WBAUnofficial
The we can't afford to get rid argument - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The we can't afford to get rid argument (/showthread.php?tid=26895)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: The we can't afford to get rid argument - ericlegrisly - 10-04-2022

(10-04-2022, 06:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Offside Wrote:We are at best a mid-table squad at the moment> Until recently I thought Bruce would manage competently enough to keep us there until we get a new owner who can invest.

However,  there is now a real danger that he's not even able to do that and we are in a relegation fight.

As we are now obviously  part way into a Denis Smith, Brian Little era of stagnation, probably for the next two or three seasons, the arrival of a coach with a game plan to consolidate a mid-table ranking would be a sensible short-term measure.

I know it lacks ambition. But until we get a new owner with some money, or we stumble across a Megson type character, who can build a team with a heart, we are mid table Championship material.
I don't agree. I think we are a top 6 squad. We under achieved in finishing 10th last season and have strengthened with the signing of one of the most effective players in this league in Wallace. Bruce seems to think the answer to everything is to drop the younger players and bring back the experienced ones. No matter how many times they've failed previously. I've seen little to suggest there are 5 better squads than Albion's, we desperately need some new ideas, some enthusiasm, some fitness. None of those things are impossible but they do appear to be beyond Bruce.
All about opinions Tom. I think there are certainly more than 5 better squads than ours.  Bruce is a calamity, but the players we have, based on the evidence of my own eyes on a week-by-week basis, aren't up to much. There's flattery to deceive absolutely AOTS, and ordinariness in every position.  That said, it's a better squad than bottom 4 chump, which is squarely on Bruce.  Wallace looks a good player, and we know Okay can be  but Swift, Reach, Button, Bryan, Molumby, Robinson, Grant, Mowatt, Dike, Ken, etc are not promotion  / top division signings. Those who have been here longer; Jake, Furlong, Townsend, Phillips, Bartley - not good enough. I think, without stating the bleedin' obvious, that we're in the shit.


RE: The we can't afford to get rid argument - Tom Joad - 10-04-2022

MancBaggie Wrote:Good post TJ

In order to get to 6th or even challenge for it - we simply need fitness energy organisation and basic coaching of how to be compact/ how to counter. We also need set piece practice. 

Pretty much any other manager would improve at least 2 or 3 of those variables. This is why I don’t think a single one of the other 91 league managers should have us in 21st fucking place.
Exactly. Plus just look at the goals we concede, 90% of them are individual errors. A decent manager would work at this and all of a sudden, we are winning matches regularly. This is the most frustrating thing, we have pretty much matched or bettered every side we've played but shot ourselves in the foot.


RE: The we can't afford to get rid argument - TETLEY74 - 10-04-2022

(10-04-2022, 06:59 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(10-04-2022, 06:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Offside Wrote:We are at best a mid-table squad at the moment> Until recently I thought Bruce would manage competently enough to keep us there until we get a new owner who can invest.

However,  there is now a real danger that he's not even able to do that and we are in a relegation fight.

As we are now obviously  part way into a Denis Smith, Brian Little era of stagnation, probably for the next two or three seasons, the arrival of a coach with a game plan to consolidate a mid-table ranking would be a sensible short-term measure.

I know it lacks ambition. But until we get a new owner with some money, or we stumble across a Megson type character, who can build a team with a heart, we are mid table Championship material.
I don't agree. I think we are a top 6 squad. We under achieved in finishing 10th last season and have strengthened with the signing of one of the most effective players in this league in Wallace. Bruce seems to think the answer to everything is to drop the younger players and bring back the experienced ones. No matter how many times they've failed previously. I've seen little to suggest there are 5 better squads than Albion's, we desperately need some new ideas, some enthusiasm, some fitness. None of those things are impossible but they do appear to be beyond Bruce.
All about opinions Tom. I think there are certainly more than 5 better squads than ours.  Bruce is a calamity, but the players we have, based on the evidence of my own eyes on a week-by-week basis, aren't up to much. There's flattery to deceive absolutely AOTS, and ordinariness in every position.  That said, it's a better squad than bottom 4 chump, which is squarely on Bruce.  Wallace looks a good player, and we know Okay can be  but Swift, Reach, Button, Bryan, Molumby, Robinson, Grant, Mowatt, Dike, Ken, etc are not promotion  / top division signings. Those who have been here longer; Jake, Furlong, Townsend, Phillips, Bartley - not good enough. I think, without stating the bleedin' obvious, that we're in the shit.

Really hard not to agree with that.


RE: The we can't afford to get rid argument - Calgary_Baggie - 10-04-2022

(10-04-2022, 06:59 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(10-04-2022, 06:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Offside Wrote:We are at best a mid-table squad at the moment> Until recently I thought Bruce would manage competently enough to keep us there until we get a new owner who can invest.

However,  there is now a real danger that he's not even able to do that and we are in a relegation fight.

As we are now obviously  part way into a Denis Smith, Brian Little era of stagnation, probably for the next two or three seasons, the arrival of a coach with a game plan to consolidate a mid-table ranking would be a sensible short-term measure.

I know it lacks ambition. But until we get a new owner with some money, or we stumble across a Megson type character, who can build a team with a heart, we are mid table Championship material.
I don't agree. I think we are a top 6 squad. We under achieved in finishing 10th last season and have strengthened with the signing of one of the most effective players in this league in Wallace. Bruce seems to think the answer to everything is to drop the younger players and bring back the experienced ones. No matter how many times they've failed previously. I've seen little to suggest there are 5 better squads than Albion's, we desperately need some new ideas, some enthusiasm, some fitness. None of those things are impossible but they do appear to be beyond Bruce.
All about opinions Tom. I think there are certainly more than 5 better squads than ours.  Bruce is a calamity, but the players we have, based on the evidence of my own eyes on a week-by-week basis, aren't up to much. There's flattery to deceive absolutely AOTS, and ordinariness in every position.  That said, it's a better squad than bottom 4 chump, which is squarely on Bruce.  Wallace looks a good player, and we know Okay can be  but Swift, Reach, Button, Bryan, Molumby, Robinson, Grant, Mowatt, Dike, Ken, etc are not promotion  / top division signings. Those who have been here longer; Jake, Furlong, Townsend, Phillips, Bartley - not good enough. I think, without stating the bleedin' obvious, that we're in the shit.

Correct- players nowhere near good enough. Lack of investment and the fact that we continually seem to think that we can get away without bringing in a decent forward has rotted us away. We can all blame Bruce and he deserves to take some of the blame but he has awful tools to work with.

Championship Top Scorers

The above tells its own story.


RE: The we can't afford to get rid argument - Remi_Moses - 10-04-2022

(10-04-2022, 07:37 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(10-04-2022, 06:59 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(10-04-2022, 06:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Offside Wrote:We are at best a mid-table squad at the moment> Until recently I thought Bruce would manage competently enough to keep us there until we get a new owner who can invest.

However,  there is now a real danger that he's not even able to do that and we are in a relegation fight.

As we are now obviously  part way into a Denis Smith, Brian Little era of stagnation, probably for the next two or three seasons, the arrival of a coach with a game plan to consolidate a mid-table ranking would be a sensible short-term measure.

I know it lacks ambition. But until we get a new owner with some money, or we stumble across a Megson type character, who can build a team with a heart, we are mid table Championship material.
I don't agree. I think we are a top 6 squad. We under achieved in finishing 10th last season and have strengthened with the signing of one of the most effective players in this league in Wallace. Bruce seems to think the answer to everything is to drop the younger players and bring back the experienced ones. No matter how many times they've failed previously. I've seen little to suggest there are 5 better squads than Albion's, we desperately need some new ideas, some enthusiasm, some fitness. None of those things are impossible but they do appear to be beyond Bruce.
All about opinions Tom. I think there are certainly more than 5 better squads than ours.  Bruce is a calamity, but the players we have, based on the evidence of my own eyes on a week-by-week basis, aren't up to much. There's flattery to deceive absolutely AOTS, and ordinariness in every position.  That said, it's a better squad than bottom 4 chump, which is squarely on Bruce.  Wallace looks a good player, and we know Okay can be  but Swift, Reach, Button, Bryan, Molumby, Robinson, Grant, Mowatt, Dike, Ken, etc are not promotion  / top division signings. Those who have been here longer; Jake, Furlong, Townsend, Phillips, Bartley - not good enough. I think, without stating the bleedin' obvious, that we're in the shit.

Correct- players nowhere near good enough. Lack of investment and the fact that we continually seem to think that we can get away without bringing in a decent forward has rotted us away. We can all blame Bruce and he deserves to take some of the blame but he has awful tools to work with.

Championship Top Scorers

The above tells its own story.

When Bruce finally departs and he will, the new manager will have a massive job getting these guys fit and organised.
Bruce has let them act like happy headless chickens. Whoever comes in will need a big stick IMO.
Some will think great let's step up, others will down tools. as soon as the happy party is disbanded.
Tough times ahead.