WBAUnofficial
Injuries and more injuries - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Injuries and more injuries (/showthread.php?tid=31542)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Injuries and more injuries - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 10-25-2023

(10-24-2023, 11:11 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-24-2023, 10:29 PM)Topman Wrote: I am struggling with the news that kipre is out for months to ever remember a time in the last 35 years of me going down to have ever seen anything like this. His injury will I think be the around six long term injuries I can think of in one year

Dike
Grady 
Kipre 
Reach 
Maja 
Swift

Anyone I have left out. It’s getting beyond a joke now

I feel we are just cursed at the moment, destined to stay put as we can’t gain significant momentum whilst these injuries pile up 

It’s really spoilt the night knowing we’ve picked up yet another long term injury

Swift is only short-term in comparison!

But a big chance now for Taylor to step up.  It could be a big breakthrough for him.  And we can play Pieters there with Townsend left back.  Okay can also play there if needed (we have lots of midfield options).
Would love to see Taylor get a run of games, only way we will find out if he is good enough, hope he gets the chance.


RE: Injuries and more injuries - Old Stroller - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: A couple of years ago now, I was chatting to some friends that are involved in football about this. Our solution, fuelled by alcohol too, was to divide the league's below the prem into north and south divisions. Top team from each regional division gets promoted, second and third have a play off to play the other in a play off final. 

Travel actually really impacts lower league teams, Plymouth really struggle with it for example, and this would help alleviate that. Then have a cup competition for each level too, so a championship cup, a League one cup etc that isn't region based. Games end up about the same as a premier League team, and everyone can win a cup, while also not paying fortunes to travel all over the country.

To this day, I don't see much wrong with the idea. Never happen of course.

That’s what’s happened outside the top two divisions from 1921 until 1958, without the play off add on. National League South and North replicates that nowadays.


RE: Injuries and more injuries - hudds - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 09:01 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: 46 games a season is ridiculous. The Premiership is only 38 and even with the addition for some of them of European matches etc, most top flight games will not play as many matches as the lower leagues, plus they generally have larger squads, better medical teams, recovery facilities and longer times between games. The load on players, given how the game has advanced in the last 30 years, having become faster and more relentless, makes more injuries inevitable. The lower leagues' numbers should be cut - that's the only answer.  It won't happen but it should.

A couple of years ago now, I was chatting to some friends that are involved in football about this. Our solution, fuelled by alcohol too, was to divide the league's below the prem into north and south divisions. Top team from each regional division gets promoted, second and third have a play off to play the other in a play off final. 

Travel actually really impacts lower league teams, Plymouth really struggle with it for example, and this would help alleviate that. Then have a cup competition for each level too, so a championship cup, a League one cup etc that isn't region based. Games end up about the same as a premier League team, and everyone can win a cup, while also not paying fortunes to travel all over the country.

To this day, I don't see much wrong with the idea. Never happen of course.

That's what they did for many years for Football League Div 3 North and South before having national Div 3 and Div 4 (old money).  Now They are Divs 1 and 2  ((pheww!)

Ah - OS got here fust.


RE: Injuries and more injuries - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 12:57 PM)hudds Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 09:01 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: 46 games a season is ridiculous. The Premiership is only 38 and even with the addition for some of them of European matches etc, most top flight games will not play as many matches as the lower leagues, plus they generally have larger squads, better medical teams, recovery facilities and longer times between games. The load on players, given how the game has advanced in the last 30 years, having become faster and more relentless, makes more injuries inevitable. The lower leagues' numbers should be cut - that's the only answer.  It won't happen but it should.

A couple of years ago now, I was chatting to some friends that are involved in football about this. Our solution, fuelled by alcohol too, was to divide the league's below the prem into north and south divisions. Top team from each regional division gets promoted, second and third have a play off to play the other in a play off final. 

Travel actually really impacts lower league teams, Plymouth really struggle with it for example, and this would help alleviate that. Then have a cup competition for each level too, so a championship cup, a League one cup etc that isn't region based. Games end up about the same as a premier League team, and everyone can win a cup, while also not paying fortunes to travel all over the country.

To this day, I don't see much wrong with the idea. Never happen of course.

That's what they did for many years for Football League Div 3 North and South before having national Div 3 and Div 4 (old money).  Now They are Divs 1 and 2  ((pheww!)

Ah - OS got here fust.

I think most European leagues do have two or three top divisions, then it goes to more regional stuff.
Italy, Serie A, Serie B, then Serie C,  is three regional Divisions. North, Central & South.
Spain, La Liga, Segunda Liga, then Regional Leagues.
Germany,  Bundesliga, 1,2,3. Then Regionalliga, ( with classic teams like Kickers Offenbach, FC Babelsburg, Rot Weiss Erfurt etc ).


RE: Injuries and more injuries - Birdman1811 - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 12:46 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: A couple of years ago now, I was chatting to some friends that are involved in football about this. Our solution, fuelled by alcohol too, was to divide the league's below the prem into north and south divisions. Top team from each regional division gets promoted, second and third have a play off to play the other in a play off final. 

Travel actually really impacts lower league teams, Plymouth really struggle with it for example, and this would help alleviate that. Then have a cup competition for each level too, so a championship cup, a League one cup etc that isn't region based. Games end up about the same as a premier League team, and everyone can win a cup, while also not paying fortunes to travel all over the country.

To this day, I don't see much wrong with the idea. Never happen of course.

That’s what’s happened outside the top two divisions from 1921 until 1958, without the play off add on. National League South and North replicates that nowadays.

Where the idea came from. But we all liked it, though realise it's got no chance of happening.


RE: Injuries and more injuries - SW4Baggie - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 01:18 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 12:46 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(10-25-2023, 10:24 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: A couple of years ago now, I was chatting to some friends that are involved in football about this. Our solution, fuelled by alcohol too, was to divide the league's below the prem into north and south divisions. Top team from each regional division gets promoted, second and third have a play off to play the other in a play off final. 

Travel actually really impacts lower league teams, Plymouth really struggle with it for example, and this would help alleviate that. Then have a cup competition for each level too, so a championship cup, a League one cup etc that isn't region based. Games end up about the same as a premier League team, and everyone can win a cup, while also not paying fortunes to travel all over the country.

To this day, I don't see much wrong with the idea. Never happen of course.

That’s what’s happened outside the top two divisions from 1921 until 1958, without the play off add on. National League South and North replicates that nowadays.

Where the idea came from. But we all liked it, though realise it's got no chance of happening.

I think the barrier has always been the perception that regionalising leagues will make them less marketable, but from a fan experience point of view, it makes total sense.  It seems ridiculous to me that we have 5 fully national tiers of league in this country.

I think we have to have national leagues at both Steps 1 and 2 - so the PL and Championship should remain the same but there's no reason why Leagues One and Two couldn't be regionalised, with the National League also falling into this process.

Two top divisions of 20 teams would leave (4+24+24+24 in the National League - or 76 teams) - there could quite easily be 2 tiers of N/S divisions - and whilst not the most popular view, we could look to merge the SPL into this system too!

Of course, this would require the agreement of 3-4 self-serving league bodies, as well as 2 FAs...


RE: Injuries and more injuries - Tom Joad - 10-25-2023

I believe the clubs themselves were all for changing from the North/ South separation, not wanting to miss out on a fixture v the odd big club that washes up down there. Sunderland, Wednesday, Man City. Shame, all they got was villa and wolves.....


RE: Injuries and more injuries - Everything Zin - 10-25-2023

Another factor against this is that the regional split would go through the Midlands meaning that clubs a few miles apart could be in different sections, as happens with the regionalised draw for the 1st round of the league cup. Would we really want to miss out on 6 points from matches against Wolves after their relegation? You'd also face the prospect of a club having to be moved from North to South depending on who got promoted and relegated.


RE: Injuries and more injuries - SW4Baggie - 10-25-2023

(10-25-2023, 05:28 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Another factor against this is that the regional split would go through the Midlands meaning that clubs a few miles apart could be in different sections, as happens with the regionalised draw for the 1st round of the league cup. Would we really want to miss out on 6 points from matches against Wolves after their relegation? You'd also face the prospect of a club having to be moved from North to South depending on who got promoted and relegated.

Yup - also you tend to find Southern splits end up being more difficult divisions due to funding and better youth facilities at larger clubs creating an imbalance.