WBAUnofficial
Player Ratings v Boro - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Player Ratings v Boro (/showthread.php?tid=30994)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Player Ratings v Boro - Tom Joad - 08-28-2023

(08-27-2023, 10:32 PM)igorbalis Wrote: dont get the love in for phillips, any decent full back would have prevented the cross for their first, i know he's no full back but apart from that had one of his better games, rather start with Townsend than philips - mom - kipre 8 everyone else 7

I disagree. Almost all our attacks were via Phillips and we missed his direct approach when he was subbed. I maintain it was as much the loss of Phillips ( as Okay), that handed the initiative to 'boro.


RE: Player Ratings v Boro - SW4Baggie - 08-28-2023

(08-28-2023, 07:51 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(08-27-2023, 10:32 PM)igorbalis Wrote: dont get the love in for phillips, any decent full back would have prevented the cross for their first, i know he's no full back but apart from that had one of his better games, rather start with Townsend than philips - mom - kipre 8 everyone else 7

I disagree. Almost all our attacks were via Phillips and we missed his direct approach when he was subbed. I maintain it was as much the loss of Phillips ( as Okay), that handed the initiative to 'boro.

Agree - for all his faults over the last few years, Phillips is probably one of our most important players, it’s no coincidence that our form collapsed with his injury last year


RE: Player Ratings v Boro - Sliced - 08-28-2023

He's certainly been our best player this season.

I thought Boro looked pretty decent, better than some of the other teams we've played this season despite the bad start.


RE: Player Ratings v Boro - Johnnykayeengland - 08-28-2023

(08-26-2023, 09:04 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Palmer 7 Couple of good stops, no chance with the goals, decent on the ball but would have liked him to command his box a bit better today

Furlong 6 Mixed bag, clearly a position CC wants competition for and let’s hope he gets it.

Phillips 8 Excellent showing for 60 until he hit the fitness wall, full of running and a constant threat, could have prevented cross for their first but was left exposed with Molumby being off the pitch

Ajayi 8* Thouht he was good today, nearly caught on the ball first half but generally his passing was good, switches of play was excellent and was good in the air

Pieters 6 Slow and loses way too much in the air, targeted with pace down our left as most teams go at him. OK in possession but ideally we should be improving this position if we can

Kipre 8 Good passing, great goal and an assured display, we will play out from the back and frankly he’s the best we’ve got at it

Turk 6 Gets better when he goes off the pitch as we seem to fall apart but not quite up to his levels of last season yet and I’m his biggest fan

Molumby 7 Full of running as always, sometimes too negative in possession but one of the rare times he opened up his body when receiving the ball and looked forward we scored the excellent 2nd goal, he needs to do a bit more of that

Swift 8 Much more like it and a great goal, found some great dangerous areas to receive the ball and increases work rate

Wallace 6 Worked his socks off but this system certainly negates his greatest strengths which is a shame

BTA 8 Fantastic shift, some real clever link up play and showed excellent footwork on more than one occasion. Real fan favorite as gives his all every time he dons he shirt

Subs

Townsend 7 Good energy, bit wasteful with final ball at times but got in some good positions

Mowatt 7 Thought he did really well today, pick of the subs, kept the ball well and full of running, nice ball for Sarmiento goal too

Chalobah 5 Seems to really struggle to get up to speed of the games when coming on, poor showing

Maja 6 Good running and some ok hold up play but expect a lot more, not the quickest, seemed to mistime a jump for a good headed chance and at times sloppy link play

Sarmiento 7 Gave it away early doors but desperately wants the ball and to make things happen, took his goal superbly. Question would be where do you play him as must be wanting to start soon

Good win, really poor we took our foot off the gas and played keep ball at 3-1 v 10, much better side go and get the fourth and kill any doubt, a win next week shoukd we manage it would be an excellent start given all the Shute going on up there

Cuzer
much better side go and get the fourth and kill any doubt

Isn't that the point?
We're not a "much better side".
CC is improving some good to OK players, sticking to his guns and convincing us fans that we've got a decent team. It's at a point where the whole is becoming better than the sum of the parts isn't it?
That's why football is a team game.
7th is brilliant, and I'll be surprised if we finish that high, sadly.
I'm happy to trust his judgement, -with the centre halves, and even with the latest scapegoat.


RE: Player Ratings v Boro - Cuzer - 08-28-2023

It’s a confidence game Jonny and we slipped, for me, into quite a lethargic approach at 3-1 against 10 which made it a lot more nerve wracking than it should ever have been

Agree we’re in transition and nobody complaining about the start, especially should we pick up 3 points Saturday before the International break, and we manage to get the couple in, and likely couple out, CC wants

Cuzer


RE: Player Ratings v Boro - MrFizz - 08-28-2023

(08-28-2023, 08:06 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(08-26-2023, 09:04 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Palmer 7 Couple of good stops, no chance with the goals, decent on the ball but would have liked him to command his box a bit better today

Furlong 6 Mixed bag, clearly a position CC wants competition for and let’s hope he gets it.

Phillips 8 Excellent showing for 60 until he hit the fitness wall, full of running and a constant threat, could have prevented cross for their first but was left exposed with Molumby being off the pitch

Ajayi 8* Thouht he was good today, nearly caught on the ball first half but generally his passing was good, switches of play was excellent and was good in the air

Pieters 6 Slow and loses way too much in the air, targeted with pace down our left as most teams go at him. OK in possession but ideally we should be improving this position if we can

Kipre 8 Good passing, great goal and an assured display, we will play out from the back and frankly he’s the best we’ve got at it

Turk 6 Gets better when he goes off the pitch as we seem to fall apart but not quite up to his levels of last season yet and I’m his biggest fan

Molumby 7 Full of running as always, sometimes too negative in possession but one of the rare times he opened up his body when receiving the ball and looked forward we scored the excellent 2nd goal, he needs to do a bit more of that

Swift 8 Much more like it and a great goal, found some great dangerous areas to receive the ball and increases work rate

Wallace 6 Worked his socks off but this system certainly negates his greatest strengths which is a shame

BTA 8 Fantastic shift, some real clever link up play and showed excellent footwork on more than one occasion. Real fan favorite as gives his all every time he dons he shirt

Subs

Townsend 7 Good energy, bit wasteful with final ball at times but got in some good positions

Mowatt 7 Thought he did really well today, pick of the subs, kept the ball well and full of running, nice ball for Sarmiento goal too

Chalobah 5 Seems to really struggle to get up to speed of the games when coming on, poor showing

Maja 6 Good running and some ok hold up play but expect a lot more, not the quickest, seemed to mistime a jump for a good headed chance and at times sloppy link play

Sarmiento 7 Gave it away early doors but desperately wants the ball and to make things happen, took his goal superbly. Question would be where do you play him as must be wanting to start soon

Good win, really poor we took our foot off the gas and played keep ball at 3-1 v 10, much better side go and get the fourth and kill any doubt, a win next week shoukd we manage it would be an excellent start given all the Shute going on up there

Cuzer
much better side go and get the fourth and kill any doubt

Isn't that the point?
We're not a "much better side".
CC is improving some good to OK players, sticking to his guns and convincing us fans that we've got a decent team. It's at a point where the whole is becoming better than the sum of the parts isn't it?
That's why football is a team game.
7th is brilliant, and I'll be surprised if we finish that high, sadly.
I'm happy to trust his judgement, -with the centre halves, and even with the latest scapegoat.

Its because we are not a 'much better side' that we can't afford to trot around trying to play passy passy keepball. Bilic's team could. This one can't. We are susceptible at the back, and therefore need to be 100% on it for 90mins. A two-goal lead is no guarantee of points with this squad.