WBAUnofficial
HS2 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: HS2 (/showthread.php?tid=28601)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: HS2 - Hopalong - 01-29-2023

It's 1hr 20m from the 'stone £25.90 OPR.  

Come on Board!   Big Grin


RE: HS2 - BurleyBaggie - 01-29-2023

HS2 isn’t about speed it’s mostly about capacity. Yes there will be economic benefit and redistribution of wealth, which there are well founded use cases on, as it allows people to work in or commute into London at further distances. It also allows regional hubs for big corps to be more effective.

Though as I started it’s all about capacity: you simply cannot keep upgrading track, even now post pandemic, we have more people using the railways than we did 10 years ago. The need for regional services to use mainlines means at some point everything is going to crunch. If we also want to move more freight onto rail (decarbonise and reduce congestion on the roads) we have to build more rail, the original Y shape from London to Birmingham branching to Manchester and Leeds was designed specifically to reduce traffic and use by national services on the East and West Coast mainlines.

This allowed more capacity for freight, but also an increase to regional services who need to use those lines to serve communities - like Doncaster, Wakefield, Huddersfield etc who all interconnect on the ECML.

I’m a bit tired of people in the media claiming we don’t need quicker services (ok fair) but a) even a country our size lags behind on high speed rail b) this is about capacity to improve local services and b) those eco warrior NIMBYs claiming it’s spoiling our green and pleasant land should consider the millions of CO2 being pumped into the atmosphere by freight unable to use the railways - that ultimately will have a much more severe impact to their back field. 

Sorry. Rant over.


RE: HS2 - Fulham Fallout - 01-29-2023

(01-29-2023, 11:38 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: HS2 isn’t about speed it’s mostly about capacity. Yes there will be economic benefit and redistribution of wealth, which there are well founded use cases on, as it allows people to work in or commute into London at further distances. It also allows regional hubs for big corps to be more effective.

Though as I started it’s all about capacity: you simply cannot keep upgrading track, even now post pandemic, we have more people using the railways than we did 10 years ago. The need for regional services to use mainlines means at some point everything is going to crunch. If we also want to move more freight onto rail (decarbonise and reduce congestion on the roads) we have to build more rail, the original Y shape from London to Birmingham branching to Manchester and Leeds was designed specifically to reduce traffic and use by national services on the East and West Coast mainlines.

This allowed more capacity for freight, but also an increase to regional services who need to use those lines to serve communities - like Doncaster, Wakefield, Huddersfield etc who all interconnect on the ECML.

I’m a bit tired of people in the media claiming we don’t need quicker services (ok fair) but a) even a country our size lags behind on high speed rail b) this is about capacity to improve local services and b) those eco warrior NIMBYs claiming it’s spoiling our green and pleasant land should consider the millions of CO2 being pumped into the atmosphere by freight unable to use the railways - that ultimately will have a much more severe impact to their back field. 

Sorry. Rant over.

Companies won’t pay the higher rail fare for the average employee, when they can catch a virgin or chiltern train for a lot less. It will only be top executives who will use the line. 

As mentioned, with more people remote working there’s now far less demand to travel to London than ever before.  Add to this companies moving out of London for cheaper rent & staff costs (see HSBC retail head office on Broad Street when it used to be in Canary Wharf. 

Royal Bank of Scotland closed 5 large offices in London and sent the jobs abroad, Manchester & Edinburgh or got rid of the job completely. 

RBS also introduced compulsory 3 day home working each week in order to reduce office space and therefore rent. You also had to have a decent reason why you needed to travel to London and not have a video call.  This was way before Covid came along. 

HS2 may have been a good idea at the outset, but it’s looking a bad decision with hindsight due to the changes companies have made in the way their employees work and where.


RE: HS2 - BurleyBaggie - 01-29-2023

Rail use is at 81% of pre pandemic use growing every quarter when you factor in the strikes in Q4. The assertion Rail use is declining isn’t quite accurate. However again it comes to capacity.

Capacity on the network even for 81% train occupancy doesn’t mean we can reduce rolling stock in the lines. As anyone knows who has commuted into any major city in the last 12 months. Also, as per the last ORR capacity and utilisation data the network runs at near full capacity on a daily basis and freight on the line peaked in 2006/7 again according to the ORR.

The passenger number stat and trend is a misnomer - we barely run enough trains for current demand - the line capacity of the network is almost maxed.

HS2 delivers vital capacity on the WCML and ECML - aside from the fact they’ve canned the leeds line (no surprise for a southern based gov)  -  but where it will will run it delivers that capacity. People keep saying forget HS2 invest in regional rail - it’s not binary, if we don’t invest in intercity we can’t improve local.

On a personal view - I find it incredible we even contemplate not investing in rail and high speed rail. We lag so far behind, infrastructure investments of all the money gov spends yield more benefit to the economy. This is especially true in HS2 Where so many of the contracts are to UK based firms. We build less rail per capita than any of the G7.


RE: HS2 - coxy134 - 01-29-2023

Bit like midland metro. (wednesbury to B'hill) now only going to Dudley.

It was planned to start in 1996 then put back years and years due to cost etc. We never seem to get such big projects within budget or kicked off on time.


RE: HS2 - Fulham Fallout - 01-29-2023

(01-29-2023, 04:49 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Rail use is at 81% of pre pandemic use growing every quarter when you factor in the strikes in Q4. The assertion Rail use is declining isn’t quite accurate. However again it comes to capacity.

Capacity on the network even for 81% train occupancy doesn’t mean we can reduce rolling stock in the lines. As anyone knows who has commuted into any major city in the last 12 months. Also, as per the last ORR capacity and utilisation data the network runs at near full capacity on a daily basis and freight on the line peaked in 2006/7 again according to the ORR.

The passenger number stat and trend is a misnomer - we barely run enough trains for current demand - the line capacity of the network is almost maxed.

HS2 delivers vital capacity on the WCML and ECML - aside from the fact they’ve canned the leeds line (no surprise for a southern based gov)  -  but where it will will run it delivers that capacity. People keep saying forget HS2 invest in regional rail - it’s not binary, if we don’t invest in intercity we can’t improve local.

On a personal view - I find it incredible we even contemplate not investing in rail and high speed rail. We lag so far behind, infrastructure investments of all the money gov spends yield more benefit to the economy. This is especially true in HS2 Where so many of the contracts are to UK based firms. We build less rail per capita than any of the G7.

And takes a fucking lot longer and costs a ducking load more than originally budgeted.  And that’s without removing the Leeds link.


RE: HS2 - BurleyBaggie - 01-29-2023

(01-29-2023, 05:43 PM)coxy134 Wrote: Bit like midland metro. (wednesbury to B'hill) now only going to Dudley.

It was planned to start in 1996 then put back years and years due to cost etc. We never seem to get such big projects within budget or kicked off on time.

This. 

The cost per kilometre in the UK is highest in Europe. Mainly due to our prohibitive planning laws and appeals system. There’s tonnes of research on it. 

Appeals allow for delays that allow for political pressure that allow for u-turns, cut backs or delays that result in capital projects going majorly over budget.


RE: HS2 - Derek Hardballs - 01-29-2023

(01-29-2023, 05:55 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(01-29-2023, 05:43 PM)coxy134 Wrote: Bit like midland metro. (wednesbury to B'hill) now only going to Dudley.

It was planned to start in 1996 then put back years and years due to cost etc. We never seem to get such big projects within budget or kicked off on time.

This. 

The cost per kilometre in the UK is highest in Europe. Mainly due to our prohibitive planning laws and appeals system. There’s tonnes of research on it. 

Appeals allow for delays that allow for political pressure that allow for u-turns, cut backs or delays that result in capital projects going majorly over budget.

Heaven forbid local communities and those concerned about the environment should be listened to. Just let corporations and governments do wtf they like, where they like.


RE: HS2 - BurleyBaggie - 01-29-2023

(01-29-2023, 06:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-29-2023, 05:55 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(01-29-2023, 05:43 PM)coxy134 Wrote: Bit like midland metro. (wednesbury to B'hill) now only going to Dudley.

It was planned to start in 1996 then put back years and years due to cost etc. We never seem to get such big projects within budget or kicked off on time.

This. 

The cost per kilometre in the UK is highest in Europe. Mainly due to our prohibitive planning laws and appeals system. There’s tonnes of research on it. 

Appeals allow for delays that allow for political pressure that allow for u-turns, cut backs or delays that result in capital projects going majorly over budget.

Heaven forbid local communities and those concerned about the environment should be listened to. Just let corporations and governments do wtf they like, where they like.

We have some of the tightest environmental protections in the world. You only have to look at the third runway at Heathrow to see that - 25 years later. 

However I totally agree in local input and communities working together on local Issues. The problem with the UK planning system is it is too far weighted to NIMBYism, especially in affluent areas, than actual relevant objections. Also, environmental issues is a broad church, a spoiled vista in a landowners back field versus millions of tonnes of carbon not being pumped into the atmospheres. It’s complex and needs to be considered on a macro and micro level.


RE: HS2 - Tom Joad - 01-29-2023

I take BurleyBaggie's point -particularly about capacity-  but still have hefty misgivings over HS2. Firstly, the much vaunted "slashed" journey time shaves off a mere 10 minutes over the current speed, but it does drop you off 10 minutes from Brum City Centre. Next, the cost and under use of HS1 doesnt appear to have been considered before commiting to this huge spend up.  Also, By hurtling between London, Brum and Manchester, it is catering for less people, surely a train stopping at all stations between would be more inclusive. Then again, inclusivity is hardly a government concern. The cynical side of me thinks it is all about getting people to London. I really think we need more East to West lines and much less focus on London and the SE.