WBAUnofficial
Do we really want to go up this year ? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Do we really want to go up this year ? (/showthread.php?tid=33509)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - Runaroundandgroovelikeabaggie - 04-28-2024

Quite simply we have to go up for financial reasons.  We'll likely get battered most weeks, but it's a necessary evil for the long term future of the club.  I can cope with a repeat of the early noughties if it benefits the club longer term.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - garryowensneck - 04-28-2024

Personally no but from a financial point of view I'd take the pain of being mullered every week if there was a plan to build a team that could come back again the season after.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - SuperBob2002 - 04-28-2024

I kind of understand the point of the question, but I think it's the wrong question to ask. Of course, as a club, we want to be in the PL for obvious monetary reasons. Also, as a fan you should really want to see your club at the highest level it can possibly go.

The question should be: do you enjoy the PL? It's a resounding no for any fan with half a brain cell. Why would anyone enjoy watching their side compete in a league they've no chance of winning, or even finishing in the top half (it's possible but very, very unlikely). Why would any fan enjoy watching a game that is consistently ruined by the farce that is VAR?

This is why I'm so relaxed about the outcome of this season. If we make the play-offs, great, we have a chance of getting promoted. If we do get promoted, great, we're back in the PL and will receive a much needed boost in finances. If we don't get promoted, or even make the play-offs, then OK, that's fine, as I, on a personal level, have little interest in the PL and everything that makes it the most corrupt, boring and ridiculous competition going.

I'm seeing whatever happens on Saturday as win win, on a personal level. No winning promotion won't be great for the club, but we'll be OK in the long term, PL or no PL.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - Huggybear - 04-28-2024

Yes we do but not for the right reasons.All to do with financial reasons and nothing else.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - ghanaian_baggie - 04-28-2024

(04-28-2024, 04:01 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I kind of understand the point of the question, but I think it's the wrong question to ask. Of course, as a club, we want to be in the PL for obvious monetary reasons. Also, as a fan you should really want to see your club at the highest level it can possibly go.

The question should be: do you enjoy the PL? It's a resounding no for any fan with half a brain cell. Why would anyone enjoy watching their side compete in a league they've no chance of winning, or even finishing in the top half (it's possible but very, very unlikely). Why would any fan enjoy watching a game that is consistently ruined by the farce that is VAR?

This is why I'm so relaxed about the outcome of this season. If we make the play-offs, great, we have a chance of getting promoted. If we do get promoted, great, we're back in the PL and will receive a much needed boost in finances. If we don't get promoted, or even make the play-offs, then OK, that's fine, as I, on a personal level, have little interest in the PL and everything that makes it the most corrupt, boring and ridiculous competition going.

I'm seeing whatever happens on Saturday as win win, on a personal level. No winning promotion won't be great for the club, but we'll be OK in the long term, PL or no PL.
This

plus I'll get the weekly banter with the kids I teach about how well (or more likely, badly we'll do). 
After two decades teaching secondary, now working in a primary, and the African kids I teach have never heard of us!


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - Peachy - 04-28-2024

Quite simple for me. Do I want us to go up this season? Not really. It would be an absolute mauling most weeks.

Do we need to go up? Yes 100%.

For the long term future of the club we need that injection of Prem money again so we can build again. I'd also love to see what Carlos could do with a few quid and a decent owner. I detest the prem. I hate the monopoly of the big clubs and VAR is completely ruining the game but I do understand that as a club we need to be back in that god awful division.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - Borin' Baggie - 04-28-2024

For sporting reasons, I would 100% rather we stay in the Championship.

For the future of the club, I would take the hit of going up and taking the money, reinvesting it into infrastructure and a solid core of players that can compete at the top of the Championship and accept the fact that next season would be a complete write off.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - Squid - 04-29-2024

(04-28-2024, 09:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: Quite simple for me. Do I want us to go up this season? Not really. It would be an absolute mauling most weeks.

Do we need to go up? Yes 100%.

For the long term future of the club we need that injection of Prem money again so we can build again. I'd also love to see what Carlos could do with a few quid and a decent owner. I detest the prem. I hate the monopoly of the big clubs and VAR is completely ruining the game but I do understand that as a club we need to be back in that god awful division.

This is where I'm at. I suspect it's where more than a few of the fans in places 2 - 7 in the table are too, which cannot be a healthy thing for the game.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - Johnnykayeengland - 04-29-2024

(04-29-2024, 08:26 AM)Squid Wrote:
(04-28-2024, 09:53 PM)Peachy Wrote: Quite simple for me. Do I want us to go up this season? Not really. It would be an absolute mauling most weeks.

Do we need to go up? Yes 100%.

For the long term future of the club we need that injection of Prem money again so we can build again. I'd also love to see what Carlos could do with a few quid and a decent owner. I detest the prem. I hate the monopoly of the big clubs and VAR is completely ruining the game but I do understand that as a club we need to be back in that god awful division.

This is where I'm at. I suspect it's where more than a few of the fans in places 2 - 7 in the table are too, which cannot be a healthy thing for the game.
I think you're right. It's not good for the game that most lower league fans despise the prem... but at the same time, and for the same reasons  want to be part of it, thus propping up the system.
It's interesting that there are some moves to balance the inequalities atm, with a salary cap format related to TV revenue being discussed. And that, with the prem unable to agree its handout to the FL, there's a strong possibility of an independent regulator... but would that body have any teeth?
It's gone quiet on the FA cup replays front.


RE: Do we really want to go up this year ? - HawkingsHalfpint - 04-29-2024

I prefer name on yer bowl posts

To get to this year rewards everyone. It may suck but we’ve been there before and we can exist there again.