WBAUnofficial
Palmer - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Palmer (/showthread.php?tid=26618)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Palmer - Ted Maul - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 07:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not convinced by Button.

But how many of the goals conceded did he have a reasonable chance of saving.

Don't tell Derek, but it might be worth looking at our xg for goals conceded. If we are letting in significantly more than our xg then it points to a potential problem with the goalkeeper.

We do seem susceptible to the counter attack, which will leave a goalkeeper exposed.

And we have conceded some goals of quality. The second last night was of the highest quality.

We're susceptible to the counter attack because we attack without any plan or direction. Their second goal last night was not the highest quality, it was three simple passes that ripped us apart because we're the most poorly coached and disorganised side in the division. It's the sort of goal a pub team concedes, credit where it's due he finished it well. All of the above stems from the manager.

If Button wasn't keeping out a lad who'd come through our youth system the stick wouldn't be half as bad. Why are we so reluctant to give one of our own a go, how can it be worse? If nothing else I would expect fans to be more patient with Palmer. Button is already finished here.


RE: Palmer - Shabby Russian - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not convinced by Button.

But how many of the goals conceded did he have a reasonable chance of saving.

Don't tell Derek, but it might be worth looking at our xg for goals conceded. If we are letting in significantly more than our xg then it points to a potential problem with the goalkeeper.

We do seem susceptible to the counter attack, which will leave a goalkeeper exposed.

And we have conceded some goals of quality. The second last night was of the highest quality.

We're susceptible to the counter attack because we attack without any plan or direction. Their second goal last night was not the highest quality, it was three simple passes that ripped us apart because we're the most poorly coached and disorganised side in the division. It's the sort of goal a pub team concedes, credit where it's due he finished it well. All of the above stems from the manager.

If Button wasn't keeping out a lad who'd come through our youth system the stick wouldn't be half as bad. Why are we so reluctant to give one of our own a go, how can it be worse? If nothing else I would expect fans to be more patient with Palmer. Button is already finished here.

If we had scored that goal I would have been delighted.
From an attacking point of view, everything was done well, not just the finish.
Fans and pundits waxed lyrical about Brentfords third against Man U the other week, this was as good if nit better.


RE: Palmer - Ted Maul - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 07:31 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not convinced by Button.

But how many of the goals conceded did he have a reasonable chance of saving.

Don't tell Derek, but it might be worth looking at our xg for goals conceded. If we are letting in significantly more than our xg then it points to a potential problem with the goalkeeper.

We do seem susceptible to the counter attack, which will leave a goalkeeper exposed.

And we have conceded some goals of quality. The second last night was of the highest quality.

We're susceptible to the counter attack because we attack without any plan or direction. Their second goal last night was not the highest quality, it was three simple passes that ripped us apart because we're the most poorly coached and disorganised side in the division. It's the sort of goal a pub team concedes, credit where it's due he finished it well. All of the above stems from the manager.

If Button wasn't keeping out a lad who'd come through our youth system the stick wouldn't be half as bad. Why are we so reluctant to give one of our own a go, how can it be worse? If nothing else I would expect fans to be more patient with Palmer. Button is already finished here.

If we had scored that goal I would have been delighted.
From an attacking point of view, everything was done well, not just the finish.
Fans and pundits waxed lyrical about Brentfords third against Man U the other week, this was as good if nit better.

We wouldn't have scored that goal. We'd have turned round and given it to Townsend to play a big diagonal. You're not going to convince me it's anything other than wank defending as we're set up to play like a bunch of kids at a birthday party. Blues, as they did all night to their credit did the basics very well and deserved their win.


RE: Palmer - MassDebater - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 06:04 AM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote: Not to say I told you so but I told you so. Been saying for weeks and weeks that Button is absolute garbage.

I think you'll struggle to find anyone who really thought that Button (he's so bad I can't remember his first name and do keep thinking it's Benjamin!) Was a great keeper, he was and always will be back up at best... The only reason people wanted him to be played was because of SJ being a wanker


RE: Palmer - Fido - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 07:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:31 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 07:13 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not convinced by Button.

But how many of the goals conceded did he have a reasonable chance of saving.

Don't tell Derek, but it might be worth looking at our xg for goals conceded. If we are letting in significantly more than our xg then it points to a potential problem with the goalkeeper.

We do seem susceptible to the counter attack, which will leave a goalkeeper exposed.

And we have conceded some goals of quality. The second last night was of the highest quality.

We're susceptible to the counter attack because we attack without any plan or direction. Their second goal last night was not the highest quality, it was three simple passes that ripped us apart because we're the most poorly coached and disorganised side in the division. It's the sort of goal a pub team concedes, credit where it's due he finished it well. All of the above stems from the manager.

If Button wasn't keeping out a lad who'd come through our youth system the stick wouldn't be half as bad. Why are we so reluctant to give one of our own a go, how can it be worse? If nothing else I would expect fans to be more patient with Palmer. Button is already finished here.

If we had scored that goal I would have been delighted.
From an attacking point of view, everything was done well, not just the finish.
Fans and pundits waxed lyrical about Brentfords third against Man U the other week, this was as good if nit better.

We wouldn't have scored that goal. We'd have turned round and given it to Townsend to play a big diagonal. You're not going to convince me it's anything other than wank defending as we're set up to play like a bunch of kids at a birthday party. Blues, as they did all night to their credit did the basics very well and deserved their win.

Sort of agree with both sides of this. It was extremely well moved, great ball into the middle and a tight finish. But losing the ball high up, neither Bartley or O'Shea dealing with it were all more to blame than Button in this instance. And yes, we wouldn't have scored that as we can't fuggin break at speed.


RE: Palmer - Big Daddy Cool - 09-15-2022

How many other Championship sides would have Button as first choice?

He's awful. Palmer should be given a chance now.


RE: Palmer - Fido - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 08:25 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: How many other Championship sides would have Button as first choice?

He's awful. Palmer should be given a chance now.

You can understand as a young kid (in goalkeeping terms) if you are being kept out by an experienced keeper who had had international experience but he must be wondering why he hasn't been tossed the gloves by now when he sees Button watching the ball fly past him on a regular basis..


RE: Palmer - Bob Fossil - 09-15-2022

(09-15-2022, 08:27 AM)Fido Wrote:
(09-15-2022, 08:25 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: How many other Championship sides would have Button as first choice?

He's awful. Palmer should be given a chance now.

You can understand as a young kid (in goalkeeping terms) if you are being kept out by an experienced keeper who had had international experience but he must be wondering why he hasn't been tossed the gloves by now when he sees Button watching the ball fly past him on a regular basis..
It doesn't fly past him though, it goes through him. It's like he's made of mist!


RE: Palmer - Kit Kat Chunky - 09-15-2022

It's well documented on here that I didn't rate Johnstone - and I still stand by that.

Johnstone was a £5M keeper with pedigree though, who I thought was over-rated (who played for England and reached the final of the Euros in our colours). He has been replaced by a pub league player.


RE: Palmer - wbamitch - 09-15-2022

Making do with what we already had at GK and Striker was a huge mistake. No decent keeper should be happy being a backup for 4 seasons at age 29-33, those are your peak years. We’ve no idea if Palmer is good enough but he has to be given a go, we gave him a 4 year contract for one reason or another so someone at the club must rate him.