WBAUnofficial
PMQS - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: PMQS (/showthread.php?tid=32867)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: PMQS - Ted Maul - 02-29-2024

(02-29-2024, 03:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-29-2024, 01:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Apart from the fact that none of Proths list that are ‘carried out in the name of Islam’ are intrinsic to Islam, and in fact are carried out in many religions including Christianity. A quick google search is all that is needed.

Please go on with examples extreme misogyny, Jew hate, gay hate, political repression, summary execution & FGM carried out by 21st Century Christian Theocracies.

I am looking forward to this immensely. <Feet up> <opens popcorn>

Why does "Jew hate" matter more than say, Muslim hate?


RE: PMQS - Protheroe - 02-29-2024

(02-29-2024, 01:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's honestly incredible, Proth gaslighting trying to pretend that B1 bringing up Islamaphobia in the Tory party was about Islam's conflict with liberalism instead of the targeting of individuals based on religious background (regardless of whether they're practicing or not) as per the Singh report. Anderson's comments (that several Tories including the PM have failed to condemn when directly asked) were about attacking an individual based on background, an individual that is clearly a liberal Muslim who was subject to death threats from Islamists for voting for gay marriage (something that Proth's former party had to be dragged kicking and screaming by an actual liberal party to bring forward).

And also gaslighting that a centralised state is inherently left wing in complete ignorance of the history of liberalism (spoiler, Adam Smith and James Mill were the lefties of their time) and that the principle of state centralisation is historically a right wing ideology (theocracy - right wing, absolute monarchy - right wing, mercantile republics - right wing) with which liberal principles evolved to attack FROM THE LEFT.

I'm more concerned about the term "Islamophobia" being used to shut down legitimate criticism of Islamism. Lee Anderson is not being Islamophobic in my book, he's simply being a racist thug.

Just as anti-Zionists might complain about the term "anti semitism" being used to shut down legitimate criticism of Zionism.

And thanks for proving my point. The Tory Party is mot lurching to big state theocracy, absolute monarchy or mercantilism - it's lurching to big state centrism, just as the Labour Party is and the Liberal Party would in the highly unlikely event they ever sniff a share of power again.

(02-29-2024, 03:50 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Why does "Jew hate" matter more than say, Muslim hate?

Who said that it did? And Muslim hate is not a feature of Islamic societies in my experience.


RE: PMQS - Borin' Baggie - 02-29-2024

(02-29-2024, 04:06 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-29-2024, 01:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's honestly incredible, Proth gaslighting trying to pretend that B1 bringing up Islamaphobia in the Tory party was about Islam's conflict with liberalism instead of the targeting of individuals based on religious background (regardless of whether they're practicing or not) as per the Singh report. Anderson's comments (that several Tories including the PM have failed to condemn when directly asked) were about attacking an individual based on background, an individual that is clearly a liberal Muslim who was subject to death threats from Islamists for voting for gay marriage (something that Proth's former party had to be dragged kicking and screaming by an actual liberal party to bring forward).

And also gaslighting that a centralised state is inherently left wing in complete ignorance of the history of liberalism (spoiler, Adam Smith and James Mill were the lefties of their time) and that the principle of state centralisation is historically a right wing ideology (theocracy - right wing, absolute monarchy - right wing, mercantile republics - right wing) with which liberal principles evolved to attack FROM THE LEFT.

I'm more concerned about the term "Islamophobia" being used to shut down legitimate criticism of Islamism. Lee Anderson is not being Islamophobic in my book, he's simply being a racist thug.

Just as anti-Zionists might complain about the term "anti semitism" being used to shut down legitimate criticism of Zionism.

And thanks for proving my point. The Tory Party is mot lurching to big state theocracy, absolute monarchy or mercantilism - it's lurching to big state centrism, just as the Labour Party is and the Liberal Party would in the highly unlikely event they ever sniff a share of power again.

You know full well that Islamophobia is applied to criticising ethnic and religious background including secular and liberal muslims rather than Islamism, and you know full well that is the context that it was brought up by B1 - not criticisms of Islam. Stop pretending to be obtuse in an attempt to deflect from the point. That is the systemic issue with the Tory Party, in the same context that Labour has had with anti-semitism.

The Tory Party is lurching towards hierarchic centralisation to support its key interest groups and preserve the social order to the detriment of society, that is right wing. They are not doing it out of a collectivist desire. And they absolutely are supporting mercantilism, neomercantilism sums up the entire protectionist agenda of the Tory Party from 2016 onwards, and now their time is numbered they're salting the earth. You are arguing up is down and left is right by pretending that the Tories have lurched to the left.


RE: PMQS - Protheroe - 02-29-2024

Hmm. Where to start.

The term Islamophobia is deliberately obfuscated in an attempt to confect as broad an offence as possible.

The Tory party is not lurching towards anything. It's thoroughly lacking in any plan whatsoever. It is institutionally incompetent. It has merely reverted to the depressing centrist / statist mean of this country - aside from the years 1979-1988 of course.


RE: PMQS - Borin' Baggie - 02-29-2024

Talking complete bollocks, you know full well the context that B1 brought it up and you know full well how it has been applied in this thread. Stop being deliberately obtuse in an attempt to gaslight. Anti-semitism can be applied to a wide range of contexts including Maltese and Arabic speakers but when someone brings it up everyone knows they're on about anti-Jew hate.

As for 1979-1988, completing the process of transfer of local democracy to Whitehall that was started in 1948, dictating how local government could use land for development, dictating how local government can sell assets and raise funds. How very decentralising.

And the Tories have a clear plan, pander to their voter demographics and their donors and salt the earth to make it as difficult for anyone else to fix the imbalances they have created and re-enable progression between the social orders.


RE: PMQS - Protheroe - 02-29-2024

The Tories don’t appear to be pandering to their base if people like me won’t vote for them.


RE: PMQS - Borin' Baggie - 02-29-2024

Middle class, middle aged professionals are not the Tory base.


RE: PMQS - CaptainFantastico - 02-29-2024

(02-29-2024, 08:31 AM)Protheroe Wrote: What Starmer appears to have dealt with, is tacking his party so far back to centre as to make a change of government an exercise in rearranging the deckchairs. So much so that I could possibly vote Labour if it wasn't for the rank hypocrisy in their ranks and the lasting stench of anti semitism.

Sounds like you may have conveniently abandoned your aged claims to opt for least worst. How unsurprising


RE: PMQS - Protheroe - 02-29-2024

(02-29-2024, 07:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Middle class, middle aged professionals are not the Tory base.

That’s been the Labour party’s base for 3 decades.

(02-29-2024, 07:35 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(02-29-2024, 08:31 AM)Protheroe Wrote: What Starmer appears to have dealt with, is tacking his party so far back to centre as to make a change of government an exercise in rearranging the deckchairs. So much so that I could possibly vote Labour if it wasn't for the rank hypocrisy in their ranks and the lasting stench of anti semitism.

Sounds like you may have conveniently abandoned your aged claims to opt for least worst. How unsurprising

I shan’t be voting at all. All parties have complicit in the awful outcomes we’ve experienced since the GFC. None of them have the first idea how to address the challenges that face us.

We’re not alone. It’s the same in France, Germany, US and most of the rest of developed world.


RE: PMQS - Borin' Baggie - 02-29-2024

(02-29-2024, 10:35 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-29-2024, 07:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Middle class, middle aged professionals are not the Tory base.

That’s been the Labour party’s base for 3 decades.

That's young professionals, not middle aged professionals. Middle aged professionals backed Blair but moved away from Brown and have generally voted Tory for the last 15 years - until now where they're pivoting towards Labour. Young professionals were also the demographic that voted Tory in 1979.

The Tory base has always been the moderate social conservatives that are resistant to social and economic change and have a protectionist streak, the landed gentry and the protectionist merchant classes. Are you one of those?