WBAUnofficial
Bruce Sackometer - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bruce Sackometer (/showthread.php?tid=26102)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Bruce Sackometer - Baggie in Valley - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 08:37 AM)MrFizz Wrote: Some folks just can't wait to stick a fuckin knife in.

Yay lets sack another one and bring in another muppet who will be given a grace period of precisely 5mins. If we haven't signed Eden Hazard by then or if TGH hasn't started at right-back then SACK THE BASTARD!!!!!

Spud Yed was appointed on 2nd February 2022 - he didn't win any of his first six games taking us from 5th to 11th and effectively killing our top six hopes

His persistent playing of Livermore, favouring Reach over TGH combined with poor results - means this is hardly knee jerk stuff.

His Albion record is poor.


RE: Bruce Sackometer - devonstroller - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 08:39 AM)SophLad Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 08:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Sorry this is ridiculous. We got a point at Boro, a decent result, a point against Watford(who will be very strong) and had our first bad result yesterday.
There is no hope whatsoever of this club or any rebuilding if some of you can't see beyond the sacking the manager at the first opportunity.

He's had 3 games, how many more does he want?  We are the mighty Albion, a big club with big expectations.  1982.

Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Spot on


RE: Bruce Sackometer - TartanRug - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 08:47 AM)OneAlb1on Wrote: The reality is we have no divine right to getting promoted and likes of Blackburn want it as much as us . The effort and commitment is much improved, Bruce can only work with he has and sadly it is on par with the majority of teams in this league.

Hold on, so now we're on a par with the majority of teams in the league? So are you saying based on this a mid-table finish is about what we should expect? Hate to think what we'll be like next season when the parachutes run out.


RE: Bruce Sackometer - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-15-2022

I'm not in the "sack Bruce" camp - we can't keep changing manager and expecting that to transform things. I am concerned that Bruce is showing signs of age, a lack of judgement, a tendency to rely on the old pros who can talk to him as equals and share war stories.

He's stuck with Livermore and Phillips for another season (or two), but does he have to keep playing them? I want to see Okay in the side and Livermore restricted to late sub appearances. If that doesn't happen soon, Bruce is getting it wrong. Most of all, he has made a huge error in putting his faith in Semi Ajayi. He's tall, quick and athletic, but his first touch and passing are average and he can't defend. I'm bemused by the rave reviews he's been getting. I know I'll get stick for this, but yesterday he was brushed aside twice, twice when it mattered. A game changing goal just before the break and a sucker punch straight after the restart. He will cost us goals on a regular basis. I will gladly retract this statement once we've kept 4 consecutive clean sheets in the league. Watch this space - - - -


RE: Bruce Sackometer - TartanRug - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 09:40 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm not in the "sack Bruce" camp - we can't keep changing manager and expecting that to transform things. I am concerned that Bruce is showing signs of age, a lack of judgement, a tendency to rely on the old pros who can talk to him as equals and share war stories.

He's stuck with Livermore and Phillips for another season (or two), but does he have to keep playing them? I want to see Okay in the side and Livermore restricted to late sub appearances. If that doesn't happen soon, Bruce is getting it wrong. Most of all, he has made a huge error in putting his faith in Semi Ajayi. He's tall, quick and athletic, but his first touch and passing are average and he can't defend. I'm bemused by the rave reviews he's been getting. I know I'll get stick for this, but yesterday he was brushed aside twice, twice when it mattered. A game changing goal just before the break and a sucker punch straight after the restart. He will cost us goals on a regular basis. I will gladly retract this statement once we've kept 4 consecutive clean sheets in the league. Watch this space - - - -

With Ajayi IMO he can look very impressive for large parts of the game but then you get these key moments where it goes wrong and it happens in quite a few games.


RE: Bruce Sackometer - MrFizz - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 09:45 AM)TartanRug Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 09:40 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm not in the "sack Bruce" camp - we can't keep changing manager and expecting that to transform things. I am concerned that Bruce is showing signs of age, a lack of judgement, a tendency to rely on the old pros who can talk to him as equals and share war stories.

He's stuck with Livermore and Phillips for another season (or two), but does he have to keep playing them? I want to see Okay in the side and Livermore restricted to late sub appearances. If that doesn't happen soon, Bruce is getting it wrong. Most of all, he has made a huge error in putting his faith in Semi Ajayi. He's tall, quick and athletic, but his first touch and passing are average and he can't defend. I'm bemused by the rave reviews he's been getting. I know I'll get stick for this, but yesterday he was brushed aside twice, twice when it mattered. A game changing goal just before the break and a sucker punch straight after the restart. He will cost us goals on a regular basis. I will gladly retract this statement once we've kept 4 consecutive clean sheets in the league. Watch this space - - - -

With Ajayi IMO he can look very impressive for large parts of the game but then you get these key moments where it goes wrong and it happens in quite a few games.

The alternative of course is Kyle Bartley.


RE: Bruce Sackometer - Squid - 08-15-2022

No, we shouldn't be talking about sacking Bruce yet.

But we shouldn't be giving him a clean slate from last season either, which featured several inexplicable team selections and dire performances.

As has been said upthread, I am concerned about his abilities as a coach and to improve players. And no, I don't care what he did at Hull, etc. It's what he can do at Albion that matters.

If we're outside the playoffs come November, he'll be gone anyway. As people are fond of saying, we don't have the time for projects.


RE: Bruce Sackometer - HawkingsHalfpint - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 08:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Sorry this is ridiculous. We got a point at Boro, a decent result, a point against Watford(who will be very strong) and had our first bad result yesterday.
There is no hope whatsoever of this club or any rebuilding if some of you can't see beyond the sacking the manager at the first opportunity.

Completely agree. 

Two away plus one home all against tough sides, we are part way through a rebuild and have been dealt some shitty luck regarding Dyke. pERSPECTIVE?

I'm no Bruce fan. It was an uninspiring appointment made by the type of club we sadly now are. Compared to the also rans, as a parachute club we no longer have that 'x-factor' we did as a relegated club under Peace, because despite the similar tight-bastard approach he at least didn't overfish the waters; and always ensured the hopeful head coach had enough residual quality in the side to give promotion a fair shot (I'm no fan of Val or his faddish football either, but it's more than fair to say he was not given this). 

We couldn't attract any better from a pool of candidates, who weren't really there (we had missed a better one or two earlier on perhaps, but the constraints would have been the same and again that's history now). Again, we don't have the comparative residual quality we have enjoyed under relegations following TP, TM, BR or GM; especially up-top where it matters most. Zahore ain't his fault, the combination of clusterfuck contract situations holding us back aren't his fault. To me, besides taking too long to figure out what we already knew about certain players and their abilities (or lack thereof), and dicking about with that, there isn't actually too much wrong given that our squad realy isn't what so many believe, and assuming of course that the obvious necessary replacements are made quickly (Okay going straight in for Livermore being the most obvious).

From where I sit, he's looking to fix what was wrong under constraints we are all aware of. What is his fault are the performances, which in spite of a dour couple of periods have not been that bad, and clearly show the problems we have and still need to fix. Meanwhile his fat fwend upstairs is happy. So why torment yourselves?

Wanting us to offload/pay-off this player or that player is great. Wanting TGH to be Pele and wishing Bruce could see it is also great. Periera coming back would be great. But none of it may happen and it's all out of his hands. Let's judge on what is in his hands and what he can do to fix it within the limited scope he has to. But meanwhile, even if you hate the guy's guts, at least be fair and consistent. Because if he suddenly goes now after not being allowed to complete what he's clearly trying to assemble correctly, I'm dying to know what it is over semi-recent history we can point to exactly that suggests to any of the cabbage-haters that Antonio Tracksuit or whomever else out there could make a better fist of this shit show?

It sure isn't perfect, and if he is where Val was by the time Val was then he deserves to go the same way Val did. But let's give that a bit of time, otherwise we've just loaded all of our war chest on another comet manager headed back to deep space.


RE: Bruce Sackometer - WorcsWBA - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 09:53 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 09:45 AM)TartanRug Wrote: With Ajayi IMO he can look very impressive for large parts of the game but then you get these key moments where it goes wrong and it happens in quite a few games.

The alternative of course is Kyle Bartley.

The lack of alternatives being Bruce's decision of course.


RE: Bruce Sackometer - Big Daddy Cool - 08-15-2022

(08-15-2022, 09:01 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(08-15-2022, 08:13 AM)Baggie in Valley Wrote: We now have a run of four winnable games - anything less than nine points and we should sack spud yed.

If you have pretensions to get promoted, all games should be looked at as being winnable.

For my part, I'll see how we're doing after 10 games. To be in a play-off position by then, we'll probably need to have something like 16-17 points, so we need to get 14-15 points from the next 7 games.

After 10 games last season we had 22 points and were unbeaten (6 wins and 4 draws), having scored 20 and conceded 8 goals. At the point fans started booing, we'd got 15 points from 7 games (4 wins and 3 draws) and had scored 13 and conceded 7.

But the fans didn't boo because of the results we were getting, it was because the football was awful to watch. A draw at home to Watford generated one of the best atmosphere at the Hawthorns for a long while and that was because of the way we played. Its very similar to the Pulis debate. Pulis kept us up but the standard of football was dire most weeks. Should fans have been happy as long as he was keeping us up? Football is an expensive game to watch and fans want to see more for their money than the ball getting hoofed up the pitch. 

And the fans were proved right in the end because our form and performances dropped dramatically and Val was rightly given the boot.