WBAUnofficial
The state of the criminal justice system - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The state of the criminal justice system (/showthread.php?tid=34380)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Protheroe - 07-15-2024

(07-14-2024, 03:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: There’s always a ‘do nothing’ option. It’s failed, it’s weakened our state structure to the point that we need to break the bank to repair it. But that was always the plan

Debt has weakened the structure of the state far more than the austerity-lite imposed during 2010-15.

You've never detailed what the alternative to austerity was 2010-15. Let me fill that in for you. More debt, or more tax or both - as has happened from 2015.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Pontificator - 07-15-2024

(07-15-2024, 07:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-14-2024, 03:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: There’s always a ‘do nothing’ option. It’s failed, it’s weakened our state structure to the point that we need to break the bank to repair it. But that was always the plan

Debt has weakened the structure of the state far more than the austerity-lite imposed during 2010-15.

You've never detailed what the alternative to austerity was 2010-15. Let me fill that in for you. More debt, or more tax or both - as has happened from 2015.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End_This_Depression_Now!
It was set out in this book, which I read at the time. The point is you have never accepted there was an alternative and never will.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Protheroe - 07-15-2024

Yes, yes, yes only if you believe in Keynesianism which served this country so badly up to 1979. Krugman, like Keynes would pay people to dig ditches and fill them back in.

At the time I said that we'd all have to accept being a little bit poorer and paying more tax. As it is no-one accepted they needed to be poorer for the sake of our kids and grandkids, and the coalition largely avoided tax increases (quite the opposite for the lowest paid). Instead choosing to kick the can down the road on debt (as I also said ad infinitum 2010-15).

Add in Covid and Energy Price Support and this is the reckoning.

With virtual full employment the only thing a Keynesian boom would have done then or do now is revive inflation. Which would force interest rates on government debt up. There is a reason Labour, the Tories, the BoE and the bond markets all supported a degree of austerity in 2010. #LeastWorst, you could say.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Derek Hardballs - 07-15-2024

Of course when Proth says ‘we’ he doesn’t mean the very wealthy should be hit by austerity. There are separate rules for them than say a librarian in Wolverhampton whose job was cut for the sake of the country.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - man in the corner shop - 07-15-2024

I am a million miles from Proths economic assessments. I will never agree with him, nor he with me, so little point debating.

Suffice to say, two or three capitalist parties agreeing in 2010 to do what capitalism wants to do to maintain the staus quo, cuts no mustard with me.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Protheroe - 07-15-2024

(07-15-2024, 12:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Of course when Proth says ‘we’ he doesn’t mean the very wealthy should be hit by austerity. There are separate rules for them than say a librarian in Wolverhampton whose job was cut for the sake of the country.

I'm being told what I think again. 

You do understand that highest earners have been squeezed more than any other group over the last 14 years don't you?

And you also understand that the most wealthy will simply shift their assets if you threaten to tax wealth too much? As the French found out 20 years ago and as we're about to find out. Italy is has a very benign tax regime for mobile capital right now (if you're interested). And much better weather.

(07-15-2024, 12:39 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Suffice to say, two or three capitalist parties agreeing in 2010 to do what capitalism wants to do to maintain the staus quo, cuts no mustard with me.

Labour and the Tories did what was good for themselves between 2008-2010. In the wholesale nationalisation of debt Gordon Brown was acting in the interests of his government, not capitalism. You do not restore equilibrium in a market by bailing it out at taxpayer expense. You do not restore equilibrium in a market by suppressing interest rates for a decade, essentially making borrowing free of charge.

All you do with such a policy is encourage bad actors, zombie companies, spivs and speculators. Which is what you got.

I never cease to be amazed by how many on this Board support the subsidies given to those in most debt - particularly zombie companies paying poverty wages and overleveraged property investment companies. You're the greatest friends of the very worst aspects of crony-capitalism. False consciousness, you could say.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Derek Hardballs - 07-15-2024

(07-15-2024, 01:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-15-2024, 12:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Of course when Proth says ‘we’ he doesn’t mean the very wealthy should be hit by austerity. There are separate rules for them than say a librarian in Wolverhampton whose job was cut for the sake of the country.

I'm being told what I think again. 

You do understand that highest earners have been squeezed more than any other group over the last 14 years don't you?

And you also understand that the most wealthy will simply shift their assets if you threaten to tax wealth too much? As the French found out 20 years ago and as we're about to find out. Italy is has a very benign tax regime for mobile capital right now (if you're interested). And much better weather.

(07-15-2024, 12:39 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Suffice to say, two or three capitalist parties agreeing in 2010 to do what capitalism wants to do to maintain the staus quo, cuts no mustard with me.

Labour and the Tories did what was good for themselves between 2008-2010. In the wholesale nationalisation of debt Gordon Brown was acting in the interests of his government, not capitalism. You do not restore equilibrium in a market by bailing it out at taxpayer expense. You do not restore equilibrium in a market by suppressing interest rates for a decade, essentially making borrowing free of charge.

All you do with such a policy is encourage bad actors, zombie companies, spivs and speculators. Which is what you got.

I never cease to be amazed by how many on this Board support the subsidies given to those in most debt - particularly zombie companies paying poverty wages and overleveraged property investment companies. You're the greatest friends of the very worst aspects of crony-capitalism. False consciousness, you could say.

The usual reply then. What have those paying the most suffered whilst being ‘squeezed the most’? Your policies seem to include kicking the financial crap out of the poorest so that you don’t upset the richest and most tax avoiding savvy. This has cost the country billions via care, social services, health, education and justice. Austerity solved absolutely nothing it kicked the can down the road for fear or favour for the rich. It was a choice and they chose to bully the poorest and most vulnerable. Tell me what you expect can be cut this time around that will solve debt?


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Protheroe - 07-15-2024

(07-15-2024, 01:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The usual reply then. What have those paying the most suffered whilst being ‘squeezed the most’? Your policies seem to include kicking the financial crap out of the poorest so that you don’t upset the richest and most tax avoiding savvy. This has cost the country billions via care, social services, health, education and justice. Austerity solved absolutely nothing it kicked the can down the road for fear or favour for the rich. It was a choice and they chose to bully the poorest and most vulnerable. Tell me what you expect can be cut this time around that will solve debt?

No, not "my policies". My policies (as I've stated very often, not that ever remember) would've been lots of supply side reform - particularly planning, fundamental reform of the NHS and a realignment of the relationship between the individual and the state - where the individual is not in need of state support.

Instead we have the biggest client state ever (thanks largely to Rishi Sunak essentially being the son of Gordon Brown), we're a decade and a half further into a housing crisis and the NHS remains an unproductive hospital-focused anachronism. 

As for what will solve debt (or at least reduce the deficit)- well, see above.

Wes Streeting is talking a good game on the NHS. Planning reforms don't sound nearly as radical as they need to be. There is Royal Commission conversation going on about social care that will largely be a can-kicking exercise I expect. And expect more tax. Lots more tax. And the reduction of pension freedoms and alterations to the tax treatment of pensions.

For the avoidance of doubt for the weak-minded. If you simply believe that imposing taxes on the most wealthy will solve your debt problems then you haven't being paying attention to everywhere wealth taxes have ever been implemented. This is not a value judgement or a policy - it's simply a fact of life.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - man in the corner shop - 07-15-2024

(07-15-2024, 01:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-15-2024, 12:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Of course when Proth says ‘we’ he doesn’t mean the very wealthy should be hit by austerity. There are separate rules for them than say a librarian in Wolverhampton whose job was cut for the sake of the country.

I'm being told what I think again. 

You do understand that highest earners have been squeezed more than any other group over the last 14 years don't you?

And you also understand that the most wealthy will simply shift their assets if you threaten to tax wealth too much? As the French found out 20 years ago and as we're about to find out. Italy is has a very benign tax regime for mobile capital right now (if you're interested). And much better weather.

(07-15-2024, 12:39 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Suffice to say, two or three capitalist parties agreeing in 2010 to do what capitalism wants to do to maintain the staus quo, cuts no mustard with me.

Labour and the Tories did what was good for themselves between 2008-2010. In the wholesale nationalisation of debt Gordon Brown was acting in the interests of his government, not capitalism. You do not restore equilibrium in a market by bailing it out at taxpayer expense. You do not restore equilibrium in a market by suppressing interest rates for a decade, essentially making borrowing free of charge.

All you do with such a policy is encourage bad actors, zombie companies, spivs and speculators. Which is what you got.

I never cease to be amazed by how many on this Board support the subsidies given to those in most debt - particularly zombie companies paying poverty wages and overleveraged property investment companies. You're the greatest friends of the very worst aspects of crony-capitalism. False consciousness, you could say.

Ive agreed with you on that. Pay the number of people you can afford on a rate that you can afford. Or dont employ them. What a swizz the tax credits thing is.


RE: The state of the criminal justice system - Protheroe - 07-15-2024

Quite. And completely designed to create dependency and Labour votes.