WBAUnofficial
Plymouth Argyle - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Plymouth Argyle (/showthread.php?tid=29897)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Plymouth Argyle - GunsOfNavarone - 05-08-2023

(05-07-2023, 06:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-07-2023, 06:37 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(05-07-2023, 06:24 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-07-2023, 06:11 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Never forgiven them for knocking us out the 5th round in 85. Good trip though if it lands on a sunny weekend

Never get this logic.

It's sport, the other team's job is to try to beat you, I don't harbour a grudge against teams for beating us, unless there's a very good reason, Derby as an example.

I was only half serious Birdmao. It was hard to take at that age

Fair enough, I can get that.

I've heard people say that though, I hate this team because they beat us in this one game years ago.

I've hated QPR since 1967 and I wasn't even born until 1968. I've also hated Aston Villa since the first time they beat us although from memory I'm not entirely sure when that was but I know they deserve it more than QPR who also deserve it. Cunts.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - wbamitch - 05-08-2023

How was Finn Azaz for Plymouth this season, Birdy? I remember in the first half of the season seeing he had started well. Imagine he will get a loan in the championship next season


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Pragmatist - 05-08-2023

(05-07-2023, 10:13 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: A fine example on how a club should be run in this day and age.
The people running the show have to know what they're doing.
We don't have the people or the know how.
We are financially in the deep stuff. Administration needs to come very quickly before the asset stripping and fire sale begin. We may then have a chance to rebuild.
Tough times ahead - but we are Albion.

Anybody who thinks that going into administration would be a step forward for us needs to give their head a big wobble.  It would make things far worse than they are. 

There won’t be any “asset stripping”.  The strict terms of the MSD debenture prevents any money leaving the Group now while any of that £20m is outstanding.  If we don’t get a new owner then several players will get sold, which would stave off administration. 

Administration would not help Yunyai or Lai at all.  They would sell before that becomes a realistic possibility.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Remi_Moses - 05-08-2023

(05-08-2023, 06:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-07-2023, 10:13 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: A fine example on how a club should be run in this day and age.
The people running the show have to know what they're doing.
We don't have the people or the know how.
We are financially in the deep stuff. Administration needs to come very quickly before the asset stripping and fire sale begin. We may then have a chance to rebuild.
Tough times ahead - but we are Albion.

Anybody who thinks that going into administration would be a step forward for us needs to give their head a big wobble.  It would make things far worse than they are. 

There won’t be any “asset stripping”.  The strict terms of the MSD debenture prevents any money leaving the Group now while any of that £20m is outstanding.  If we don’t get a new owner then several players will get sold, which would stave off administration. 

Administration would not help Yunyai or Lai at all.  They would sell before that becomes a realistic possibility.

Unfortunately our thoughts differ. 
Money leaving is in your mind lump sums to Lai, my thoughts are the clubs substantial running costs. MSD have little or no control over already owed money or wages and contracts. Selling players to keep the club going is asset stripping IMO. 
This will continue to bleed the club to it's death.
The only option is to get investment and the Chinese won't solve that, so administration is the only way to reduce debt and change ownership.
The sooner the better to minimize the damage that increases every day.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Pragmatist - 05-08-2023

Maybe your use of the term “asset stripping” was incorrect. That terms refers to stripping assets from the club by the owner. Selling players to raise cash raises vital liquidity to meet running costs, which is definitely not “asset stripping”. There is no doubt that players need to be sold, probably even if we get a new owner.

There is no way that Lai or Yunyai will risk administration, under which they will lose everything. The MSD loan was taken out to buy time, to prevent the club running out of cash. A sale would recover at least £50m of their investment. I would expect something to happen within the next two months from now, whatever the final outcome of this season.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Tom Joad - 05-08-2023

(05-08-2023, 08:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Maybe your use of the term “asset stripping” was incorrect.  That terms refers to stripping assets from the club by the owner. Selling players to raise cash raises vital liquidity to meet running costs, which is definitely not “asset stripping”.  There is no doubt that players need to be sold, probably even if we get a new owner.

There is no way that Lai or Yunyai will risk administration, under which they will lose everything.  The MSD loan was taken out to buy time, to prevent the club running out of cash.  A sale would recover at least £50m of their investment.  I would expect something to happen within the next two months from now, whatever the final outcome of this season.

That's quite reassuring. Although where many millions are involved, often common sense plays no part. Generally because it is always "other people's money". Look at Blues, or Dr.Tony at villa. 
I never had a problem with Lai not putting millions in, the problem is him taking it out.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Birdman1811 - 05-08-2023

(05-08-2023, 06:27 AM)wbamitch Wrote: How was Finn Azaz for Plymouth this season, Birdy? I remember in the first half of the season seeing he had started well. Imagine he will get a loan in the championship next season

He got injured and took a while to get back, but he's been impressive. Very lightweight though, physical teams stopped him.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Remi_Moses - 05-08-2023

(05-08-2023, 08:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Maybe your use of the term “asset stripping” was incorrect.  That terms refers to stripping assets from the club by the owner. Selling players to raise cash raises vital liquidity to meet running costs, which is definitely not “asset stripping”.  There is no doubt that players need to be sold, probably even if we get a new owner.

There is no way that Lai or Yunyai will risk administration, under which they will lose everything.  The MSD loan was taken out to buy time, to prevent the club running out of cash.  A sale would recover at least £50m of their investment.  I would expect something to happen within the next two months from now, whatever the final outcome of this season.

Players are traded for money, in my book that makes them assets.
A ground that can be sold is an asset.
So a player who can be sold must also be an asset.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Pragmatist - 05-08-2023

(05-08-2023, 10:41 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(05-08-2023, 08:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Maybe your use of the term “asset stripping” was incorrect.  That terms refers to stripping assets from the club by the owner. Selling players to raise cash raises vital liquidity to meet running costs, which is definitely not “asset stripping”.  There is no doubt that players need to be sold, probably even if we get a new owner.

There is no way that Lai or Yunyai will risk administration, under which they will lose everything.  The MSD loan was taken out to buy time, to prevent the club running out of cash.  A sale would recover at least £50m of their investment.  I would expect something to happen within the next two months from now, whatever the final outcome of this season.

Players are traded for money, in my book that makes them assets.
A ground that can be sold is an asset.
So a player who can be sold must also be an asset.

Simple accounting - player is an asset. Player gets sold for cash.  Cash comes in.  Cash is an asset.  One asset of identical value replaces another asset.  So no asset-stripping.  Asset-stripping is when the shareholders remove value from the balance sheet. Not the same at all.


RE: Plymouth Argyle - Calgary_Baggie - 05-08-2023

(05-08-2023, 10:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-08-2023, 10:41 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(05-08-2023, 08:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Maybe your use of the term “asset stripping” was incorrect.  That terms refers to stripping assets from the club by the owner. Selling players to raise cash raises vital liquidity to meet running costs, which is definitely not “asset stripping”.  There is no doubt that players need to be sold, probably even if we get a new owner.

There is no way that Lai or Yunyai will risk administration, under which they will lose everything.  The MSD loan was taken out to buy time, to prevent the club running out of cash.  A sale would recover at least £50m of their investment.  I would expect something to happen within the next two months from now, whatever the final outcome of this season.

Players are traded for money, in my book that makes them assets.
A ground that can be sold is an asset.
So a player who can be sold must also be an asset.

Simple accounting - player is an asset. Player gets sold for cash.  Cash comes in.  Cash is an asset.  One asset of identical value replaces another asset.  So no asset-stripping.  Asset-stripping is when the shareholders remove value from the balance sheet. Not the same at all.

What like the sale of Pereira?