WBAUnofficial
Alex Palmer - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Alex Palmer (/showthread.php?tid=32133)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Alex Palmer - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-27-2023

Some will say I'm being over dramatic, but to my mind this season was about hitting 50 points and avoiding Administration. I think we are close on both fronts.

The wage bill is unsustainable for FFP, and with FFP being calculated on a 3 year average, we will face similar problems to Blues a few years ago, where it will take a couple of years to "wash out" previous excesses.


RE: Alex Palmer - SW4Baggie - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 11:34 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:46 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:41 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:36 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:05 AM)Lightnin Wrote: Let’s hope the potential new owners were watching like I suspect they probably were.

We may have a bit of cash with the extension of the sponsorship deal floating about to hold of any potential buyers. Especially with CC wanting to keep him and Palmer wanting to stay also in our favour.

It’s not so much about the cash flow, it’s about chopping millions off our wage bill to comply with FFP.

Can't see Palmer being a high earner unless he was given a tickle due to Luton's interest.

If we have to shift players it will be likes of Wallace, Swift, Barts, Grady etc BUT who would want them or more importantly be able to afford those wages apart from current parachutes?  Interesting.

Saying that I think Wallace would improve any squad in this division.

Agreed re Palmer’s wages, but he cost us nothing, so selling him would be all profit on this financial year for FFP purposes, just like selling Dara was. 

We are at genuine risk of losing several key players in the coming weeks.

Exactly this, Prag, as you well know. Selling the home grown players (hence the reason for touting Griffiths in the summer) and those acquired on "Frees" for money (Wallace, Okay & Swift) is the easiest way to balance the FFP hole that we face. That hole will exist if we have new owners or not.

Selling Grady & Grant may ease the wage bill, but there is possibly FFP losses with moving them on!

Fortunately Kelly, Reach and Chalobah were all frees too………


RE: Alex Palmer - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 12:27 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 11:34 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:46 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:41 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:36 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: It’s not so much about the cash flow, it’s about chopping millions off our wage bill to comply with FFP.

Can't see Palmer being a high earner unless he was given a tickle due to Luton's interest.

If we have to shift players it will be likes of Wallace, Swift, Barts, Grady etc BUT who would want them or more importantly be able to afford those wages apart from current parachutes?  Interesting.

Saying that I think Wallace would improve any squad in this division.

Agreed re Palmer’s wages, but he cost us nothing, so selling him would be all profit on this financial year for FFP purposes, just like selling Dara was. 

We are at genuine risk of losing several key players in the coming weeks.

Exactly this, Prag, as you well know. Selling the home grown players (hence the reason for touting Griffiths in the summer) and those acquired on "Frees" for money (Wallace, Okay & Swift) is the easiest way to balance the FFP hole that we face. That hole will exist if we have new owners or not.

Selling Grady & Grant may ease the wage bill, but there is possibly FFP losses with moving them on!

Fortunately Kelly, Reach and Chalobah were all frees too………

But no fucker wants them! They won't be missed off the wage bill, that's for sure.


RE: Alex Palmer - Derek Hardballs - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 12:18 PM)Jerry Wrote: If the club believe that Griffiths will become the better goal keeper which was the previous view then Palmer will be the one to go if money is needed. I think that Palmer has improved this season after a slow start and will have increased in value. I do not want Palmer sold but if what is being said on here is correct then needs must. Likewise where we have backups we are in danger of losing some of those. We then may be able to add a couple of good young loan players. Not at all ideal but may be able to stay competitive and allow the rebuild to start next year.

Selling players when we have a reasonable chance of promotion will solve nothing. Promotion and keeping the squad together until we know what league we will be in next season should be the priority. Before anyone says I know the circumstances the club is in but all the talk of selling x,y,z does the following, weakens us when we have a chance to help our financial problems via promotion, just delays major surgery if we don’t find new owners. If we do we have no idea what the plans are so I question anybody’s itk credentials on what will transpire.


RE: Alex Palmer - Hudds1 - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 12:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 12:18 PM)Jerry Wrote: If the club believe that Griffiths will become the better goal keeper which was the previous view then Palmer will be the one to go if money is needed. I think that Palmer has improved this season after a slow start and will have increased in value. I do not want Palmer sold but if what is being said on here is correct then needs must. Likewise where we have backups we are in danger of losing some of those. We then may be able to add a couple of good young loan players. Not at all ideal but may be able to stay competitive and allow the rebuild to start next year.

Selling players when we have a reasonable chance of promotion will solve nothing. Promotion and keeping the squad together until we know what league we will be in next season should be the priority. Before anyone says I know the circumstances the club is in but all the talk of selling x,y,z does the following, weakens us when we have a chance to help our financial problems via promotion, just delays major surgery if we don’t find new owners. If we do we have no idea what the plans are so I question anybody’s itk credentials on what will transpire.

Ok, but if we are in a really bad state (let us assume we are) then we have a major cashflow problem and a FFP disaster imminent-  a transfer window next month gives the chance to off load with transfer fees (if we can get some) to wash out some of the losses.  Of course it weakens us but if your arm is gangrenous, having it cut off weakens you but keeps you alive.  If things are that serious.  If they are, promotion is a chimera and a fool's paradise, to mix thingies. Edit. I don't think we have a reasonable chance of promotion, we have an outside chance but would you actually put serious money on it?


RE: Alex Palmer - Fulham Fallout - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 12:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 12:18 PM)Jerry Wrote: If the club believe that Griffiths will become the better goal keeper which was the previous view then Palmer will be the one to go if money is needed. I think that Palmer has improved this season after a slow start and will have increased in value. I do not want Palmer sold but if what is being said on here is correct then needs must. Likewise where we have backups we are in danger of losing some of those. We then may be able to add a couple of good young loan players. Not at all ideal but may be able to stay competitive and allow the rebuild to start next year.

Selling players when we have a reasonable chance of promotion will solve nothing. Promotion and keeping the squad together until we know what league we will be in next season should be the priority. Before anyone says I know the circumstances the club is in but all the talk of selling x,y,z does the following, weakens us when we have a chance to help our financial problems via promotion, just delays major surgery if we don’t find new owners. If we do we have no idea what the plans are so I question anybody’s itk credentials on what will transpire.


Depends when the takeover is likely to take place. 

The original £20m MSD loan lasted 11 months. 

What you are suggesting is effectively for us “to do a Leeds” and we all know how that turned out.


RE: Alex Palmer - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 12:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 12:18 PM)Jerry Wrote: If the club believe that Griffiths will become the better goal keeper which was the previous view then Palmer will be the one to go if money is needed. I think that Palmer has improved this season after a slow start and will have increased in value. I do not want Palmer sold but if what is being said on here is correct then needs must. Likewise where we have backups we are in danger of losing some of those. We then may be able to add a couple of good young loan players. Not at all ideal but may be able to stay competitive and allow the rebuild to start next year.

Selling players when we have a reasonable chance of promotion will solve nothing. Promotion and keeping the squad together until we know what league we will be in next season should be the priority. Before anyone says I know the circumstances the club is in but all the talk of selling x,y,z does the following, weakens us when we have a chance to help our financial problems via promotion, just delays major surgery if we don’t find new owners. If we do we have no idea what the plans are so I question anybody’s itk credentials on what will transpire.

New owners will not solve FFP, Derek.

In the Year Ended June 2022 (last published figures) our turnover without any Sky Monies (mostly parachutes) was c£15M. Our wage bill was c£42M. Whilst some high earners have left since then, the core of the team you watched yesterday (Townsend, Furlong, Ajayai, Bartley, Wallace, Swift, Grady, Okay) not to mention Phillips, Dike and a few others are earning good money. Put it another way, £42M spread across a 24 man squad is an average of £33K a week. Yes I know there are all the other staff costs to deduct, but I'm making the point that the average wage of the playing squad is way too high and has to come down.

If we aren't promoted, then we need to halve that cost per player cost to break even, if not we will breach FFP. Don't forget the MSD loans are costing c£4M in interest alone according to some, as well. The alternative is we gamble on winning the play-offs, and hope for immunity (like Villa) upon promotion. We have never been that lucky, though.


RE: Alex Palmer - Borin' Baggie - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 12:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 12:18 PM)Jerry Wrote: If the club believe that Griffiths will become the better goal keeper which was the previous view then Palmer will be the one to go if money is needed. I think that Palmer has improved this season after a slow start and will have increased in value. I do not want Palmer sold but if what is being said on here is correct then needs must. Likewise where we have backups we are in danger of losing some of those. We then may be able to add a couple of good young loan players. Not at all ideal but may be able to stay competitive and allow the rebuild to start next year.

Selling players when we have a reasonable chance of promotion will solve nothing. Promotion and keeping the squad together until we know what league we will be in next season should be the priority. Before anyone says I know the circumstances the club is in but all the talk of selling x,y,z does the following, weakens us when we have a chance to help our financial problems via promotion, just delays major surgery if we don’t find new owners. If we do we have no idea what the plans are so I question anybody’s itk credentials on what will transpire.

The only thing that will solve anything is securing adequate cashflow and reducing operational costs (namely, player wages) until we're sold. If we can't flog off fringe players like Chalobah/Ajayi then unfortunately we may have to sell some of our best players.


RE: Alex Palmer - Pragmatist - 12-27-2023

(12-27-2023, 11:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 11:26 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 10:50 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:46 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 09:41 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Can't see Palmer being a high earner unless he was given a tickle due to Luton's interest.

If we have to shift players it will be likes of Wallace, Swift, Barts, Grady etc BUT who would want them or more importantly be able to afford those wages apart from current parachutes?  Interesting.

Saying that I think Wallace would improve any squad in this division.

Agreed re Palmer’s wages, but he cost us nothing, so selling him would be all profit on this financial year for FFP purposes, just like selling Dara was. 

We are at genuine risk of losing several key players in the coming weeks.

We aren't.

I’m not sure how that can be case.  Sure, new owners can improve the cash flow position but how can they assist the built-up FFP problem?

Prag no disrespect intended but if the financial commentators on here and those ‘itk’ were to be believed / advice followed in the Summer we would be playing the kids and Adam Reach now and fumbling around the bottom of the table. Selling Palmer was the pinnacle of this frenzy to sell our best players for knock down prices and zero plan for the future.

The flaw in that plan was that there were no takers for the players who we could have sold in the summer. It’s extremely difficult to offload players on very high wages in this division without paying them off, which defeats the object.  We sold O’Shea but we needed to offload 2 or 3 more.

(12-27-2023, 12:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-27-2023, 12:18 PM)Jerry Wrote: If the club believe that Griffiths will become the better goal keeper which was the previous view then Palmer will be the one to go if money is needed. I think that Palmer has improved this season after a slow start and will have increased in value. I do not want Palmer sold but if what is being said on here is correct then needs must. Likewise where we have backups we are in danger of losing some of those. We then may be able to add a couple of good young loan players. Not at all ideal but may be able to stay competitive and allow the rebuild to start next year.

Selling players when we have a reasonable chance of promotion will solve nothing. Promotion and keeping the squad together until we know what league we will be in next season should be the priority. Before anyone says I know the circumstances the club is in but all the talk of selling x,y,z does the following, weakens us when we have a chance to help our financial problems via promotion, just delays major surgery if we don’t find new owners. If we do we have no idea what the plans are so I question anybody’s itk credentials on what will transpire.

Risking knowingly an FFP points deduction would be an insane strategy


RE: Alex Palmer - CaptainFantastico - 12-27-2023

If we can get decent cash for JG most likely departure in the window.

We have some challenges regardless of the takeover but talk of a fire sale or large exodus of key players is way off the truth