WBAUnofficial
Here you go Proth - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Here you go Proth (/showthread.php?tid=26993)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-07-2022

I don't accept that pre-WW2 UK or Germany now has any bearing on what we ought to do here. Frank Field agrees with me, and he's hardly on my side of the fence, is he?


RE: Here you go Proth - Borin' Baggie - 10-07-2022

You don't accept that two implementations of the system you want had and have the same issues that you want the system to address have a bearing on the capability of the issue you want to solve? Seriously?

Jesus wept.

As for Frank Field, I don't give a shit. Much as I don't give a shit about David Laws position on the matter where myself and Laws are on the same side of the fence.


RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-07-2022

(10-07-2022, 04:18 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You don't accept that two implementations of the system you want had and have the same issues that you want the system to address have a bearing on the capability of the issue you want to solve? Seriously?

Jesus wept.

I don't accept that they are or have to be functionally equivalent, you assert that they are. We've been over this ad nauseum for years, so save your incredulity for something novel, eh?


RE: Here you go Proth - Borin' Baggie - 10-07-2022

So you'd risk wasting billions of taxpayer money on implementing something that has been shown to not address the issues you assert will be resolved to change the funding model when that isn't the issue and people will still be paying money into the state with the majority of funding still coming out of general taxation.

Very small state, value for money for taxpayers and economically liberal that, risking billions for something that offers no material difference. We know the problems with the NHS and social care in this country, it's that carers in this country are paid a pittance so nobody wants to do it and healthcare spending as a percentage of GDP is too low. It isn't how the Treasury raise revenues.


RE: Here you go Proth - baggy1 - 10-07-2022

(10-07-2022, 04:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-07-2022, 03:53 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You probably need to shoehorn something about benefits recipients into that fabrication of a line. Do you think that the bloke in the OP should sell his house in his late 60s to pay for his wife's care?

I don't see why a young person on a modest income, paying a higher marginal tax rate due to a student loan, renting an expensive poky 1-bed flat and unable in the medium term to even contemplate buying a home ought to subsidise Jo and her husband if they have wholly unearned slug of equity in their property. 

That is the very definition of trickle-up economics. Taking from the asset poor to subsidise the asset rich. Just as Gordon Brown did in 2008. At least you Labour lot are consistent in your contempt for the low paid / asset poor.

And here we have the next Tory soundbite - set one group of poor (the youngsters struggling because of Tory policies) against the other set of poor folk (the elderly who are struggling because of another set of Tory policies). If you can cream what small amount the old folk have off them then you'll have everybody fucked. 

As you mention novel ideas, here's one for you why don't you try and give the one set of those struggling a helping hand to get up to the position of those with assets instead of trying to bring everyone down to the status of having nothing. The only winners are the ones left with the money, and that isn't either of the groups you suggest.

Bonkers economics of the short termist that has got us to where we are today.


RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-07-2022

Fatuous rubbish. Tell me, exactly, about this helping hand? We’ve just had a decade of the cheapest money ever (a terrible central bank policy) which has merely served to inflate asset prices.

Where on Earth does this “helping hand” come from in an era of interest rates returning to historic norms?

Are you realistically suggesting the state ought to subsidise the accumulation of wealth more than the BoE and the Fed have since 2008? How? What with?

We’re in a situation where the current lot are going to have to find £30 billion in savings / cuts to prevent another run on the market. Labour hasn’t yet explained how they’d fill this hole and are actually supporting two of the headline cuts in nominal rates of PAYE and NI.

It’s so easy to be a bleeding heart, it’s a lot harder to explain how you’ll pay for it.

We’ve all become such titty babbies for a bailout for 14 years I guarantee you the next indiscriminate bung will be for mortgage holders facing a cliff edge. When does this free shit ever end? How do we ever pay for it?

Helping hand, my arse.


RE: Here you go Proth - Tom Joad - 10-07-2022

Ossian Wrote:
Protheroe Wrote:
Ossian Wrote:We need to build homes - 200,000 a year, year on year (like the Attlee government did) providing employment in the process. Again, our young workforce needs to be skilled up to benefit from the opportunity to work and then afford these homes. Add in roads, railways, infrastructure in all of its many guises...

I was at the Investment Property Forum dinner last night discussing this. Can you explain where you're going to get the labour and materials to build 200,000 homes year on year?

No one there could.

No, not right now I can't - that's the point. It's a medium/long-term programme and we might have to accept that some of the labour in the early years is provided by migrants, as it has been in the past. And I'm not revisiting Brexit - that ship has sailed.

Or we could kick multiple cans down the road for a few more years then revisit the same conversations again.
Yes, it's a slow starter. But with a multitude of training courses and then adequate supervision, all of a sudden, we have tradesmen. It isn't something you learn at college, with supervision (and the building inspector!), you learn on the job. It really doesnt take very long to follow a plan, the instructions are already there. Many years of cheap imported labour has led to no one being able to find a local builder while our own younger generation see the work as somehow unfashionable despite the fact it is one of the few trades where you can actually earn well and progress as far as you like. Plus, it's a lot more fun than being chained to a keyboard all day!
Actually, after that rant I've just remembered I only replied to agree with that last sentence. (Kicking cans down the road).


RE: Here you go Proth - baggy1 - 10-07-2022

(10-07-2022, 06:06 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fatuous rubbish. Tell me, exactly, about this helping hand? We’ve just had a decade of the cheapest money ever (a terrible central bank policy) which has merely served to inflate asset prices.

Where on Earth does this “helping hand” come from in an era of interest rates returning to historic norms?

Are you realistically suggesting the state ought to subsidise the accumulation of wealth more than the BoE and the Fed have since 2008? How? What with?

We’re in a situation where the current lot are going to have to find £30 billion in savings / cuts to prevent another run on the market. Labour hasn’t yet explained how they’d fill this hole and are actually supporting two of the headline cuts in nominal rates of PAYE and NI.

It’s so easy to be a bleeding heart, it’s a lot harder to explain how you’ll pay for it.

We’ve all become such titty babbies for a bailout for 14 years I guarantee you the next indiscriminate bung will be for mortgage holders facing a cliff edge. When does this free shit ever end? How do we ever pay for it?

Helping hand, my arse.

You’ve even stated the helping hand yourself - build more fucking houses! Not only does that help those trying to get on the property ladder it also dilutes the market to move us away from the paper fortunes that people sit on in their old age.

I swear to god, you really are one of the most blinkered fools I have ever come across. You don’t even see, or understand, the policies you promote.


RE: Here you go Proth - Protheroe - 10-08-2022

(10-07-2022, 06:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You’ve even stated the helping hand yourself - build more fucking houses! Not only does that help those trying to get on the property ladder it also dilutes the market to move us away from the paper fortunes that people sit on in their old age.

I swear to god, you really are one of the most blinkered fools I have ever come across. You don’t even see, or understand, the policies you promote.

Ground your thoughts in reality FFS. Money is (at least) 3 times as expensive to borrow as it was a year ago.

The interest funding costs of development have gone through the roof, ask KKC how much he's lending to a poorly capitalised (most of them) house builder at the moment? Just the other night we were discussing who the first big contractor to go this cycle would be, let alone which housebuilders.

Every firm I spoke to on Thursday night is pulling the oars in.

We had a chance during to the goldilocks economy from 1992-2007 and then again in the free money era of 2009-2021 to seriously reform planning and seriously throw money at building the number of houses we need. That ship has sailed again. To coin a phrase we didn't fix the roof while the sun was shining (again). No supply side reform, just more inflationary gimmicks.

All the young have got to look forward to for the forseeable future is the highest tax burden in 70 years, increasing rents and mortgage rates that render any attempt at a foothold on the housing ladder laughable - prices are likely to stagnate at worse - the lack of starts, rapid household formation and the stamp duty cut will see to that.