WBAUnofficial
Is free speech over? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Is free speech over? (/showthread.php?tid=29186)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Is free speech over? - Remi_Moses - 03-11-2023

The free speech is no longer a viable option. No matter what you say someone will be upset. More often then not about what you didn't say.
The bigger issue will come when we as a society have to admit it has gone too far and a new rebellion begins.


RE: Is free speech over? - chasetownbaggie - 03-11-2023

(03-11-2023, 02:10 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(03-11-2023, 01:01 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Don’t know if this is politics but out with a mate last night and we were discussing this in light of the Lineker situation. 
Both of us think it is. 
The issue is cancel culture and it’s from the right and the left. 
People can not honesty say what they think about a host of things for fear of recriminations. 
As a nobody and the cloak of somewhat anonymity this forum gives we can sometimes say stuff here we wouldn’t dare say in a more visible forum. 
However, wherever I look now there seems an utter intolerance from so many sides to people expressing views they disagree with. 
Be it a footballer saying the government are cruel or a well known author saying biological women are different from a bloke who puts on a pair of false ones and gets the Guardian to call him she.
From your right the left and friggin everywhere I see the ability to tolerate views diminished. 
Am I an old man yelling at a cloud or do I have a point? 
I think those with tolerance will know the answer.

What about mcarthyism in the 50s?

Personally, I see this as evidence of exactly the opposite to your viewpoint.
In times gone by, he would have been blacklisted.

The only difference from times gone by is that Lineker and his mates don't need the money and the balance of power has shifted, so its harder for the BBC to muzzle them.

In an employment contract there is always a clause about bringing the company into disrepute and I would imagine that the BBC whose very charter rests upon being politically neutral has something telling it's 'talent' to tow the neutral line.

The minute you sign an employment contract - or any other contract - you are limiting your freedoms.
But the freedom comes in your choice of deciding whether to sign their contract. 
He chose to sign the contract.

He hasn't broken any rules if the tweet I saw showing the BBC guidelines can be believed


RE: Is free speech over? - Spandaubaggie - 03-12-2023

(03-11-2023, 03:01 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The free speech is no longer a viable option. No matter what you say someone will be upset. More often then not about what you didn't say.
The bigger issue will come when we as a society have to admit it has gone too far and a new rebellion begins.

Had a good chat with 2 chaps at the Hawthorns station waiting for the train back yesterday. We all came to the conclusion that social media and the inability to understand its reach is the problem for many.
For instance if a guy who is racist in a pub with his Neanderthal friends and uses a slur his mates will agree and laugh etc. His message is to the right audience. 
However if that same message goes out to all and sundry via Twitter then he’s going to be challenged. 
Lineker in the same way made a stick for his back with the Nazi comparison.


RE: Is free speech over? - Remi_Moses - 03-12-2023

(03-12-2023, 09:10 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-11-2023, 03:01 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The free speech is no longer a viable option. No matter what you say someone will be upset. More often then not about what you didn't say.
The bigger issue will come when we as a society have to admit it has gone too far and a new rebellion begins.

Had a good chat with 2 chaps at the Hawthorns station waiting for the train back yesterday. We all came to the conclusion that social media and the inability to understand its reach is the problem. 
For instance if a guy who is racist in a pub with his Neanderthal friends and uses a slur his mates will agree and laugh etc. His message is to the right audience. 
However if that same message goes out to all and sundry via Twitter then he’s going to be challenged. 
Lineker in the same way made a stick for his back with the Nazi comparison.

Was chatting about this subject with some English and French friends and they came to the conclusion the media is no longer representative of reality. Instead of taking it with a pinch of salt some people are manipulating it for their own agenda.


RE: Is free speech over? - Spandaubaggie - 03-12-2023

(03-12-2023, 09:28 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-12-2023, 09:10 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-11-2023, 03:01 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The free speech is no longer a viable option. No matter what you say someone will be upset. More often then not about what you didn't say.
The bigger issue will come when we as a society have to admit it has gone too far and a new rebellion begins.

Had a good chat with 2 chaps at the Hawthorns station waiting for the train back yesterday. We all came to the conclusion that social media and the inability to understand its reach is the problem. 
For instance if a guy who is racist in a pub with his Neanderthal friends and uses a slur his mates will agree and laugh etc. His message is to the right audience. 
However if that same message goes out to all and sundry via Twitter then he’s going to be challenged. 
Lineker in the same way made a stick for his back with the Nazi comparison.

Was chatting about this subject with some English and French friends and they came to the conclusion the media is no longer representative of reality. Instead of taking it with a pinch of salt some people are manipulating it for their own agenda.

Yes that’s certainly true. Thing is so many get on their high horse and try to shame people who disagree with them as if their views are evil. 
We’ve seen it here.


RE: Is free speech over? - Derek Hardballs - 03-12-2023

The irony of a message board thread asking if free speech is dead seems to have escaped some.


RE: Is free speech over? - Tom Joad - 03-12-2023

fuzzbox Wrote:
SussexBaggie Wrote:
fuzzbox Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:Don’t know if this is politics but out with a mate last night and we were discussing this in light of the Lineker situation. 
Both of us think it is. 
The issue is cancel culture and it’s from the right and the left. 
People can not honesty say what they think about a host of things for fear of recriminations. 
As a nobody and the cloak of somewhat anonymity this forum gives we can sometimes say stuff here we wouldn’t dare say in a more visible forum. 
However, wherever I look now there seems an utter intolerance from so many sides to people expressing views they disagree with. 
Be it a footballer saying the government are cruel or a well known author saying biological women are different from a bloke who puts on a pair of false ones and gets the Guardian to call him she.
From your right the left and friggin everywhere I see the ability to tolerate views diminished. 
Am I an old man yelling at a cloud or do I have a point? 
I think those with tolerance will know the answer.

What about mcarthyism in the 50s?

Personally, I see this as evidence of exactly the opposite to your viewpoint.
In times gone by, he would have been blacklisted.

The only difference from times gone by is that Lineker and his mates don't need the money and the balance of power has shifted, so its harder for the BBC to muzzle them.

In an employment contract there is always a clause about bringing the company into disrepute and I would imagine that the BBC whose very charter rests upon being politically neutral has something telling it's 'talent' to tow the neutral line.

The minute you sign an employment contract - or any other contract - you are limiting your freedoms.
But the freedom comes in your choice of deciding whether to sign their contract. 
He chose to sign the contract.
is he employed? Though he was self-employed or through his own company in which case he is withdrawing his services (after pressure of course); anyway, the BBC don't care a fig about contracts, and regularly tear them up, walk away or sack people early. The top of the BBC is riddled with such power-mad petulance; their behaviours are simply not sustainable in a world where everyone wants to talk or know about everything.

That's irrelevant. In fact, it weakens his position. He doesn't even have employment laws to fall back on. When his 'company' signed the deal, it would still have the same clauses.

I work in entertainment, although more b, c and d listers and I know that if any of them came to me I would tell them the same thing. Say what you like but risk losing the business. Especially on the bbc, ITV, Disney or any of the big american networks. It's always been that way in the forty years I've been doing it.

It used to be worse, because once they had blacklisted you, you had nowhere else to go. Now, not so much. There is always netflix, sky or amazon.....as Jeremy clarkson, Piers Morgan and that weird right wing woman who I've forgotten her name  will tell you.

If anything, celebrities have more 'free speech' than they ever did.
 She sought fame and fortune by saying offensive things and no one remembers her name.  Wonderful!