RE: Paradigm Shift - Fido - 08-07-2022
(08-07-2022, 08:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So in France they are…
‘The French government have just announced a number of measures including pensions/benefits increases, continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation, financial aid to poor families, rent rise limits and others to curb inflation. All passed through parliament.’
We are introducing tax cuts which won’t help the most vulnerable in society yet again, and most likely fuel inflation exasperating the situation. This is the best this country has to offer? Liz Pork Market Truss as replacement for a serial liar! Circling the drain.
Derek. I think your problem is that ultimately you don't actually think for yourself. I could have written something glib like "Derek in 'throw money at it again' shocker" or similar but that ultimately leads nowhere.
You have a tiny little box from which your ideas get pulled and you see nothing outside of that, quite frankly. There have been multiple suggestions on here from people to the left and right of the spectrum that would start to address some of the long-term issues. Trying to rig a market is never the best way to go because it nearly always have negative implications elsewhere. People have suggested wealth and land tax, rationalising the NHS instead of throwing more money at it. The former means that funds can be freed up to then benefit the poorer or more vulnerable in society.
Just because you are a pensioner it doesn't mean you are surviving on one bar of heat in one room and eating one can of beans per day.
There are those who because of luck more than judgement have lucrative pension plans that they will receive until they die, maybe lasting for the same length of time that they actually worked or near to it; this is completely unsustainable and becomes more so each day. So you worked very day until you were 60 and then retired? Yes, well now that means that people who can't afford a deposit for their first home are effectively funding that lifestyle. Despite the EU being a very good thing in your mind it still allows companies to base themselves in one of the member states i.e. Luxembourg and pay next to no taxes in the countries where it should go therefore making people in a tiny state quite rich. Likewise it could have put pressure on a nation such as Switzerland that does the exact same. For me the EU has always been completely ineffectual in terms of the big questions.
Face it, the Russia/Ukraine thing won't go away for decades now. It's time for a root and branch approach because as we are know prices fly up and rarely come down to the levels we'd known before. Targeted help is good but also should be targeted taxation; they should go hand-in-hand. If you are saying the ideas proposed by Truss and Sunak have fundamental flaws I would tend to agree but it's because they are thinking along the different in the same way very narrow lines.
Rant over.
RE: Paradigm Shift - Derek Hardballs - 08-07-2022
(08-07-2022, 09:07 AM)Fido Wrote: (08-07-2022, 08:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So in France they are…
‘The French government have just announced a number of measures including pensions/benefits increases, continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation, financial aid to poor families, rent rise limits and others to curb inflation. All passed through parliament.’
We are introducing tax cuts which won’t help the most vulnerable in society yet again, and most likely fuel inflation exasperating the situation. This is the best this country has to offer? Liz Pork Market Truss as replacement for a serial liar! Circling the drain.
Derek. I think your problem is that ultimately you don't actually think for yourself. I could have written something glib like "Derek in 'throw money at it again' shocker" or similar but that ultimately leads nowhere.
You have a tiny little box from which your ideas get pulled and you see nothing outside of that, quite frankly. There have been multiple suggestions on here from people to the left and right of the spectrum that would start to address some of the long-term issues. Trying to rig a market is never the best way to go because it nearly always have negative implications elsewhere. People have suggested wealth and land tax, rationalising the NHS instead of throwing more money at it. The former means that funds can be freed up to then benefit the poorer or more vulnerable in society.
Just because you are a pensioner it doesn't mean you are surviving on one bar of heat in one room and eating one can of beans per day.
There are those who because of luck more than judgement have lucrative pension plans that they will receive until they die, maybe lasting for the same length of time that they actually worked or near to it; this is completely unsustainable and becomes more so each day. So you worked very day until you were 60 and then retired? Yes, well now that means that people who can't afford a deposit for their first home are effectively funding that lifestyle. Despite the EU being a very good thing in your mind it still allows companies to base themselves in one of the member states i.e. Luxembourg and pay next to no taxes in the countries where it should go therefore making people in a tiny state quite rich. Likewise it could have put pressure on a nation such as Switzerland that does the exact same. For me the EU has always been completely ineffectual in terms of the big questions.
Face it, the Russia/Ukraine thing won't go away for decades now. It's time for a root and branch approach because as we are know prices fly up and rarely come down to the levels we'd known before. Targeted help is good but also should be targeted taxation; they should go hand-in-hand. If you are saying the ideas proposed by Truss and Sunak have fundamental flaws I would tend to agree but it's because they are thinking along the different in the same way very narrow lines.
Rant over.
Fido there has been zero talk of targeted help for those on low incomes. Not sure why you rambled onto comfortably off pensioners territory, it wasn’t who I was referring to when I says the poorest or most vulnerable. Tax cuts to NI won’t help those working or caring below the NI tax threshold. Until recently they were in many cases described as key workers, that narrative ended when Covid ended (arf) and now they are ungrateful activists demanding unrealistic cost of living rises. At the same time bosses and owners are taking home inflation busting pay rises. When it is pointed out to Truss that the low paid won’t benefit she (they) has no answers to this problem. Instead all we have witnessed is an arms race of right wing policies to appeal to a incredibly narrow electorate of on the main ageing white men in the shires, amplified and endorsed by the Mail, Express, Telegraph and Sun etc. You accuse me of not thinking for myself and yet your opinions are pretty much what many would expect from a Tory from the south of England. Small state, low tax, NHS sceptic / rationaliser who doesn’t like the EU. Hardly the maverick free thinker you seem to imply you are or insist other should be to comment
You fall into the same trap as almost all the Brexit supporters on here do and argue that those who thought it was a mistake to leave the EU are besotted by it and can see no fault in how it works. That isn’t the case we all know there are faults but on the whole we decided pragmatically we were better off being part of it than as a third country. All we have done is hobble ourselves financially, culturally and socially for the benefit of who? No matter how you dress it up with talk of sovereignty etc the decision hasn’t had any real benefits to the average person in the street, it’s divided the nation and those divides aren’t getting smaller and won’t go away they are now embedded, entrenched and are now bigger than just Brexit it a fundamental difference in how people see the future if the country.
My politics are simple and not party political, a fairer society for all. So those at the top recognise they didn’t get where they are simply through their hard work, that they recognise that those below them economically and socially were integral to their success / good fortune. Reduce inequality in society and our country would be far less divided, happier, more productive and kinder. Sadly the Conservative Party is not a party when the poop hits the fan that really wants to make society fairer. It’s idea of equality is for a few people from working class backgrounds to accrue millions via the City etc and then point to that as proof the system works for all when it’s obvious that isn’t the case. When a nurse, or youth worker single parent can live a good life, have a decent house, holiday and are just as valued as a banker etc then I might stop highlighting the completely flawed Conservative ideology that has brought this country to where it is now after 13 years of largely failure, vandalism and bitter infighting.
You don’t like my posts, I’m ambivalent to yours, I doubt it’ll ever change.
RE: Paradigm Shift - Fido - 08-07-2022
Yes, I know your politics are simple. You think you know who needs to get more money without really thinking about where it will come from.
Let's take your opening gambit here:
The French government have just announced a number of measures including pensions/benefits increases, continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation, financial aid to poor families, rent rise limits and others to curb inflation. All passed through parliament.’
1) Pensions/benefit increases. So does that mean ALL pensions need to be increased? I made a specific point about targeting pensions and those that got them. Some pensioners definitely don't need an increase. Everyone needs to tighten their belts at the moment across the board - I think that is a point that needs to be made - and for those who can't support should be made available. I mentioned pensioners because you mentioned it. Sort of how a debate works in most cases but you don't get the point that you have to listen to what the other person is saying first.
2) Continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation. Again, mentions nothing about helped out those in need. We're not in any way "well off" (subjective I know) but can still pay for bills if they go up. Others can't - they're the ones who need help.
3) Financial aid to poor families. Hard to disagree. First mention of a target of sorts.
4) Rent rise limits. Others who have a much better idea of this would be better informed to comment but rigging a market will bring its own complications and is rarely something governments are any good at.
5) Others. OK, could be anything.
So out of those listed above and without further information one makes sense, the others maybe less so. But as far as you are concerned this is what needs to be done at face value without giving any kind of thought as to how this may be afforded, hence my diatribe.
Just a couple more points to address yours (starting to see how this works yet?):
1) I'm not an NHS-sceptic, it's fundamentally a great thing but far, far too much money is wasted. Reform is necessary in my opinion as opposed to only throwing more money at it.
2) I don't like the EU as it is now. It's shown itself to be a sour divorcee (and I take on board we have been too, to a certain extent). There are many tenets of it which I do including free trade and closer co-operation. That's what we signed up to a few decades ago but it transformed itself enormously between then and now and no doubt has plans to go further. Those who prefer to remain make the point of having more influence being in than being out; my take was that this was rarely the case and I mention the tax-swindle of Lux-Co and Swiss-Co models economically plus then conflicts on it's very border that the EU were toothless in trying to resolve. An economic model that has the same currency in countries as diverse as Germany and Greece never seemed a good idea.
As opposed to "not liking your posts" you might want to consider some element of a filter - that way you can get a coherent conversation going without raking over old ground again and again and again and again. And having petty little prejudices does your case no good at all, just have a look at some of the replies other posters give who have entirely different viewpoints.
RE: Paradigm Shift - Derek Hardballs - 08-07-2022
(08-07-2022, 11:06 AM)Fido Wrote: Yes, I know your politics are simple. You think you know who needs to get more money without really thinking about where it will come from.
Let's take your opening gambit here:
The French government have just announced a number of measures including pensions/benefits increases, continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation, financial aid to poor families, rent rise limits and others to curb inflation. All passed through parliament.’
1) Pensions/benefit increases. So does that mean ALL pensions need to be increased? I made a specific point about targeting pensions and those that got them. Some pensioners definitely don't need an increase. Everyone needs to tighten their belts at the moment across the board - I think that is a point that needs to be made - and for those who can't support should be made available. I mentioned pensioners because you mentioned it. Sort of how a debate works in most cases but you don't get the point that you have to listen to what the other person is saying first.
2) Continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation. Again, mentions nothing about helped out those in need. We're not in any way "well off" (subjective I know) but can still pay for bills if they go up. Others can't - they're the ones who need help.
3) Financial aid to poor families. Hard to disagree. First mention of a target of sorts.
4) Rent rise limits. Others who have a much better idea of this would be better informed to comment but rigging a market will bring its own complications and is rarely something governments are any good at.
5) Others. OK, could be anything.
So out of those listed above and without further information one makes sense, the others maybe less so. But as far as you are concerned this is what needs to be done at face value without giving any kind of thought as to how this may be afforded, hence my diatribe.
Just a couple more points to address yours (starting to see how this works yet?):
1) I'm not an NHS-sceptic, it's fundamentally a great thing but far, far too much money is wasted. Reform is necessary in my opinion as opposed to only throwing more money at it.
2) I don't like the EU as it is now. It's shown itself to be a sour divorcee (and I take on board we have been too, to a certain extent). There are many tenets of it which I do including free trade and closer co-operation. That's what we signed up to a few decades ago but it transformed itself enormously between then and now and no doubt has plans to go further. Those who prefer to remain make the point of having more influence being in than being out; my take was that this was rarely the case and I mention the tax-swindle of Lux-Co and Swiss-Co models economically plus then conflicts on it's very border that the EU were toothless in trying to resolve. An economic model that has the same currency in countries as diverse as Germany and Greece never seemed a good idea.
As opposed to "not liking your posts" you might want to consider some element of a filter - that way you can get a coherent conversation going without raking over old ground again and again and again and again. And having petty little prejudices does your case no good at all, just have a look at some of the replies other posters give who have entirely different viewpoints.
…and the cost of doing nothing for the poorest and vulnerable is? The point is whilst Truss and Sunak only offer tax cuts as solutions it fails to solve anything for those who really need the support. Now either that is a choice they are prepared to make to see families put on the breadline or they will have to u/turn pretty much immediately in September on their ideologically driven tax cuts rather than hand outs (Truss has said this not me).
If they do nothing but tax cuts for those on or above £40k or above you will see…
NHS admissions rise due to illness related to poverty
Social Services put under pressure as families can’t feed their kids
Social housing put under impossible pressure
House repossessions
Children struggling at school due to a lack of help at home as parents work all hours god sends do just about manage.
Schools offering the only warm meal of the day
Inflation will carry on rising or stay high as those that benefit from tax cuts carry on spending
Social Care on its knees well that’s already happening let’s say belly instead as people can’t look after themselves or their loved ones. Did you know for example a full time carer for a severely disabled child in the U.K. receives £69 a week, not exactly going to benefit from Truss’s ‘solutions’ are they?
Increase in crime as people turn to crime to make ends meet be it theft, burglary, car theft, drug dealing etc
Increase in civil unrest, potential strikes, demonstrations and riots
Potential civil disobedience with people refusing to pay energy bills
Increase in prison population as crime goes up.
Recession and job losses and the easiest to let go will be those in the gig economy
Yet more food banks
Warm Banks ffs so people can stay warm… it’s 2022 not the Victorian age
In thirteen years the party in power have failed miserably to make health, social care, crime etc better for people. All we have seen is the rich getting richer at an ever growing rate. You think my politics are too simplistic I think yours have made the country a lot worse than it was just over a decade ago. Now we have Pork Market Truss to lead us through a crisis what could possibly go wrong?!?
Oh and those expected to pick up the pieces will be those told they can’t have a pay rise in the public sector whilst they see energy companies, banks, politicians and millionaires, billionaires profits and wages grow to obscene levels. If a country allows the gap between rich and poor to get too big it will cease to function properly as a democratic state.
Ps Brexit was and is a crap idea.
RE: Paradigm Shift - Squid - 08-07-2022
(08-07-2022, 11:44 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-07-2022, 11:06 AM)Fido Wrote: Yes, I know your politics are simple. You think you know who needs to get more money without really thinking about where it will come from.
Let's take your opening gambit here:
The French government have just announced a number of measures including pensions/benefits increases, continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation, financial aid to poor families, rent rise limits and others to curb inflation. All passed through parliament.’
1) Pensions/benefit increases. So does that mean ALL pensions need to be increased? I made a specific point about targeting pensions and those that got them. Some pensioners definitely don't need an increase. Everyone needs to tighten their belts at the moment across the board - I think that is a point that needs to be made - and for those who can't support should be made available. I mentioned pensioners because you mentioned it. Sort of how a debate works in most cases but you don't get the point that you have to listen to what the other person is saying first.
2) Continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation. Again, mentions nothing about helped out those in need. We're not in any way "well off" (subjective I know) but can still pay for bills if they go up. Others can't - they're the ones who need help.
3) Financial aid to poor families. Hard to disagree. First mention of a target of sorts.
4) Rent rise limits. Others who have a much better idea of this would be better informed to comment but rigging a market will bring its own complications and is rarely something governments are any good at.
5) Others. OK, could be anything.
So out of those listed above and without further information one makes sense, the others maybe less so. But as far as you are concerned this is what needs to be done at face value without giving any kind of thought as to how this may be afforded, hence my diatribe.
Just a couple more points to address yours (starting to see how this works yet?):
1) I'm not an NHS-sceptic, it's fundamentally a great thing but far, far too much money is wasted. Reform is necessary in my opinion as opposed to only throwing more money at it.
2) I don't like the EU as it is now. It's shown itself to be a sour divorcee (and I take on board we have been too, to a certain extent). There are many tenets of it which I do including free trade and closer co-operation. That's what we signed up to a few decades ago but it transformed itself enormously between then and now and no doubt has plans to go further. Those who prefer to remain make the point of having more influence being in than being out; my take was that this was rarely the case and I mention the tax-swindle of Lux-Co and Swiss-Co models economically plus then conflicts on it's very border that the EU were toothless in trying to resolve. An economic model that has the same currency in countries as diverse as Germany and Greece never seemed a good idea.
As opposed to "not liking your posts" you might want to consider some element of a filter - that way you can get a coherent conversation going without raking over old ground again and again and again and again. And having petty little prejudices does your case no good at all, just have a look at some of the replies other posters give who have entirely different viewpoints.
…and the cost of doing nothing for the poorest and vulnerable is? The point is whilst Truss and Sunak only offer tax cuts as solutions it fails to solve anything for those who really need the support. Now either that is a choice they are prepared to make to see families put on the breadline or they will have to u/turn pretty much immediately in September on their ideologically driven tax cuts rather than hand outs (Truss has said this not me).
If they do nothing but tax cuts for those on or above £40k or above you will see…
NHS admissions rise due to illness related to poverty
Social Services put under pressure as families can’t feed their kids
Social housing put under impossible pressure
House repossessions
Children struggling at school due to a lack of help at home as parents work all hours god sends do just about manage.
Schools offering the only warm meal of the day
Inflation will carry on rising or stay high as those that benefit from tax cuts carry on spending
Social Care on its knees well that’s already happening let’s say belly instead as people can’t look after themselves or their loved ones. Did you know for example a full time carer for a severely disabled child in the U.K. receives £69 a week, not exactly going to benefit from Truss’s ‘solutions’ are they?
Increase in crime as people turn to crime to make ends meet be it theft, burglary, car theft, drug dealing etc
Increase in civil unrest, potential strikes, demonstrations and riots
Potential civil disobedience with people refusing to pay energy bills
Increase in prison population as crime goes up.
Recession and job losses and the easiest to let go will be those in the gig economy
Yet more food banks
Warm Banks ffs so people can stay warm… it’s 2022 not the Victorian age
In thirteen years the party in power have failed miserably to make health, social care, crime etc better for people. All we have seen is the rich getting richer at an ever growing rate. You think my politics are too simplistic I think yours have made the country a lot worse than it was just over a decade ago. Now we have Pork Market Truss to lead us through a crisis what could possibly go wrong?!?
Oh and those expected to pick up the pieces will be those told they can’t have a pay rise in the public sector whilst they see energy companies, banks, politicians and millionaires, billionaires profits and wages grow to obscene levels. If a country allows the gap between rich and poor to get too big it will cease to function properly as a democratic state.
Ps Brexit was and is a crap idea.
Fido actually responded to your post point by point. All you have have done is provide a list of the currently suffering, which is completely irrelevant to the point you made about what France was doing, notably pension increases.
Fido didn't say, Do nothing for the most vulnerable, he said that sometimes, just throwing money at a problem isn't enough, particularly if you haven't posted where that money is going to come from.
All these problems will still exist if a Labour government is elected. Brexit will not be undone and Starmer has vowed there will be no "Magic Money Tree" economics.
RE: Paradigm Shift - Derek Hardballs - 08-07-2022
(08-07-2022, 05:34 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-07-2022, 11:44 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-07-2022, 11:06 AM)Fido Wrote: Yes, I know your politics are simple. You think you know who needs to get more money without really thinking about where it will come from.
Let's take your opening gambit here:
The French government have just announced a number of measures including pensions/benefits increases, continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation, financial aid to poor families, rent rise limits and others to curb inflation. All passed through parliament.’
1) Pensions/benefit increases. So does that mean ALL pensions need to be increased? I made a specific point about targeting pensions and those that got them. Some pensioners definitely don't need an increase. Everyone needs to tighten their belts at the moment across the board - I think that is a point that needs to be made - and for those who can't support should be made available. I mentioned pensioners because you mentioned it. Sort of how a debate works in most cases but you don't get the point that you have to listen to what the other person is saying first.
2) Continuation of fuel and energy price rise mitigation. Again, mentions nothing about helped out those in need. We're not in any way "well off" (subjective I know) but can still pay for bills if they go up. Others can't - they're the ones who need help.
3) Financial aid to poor families. Hard to disagree. First mention of a target of sorts.
4) Rent rise limits. Others who have a much better idea of this would be better informed to comment but rigging a market will bring its own complications and is rarely something governments are any good at.
5) Others. OK, could be anything.
So out of those listed above and without further information one makes sense, the others maybe less so. But as far as you are concerned this is what needs to be done at face value without giving any kind of thought as to how this may be afforded, hence my diatribe.
Just a couple more points to address yours (starting to see how this works yet?):
1) I'm not an NHS-sceptic, it's fundamentally a great thing but far, far too much money is wasted. Reform is necessary in my opinion as opposed to only throwing more money at it.
2) I don't like the EU as it is now. It's shown itself to be a sour divorcee (and I take on board we have been too, to a certain extent). There are many tenets of it which I do including free trade and closer co-operation. That's what we signed up to a few decades ago but it transformed itself enormously between then and now and no doubt has plans to go further. Those who prefer to remain make the point of having more influence being in than being out; my take was that this was rarely the case and I mention the tax-swindle of Lux-Co and Swiss-Co models economically plus then conflicts on it's very border that the EU were toothless in trying to resolve. An economic model that has the same currency in countries as diverse as Germany and Greece never seemed a good idea.
As opposed to "not liking your posts" you might want to consider some element of a filter - that way you can get a coherent conversation going without raking over old ground again and again and again and again. And having petty little prejudices does your case no good at all, just have a look at some of the replies other posters give who have entirely different viewpoints.
…and the cost of doing nothing for the poorest and vulnerable is? The point is whilst Truss and Sunak only offer tax cuts as solutions it fails to solve anything for those who really need the support. Now either that is a choice they are prepared to make to see families put on the breadline or they will have to u/turn pretty much immediately in September on their ideologically driven tax cuts rather than hand outs (Truss has said this not me).
If they do nothing but tax cuts for those on or above £40k or above you will see…
NHS admissions rise due to illness related to poverty
Social Services put under pressure as families can’t feed their kids
Social housing put under impossible pressure
House repossessions
Children struggling at school due to a lack of help at home as parents work all hours god sends do just about manage.
Schools offering the only warm meal of the day
Inflation will carry on rising or stay high as those that benefit from tax cuts carry on spending
Social Care on its knees well that’s already happening let’s say belly instead as people can’t look after themselves or their loved ones. Did you know for example a full time carer for a severely disabled child in the U.K. receives £69 a week, not exactly going to benefit from Truss’s ‘solutions’ are they?
Increase in crime as people turn to crime to make ends meet be it theft, burglary, car theft, drug dealing etc
Increase in civil unrest, potential strikes, demonstrations and riots
Potential civil disobedience with people refusing to pay energy bills
Increase in prison population as crime goes up.
Recession and job losses and the easiest to let go will be those in the gig economy
Yet more food banks
Warm Banks ffs so people can stay warm… it’s 2022 not the Victorian age
In thirteen years the party in power have failed miserably to make health, social care, crime etc better for people. All we have seen is the rich getting richer at an ever growing rate. You think my politics are too simplistic I think yours have made the country a lot worse than it was just over a decade ago. Now we have Pork Market Truss to lead us through a crisis what could possibly go wrong?!?
Oh and those expected to pick up the pieces will be those told they can’t have a pay rise in the public sector whilst they see energy companies, banks, politicians and millionaires, billionaires profits and wages grow to obscene levels. If a country allows the gap between rich and poor to get too big it will cease to function properly as a democratic state.
Ps Brexit was and is a crap idea.
Fido actually responded to your post point by point. All you have have done is provide a list of the currently suffering, which is completely irrelevant to the point you made about what France was doing, notably pension increases.
Fido didn't say, Do nothing for the most vulnerable, he said that sometimes, just throwing money at a problem isn't enough, particularly if you haven't posted where that money is going to come from.
All these problems will still exist if a Labour government is elected. Brexit will not be undone and Starmer has vowed there will be no "Magic Money Tree" economics.
No, the list is potential consequences if the government doesn’t help the poorest more financially. The fact we already have major problems in some of those areas I’ve mentioned is an indictment of the last thirteen years of failure. The point is can the government afford not to support those under the NI threshold? If they do nothing it’ll cost them more from the magic money tree and damage the political Petunia.
How will cutting taxes now and in turn giving more money to the relatively comfortable / well off to spend on non essential goods help curb inflation? Or help failing / creaking public services? It’ll make it worse surely? Support should be targeted to those who need to survive first and foremost.
Brexit isn’t over, it’s still causing major problems for industries from music to fishing. The fact Starmer and Labour have to pretend it can be anything but a political fudge with little or no benefit to the country is embarrassing but sadly where we are as a country. A complete inability to be honest with people because it’ll lose votes.
RE: Paradigm Shift - Protheroe - 08-07-2022
Dekka is right in some respects. Tax cuts are simply dog whistles to the member electorate. Truss and Sunak are not just asking the wrong questions, they’re speaking a different language from the broader electorate. I don’t think I can recall a more tin-eared response to an acute problem.
In the WhatsApp groups they’re circling the wagons around Truss. It’s thoroughly depressing. There are certain people who I’d never have believed would end up backing her who are now doing so publicly. I won’t fall out with them because they’re friends - but my time in the party is over, for good.
RE: Paradigm Shift - JOK - 08-08-2022
Just so I’m clear; France are doing this that and the other and we are doing nothing. Is that the argument?
Did I imagine then the, targeted, £150 council tax rebate? Have I misread about a £400 per household energy rebate due soon? Have I not remembered correctly a reduction on fuel duty?
So, tax cuts will "likely fuel inflation" but generous inflation busting wage rises won't?
Fido, setting out a well-constructed and reasoned argument in temperate language and expecting a reciprocal reply is, I’m sorry to say, naively optimistic.
RE: Paradigm Shift - Derek Hardballs - 08-08-2022
(08-08-2022, 05:43 AM)JOK Wrote: Just so I’m clear; France are doing this that and the other and we are doing nothing. Is that the argument?
Did I imagine then the, targeted, £150 council tax rebate? Have I misread about a £400 per household energy rebate due soon? Have I not remembered correctly a reduction on fuel duty?
So, tax cuts will "likely fuel inflation" but generous inflation busting wage rises won't?
Fido, setting out a well-constructed and reasoned argument in temperate language and expecting a reciprocal reply is, I’m sorry to say, naively optimistic.
What did I say that was rude or didn’t address the overall point that we need to do more to help those that will be plunged into serious financial difficulties?
Many people’s real term wages haven’t returned to pre-financial crash levels even before these huge jumps in fuel and inflation driven problems. So are you really arguing that they should not look to have a pay rise? Whilst many bosses and shareholders have seen their wage, bonuses and dividends rise above inflation or at least keeping up with it year on year.
Tax cuts don’t help those who need it most and the help currently given won’t touch the sides of a problem they didn’t make. What are you suggesting low income families should do? Not heat their homes, or not eat properly? If wages for them don’t rise then how do you plug the gap in the short to medium term? There will be a u-turn and Truss will pretend she was misrepresented again!
RE: Paradigm Shift - Fido - 08-08-2022
(08-08-2022, 09:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-08-2022, 05:43 AM)JOK Wrote: Just so I’m clear; France are doing this that and the other and we are doing nothing. Is that the argument?
Did I imagine then the, targeted, £150 council tax rebate? Have I misread about a £400 per household energy rebate due soon? Have I not remembered correctly a reduction on fuel duty?
So, tax cuts will "likely fuel inflation" but generous inflation busting wage rises won't?
Fido, setting out a well-constructed and reasoned argument in temperate language and expecting a reciprocal reply is, I’m sorry to say, naively optimistic.
What did I say that was rude or didn’t address the overall point that we need to do more to help those that will be plunged into serious financial difficulties?
Many people’s real term wages haven’t returned to pre-financial crash levels even before these huge jumps in fuel and inflation driven problems. So are you really arguing that they should not look to have a pay rise? Whilst many bosses and shareholders have seen their wage, bonuses and dividends rise above inflation or at least keeping up with it year on year.
Tax cuts don’t help those who need it most and the help currently given won’t touch the sides of a problem they didn’t make. What are you suggesting low income families should do? Not heat their homes, or not eat properly? If wages for them don’t rise then how do you plug the gap in the short to medium term? There will be a u-turn and Truss will pretend she was misrepresented again!
Your starting point was that the French had the right ideas. I disagreed and gave my opinions as to why. Then you replied with something not altogether related. How it normally goes, you know.
|