WBAUnofficial
Grady - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Grady (/showthread.php?tid=32843)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Grady - Lurker#3 - 02-26-2024

(02-26-2024, 11:22 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:15 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Grady had a really ineffective game v Hull no doubt about it. The concerning thing is, both he and Swift seem to be struggling to get into games in that #10 spot of late.

It could be something tactical that we are doing which is leaving them isolated in the that area of the pitch meaning they cannot find the room or support to impact games.

Grady will have a positive impact in far more games than he has a negative one that's for sure, but we need to try and work out why our #10s are having such limited involvement in matches. He only had 20 touches and 15 of those were in the midfield 1/3 rather than further forward where he usually hurts teams.

How have you happened upon the narrative that Diangana's a ten? Genuine question given I've seen you refer to him as a playmaker on a number of occasions when he's clearly best suited to playing the wide forward/modern winger role.

I mentioned above in a different reply. 

He isnt a "Winger", not in the mould that many seem to think. He doesn't run his man and look to swing in low percentage crosses. He likes to operate in tight areas. He takes and manipulates the ball in spaces where nobody else in the team can. He then passes the ball into areas where people get shots off. The stats speak for themselves in this regard and we need to get him firing again after his 5 weeks sat on his arse in Ivory Coast. 

Wallace, Fellows, Phillips etc are traditional wingers. Stay wide and try and stretch teams. Grady is a ball playing, playmaker who can operate from wide or also centrally.


RE: Grady - Wimborne Baggie - 02-26-2024

Grady was on decent form before he left for the afcon . He then sat on a bench for a month training with poorer players and lost match fitness / sharpness .

Give the lad a chance , Jese.

He will always blow hot and cold as most have said but he’s a match winner


RE: Grady - GunsOfNavarone - 02-26-2024

(02-26-2024, 11:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:22 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:15 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Grady had a really ineffective game v Hull no doubt about it. The concerning thing is, both he and Swift seem to be struggling to get into games in that #10 spot of late.

It could be something tactical that we are doing which is leaving them isolated in the that area of the pitch meaning they cannot find the room or support to impact games.

Grady will have a positive impact in far more games than he has a negative one that's for sure, but we need to try and work out why our #10s are having such limited involvement in matches. He only had 20 touches and 15 of those were in the midfield 1/3 rather than further forward where he usually hurts teams.

How have you happened upon the narrative that Diangana's a ten? Genuine question given I've seen you refer to him as a playmaker on a number of occasions when he's clearly best suited to playing the wide forward/modern winger role.

I mentioned above in a different reply. 

He isnt a "Winger", not in the mould that many seem to think. He doesn't run his man and look to swing in low percentage crosses. He likes to operate in tight areas. He takes and manipulates the ball in spaces where nobody else in the team can. He then passes the ball into areas where people get shots off. The stats speak for themselves in this regard and we need to get him firing again after his 5 weeks sat on his arse in Ivory Coast. 

Wallace, Fellows, Phillips etc are traditional wingers. Stay wide and try and stretch teams. Grady is a ball playing, playmaker who can operate from wide or also centrally.

We appear to be posting at crossed purposes. I clearly stated wide forward/modern winger. I never suggested he was a traditional winger so I've no idea why you're repeating it any more than why you stubbornly insist he's a playmaker when his historical appearance record suggests otherwise. I understand he manipultes the ball in tight areas because I've seen him do it, I just don't ever remember him conducting a game as a playmaker.


RE: Grady - Lurker#3 - 02-26-2024

(02-26-2024, 11:39 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:22 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:15 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Grady had a really ineffective game v Hull no doubt about it. The concerning thing is, both he and Swift seem to be struggling to get into games in that #10 spot of late.

It could be something tactical that we are doing which is leaving them isolated in the that area of the pitch meaning they cannot find the room or support to impact games.

Grady will have a positive impact in far more games than he has a negative one that's for sure, but we need to try and work out why our #10s are having such limited involvement in matches. He only had 20 touches and 15 of those were in the midfield 1/3 rather than further forward where he usually hurts teams.

How have you happened upon the narrative that Diangana's a ten? Genuine question given I've seen you refer to him as a playmaker on a number of occasions when he's clearly best suited to playing the wide forward/modern winger role.

I mentioned above in a different reply. 

He isnt a "Winger", not in the mould that many seem to think. He doesn't run his man and look to swing in low percentage crosses. He likes to operate in tight areas. He takes and manipulates the ball in spaces where nobody else in the team can. He then passes the ball into areas where people get shots off. The stats speak for themselves in this regard and we need to get him firing again after his 5 weeks sat on his arse in Ivory Coast. 

Wallace, Fellows, Phillips etc are traditional wingers. Stay wide and try and stretch teams. Grady is a ball playing, playmaker who can operate from wide or also centrally.

We appear to be posting at crossed purposes. I clearly stated wide forward/modern winger. I never suggested he was a traditional winger so I've no idea why you're repeating it any more than why you stubbornly insist he's a playmaker when his historical appearance record suggests otherwise. I understand he manipultes the ball in tight areas because I've seen him do it, I just don't ever remember him conducting a game as a playmaker.

Thats fair. I don't see him as a wide forward/"modern winger" either. His game isn't to threaten in behind or stretch back lines. He doesn't look to isolate a fullback with the view of creating a goal scoring action for himself. He doesn't stay high and wide ready for counter attacks and he doesn't look to carry the ball huge distances. 

For me his game is all about having lots of the ball in difficult areas of the pitch. Creating shot and goal scoring actions and making us tick in the final 1/3. He carries the ball progressively from already threatening positions and usually attempts dangerous passes which leads to his high numbers of key passes and GCA/SCAs. 

This is why I see him as a "playmaker". It's not stubbornnessess it's just what the stats and my eyes show me. I know people crave from him to be the fleet footed player when was when in loan, but his career hasn't gone that way with his injuries.


RE: Grady - GunsOfNavarone - 02-26-2024

(02-26-2024, 11:48 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:39 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:22 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:15 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Grady had a really ineffective game v Hull no doubt about it. The concerning thing is, both he and Swift seem to be struggling to get into games in that #10 spot of late.

It could be something tactical that we are doing which is leaving them isolated in the that area of the pitch meaning they cannot find the room or support to impact games.

Grady will have a positive impact in far more games than he has a negative one that's for sure, but we need to try and work out why our #10s are having such limited involvement in matches. He only had 20 touches and 15 of those were in the midfield 1/3 rather than further forward where he usually hurts teams.

How have you happened upon the narrative that Diangana's a ten? Genuine question given I've seen you refer to him as a playmaker on a number of occasions when he's clearly best suited to playing the wide forward/modern winger role.

I mentioned above in a different reply. 

He isnt a "Winger", not in the mould that many seem to think. He doesn't run his man and look to swing in low percentage crosses. He likes to operate in tight areas. He takes and manipulates the ball in spaces where nobody else in the team can. He then passes the ball into areas where people get shots off. The stats speak for themselves in this regard and we need to get him firing again after his 5 weeks sat on his arse in Ivory Coast. 

Wallace, Fellows, Phillips etc are traditional wingers. Stay wide and try and stretch teams. Grady is a ball playing, playmaker who can operate from wide or also centrally.

We appear to be posting at crossed purposes. I clearly stated wide forward/modern winger. I never suggested he was a traditional winger so I've no idea why you're repeating it any more than why you stubbornly insist he's a playmaker when his historical appearance record suggests otherwise. I understand he manipultes the ball in tight areas because I've seen him do it, I just don't ever remember him conducting a game as a playmaker.

Thats fair. I don't see him as a wide forward/"modern winger" either. His game isn't to threaten in behind or stretch back lines. He doesn't look to isolate a fullback with the view of creating a goal scoring action for himself. He doesn't stay high and wide ready for counter attacks and he doesn't look to carry the ball huge distances. 

For me his game is all about having lots of the ball in difficult areas of the pitch. Creating shot and goal scoring actions and making us tick in the final 1/3. He carries the ball progressively from already threatening positions and usually attempts dangerous passes which leads to his high numbers of key passes and GCA/SCAs. 

This is why I see him as a "playmaker". It's not stubbornnessess it's just what the stats and my eyes show me. I know people crave from him to be the fleet footed player when was when in loan, but his career hasn't gone that way with his injuries.

Fair enough chap and well explained. We see the same things but interpret what we see differently in some instances if not all. Tell you what though. Whatever happens don't do what I did a while back and read his bio on the official site where he's described as both a left midfielder and a tricky winger as he's neither  Big Grin .


RE: Grady - Bob Fossil - 02-26-2024

(02-26-2024, 11:48 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:39 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:22 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:15 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Grady had a really ineffective game v Hull no doubt about it. The concerning thing is, both he and Swift seem to be struggling to get into games in that #10 spot of late.

It could be something tactical that we are doing which is leaving them isolated in the that area of the pitch meaning they cannot find the room or support to impact games.

Grady will have a positive impact in far more games than he has a negative one that's for sure, but we need to try and work out why our #10s are having such limited involvement in matches. He only had 20 touches and 15 of those were in the midfield 1/3 rather than further forward where he usually hurts teams.

How have you happened upon the narrative that Diangana's a ten? Genuine question given I've seen you refer to him as a playmaker on a number of occasions when he's clearly best suited to playing the wide forward/modern winger role.

I mentioned above in a different reply. 

He isnt a "Winger", not in the mould that many seem to think. He doesn't run his man and look to swing in low percentage crosses. He likes to operate in tight areas. He takes and manipulates the ball in spaces where nobody else in the team can. He then passes the ball into areas where people get shots off. The stats speak for themselves in this regard and we need to get him firing again after his 5 weeks sat on his arse in Ivory Coast. 

Wallace, Fellows, Phillips etc are traditional wingers. Stay wide and try and stretch teams. Grady is a ball playing, playmaker who can operate from wide or also centrally.

We appear to be posting at crossed purposes. I clearly stated wide forward/modern winger. I never suggested he was a traditional winger so I've no idea why you're repeating it any more than why you stubbornly insist he's a playmaker when his historical appearance record suggests otherwise. I understand he manipultes the ball in tight areas because I've seen him do it, I just don't ever remember him conducting a game as a playmaker.

Thats fair. I don't see him as a wide forward/"modern winger" either. His game isn't to threaten in behind or stretch back lines. He doesn't look to isolate a fullback with the view of creating a goal scoring action for himself. He doesn't stay high and wide ready for counter attacks and he doesn't look to carry the ball huge distances. 

For me his game is all about having lots of the ball in difficult areas of the pitch. Creating shot and goal scoring actions and making us tick in the final 1/3. He carries the ball progressively from already threatening positions and usually attempts dangerous passes which leads to his high numbers of key passes and GCA/SCAs. 

This is why I see him as a "playmaker". It's not stubbornnessess it's just what the stats and my eyes show me. I know people crave from him to be the fleet footed player when was when in loan, but his career hasn't gone that way with his injuries.
I think this debate highlights the problem perfectly, no-one, including Grady, seems to know his best position. He's not a winger as such, but nor is he a playmaker (his passing is not sharp enough IMO). 
This is what's frustrating about him and it's no witch hunt, in fact it's more the opposite, in that most of us realise and accept that there's a very good technical footballer in there, it's just how to best utilise it without bringing Pereira back. I certainly don't know anyone that wants him to fail though, everyone I speak to feels the same as me and would just love to see him have a good run of games, as, as has been said, at his best he's a match winner.


RE: Grady - Fido - 02-26-2024

(02-26-2024, 11:56 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:48 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:39 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-26-2024, 11:22 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: How have you happened upon the narrative that Diangana's a ten? Genuine question given I've seen you refer to him as a playmaker on a number of occasions when he's clearly best suited to playing the wide forward/modern winger role.

I mentioned above in a different reply. 

He isnt a "Winger", not in the mould that many seem to think. He doesn't run his man and look to swing in low percentage crosses. He likes to operate in tight areas. He takes and manipulates the ball in spaces where nobody else in the team can. He then passes the ball into areas where people get shots off. The stats speak for themselves in this regard and we need to get him firing again after his 5 weeks sat on his arse in Ivory Coast. 

Wallace, Fellows, Phillips etc are traditional wingers. Stay wide and try and stretch teams. Grady is a ball playing, playmaker who can operate from wide or also centrally.

We appear to be posting at crossed purposes. I clearly stated wide forward/modern winger. I never suggested he was a traditional winger so I've no idea why you're repeating it any more than why you stubbornly insist he's a playmaker when his historical appearance record suggests otherwise. I understand he manipultes the ball in tight areas because I've seen him do it, I just don't ever remember him conducting a game as a playmaker.

Thats fair. I don't see him as a wide forward/"modern winger" either. His game isn't to threaten in behind or stretch back lines. He doesn't look to isolate a fullback with the view of creating a goal scoring action for himself. He doesn't stay high and wide ready for counter attacks and he doesn't look to carry the ball huge distances. 

For me his game is all about having lots of the ball in difficult areas of the pitch. Creating shot and goal scoring actions and making us tick in the final 1/3. He carries the ball progressively from already threatening positions and usually attempts dangerous passes which leads to his high numbers of key passes and GCA/SCAs. 

This is why I see him as a "playmaker". It's not stubbornnessess it's just what the stats and my eyes show me. I know people crave from him to be the fleet footed player when was when in loan, but his career hasn't gone that way with his injuries.
I think this debate highlights the problem perfectly, no-one, including Grady, seems to know his best position. He's not a winger as such, but nor is he a playmaker (his passing is not sharp enough IMO). 
This is what's frustrating about him and it's no witch hunt, in fact it's more the opposite, in that most of us realise and accept that there's a very good technical footballer in there, it's just how to best utilise it without bringing Pereira back. I certainly don't know anyone that wants him to fail though, everyone I speak to feels the same as me and would just love to see him have a good run of games, as, as has been said, at his best he's a match winner.

Agree with this. He has great control however he gets pushed off the ball so easily (attacking or defending) this is somewhat negated. Pereira was maybe a stronger player but if similar stature yet nearly always seemed to draw the foul which kept us higher up the pitch; Grady loses the ball as he gets pushed off it too easily.


RE: Grady - Birdman1811 - 02-26-2024

I actually understand why CC thinks he can play in the middle, as said here, nothing about his game suggests he needs to play wide, in fact, I'd say he could even play as a false 9 style forward, his finishing is ok, better than some we've seen in recent years, he works well in limited spaces, he works hard and is definitely technical enough. His inability in the air means he can't play as a lone striker for us though.


RE: Grady - Mr Nimbus - 02-26-2024

Interesting thread, normally is when Lurker's stat influenced view is involved.

Once you accept that he'll never be THAT player, the one that looked PL class feeding from Pereira, it's easier to see what he can now bring. I'd agree that injuries seem to have robbed him of some dynamism but he is still technically good footballer.

His job seems to be to taking the ball on in tight, difficult areas and make progressions rather than just receiving and passing backwards/sideways. Taking this into account it's understandable that he runs the risk of losing the ball and will have days when nothing seems to go for him.

I'm looking forward to seeing him back at full match fitness as he did hit a nice run of form pre Afcon and he has a number of different players around him now to work off.


RE: Grady - Tom Joad - 02-26-2024

Whatever people think his position is , he burst into our team as a winger. Maybe he will become more central, he certainly seems to want to learn, but he is nowhere near strong enough to warrant the role. I prefer to liken him to Swift, both are game changers, both can be totally ineffective equally. We are blessed, both with being able to choose either, one, both, or sometimes neither.