WBAUnofficial
The failed experiment... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The failed experiment... (/showthread.php?tid=27096)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: The failed experiment... - Peachy - 10-12-2022

I said it on a thread yesterday but for me getting a really good, progressive and ambitious DOF is just as key for us now as a head coach. We will not go up this season because of Bruce and Gourlays dithering so we will be looking at a very different financial landscape next season even if Lai pays us the money he owes us (which i very much doubt he will anyway).

We need someone to take ownership of player development and recruitment and work with the manager as a team to really build something. These people are out there but we have to be creative.

Darren Fletcher would have been ideal DOF material imo. Not sure how he's getting on at Utd or how much autonomy he has there but I would ask him to build his own role and crack on. If not him then look for someone with the same desire and work ethic. (Scharner?) 

Having a stable DOF also helps massively with continuity moving forwards. If we lose a manager then the club moves forwards with the same structure and vision and the new coach comes in and is fully onboard with the DOF from the outset or they don't get the gig. 

Massively important role for us which worked well for so long.....


RE: The failed experiment... - SW4Baggie - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 11:40 AM)Peachy Wrote: I said it on a thread yesterday but for me getting a really good, progressive and ambitious DOF is just as key for us now as a head coach. We will not go up this season because of Bruce and Gourlays dithering so we will be looking at a very different financial landscape next season even if Lai pays us the money he owes us (which i very much doubt he will anyway).

We need someone to take ownership of player development and recruitment and work with the manager as a team to really build something. These people are out there but we have to be creative.

Darren Fletcher would have been ideal DOF material imo. Not sure how he's getting on at Utd or how much autonomy he has there but I would ask him to build his own role and crack on. If not him then look for someone with the same desire and work ethic. (Scharner?) 

Having a stable DOF also helps massively with continuity moving forwards. If we lose a manager then the club moves forwards with the same structure and vision and the new coach comes in and is fully onboard with the DOF from the outset or they don't get the gig. 

Massively important role for us which worked well for so long.....

Couldn't care less about ambitious and progressive - what we need is fit for purpose football intelligence in the club. 
There are very few top players that transition into being successful DoFs, often it's players who've had to end their careers early and as such have spent a lot of time working with youth teams, supporting recruitment and medical departments and thus have many years footballing experience across multiple departments. Very few ex-players will have had the time or the exposure to all of these departments during their playing career. 

What we need is somebody who has been successful in the role at a club either abroad or in the Championship. We need somebody who has a track record of assembling a squad that can outperform its budget first and foremost, and who has experience of essentially building a department from the ground up. I've seen absolutely nothing from our current administration that there is even an ounce of footballing intelligence in the structure so we need to find somebody who can command respect and deliver the change that's needed.

Gourlay must be a capable businessman, he has held very senior positions in blue chip companies and at both United and Chelsea, however he just does not have the knowledge to run a successful football club. His footballing decisions to date have been woefully inept, however he has ensured that financially money has been available to Bruce and that we have been able to get signings over the line despite Lai pulling money out for his other interests so he clearly has some nous we can utilise. What we need now is somebody who he can delegate the football operations to as frankly his appointment of Bruce, persistence with Bruce and considering Ian Pearce has any use other than holding the bog-roll for his mid-morning dump proves he's utterly oblivious to what it takes to run a successful football club in 2022.


RE: The failed experiment... - Tom Joad - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 10:42 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 10:33 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 09:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I am puzzled that people think its a simple choice of appointing someone that gets us up this year, or choosing long term improvements which may/may not see us linger a slow decline? Can't we simply get things in place which make Albion improve from top to bottom? Those 'small margins' that we used to nail down.

I'm with you, but it's dependent on the mindset of the ownership. Many believe there is a doomsday scenario once the parachute payments run out. Of course that's a concern. However, not getting the foundations right will only see the same issues if by a miracle we do go up this year.
We need to plan, at this minute, now for 3 years to ensure the club long term goes in the right direction.  
This squad needs weeding out and a new culture in place.

The process of weeding players out was already underway (ref the departures). It will continue in the Summer when certain contracts are up. Bruce brought in long-term and short-term replacements, and more replacements will come in in the Summer, possibly to replace the short-term appointments as well.

Planning for the long-term should have also started as soon as Gourlay took on his present role, if he was doing his job properly. And would hopefully have been at a stage now where we were ready to start implementing the necessary changes.

I disagree, Spandau, on the point you make that the weeding out of the squad being underway. With the exception of Robinson, the players are just running down their contracts. Both Val and Bruce pointed out it would take 3 to 4 transfer windows to turn it around. On this they were both correct. There is no weeding out. It can't be done because some numpties gave contracts to Phillips, Zohore and Bartley! This must be the area to improve.


RE: The failed experiment... - Spandaubaggie - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 11:54 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 10:42 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 10:33 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 09:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I am puzzled that people think its a simple choice of appointing someone that gets us up this year, or choosing long term improvements which may/may not see us linger a slow decline? Can't we simply get things in place which make Albion improve from top to bottom? Those 'small margins' that we used to nail down.

I'm with you, but it's dependent on the mindset of the ownership. Many believe there is a doomsday scenario once the parachute payments run out. Of course that's a concern. However, not getting the foundations right will only see the same issues if by a miracle we do go up this year.
We need to plan, at this minute, now for 3 years to ensure the club long term goes in the right direction.  
This squad needs weeding out and a new culture in place.

The process of weeding players out was already underway (ref the departures). It will continue in the Summer when certain contracts are up. Bruce brought in long-term and short-term replacements, and more replacements will come in in the Summer, possibly to replace the short-term appointments as well.

Planning for the long-term should have also started as soon as Gourlay took on his present role, if he was doing his job properly. And would hopefully have been at a stage now where we were ready to start implementing the necessary changes.

I disagree, Spandau, on the point you make that the weeding out of the squad being underway. With the exception of Robinson, the players are just running down their contracts. Both Val and Bruce pointed out it would take 3 to 4 transfer windows to turn it around. On this they were both correct. There is no weeding out. It can't be done because some numpties gave contracts to Phillips, Zohore and Bartley! This must be the area to improve.

It's Baggie Ray who said that Tom. I also agree with you in disagreeing with him.

Some stupid contracts were given out especially the ones you mention.


RE: The failed experiment... - Shabby Russian - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 08:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Table doesn't ever lie. We were 5th. That is a fact, no spinning changes that.

Until players totally lost faith (he carries blame for that too) we were a finisher away from winning the vast majority of games, losing Dike so early was probably what finished him to be honest.

Wins first prize in the analysis of Ismaels time as manager competition.


RE: The failed experiment... - Johnnykayeengland - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 11:40 AM)Peachy Wrote: I said it on a thread yesterday but for me getting a really good, progressive and ambitious DOF is just as key for us now as a head coach. We will not go up this season because of Bruce and Gourlays dithering so we will be looking at a very different financial landscape next season even if Lai pays us the money he owes us (which i very much doubt he will anyway).

We need someone to take ownership of player development and recruitment and work with the manager as a team to really build something. These people are out there but we have to be creative.

Darren Fletcher would have been ideal DOF material imo. Not sure how he's getting on at Utd or how much autonomy he has there but I would ask him to build his own role and crack on. If not him then look for someone with the same desire and work ethic. (Scharner?) 

Having a stable DOF also helps massively with continuity moving forwards. If we lose a manager then the club moves forwards with the same structure and vision and the new coach comes in and is fully onboard with the DOF from the outset or they don't get the gig. 

Massively important role for us which worked well for so long.....
So true.
A good dof, a structure behind him (which tbf Gourlay may have been trying to put in place), a decent season and we're back on track.
Do we really need promotion atm anyway? I know we all want it... but imagine this group of players- even with additions - in the PL! 
It's the same old argument about the huge gap between levels.


RE: The failed experiment... - Shabby Russian - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 09:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go if the club wants to look at long term strategies, then they have to be put in place regardless of who the manager is.

This .

(10-12-2022, 10:33 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 09:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I am puzzled that people think its a simple choice of appointing someone that gets us up this year, or choosing long term improvements which may/may not see us linger a slow decline? Can't we simply get things in place which make Albion improve from top to bottom? Those 'small margins' that we used to nail down.

I'm with you, but it's dependent on the mindset of the ownership. Many believe there is a doomsday scenario once the parachute payments run out. Of course that's a concern. However, not getting the foundations right will only see the same issues if by a miracle we do go up this year.
We need to plan, at this minute, now for 3 years to ensure the club long term goes in the right direction.  
This squad needs weeding out and a new culture in place.

And both of these are good observations too.


RE: The failed experiment... - WorcsWBA - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 09:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go if the club wants to look at long term strategies, then they have to be put in place regardless of who the manager is.

Indeed - by someone who understands about playing football, rather than someone who's a bean counter.

However Gourlay, despite having had nearly 9 months, has miserably failed to add a single one of the "football people" that he promised at the outset. We can't properly have a long term strategy without these people being in post.

Equally, though, I don't want Gourlay to be the one who's choosing them, so we're still stuck between a rock and a hard place....


RE: The failed experiment... - SophLad - 10-12-2022

Fred Everiss took over as manager of Albion aged 20 years old and remained in post until 1948. Although the role of manager was somewhat different in those times, with directors (shudder!) making the decisions on who to play.


RE: The failed experiment... - baggie_ray - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 11:58 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 11:54 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 10:42 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 10:33 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 09:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I am puzzled that people think its a simple choice of appointing someone that gets us up this year, or choosing long term improvements which may/may not see us linger a slow decline? Can't we simply get things in place which make Albion improve from top to bottom? Those 'small margins' that we used to nail down.

I'm with you, but it's dependent on the mindset of the ownership. Many believe there is a doomsday scenario once the parachute payments run out. Of course that's a concern. However, not getting the foundations right will only see the same issues if by a miracle we do go up this year.
We need to plan, at this minute, now for 3 years to ensure the club long term goes in the right direction.  
This squad needs weeding out and a new culture in place.

The process of weeding players out was already underway (ref the departures). It will continue in the Summer when certain contracts are up. Bruce brought in long-term and short-term replacements, and more replacements will come in in the Summer, possibly to replace the short-term appointments as well.

Planning for the long-term should have also started as soon as Gourlay took on his present role, if he was doing his job properly. And would hopefully have been at a stage now where we were ready to start implementing the necessary changes.

I disagree, Spandau, on the point you make that the weeding out of the squad being underway. With the exception of Robinson, the players are just running down their contracts. Both Val and Bruce pointed out it would take 3 to 4 transfer windows to turn it around. On this they were both correct. There is no weeding out. It can't be done because some numpties gave contracts to Phillips, Zohore and Bartley! This must be the area to improve.

It's Baggie Ray who said that Tom. I also agree with you in disagreeing with him.

Some stupid contracts were given out especially the ones you mention.

Harrumph!  Big Grin

We've got what players we can out of the club. We’ve loaned some out that we dont want. The others that we haven't been able to get out will be out of the club at the end of the season, when their contracts run out.