WBAUnofficial
VAR - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: VAR (/showthread.php?tid=31292)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: VAR - Borin' Baggie - 09-25-2023

Would help if we knew what the hell the referees were basing decisions on, like with every other video review system


RE: VAR - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 09-25-2023

Funny though, that for years managers, Mark Hughes for example, raged that terrible decisions cost his team, refs should have video assistance, the technology exists etc, etc. Now they have VAR, they moan that it was an awful decision, the ref bottled it, if you are giving a penalty for that, if a bloke at Stockley Park is telling the ref that, VAR is ruining football etc.
Personally, I think if a ref is dreadful on the pitch, why would he be any better watching a video, Mike `I didn`t send the ref to the monitor because he is my mate` Dean, Bobby Madley for instance.


RE: VAR - Bob Fossil - 09-25-2023

The only way it becomes truly fair an unbiased is if it's completely automated, using sensors or whatever. As long as there is human involvement it will be fallible and open to abuse.
Bin it and only try again when it's truly fit for purpose.

Re-iterate my feeling though that the powers that be prefer it to be "ambiguous" because it means they can influence it to their own ends.


RE: VAR - Fido - 09-25-2023

(09-25-2023, 01:44 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: Funny though,  that for years managers, Mark Hughes for example, raged that terrible decisions cost his team, refs should have video assistance, the technology exists etc, etc. Now they have VAR, they moan that it was an awful decision, the ref bottled it, if you are giving a penalty for that, if a bloke at Stockley Park is telling the ref that, VAR is ruining football etc.
Personally, I think if a ref is dreadful on the pitch, why would he be any better watching a video, Mike `I didn`t send the ref to the monitor because he is my mate` Dean, Bobby Madley for instance.

That Dean admission was frankly incredible. Just think of the possible financial implications for a club/employees/supporters because someone didn’t want someone else’s feelings hurt.


RE: VAR - backsidebaggie - 09-25-2023

(09-25-2023, 01:49 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The only way it becomes truly fair an unbiased is if it's completely automated, using sensors or whatever. As long as there is human involvement it will be fallible and open to abuse.
Bin it and only try again when it's truly fit for purpose.

Re-iterate my feeling though that the powers that be prefer it to be "ambiguous" because it means they can influence it to their own ends.

The laws of the game are in the main subjective though. There has to be human involvement, there’s no other way (apart fro thing like ball over line). That’s why it can never be fit for purpose. You can have a million angles and there’ll still be differences in opinion as to whether something is a foul.

And this is why it’s solved nothing (apart from overturning the absolute massive errors that happen from time to time).


RE: VAR - AnelkasBeard - 09-25-2023

(09-25-2023, 01:58 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-25-2023, 01:49 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The only way it becomes truly fair an unbiased is if it's completely automated, using sensors or whatever. As long as there is human involvement it will be fallible and open to abuse.
Bin it and only try again when it's truly fit for purpose.

Re-iterate my feeling though that the powers that be prefer it to be "ambiguous" because it means they can influence it to their own ends.

The laws of the game are in the main subjective though. There has to be human involvement, there’s no other way (apart fro thing like ball over line). That’s why it can never be fit for purpose. You can have a million angles and there’ll still be differences in opinion as to whether something is a foul.

And this is why it’s solved nothing (apart from overturning the absolute massive errors that happen from time to time).

This is why we need to hear what the refs are saying. They should be mic'd up, the VAR conversations should be heard. But it hasn't even happened before where refs explain their decisions, so it will never happen.


RE: VAR - backsidebaggie - 09-25-2023

(09-25-2023, 02:14 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(09-25-2023, 01:58 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-25-2023, 01:49 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The only way it becomes truly fair an unbiased is if it's completely automated, using sensors or whatever. As long as there is human involvement it will be fallible and open to abuse.
Bin it and only try again when it's truly fit for purpose.

Re-iterate my feeling though that the powers that be prefer it to be "ambiguous" because it means they can influence it to their own ends.

The laws of the game are in the main subjective though. There has to be human involvement, there’s no other way (apart fro thing like ball over line). That’s why it can never be fit for purpose. You can have a million angles and there’ll still be differences in opinion as to whether something is a foul.

And this is why it’s solved nothing (apart from overturning the absolute massive errors that happen from time to time).

This is why we need to hear what the refs are saying. They should be mic'd up, the VAR conversations should be heard. But it hasn't even happened before where refs explain their decisions, so it will never happen.

That would just give something else for everyone to argue about IMO, and don’t solve a thing. And take us another step nearer NFL.

I think just fuck VAR off.


RE: VAR - Bob Fossil - 09-25-2023

(09-25-2023, 01:58 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-25-2023, 01:49 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The only way it becomes truly fair an unbiased is if it's completely automated, using sensors or whatever. As long as there is human involvement it will be fallible and open to abuse.
Bin it and only try again when it's truly fit for purpose.

Re-iterate my feeling though that the powers that be prefer it to be "ambiguous" because it means they can influence it to their own ends.

The laws of the game are in the main subjective though. There has to be human involvement, there’s no other way (apart fro thing like ball over line). That’s why it can never be fit for purpose. You can have a million angles and there’ll still be differences in opinion as to whether something is a foul.

And this is why it’s solved nothing (apart from overturning the absolute massive errors that happen from time to time).
Technology will eventually take over positional decisions like offsides, inside the box or outside, etc. with the use of sensors, but the rest will always be ambiguous so should not apply.