RE: Ratings - lesley - 11-06-2023
(11-06-2023, 09:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (11-06-2023, 12:07 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (11-05-2023, 11:40 PM)rickbaggie Wrote: (11-04-2023, 09:37 PM)Squid Wrote: Diang deserved more than a 8. Hull are going to be having nightmares about him.
I thought he was very average in the first half...getting bustled off the ball.
He was undoubtedly the most influential in the 2nd
Funny how we see it different. I thought that was Okay's best game this season.
Read it again, he’s talking about Grady. Agree that first half Grady struggled to get into the game, he was told to stay up and wide first half. Second half it was a flashback to when he first joined.
As for Okay, don’t think he’s quite been at it this season compared to his usual high standards but was better again. He’s our new Scharner, you only truly appreciate him when he’s not there.
Totally agree with you about Grady and Okay. I thought Grady put in an absolutely forgettable performance first half, but those 2 second half flashes that gave us 2 goals were indeed reminiscent of 2 seasons ago. Definitely a confidence player, is he happier here now all of a sudden?
As for Okay, the comparison with Scharner is spot on. We really miss his calmness, tackles, passes out,etc when he is not on the pitch. One of my current favourites.
RE: Ratings - Lurker#3 - 11-07-2023
More shots, more shots on target, more progressive passes, more progressive carries, more take-on's. All the The Albion. But yes, Rosenior, you "dominated" you massive whopper.
Player ratings/the stats:
Palmer - 6 - Not much he could do with the goal, it was a great strike, and was not under enough pressure from Townsend or tracked by Phillips. although he had to face 4 shots on target, the Post Shot xG was only 0.2 which highlights how routine his day was. Didn't bump him to a 7 as his distribution was well off, especially first half.
Furlong - 8 - Superb again from Darnell, has become Mr Consistent this year and one of a few who could say he's been POTS so far. Joint 1st with okay in the number of interceptions made (5), as always, in possession he was amongst our most progressive with 3 progressive passes, one of which was a key pass and 3 progressive carries, all of which were into the final 3rd and one was into the opponents area. He also clocked up 2 shot creating actions.
Kipre - 7 - Slightly different role for Cedric today playing in a 2. He had to be more disciplined off the ball and keep square of Bartley. This means he didn't have as much impact on the ball as in recent times. He did however pick up the mantle left by Pieters, by having the most touches in the team (71), but not many were progressive. Defensively he was solid, making the most clearances (4) and 2nd most interceptions (3). In truth he wasn't overly tested by Hull. Solid and unspectacular, which is music to my ears with Kipre.
Bartley - 6 - As above, our back 2 were not really tested. And as such Barts wasn't in the game. 1 clearance and 1 block was all that was required. As usual he had very little impact in possession, and had to leave the game early due to injury. Fingers crossed its not too bad.
Townsend - 7 - Got exposed first half, but that was more to do with shape than him personally. But that considered he plodded along competently, especially defensively winning all of his tackles (2) and challenges (1), whilst dominating aerially with 100% success rate in those duels. In possession however he wasn't progressive enough, making only 1 progressive pass, and 0 progressive carries.
Diangana - 9 - MOTM - Just brilliant. One of the best players in the league right now. 2 wonderful assists, firstly, but an all round great game. Joint second number of shots (2), 6 shot creating actions and 4 goal creating actions (both the highest in the team), joint 2nd progressive passes (3), most progressive carries (4) and most carries into the opponents box (4), he also received 7 progressive passes which was a 1/4 of our total number. As always he also committed players more than any other with 7 take on attempts and 3 successful dribbles.
Okay - 8 - Frankly, those who cant see the brilliance in what he does, especially in game like this, doesn't understand the game too well, unfortunately. Joint highest number of interceptions (5) in an area where they had numerical advantage for 60 odd minutes. Add to that joint 2nd number of progressive passes (3), with 2 of 3 going into the final 1/3. Cracking days work by our Turkish Rolls Royce.
Mowatt - 8 - Once again, had his wings clipped somewhat by the shape playing in a midfield 2 in front of a back 4. But just sublimely efficient in everything he did. He attempted the highest number of tackles/challenges in the team (5) winning 100% of them, he also made a huge, 8, progressive passes, 5 of which were into the final 1/3. He an Okay are such a well balanced, effective pairing, if not a touch slow.
Phillips - 8 - Not as good as recent times today from Matty, but not a bad performance by any stretch. He contributed, averagely, in all areas. Joint 2nd number of progressive passes, and 3 dangerous carries into the opponents area. But for balance only; 1 key pass, 1 shot creating action, no take on attempt. Also he should have tracked the run of their goal scorer.
EDIT - Forgot Matty's goal, bumped him to a 8.
BTA - 7 - Much better all round display by BTA today. He was far more involved having 24 touches, he attempted 3 take on's, but none successful, created 3 shot actions, had 2 shots on target and held the ball up well at times. He needs to work on getting himself into goal scoring areas more often though as his xG was only 0.1.
Wallace - 8 - Fantastic by Jed. Everything he did was efficient and progressive. Got a good goal, made 2 progressive passes and 3 progressive carries which allowed us a breather defensively. His work rate was just incredible too.
Subs:
Semi - 8 - Did everything he needed to do defensively, showed good concentration and gave us a little more thurst on transition. This is shown by the progressive carry he made into the final 1/3, and his total progressive carry distance per 90 minutes was higher than anyone else in the team. Add to that his goal, takes him to an 8.
Fellows - 7 - Gave us some extra pace and an out ball in the closing stages. Had more progressive receives per 90 than anyone else.
Sarmiento - 7 - See Fellows. In 5 touches, he made 3 progressive carries, 2 being in the final 1/3 and 1 being into the opponents penalty area. 1 successful take on, as well. Quite the cameo.
Chalobah/Molumby - 6 - Added pace and legs to a tiring midfield.
Manager:
CC - 8 - Yet again he managed the game superbly after his initial shape didn't quite work.
RE: Ratings - Malcolm Tucker - 11-07-2023
Superb as always, Lurker.
RE: Ratings - wba13 - 11-07-2023
Great report Lurker , I wish the idiots behind me could see exactly what Okay does.
RE: Ratings - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 11-07-2023
Top stATTiNG.
RE: Ratings - Lurker#3 - 11-07-2023
(11-07-2023, 11:10 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Top stATTiNG.
Except I forgot Matty's goal 
Bumped him to an 8!
RE: Ratings - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 11-07-2023
You're forgiven for your dedication to the cause.
RE: Ratings - MancBaggie - 11-07-2023
Good write up that Lurker
RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 11-07-2023
(11-07-2023, 10:21 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: More shots, more shots on target, more progressive passes, more progressive carries, more take-on's. All the The Albion. But yes, Rosenior, you "dominated" you massive whopper.
Player ratings/the stats:
Palmer - 6 - Not much he could do with the goal, it was a great strike, and was not under enough pressure from Townsend or tracked by Phillips. although he had to face 4 shots on target, the Post Shot xG was only 0.2 which highlights how routine his day was. Didn't bump him to a 7 as his distribution was well off, especially first half.
Furlong - 8 - Superb again from Darnell, has become Mr Consistent this year and one of a few who could say he's been POTS so far. Joint 1st with okay in the number of interceptions made (5), as always, in possession he was amongst our most progressive with 3 progressive passes, one of which was a key pass and 3 progressive carries, all of which were into the final 3rd and one was into the opponents area. He also clocked up 2 shot creating actions.
Kipre - 7 - Slightly different role for Cedric today playing in a 2. He had to be more disciplined off the ball and keep square of Bartley. This means he didn't have as much impact on the ball as in recent times. He did however pick up the mantle left by Pieters, by having the most touches in the team (71), but not many were progressive. Defensively he was solid, making the most clearances (4) and 2nd most interceptions (3). In truth he wasn't overly tested by Hull. Solid and unspectacular, which is music to my ears with Kipre.
Bartley - 6 - As above, our back 2 were not really tested. And as such Barts wasn't in the game. 1 clearance and 1 block was all that was required. As usual he had very little impact in possession, and had to leave the game early due to injury. Fingers crossed its not too bad.
Townsend - 7 - Got exposed first half, but that was more to do with shape than him personally. But that considered he plodded along competently, especially defensively winning all of his tackles (2) and challenges (1), whilst dominating aerially with 100% success rate in those duels. In possession however he wasn't progressive enough, making only 1 progressive pass, and 0 progressive carries.
Diangana - 9 - MOTM - Just brilliant. One of the best players in the league right now. 2 wonderful assists, firstly, but an all round great game. Joint second number of shots (2), 6 shot creating actions and 4 goal creating actions (both the highest in the team), joint 2nd progressive passes (3), most progressive carries (4) and most carries into the opponents box (4), he also received 7 progressive passes which was a 1/4 of our total number. As always he also committed players more than any other with 7 take on attempts and 3 successful dribbles.
Okay - 8 - Frankly, those who cant see the brilliance in what he does, especially in game like this, doesn't understand the game too well, unfortunately. Joint highest number of interceptions (5) in an area where they had numerical advantage for 60 odd minutes. Add to that joint 2nd number of progressive passes (3), with 2 of 3 going into the final 1/3. Cracking days work by our Turkish Rolls Royce.
Mowatt - 8 - Once again, had his wings clipped somewhat by the shape playing in a midfield 2 in front of a back 4. But just sublimely efficient in everything he did. He attempted the highest number of tackles/challenges in the team (5) winning 100% of them, he also made a huge, 8, progressive passes, 5 of which were into the final 1/3. He an Okay are such a well balanced, effective pairing, if not a touch slow.
Phillips - 8 - Not as good as recent times today from Matty, but not a bad performance by any stretch. He contributed, averagely, in all areas. Joint 2nd number of progressive passes, and 3 dangerous carries into the opponents area. But for balance only; 1 key pass, 1 shot creating action, no take on attempt. Also he should have tracked the run of their goal scorer.
EDIT - Forgot Matty's goal, bumped him to a 8.
BTA - 7 - Much better all round display by BTA today. He was far more involved having 24 touches, he attempted 3 take on's, but none successful, created 3 shot actions, had 2 shots on target and held the ball up well at times. He needs to work on getting himself into goal scoring areas more often though as his xG was only 0.1.
Wallace - 8 - Fantastic by Jed. Everything he did was efficient and progressive. Got a good goal, made 2 progressive passes and 3 progressive carries which allowed us a breather defensively. His work rate was just incredible too.
Subs:
Semi - 8 - Did everything he needed to do defensively, showed good concentration and gave us a little more thurst on transition. This is shown by the progressive carry he made into the final 1/3, and his total progressive carry distance per 90 minutes was higher than anyone else in the team. Add to that his goal, takes him to an 8.
Fellows - 7 - Gave us some extra pace and an out ball in the closing stages. Had more progressive receives per 90 than anyone else.
Sarmiento - 7 - See Fellows. In 5 touches, he made 3 progressive carries, 2 being in the final 1/3 and 1 being into the opponents penalty area. 1 successful take on, as well. Quite the cameo.
Chalobah/Molumby - 6 - Added pace and legs to a tiring midfield.
Manager:
CC - 8 - Yet again he managed the game superbly after his initial shape didn't quite work.
Good to see Furlong getting some credit. I admit to being his biggest critic last season but am more than happy to see the improvement. If only he had the self belief to shoot or cut inside sometimes instead of stopping dead 35 yards out looking to find a man. A vital cog in the Carlos wheel currently.
I've pretty much always said I wanted to see Kipre involved, ever since his improvement under Val, so I'm not surprised he has become the 1st choice CH. MOTM for me until Grady's 2nd half showing. Get him signed up.
Disagree with the bit about the centre halves not having much to do. Delap was a proper slippery customer and does have the knack of looking dangerous (when he isn't throwing himself to the ground).
RE: Ratings - Mr Nimbus - 11-08-2023
(11-07-2023, 10:21 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: More shots, more shots on target, more progressive passes, more progressive carries, more take-on's. All the The Albion. But yes, Rosenior, you "dominated" you massive whopper.
Player ratings/the stats:
Palmer - 6 - Not much he could do with the goal, it was a great strike, and was not under enough pressure from Townsend or tracked by Phillips. although he had to face 4 shots on target, the Post Shot xG was only 0.2 which highlights how routine his day was. Didn't bump him to a 7 as his distribution was well off, especially first half.
Furlong - 8 - Superb again from Darnell, has become Mr Consistent this year and one of a few who could say he's been POTS so far. Joint 1st with okay in the number of interceptions made (5), as always, in possession he was amongst our most progressive with 3 progressive passes, one of which was a key pass and 3 progressive carries, all of which were into the final 3rd and one was into the opponents area. He also clocked up 2 shot creating actions.
Kipre - 7 - Slightly different role for Cedric today playing in a 2. He had to be more disciplined off the ball and keep square of Bartley. This means he didn't have as much impact on the ball as in recent times. He did however pick up the mantle left by Pieters, by having the most touches in the team (71), but not many were progressive. Defensively he was solid, making the most clearances (4) and 2nd most interceptions (3). In truth he wasn't overly tested by Hull. Solid and unspectacular, which is music to my ears with Kipre.
Bartley - 6 - As above, our back 2 were not really tested. And as such Barts wasn't in the game. 1 clearance and 1 block was all that was required. As usual he had very little impact in possession, and had to leave the game early due to injury. Fingers crossed its not too bad.
Townsend - 7 - Got exposed first half, but that was more to do with shape than him personally. But that considered he plodded along competently, especially defensively winning all of his tackles (2) and challenges (1), whilst dominating aerially with 100% success rate in those duels. In possession however he wasn't progressive enough, making only 1 progressive pass, and 0 progressive carries.
Diangana - 9 - MOTM - Just brilliant. One of the best players in the league right now. 2 wonderful assists, firstly, but an all round great game. Joint second number of shots (2), 6 shot creating actions and 4 goal creating actions (both the highest in the team), joint 2nd progressive passes (3), most progressive carries (4) and most carries into the opponents box (4), he also received 7 progressive passes which was a 1/4 of our total number. As always he also committed players more than any other with 7 take on attempts and 3 successful dribbles.
Okay - 8 - Frankly, those who cant see the brilliance in what he does, especially in game like this, doesn't understand the game too well, unfortunately. Joint highest number of interceptions (5) in an area where they had numerical advantage for 60 odd minutes. Add to that joint 2nd number of progressive passes (3), with 2 of 3 going into the final 1/3. Cracking days work by our Turkish Rolls Royce.
Mowatt - 8 - Once again, had his wings clipped somewhat by the shape playing in a midfield 2 in front of a back 4. But just sublimely efficient in everything he did. He attempted the highest number of tackles/challenges in the team (5) winning 100% of them, he also made a huge, 8, progressive passes, 5 of which were into the final 1/3. He an Okay are such a well balanced, effective pairing, if not a touch slow.
Phillips - 8 - Not as good as recent times today from Matty, but not a bad performance by any stretch. He contributed, averagely, in all areas. Joint 2nd number of progressive passes, and 3 dangerous carries into the opponents area. But for balance only; 1 key pass, 1 shot creating action, no take on attempt. Also he should have tracked the run of their goal scorer.
EDIT - Forgot Matty's goal, bumped him to a 8.
BTA - 7 - Much better all round display by BTA today. He was far more involved having 24 touches, he attempted 3 take on's, but none successful, created 3 shot actions, had 2 shots on target and held the ball up well at times. He needs to work on getting himself into goal scoring areas more often though as his xG was only 0.1.
Wallace - 8 - Fantastic by Jed. Everything he did was efficient and progressive. Got a good goal, made 2 progressive passes and 3 progressive carries which allowed us a breather defensively. His work rate was just incredible too.
Subs:
Semi - 8 - Did everything he needed to do defensively, showed good concentration and gave us a little more thurst on transition. This is shown by the progressive carry he made into the final 1/3, and his total progressive carry distance per 90 minutes was higher than anyone else in the team. Add to that his goal, takes him to an 8.
Fellows - 7 - Gave us some extra pace and an out ball in the closing stages. Had more progressive receives per 90 than anyone else.
Sarmiento - 7 - See Fellows. In 5 touches, he made 3 progressive carries, 2 being in the final 1/3 and 1 being into the opponents penalty area. 1 successful take on, as well. Quite the cameo.
Chalobah/Molumby - 6 - Added pace and legs to a tiring midfield.
Manager:
CC - 8 - Yet again he managed the game superbly after his initial shape didn't quite work.
Great report and use of Stats Lurker. Look forward to the next one.
|