WBAUnofficial
Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? (/showthread.php?tid=31443)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Borin' Baggie - 10-12-2023

(10-12-2023, 10:32 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Labour is and can do that without PR. It did in 1997, and looks like it is now too.

And what about after the next election? Do they just hope that FPTP plays in their favour enough? What happens if another 1974 happens and the Liberal Democrats aren't strong enough to bail Labour out from being eaten by their left wing factions and the SNP that they were also reliant on despite getting over 18% of the vote as that only returned 13 seats?

Let's not forget that Blair was so worried by the left of the party prior to 1997 screwing him over that he made an agreement with Paddy Ashdown to form a coalition in the event of a "small" majority. Because the Labour Party is still a broad church and any broad church is beholden to it's extremists if the moderates can't command a majority large enough to contain them, you need only look at what's happened to the Tories since 2015 in that regard after the Lib Dems couldn't keep shielding them.


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Pontificator - 10-12-2023

(10-12-2023, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 08:19 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 03:44 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I don't know where this idea that the Conservatives are finished comes from.

It's very likely they will be booted out of office next year, and deservedly so, but they are unlikely to be uncompetitive in the election after. Which is very scary, given the direction of travel the party is currently on.

It's why PR is a voting red line for me, if a party does not support electoral reform it's not getting my vote.

It did look for a brief moment that Labour might get behind electoral reform, but that ship has passed, mainly because they look likely to get a majority at the next election, and see no need for it now. Short sighted.

We need genuine and real choice that produces representation at parliament that is reflective of a wide range of political views, even if you really don't like some of those views, to pretendvthey don't exist is dangerous.

There is a real danger that in 2028 or 2029 we elect a very nationalistic govt that seek to restrict the ability of opposition voices to express their opinion, what I understand is describe as the Hungrification of UK politics. Such a Govt could be elected with relatively small levels of support.

This is the best argument against PR I've read - although written from a Labour perspective it nails it for me (Easy read)

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/proportional-representation-labour-party-lib-dems

Nonsense article. Written purely from a perspective of wanting a two-party system instead of democratic representation and snacks of the typical Labour Party entitlement that they automatically deserve voters instead of having to work for them.

If there were PR then Labour can do away with the left of their party more easily and work with the overlapping interests in the Liberal Democrats.

Also, actually celebrating that voters are disenfranchised for not voting for the "big two"? Seriously

Slight overaction and hardly nonsense - it's a well put together logical argument as to why PR is not a good idea for the Labour Party. Anybody who has to use  the "It's not democracy argument really gets up my tits"  the whining Left in the LP are always bleating about democracy, but they ain't as bad as the pathetic bunch that are the Lib Dems who should never be forgiven for 2010 -2015. We had a referendum on PR and it was rejected (awaits the bleating "It wasn't proper PR") The soft/hard left in the LP have to have a PR motion every fucking year why? Coz theyre fucking losers. We have a proper Social Democratic Party now and many Torys will be joining and/or voting for it. Equally you have absolutely no idea what may happen if we do have PR and cunts likw Farige and Tommy Robinson get to sit on the green benches. If you want to enable  a far right Tory Party by not voting Labour get on with it - but away with "It's not democracy" bullshit.


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Protheroe - 10-12-2023

(10-12-2023, 11:08 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 10:32 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Labour is and can do that without PR. It did in 1997, and looks like it is now too.

And what about after the next election? Do they just hope that FPTP plays in their favour enough? What happens if another 1974 happens and the Liberal Democrats aren't strong enough to bail Labour out from being eaten by their left wing factions and the SNP that they were also reliant on despite getting over 18% of the vote as that only returned 13 seats?

Let's not forget that Blair was so worried by the left of the party prior to 1997 screwing him over that he made an agreement with Paddy Ashdown to form a coalition in the event of a "small" majority. Because the Labour Party is still a broad church and any broad church is beholden to it's extremists if the moderates can't command a majority large enough to contain them, you need only look at what's happened to the Tories since 2015 in that regard after the Lib Dems couldn't keep shielding them.

Which is why I hope Starmer gets a stonking majority so he's not hock to the Campaign Group.

The power PR would give to the Lib Dems would massively outweigh its popular vote, and the price they'd extract for a coalition would be far greater next time that the thick end of fuck all they achieved last time.


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Borin' Baggie - 10-12-2023

I'm sorry? Compared with getting 100% of the power from 43% of the vote? Or pandering to your extremist MPs because you're so worried that 60 swivel-eyed loons could derail the government even going so far to abandon manifesto pledges you were elected on? The whole point of PR is that it's proportional, any government formed under it has confidence of a majority of the electorate. That's literally the whole point. We literally have an electoral system where MPs in Northern Ireland are elected on vote shares of less than 30%. Our current electoral system has been shown up with how much power it hands to minority factions, that argument doesn't make sense.

And the price they'd extract for a coalition next time would be social care reforms, dealing with sewage discharges and water infrastructure, land market reform, increasing tax thresholds with inflation and constitutional reform. How extreme. I'm sure Starmer and Sunak would rather deal with those demands than the SCG and ERG loons.


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Protheroe - 10-12-2023

(10-12-2023, 12:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm sorry? Compared with getting 100% of the power from 43% of the vote? Or pandering to your extremist MPs because you're so worried that 60 swivel-eyed loons could derail the government even going so far to abandon manifesto pledges you were elected on? The whole point of PR is that it's proportional, any government formed under it has confidence of a majority of the electorate. That's literally the whole point. We literally have an electoral system where MPs in Northern Ireland are elected on vote shares of less than 30%. Our current electoral system has been shown up with how much power it hands to minority factions, that argument doesn't make sense.

And the price they'd extract for a coalition next time would be social care reforms, dealing with sewage discharges and water infrastructure, land market reform, increasing tax thresholds with inflation and constitutional reform. How extreme. I'm sure Starmer and Sunak would rather deal with those demands than the SCG and ERG loons.

1,2,3 At what cost? Probably one that a senior coalition partner would not want to be bound by.

4 There's a vote winner if ever there was one


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Shabby Russian - 10-12-2023

(10-12-2023, 12:08 PM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 08:19 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 03:44 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I don't know where this idea that the Conservatives are finished comes from.

It's very likely they will be booted out of office next year, and deservedly so, but they are unlikely to be uncompetitive in the election after. Which is very scary, given the direction of travel the party is currently on.

It's why PR is a voting red line for me, if a party does not support electoral reform it's not getting my vote.

It did look for a brief moment that Labour might get behind electoral reform, but that ship has passed, mainly because they look likely to get a majority at the next election, and see no need for it now. Short sighted.

We need genuine and real choice that produces representation at parliament that is reflective of a wide range of political views, even if you really don't like some of those views, to pretendvthey don't exist is dangerous.

There is a real danger that in 2028 or 2029 we elect a very nationalistic govt that seek to restrict the ability of opposition voices to express their opinion, what I understand is describe as the Hungrification of UK politics. Such a Govt could be elected with relatively small levels of support.

This is the best argument against PR I've read - although written from a Labour perspective it nails it for me (Easy read)

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/proportional-representation-labour-party-lib-dems

Nonsense article. Written purely from a perspective of wanting a two-party system instead of democratic representation and snacks of the typical Labour Party entitlement that they automatically deserve voters instead of having to work for them.

If there were PR then Labour can do away with the left of their party more easily and work with the overlapping interests in the Liberal Democrats.

Also, actually celebrating that voters are disenfranchised for not voting for the "big two"? Seriously

Slight overaction and hardly nonsense - it's a well put together logical argument as to why PR is not a good idea for the Labour Party. Anybody who has to use  the "It's not democracy argument really gets up my tits"  the whining Left in the LP are always bleating about democracy, but they ain't as bad as the pathetic bunch that are the Lib Dems who should never be forgiven for 2010 -2015. We had a referendum on PR and it was rejected (awaits the bleating "It wasn't proper PR") The soft/hard left in the LP have to have a PR motion every fucking year why? Coz theyre fucking losers. We have a proper Social Democratic Party now and many Torys will be joining and/or voting for it. Equally you have absolutely no idea what may happen if we do have PR and cunts likw Farige and Tommy Robinson get to sit on the green benches. If you want to enable  a far right Tory Party by not voting Labour get on with it - but away with "It's not democracy" bullshit.

We did not have a referendum on pr...whether the right sort or not.

It was a referendum on the Alternative vote which in essence is another first past the post system, albeit by a more indirect route.


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Borin' Baggie - 10-12-2023

(10-12-2023, 01:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 12:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm sorry? Compared with getting 100% of the power from 43% of the vote? Or pandering to your extremist MPs because you're so worried that 60 swivel-eyed loons could derail the government even going so far to abandon manifesto pledges you were elected on? The whole point of PR is that it's proportional, any government formed under it has confidence of a majority of the electorate. That's literally the whole point. We literally have an electoral system where MPs in Northern Ireland are elected on vote shares of less than 30%. Our current electoral system has been shown up with how much power it hands to minority factions, that argument doesn't make sense.

And the price they'd extract for a coalition next time would be social care reforms, dealing with sewage discharges and water infrastructure, land market reform, increasing tax thresholds with inflation and constitutional reform. How extreme. I'm sure Starmer and Sunak would rather deal with those demands than the SCG and ERG loons.

1,2,3 At what cost? Probably one that a senior coalition partner would not want to be bound by.

4 There's a vote winner if ever there was one

1, 2 and 3 would cost less than increasing tax thresholds in line with inflation (1 would save money through more efficient allocation of social care funding and use of healthcare resources, Labour have also sounded out they want to deal with this as a priority and 3 would be revenue neutral), and I find it curious that you omitted the tax thresholds point.

As for 4, that's literally the only thing Labour had announced they were expending effort doing before their recent conference so I highly doubt it's a massive voter turnoff. Starmer has asked Brown to build a platform for constitutional reform, do you think that's going to be omitted from the manifesto?

(10-12-2023, 12:08 PM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 08:19 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 03:44 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I don't know where this idea that the Conservatives are finished comes from.

It's very likely they will be booted out of office next year, and deservedly so, but they are unlikely to be uncompetitive in the election after. Which is very scary, given the direction of travel the party is currently on.

It's why PR is a voting red line for me, if a party does not support electoral reform it's not getting my vote.

It did look for a brief moment that Labour might get behind electoral reform, but that ship has passed, mainly because they look likely to get a majority at the next election, and see no need for it now. Short sighted.

We need genuine and real choice that produces representation at parliament that is reflective of a wide range of political views, even if you really don't like some of those views, to pretendvthey don't exist is dangerous.

There is a real danger that in 2028 or 2029 we elect a very nationalistic govt that seek to restrict the ability of opposition voices to express their opinion, what I understand is describe as the Hungrification of UK politics. Such a Govt could be elected with relatively small levels of support.

This is the best argument against PR I've read - although written from a Labour perspective it nails it for me (Easy read)

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/proportional-representation-labour-party-lib-dems

Nonsense article. Written purely from a perspective of wanting a two-party system instead of democratic representation and snacks of the typical Labour Party entitlement that they automatically deserve voters instead of having to work for them.

If there were PR then Labour can do away with the left of their party more easily and work with the overlapping interests in the Liberal Democrats.

Also, actually celebrating that voters are disenfranchised for not voting for the "big two"? Seriously

Slight overaction and hardly nonsense - it's a well put together logical argument as to why PR is not a good idea for the Labour Party. Anybody who has to use  the "It's not democracy argument really gets up my tits"  the whining Left in the LP are always bleating about democracy, but they ain't as bad as the pathetic bunch that are the Lib Dems who should never be forgiven for 2010 -2015. We had a referendum on PR and it was rejected (awaits the bleating "It wasn't proper PR") The soft/hard left in the LP have to have a PR motion every fucking year why? Coz theyre fucking losers. We have a proper Social Democratic Party now and many Torys will be joining and/or voting for it. Equally you have absolutely no idea what may happen if we do have PR and cunts likw Farige and Tommy Robinson get to sit on the green benches. If you want to enable  a far right Tory Party by not voting Labour get on with it - but away with "It's not democracy" bullshit.

It's complete nonsense and the entire premise relies on the patronising view that Labour are entitled in perpetuity to the anti-Tory vote.

We have never had a referendum on PR, we had a referendum on AV which is explicitly not PR.

The "SDP" are Reform, and they are only known to permanently online people who hate gay and brown people but also like big government spending. And I assure you that the MP to my immediate north, Zarah Sultana, would most certainly not be an MP for a truly social democratic party so I don't class Labour as one - unlike the true social democratic parties in Germany, Austria and the Nordic countries. Zarah Sultana would never be elected for the Norwegian Labour Party.

The Lib Dems went into coalition in 2010 because there was no alternative, they had no funding left for another election and the numbers did not add up for any alternative even accounting for APNI and SDLP MPs. Furthermore, you need only look at the difference between 2010-2015 and 2015-now to see how the Lib Dems kept the Tory loons in check.

And without PR we have Suella Braverman as Home Secretary (even after she was sacked for being a national security threat). Liz Truss became Prime Minister for god's sakes. Really great system we have there, really keeping the extremists away from the thresholds of power.

Also, further to countering the blinkered entitlement of Labour activists that they are entitled to the anti-Tory vote the only party that stands a chance of winning in my constituency other than Tories is the Lib Dems. If I vote Labour I would be helping the Tories. So I think I'll not vote Labour at the next election, thanks.


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Pontificator - 10-13-2023

(10-12-2023, 01:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 12:08 PM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2023, 08:19 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 03:44 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I don't know where this idea that the Conservatives are finished comes from.

It's very likely they will be booted out of office next year, and deservedly so, but they are unlikely to be uncompetitive in the election after. Which is very scary, given the direction of travel the party is currently on.

It's why PR is a voting red line for me, if a party does not support electoral reform it's not getting my vote.

It did look for a brief moment that Labour might get behind electoral reform, but that ship has passed, mainly because they look likely to get a majority at the next election, and see no need for it now. Short sighted.

We need genuine and real choice that produces representation at parliament that is reflective of a wide range of political views, even if you really don't like some of those views, to pretendvthey don't exist is dangerous.

There is a real danger that in 2028 or 2029 we elect a very nationalistic govt that seek to restrict the ability of opposition voices to express their opinion, what I understand is describe as the Hungrification of UK politics. Such a Govt could be elected with relatively small levels of support.

This is the best argument against PR I've read - although written from a Labour perspective it nails it for me (Easy read)

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/proportional-representation-labour-party-lib-dems

Nonsense article. Written purely from a perspective of wanting a two-party system instead of democratic representation and snacks of the typical Labour Party entitlement that they automatically deserve voters instead of having to work for them.

If there were PR then Labour can do away with the left of their party more easily and work with the overlapping interests in the Liberal Democrats.

Also, actually celebrating that voters are disenfranchised for not voting for the "big two"? Seriously

Slight overaction and hardly nonsense - it's a well put together logical argument as to why PR is not a good idea for the Labour Party. Anybody who has to use  the "It's not democracy argument really gets up my tits"  the whining Left in the LP are always bleating about democracy, but they ain't as bad as the pathetic bunch that are the Lib Dems who should never be forgiven for 2010 -2015. We had a referendum on PR and it was rejected (awaits the bleating "It wasn't proper PR") The soft/hard left in the LP have to have a PR motion every fucking year why? Coz theyre fucking losers. We have a proper Social Democratic Party now and many Torys will be joining and/or voting for it. Equally you have absolutely no idea what may happen if we do have PR and cunts likw Farige and Tommy Robinson get to sit on the green benches. If you want to enable  a far right Tory Party by not voting Labour get on with it - but away with "It's not democracy" bullshit.

We did not have a referendum on pr...whether the right sort or not.

It was a referendum on the Alternative vote which in essence is another first past the post system, albeit by a more indirect route.

If the eleectorate had walked into the polling booth with full fat PR on offer it would have been rejected - end of


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Protheroe - 10-13-2023

(10-13-2023, 06:50 AM)Pontificator Wrote: If the eleectorate had walked into the polling booth with full fat PR on offer it would have been rejected - end of

That is true.


RE: Has the EU ended the Tory Party? - Shabby Russian - 10-13-2023

(10-13-2023, 07:19 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 06:50 AM)Pontificator Wrote: If the eleectorate had walked into the polling booth with full fat PR on offer it would have been rejected - end of

That is true.

But they weren't   so this is just speculation.