

(08-15-2024, 09:07 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 07:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Business first approach, not always best imo for the fans.
I guess all clubs will be forced into this approach.
I see the reasons but the game as I knew it will be lost forever. The rich and wealthy have taken over and the rest are just making the numbers up.
The cups were always capable of shock results but as the rewards are dwindling only the fans are interested. Business has ensured they've become almost worthless.

Rose tinted spectacles. Yes there were cup shocks and yes the league was more open. However the football was played on mud, a lot of the play was akin to rugby league, players kicked up in the air, violence in the terraces, overt racism, organised hooliganism…I could go on. Even in the 80s 4 teams shared 10 titles. 2014-2024…guess what…4 teams shared 10 titles. 

Every generation thinks the current one isn’t as good as theirs.
Do you work for the Prem or Sky Burley because this is a very selective use of facts to justify a false statement on the competitive state of football.
The lack of fluidity in football at the highest level now is like nothing else in the past.
Year after year the same few sides end up in the top four, with one or two teams lucky to break in.
Yes Liverpool won heaps of titles in the 70s and 80s, but the likes of Ipswich, Watford and Southampton were runners up.
Now the cups are being dominated by the same few.
Also teams are finishing half way up the league with points totals that would have seen them relegated in the Pre Prem days.
Better football these days to watch if the teams are even in resources but if watching Man City and Liverpool score 6 or 7 v teams supposed to be equal, in terms of the league their in, is great then that’s your opinion.
A lot of things have improved but the game has been destroyed for many clubs dreaming of honours- ours included.


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - BurleyBaggie - 08-15-2024

(08-15-2024, 10:29 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 09:07 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 07:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Business first approach, not always best imo for the fans.
I guess all clubs will be forced into this approach.
I see the reasons but the game as I knew it will be lost forever. The rich and wealthy have taken over and the rest are just making the numbers up.
The cups were always capable of shock results but as the rewards are dwindling only the fans are interested. Business has ensured they've become almost worthless.

Rose tinted spectacles. Yes there were cup shocks and yes the league was more open. However the football was played on mud, a lot of the play was akin to rugby league, players kicked up in the air, violence in the terraces, overt racism, organised hooliganism…I could go on. Even in the 80s 4 teams shared 10 titles. 2014-2024…guess what…4 teams shared 10 titles. 

Every generation thinks the current one isn’t as good as theirs.
Do you work for the Prem or Sky Burley because this is a very selective use of facts to justify a false statement on the competitive state of football.
The lack of fluidity in football at the highest level now is like nothing else in the past.
Year after year the same few sides end up in the top four, with one or two teams lucky to break in.
Yes Liverpool won heaps of titles in the 70s and 80s, but the likes of Ipswich, Watford and Southampton were runners up.
Now the cups are being dominated by the same few.
Also teams are finishing half way up the league with points totals that would have seen them relegated in the Pre Prem days.
Better football these days to watch if the teams are even in resources but if watching Man City and Liverpool score 6 or 7 v teams supposed to be equal, in terms of the league their in, is great then that’s your opinion.
A lot of things have improved but the game has been destroyed for many clubs dreaming of honours- ours included.

OK. In the last 64 years only 14 different teams have won the league. Between 1970 and 1989 only 6 different teams won the league. 

That said my opening sentence read “Yes there were cup shocks and yes the league was more open”. However it’s a fallacy that the league has changed dramatically. Arsenal, Chelsea, Man Utd, Liverpool and City have been dominant over the last 60 years. The league as a whole isn’t as competitive - but it’s easy to look back and say things were better back then. I’m not sure they were. 

The area I agree with is it was more inclusive for working class fans, more affordable, more community based. 

One final stat on competitiveness, since 1992 51 [FIFTY ONE] different teams have competed in the Premier League, that suggests the Champonship is still competitive and there isn’t a complete lack of mobility of clubs.  


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - PatelsPlatoon - 08-16-2024

(08-15-2024, 11:24 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 10:29 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 09:07 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 07:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Business first approach, not always best imo for the fans.
I guess all clubs will be forced into this approach.
I see the reasons but the game as I knew it will be lost forever. The rich and wealthy have taken over and the rest are just making the numbers up.
The cups were always capable of shock results but as the rewards are dwindling only the fans are interested. Business has ensured they've become almost worthless.

Rose tinted spectacles. Yes there were cup shocks and yes the league was more open. However the football was played on mud, a lot of the play was akin to rugby league, players kicked up in the air, violence in the terraces, overt racism, organised hooliganism…I could go on. Even in the 80s 4 teams shared 10 titles. 2014-2024…guess what…4 teams shared 10 titles. 

Every generation thinks the current one isn’t as good as theirs.
Do you work for the Prem or Sky Burley because this is a very selective use of facts to justify a false statement on the competitive state of football.
The lack of fluidity in football at the highest level now is like nothing else in the past.
Year after year the same few sides end up in the top four, with one or two teams lucky to break in.
Yes Liverpool won heaps of titles in the 70s and 80s, but the likes of Ipswich, Watford and Southampton were runners up.
Now the cups are being dominated by the same few.
Also teams are finishing half way up the league with points totals that would have seen them relegated in the Pre Prem days.
Better football these days to watch if the teams are even in resources but if watching Man City and Liverpool score 6 or 7 v teams supposed to be equal, in terms of the league their in, is great then that’s your opinion.
A lot of things have improved but the game has been destroyed for many clubs dreaming of honours- ours included.

OK. In the last 64 years only 14 different teams have won the league. Between 1970 and 1989 only 6 different teams won the league. 

That said my opening sentence read “Yes there were cup shocks and yes the league was more open”. However it’s a fallacy that the league has changed dramatically. Arsenal, Chelsea, Man Utd, Liverpool and City have been dominant over the last 60 years. The league as a whole isn’t as competitive - but it’s easy to look back and say things were better back then. I’m not sure they were. 

The area I agree with is it was more inclusive for working class fans, more affordable, more community based. 

One final stat on competitiveness, since 1992 51 [FIFTY ONE] different teams have competed in the Premier League, that suggests the Champonship is still competitive and there isn’t a complete lack of mobility of clubs.  

Football is competitive at the highest level until you get to the very highest level. 
There’s good and bad in all generations and unquestionably it’s a better sport on the whole now. Hatchet men and awful pitches aren’t something I miss.
However, the Champions League and billionaires have ruined the hopes of clubs that were rubbing shoulders with the likes of Man City a generation ago.
Man City’s reserves would finish top 8 of the Prem.
Something has to be done to make the Premier League more competitive. You can bet top 4 will be 4 teams who will have played Champions League past 3 years.


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - ColliersWoodBaggie - 08-16-2024

(08-15-2024, 11:24 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 10:29 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 09:07 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-15-2024, 07:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Business first approach, not always best imo for the fans.
I guess all clubs will be forced into this approach.
I see the reasons but the game as I knew it will be lost forever. The rich and wealthy have taken over and the rest are just making the numbers up.
The cups were always capable of shock results but as the rewards are dwindling only the fans are interested. Business has ensured they've become almost worthless.

Rose tinted spectacles. Yes there were cup shocks and yes the league was more open. However the football was played on mud, a lot of the play was akin to rugby league, players kicked up in the air, violence in the terraces, overt racism, organised hooliganism…I could go on. Even in the 80s 4 teams shared 10 titles. 2014-2024…guess what…4 teams shared 10 titles. 

Every generation thinks the current one isn’t as good as theirs.
Do you work for the Prem or Sky Burley because this is a very selective use of facts to justify a false statement on the competitive state of football.
The lack of fluidity in football at the highest level now is like nothing else in the past.
Year after year the same few sides end up in the top four, with one or two teams lucky to break in.
Yes Liverpool won heaps of titles in the 70s and 80s, but the likes of Ipswich, Watford and Southampton were runners up.
Now the cups are being dominated by the same few.
Also teams are finishing half way up the league with points totals that would have seen them relegated in the Pre Prem days.
Better football these days to watch if the teams are even in resources but if watching Man City and Liverpool score 6 or 7 v teams supposed to be equal, in terms of the league their in, is great then that’s your opinion.
A lot of things have improved but the game has been destroyed for many clubs dreaming of honours- ours included.

OK. In the last 64 years only 14 different teams have won the league. Between 1970 and 1989 only 6 different teams won the league. 

That said my opening sentence read “Yes there were cup shocks and yes the league was more open”. However it’s a fallacy that the league has changed dramatically. Arsenal, Chelsea, Man Utd, Liverpool and City have been dominant over the last 60 years. The league as a whole isn’t as competitive - but it’s easy to look back and say things were better back then. I’m not sure they were. 

The area I agree with is it was more inclusive for working class fans, more affordable, more community based. 

One final stat on competitiveness, since 1992 51 [FIFTY ONE] different teams have competed in the Premier League, that suggests the Champonship is still competitive and there isn’t a complete lack of mobility of clubs.  

I'd argue differently against that. Whereas the winners of the thing, may not be too different over this period (more shared out though), the ones challenging certainly have. 

In the 70s & 80s, at various times the likes of; Albion,  Forest, Watford, Sheffield Wednesday, Villa, Ipswich , Derby, QPR, West Ham & Everton all challenged on a fairly regular basis, or on occasion. Usually in the Top 3/Runners up. Forest, Villa and Everton won it in an 8 year stretch from 1978 to 1985. Watford were promoted and finished 2nd in 1983. Famously, Forest won it in 1978 immediately after promotion, and had a 42 league game unbeaten stretch (only Albion beat them in that time in the 6th round of the Cup).

This would not happen now. 

Another thing which has changed, and I alluded to this with some clubs who came up from Div 2 and did well, is the struggle for Championship promoted sides to compete in the Prem. The gap is a a chasm compared to pre late 90s. All 3 promoted clubs went down last season. Off the top of my head, I can't recall how many seasons all 3 have stayed up in the EPL era , post 1992. I'd hazard a guess not one season would have seen this post 2005 ish. It would be interesting to see how many promoted clubs had stayed up in the 70s/80s, or how many season had all 3 promoted clubs stayed up. And where they'd finished on average. One for the stattos, there.

As for saying Man City have dominated in the last 60 years, well, they have very recently; but only since 2010/11 ish. And more totally since Guardiola became manager and their alleged financial doping took root. Before the 2008 Abu Dhabi takeover, I'd argue Man City were basically a bigger version of ourselves.  They'd hardly "dominated". 1998-99 they were in the third tier and had trodden water in the Championship by that time for 3/4 years. They were 7 years out of the top flight (1995-2002). And had 2 spells in old Div 2 in the 80s. Look at their honours list. That is eye wateringly inconsistent and unbalanced. 5 League title wins in 5 seasons is it? 9 since the takeover? I'm sure they'd only won it once or twice prior to 2008.  Not to mention League/FA Cups.


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - PatelsPlatoon - 08-16-2024

Man City had a good spell around 1970, but then did pretty much nothing until dodgy Arab money arrived by the truckload, bar the League Cup win in 1976.
Teams often won the old Div 1 and still lost several games and ended up with around 60 points in the old 2 point win system. That doesn't happen now.
Now the bigger clubs hoover up the points in a totally disproportionate way compared to anything in the past. I read some great research done by a University on this a year or two ago.
I wish I could find the article, but basically the bigger clubs win more of the time by bigger margins than at any time in history. It is true for all the top Leagues with clubs that now have a global following.


RE: Andrew Nestor appointed DoF - SW4Baggie - 08-16-2024

(08-16-2024, 09:27 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Man City had a good spell around 1970, but then did pretty much nothing until dodgy Arab money arrived by the truckload, bar the League Cup win in 1976.
Teams often won the old Div 1 and still lost several games and ended up with around 60 points in the old 2 point win system. That doesn't happen now.
Now the bigger clubs hoover up the points in a totally disproportionate way compared to anything in the past. I read some great research done by a University on this a year or two ago.
I wish I could find the article, but basically the bigger clubs win more of the time by bigger margins than at any time in history. It is true for all the top Leagues with clubs that now have a global following.

The financial disparity between the clubs in the CL and those that aren't is ruining the competitiveness of local leagues. Add to this, the additional revenues that come through the publicity of being in those competitions via global fanbases and the financial restrictions limiting clubs spending beyond their means has led to a two tier system. Whilst we may still be seeing variation between who is winning the title, the pool of clubs finishing in the positions which qualify for the CL has been largely the same for the last 20 years.

The only real solution is for the CL clubs to leave and join a Super League, and concentrate the wealth there - this ought to lead to more competitive local leagues, but looking at what's happened to the local leagues in Australia, the US and India for example on the creation of a "Super League" there suggests any local league remaining here would soon become distorted by the presence of "Man United 2" fielding a reserve/development squad. It would also only be a matter of time before those leagues wanted an international tournament and the whole process of distortion would start again. 

As with all things, money will always find its way to a disproportionate number at the very top and consolidate.