WBAUnofficial
This loan - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This loan (/showthread.php?tid=27432)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: This loan - baggiebloke - 10-30-2022

Furthermore, it is certain that the lender would want first charge on the shrine, the training ground and probably Greggs.

Tangible assets only for any transaction with our lot.


RE: This loan - Peachy - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 06:50 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Furthermore, it is certain that the lender would want first charge on the shrine, the training ground and probably Greggs.

Big Ron has sanctioned the first two but he said under no circumstances would he agree to the third.....


RE: This loan - Pragmatist - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 06:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 05:45 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 05:36 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The loan would almost certainly be secured by legal charges and a debenture. Ironically that is a positive in that the ground then can't be separated from the club unless a "newco" buys these assets from the club (hence the cash injection) and then mortgages them. The club then enters into a lease to rent the ground/training ground etc. I can't see them being worth £35M though, which is what you would need to borrow £25M against them.

MDS are associated with Michael Dell of Dell computers. From what I can see, the loans are usually Interest Only, and for a 5 year period.

Lai would hope to secure promotion and sell in that time. I would guess there are various bonuses etc payable to MDS if this happens. If we don't achieve it though, you can look towards Derby for an outcome. I would think MDS  would  be cautious until our Chump position is looking safer. If you want to get to the promised land, you don't want to be starting in the First Division.

Good points KKC

What we need to find out is whether this would be (a) a loan by MSD to West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited, secured by a charge over its 100% shareholding of the new clean Jersey company, or (b) a loan to the new clean Jersey company secured by a charge over its 88% shareholding in West Bromwich Albion Group Limited (which operates the club and owns the ground), or © a loan to West Bromwich Albion Group Limited secured by a debenture over its assets including a charge on the ground. 

If its (a) or (b) then its really nothing to be concerned about as it’s not the club’s risk at all.  If it’s © then it’s obviously a real concern.   My gut feeling is that it’s most likely to be (b) which is by far the neatest and easiest to make a loan to, and a charge over that company’s 88% shareholding is also very clean and simple and reflects the value of that 88% shareholding (probably around £50m).

If it is a or b, then MDS can't get their hands on the ground,and the owner can deal with them as they see fit. I couldn't see MDS agreeing to this.

I would almost welcome C, because it takes the ground out of the equation and keeps everything together. The most problematic problems faced by Derby and now Blues is trying to repatriate the two.

None of the scenarios are good news though. High risk and expensive.

Not quite - there could be Reserved Matters built into the loan agreement re the ground.   I’m not sure I follow your logic re Option C.  Keeping it all together in that way shifts the risk of the debt back into the football club rather than leaving the risk with the top two companies which are both 100% owned by Yunwai - so solely at their risk.


RE: This loan - baggiebloke - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 07:00 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 06:50 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Furthermore, it is certain that the lender would want first charge on the shrine, the training ground and probably Greggs.

Big Ron has sanctioned the first two but he said under no circumstances would he agree to the third.....

You're right.

The BFG refers to Greggs as the shrine...


RE: This loan - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 06:20 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 06:09 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: ‘This Loan’ would make a great but gritty, amusing at times, semi-biographic BBC3 or E4 fiction of semi-youthful professionals making their way in the brutal world of corporate football.

Phil Jupitus should play Gourlay. We can break the budget to get Daniel Dae Kim in to play Lia (he could probably shoot all his scenes in a fucking afternoon take anyway so why not reel him in). For Corberan, possibly the dark-eyed gay lad from Corrie with that sexy scar on his face. We’re lacking a female lead of course but we can write in Michelle Davies somehow. Sarah Parish is standing by.

Will this sexy quartet secure the loan, from big bad Michael Dell (Adrian Dunbar)? Find out only on Birdbox.

Your posts are more entertaining then anything on the pitch at the moment.

Yes but I could be writing in the style of Dan Brown and that would still be true. Big Grin 

Thanks. Smile


RE: This loan - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 07:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 06:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 05:45 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 05:36 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The loan would almost certainly be secured by legal charges and a debenture. Ironically that is a positive in that the ground then can't be separated from the club unless a "newco" buys these assets from the club (hence the cash injection) and then mortgages them. The club then enters into a lease to rent the ground/training ground etc. I can't see them being worth £35M though, which is what you would need to borrow £25M against them.

MDS are associated with Michael Dell of Dell computers. From what I can see, the loans are usually Interest Only, and for a 5 year period.

Lai would hope to secure promotion and sell in that time. I would guess there are various bonuses etc payable to MDS if this happens. If we don't achieve it though, you can look towards Derby for an outcome. I would think MDS  would  be cautious until our Chump position is looking safer. If you want to get to the promised land, you don't want to be starting in the First Division.

Good points KKC

What we need to find out is whether this would be (a) a loan by MSD to West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited, secured by a charge over its 100% shareholding of the new clean Jersey company, or (b) a loan to the new clean Jersey company secured by a charge over its 88% shareholding in West Bromwich Albion Group Limited (which operates the club and owns the ground), or © a loan to West Bromwich Albion Group Limited secured by a debenture over its assets including a charge on the ground. 

If its (a) or (b) then its really nothing to be concerned about as it’s not the club’s risk at all.  If it’s © then it’s obviously a real concern.   My gut feeling is that it’s most likely to be (b) which is by far the neatest and easiest to make a loan to, and a charge over that company’s 88% shareholding is also very clean and simple and reflects the value of that 88% shareholding (probably around £50m).

If it is a or b, then MDS can't get their hands on the ground,and the owner can deal with them as they see fit. I couldn't see MDS agreeing to this.

I would almost welcome C, because it takes the ground out of the equation and keeps everything together. The most problematic problems faced by Derby and now Blues is trying to repatriate the two.

None of the scenarios are good news though. High risk and expensive.

Not quite - there could be Reserved Matters built into the loan agreement re the ground.   I’m not sure I follow your logic re Option C.  Keeping it all together in that way shifts the risk of the debt back into the football club rather than leaving the risk with the top two companies which are both 100% owned by Yunwai - so solely at their risk.

I've never seen a loan agreement written like that, Prag, but my background is bank debt rather than equity, which is a different game.

I take your points on option a and b, both which would be better for the club. Vanilla debt structures would call for inter-company composite guarantees- if Commercial Benefit could be proven.

Your background means you have seen more equity structures than me. I think it will be interesting to see both the corporate structure, and also the structure of the advance. Its probably wrong to call it a loan, because technically it might not be !!


RE: This loan - Pragmatist - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 08:27 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 07:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 06:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 05:45 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-30-2022, 05:36 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The loan would almost certainly be secured by legal charges and a debenture. Ironically that is a positive in that the ground then can't be separated from the club unless a "newco" buys these assets from the club (hence the cash injection) and then mortgages them. The club then enters into a lease to rent the ground/training ground etc. I can't see them being worth £35M though, which is what you would need to borrow £25M against them.

MDS are associated with Michael Dell of Dell computers. From what I can see, the loans are usually Interest Only, and for a 5 year period.

Lai would hope to secure promotion and sell in that time. I would guess there are various bonuses etc payable to MDS if this happens. If we don't achieve it though, you can look towards Derby for an outcome. I would think MDS  would  be cautious until our Chump position is looking safer. If you want to get to the promised land, you don't want to be starting in the First Division.

Good points KKC

What we need to find out is whether this would be (a) a loan by MSD to West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited, secured by a charge over its 100% shareholding of the new clean Jersey company, or (b) a loan to the new clean Jersey company secured by a charge over its 88% shareholding in West Bromwich Albion Group Limited (which operates the club and owns the ground), or © a loan to West Bromwich Albion Group Limited secured by a debenture over its assets including a charge on the ground. 

If its (a) or (b) then its really nothing to be concerned about as it’s not the club’s risk at all.  If it’s © then it’s obviously a real concern.   My gut feeling is that it’s most likely to be (b) which is by far the neatest and easiest to make a loan to, and a charge over that company’s 88% shareholding is also very clean and simple and reflects the value of that 88% shareholding (probably around £50m).

If it is a or b, then MDS can't get their hands on the ground,and the owner can deal with them as they see fit. I couldn't see MDS agreeing to this.

I would almost welcome C, because it takes the ground out of the equation and keeps everything together. The most problematic problems faced by Derby and now Blues is trying to repatriate the two.

None of the scenarios are good news though. High risk and expensive.

Not quite - there could be Reserved Matters built into the loan agreement re the ground.   I’m not sure I follow your logic re Option C.  Keeping it all together in that way shifts the risk of the debt back into the football club rather than leaving the risk with the top two companies which are both 100% owned by Yunwai - so solely at their risk.

I've never seen a loan agreement written like that, Prag, but my background is bank debt rather than equity, which is a different game.

I take your points on option a and b, both which would be better for the club. Vanilla debt structures would call for inter-company composite guarantees- if Commercial Benefit could be proven.

Your background means you have seen more equity structures than me. I think it will be interesting to see both the corporate structure, and also the structure of the advance. Its probably wrong to call it a loan, because technically it might not be !!

Agreed KKC.  These types of “loans” from MSD are often very quirky, usually tied to loan issued on TISE (The International Stock Exchange in the Channel Islands). Both the Southampton and Derby loans were done that way. It could well be the specific reason for the new Jersey company.


RE: This loan - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-30-2022

It's going to be interesting, Prag. From what you are saying about MSD, it looks like you have highlighted why a Jersey Co has been incorporated.

I'm not quite sure where this leaves S4A if a or b is followed. They wouldn't be a party to the loan, but couldn't block it, even if they 25% of the shares.

If the jersey co defaulted on the agreement, then MSD would have control of the shares in WBA. Presumably they would then sell these to repay the obligation?

Not sure how the football league would view a scenario of the holding company of the majority shareholder going into Admin?

Also how would you transfer funds from WBA to Jersey Co? I presume a dividend is a non-starter.


RE: This loan - CA Baggie - 10-30-2022

I recall reading something a while back that The EFL treat a holding company going into admin the same way as if it was the club itself.

Otherwise it would be a relatively simple way of avoiding all the associated punishments of Admin.


RE: This loan - Sliced - 10-30-2022

(10-30-2022, 08:59 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I recall reading something a while back that The EFL treat a holding company going into admin the same way as if it was the club itself.

Otherwise it would be a relatively simple way of avoiding all the associated punishments of Admin.

Makes sense to me