WBAUnofficial
Dial that G - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Dial that G (/showthread.php?tid=25698)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Dial that G - Protheroe - 07-08-2022

There's a bloke who sits behind me who's still hoping we get to sign Graham Fenton permanently.


RE: Dial that G - Dumbo - 07-08-2022

(07-08-2022, 07:20 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Christ, are we still hoping he'd come back. Pack it in, and let it go. We really do have some clueless fans.

What’s clueless about exploring the possibility of bringing back a proven goal scorer at this level? A free transfer? A player that has already shone at this club before? 

He hasn’t played much lately, admittedly…so I like to think we’d do some digging and see if a deal is right for all parties. If it’s not, we move on. But that doesn’t make fans ‘clueless’ for hoping we’re exploring an option on doing the deal.


RE: Dial that G - TartanRug - 07-08-2022

Can't wait for the meltdown when he scores the winner against us


RE: Dial that G - KratosBaggie - 07-08-2022

(07-08-2022, 08:27 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-08-2022, 07:20 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Christ, are we still hoping he'd come back. Pack it in, and let it go. We really do have some clueless fans.
He hasn’t played much lately, admittedly…

Not sure why I'm dignifiying your posts with a response, given the obvious clichéd adage, but you've answered your own question here. 

This strange obsession with Gayle, from some of our fans, has to stop. Yes, he was decent for us. Maybe he would he worth a gamble, who knows, but we should stop clamouring for him like he's a messiah. That's the 'clueless' part of my original statement, more than anything else.

Let's not forget his stupid red card in the play-offs that arguably cost us promotion.


RE: Dial that G - wba13 - 07-08-2022

Loved Gayle when he was with us but that ship has sailed, he’s hardly played since leaving us same as Yokoslu I personally would not want either back we need younger and hungrier players.


RE: Dial that G - Spandaubaggie - 07-08-2022

(07-08-2022, 08:27 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-08-2022, 07:20 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Christ, are we still hoping he'd come back. Pack it in, and let it go. We really do have some clueless fans.

What’s clueless about exploring the possibility of bringing back a proven goal scorer at this level? A free transfer? A player that has already shone at this club before? 

He hasn’t played much lately, admittedly…so I like to think we’d do some digging and see if a deal is right for all parties. If it’s not, we move on. But that doesn’t make fans ‘clueless’ for hoping we’re exploring an option on doing the deal.

I'm with you on this Dumbo. There's no clamouring etc as some are saying, but given a choice of Zohore or Gayle I know who I'd like in the melting pot. 

Also, while some try to sarcastically compare him to us wanting to get people like Bob Taylor back, or Graham Fenton, Gayle is actually a current player and one who a team in our division are willing to pay good wages to. He's not someone in his 50s- he is 32.

I'm not advocating bringing him back at all, just trying to defend those who are interested, which seems a fairly logical thing to think as he is a proven goalscorer at this level and still playing, and probably has 3-4 more years in him.


RE: Dial that G - MGalea - 07-08-2022

(07-08-2022, 10:16 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(07-08-2022, 08:27 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(07-08-2022, 07:20 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Christ, are we still hoping he'd come back. Pack it in, and let it go. We really do have some clueless fans.

What’s clueless about exploring the possibility of bringing back a proven goal scorer at this level? A free transfer? A player that has already shone at this club before? 

He hasn’t played much lately, admittedly…so I like to think we’d do some digging and see if a deal is right for all parties. If it’s not, we move on. But that doesn’t make fans ‘clueless’ for hoping we’re exploring an option on doing the deal.

I'm with you on this Dumbo. There's no clamouring etc as some are saying, but given a choice of Zohore or Gayle I know who I'd like in the melting pot. 

Also, while some try to sarcastically compare him to us wanting to get people like Bob Taylor back, or Graham Fenton, Gayle is actually a current player and one who a team in our division are willing to pay good wages to. He's not someone in his 50s- he is 32.

I'm not advocating bringing him back at all, just trying to defend those who are interested, which seems a fairly logical thing to think as he is a proven goalscorer at this level and still playing, and probably has 3-4 more years in him.

Wasn't Super Bob the same age as Gayle is when he came back? Also same age as Kevin Phillips at the point of signing for us...


RE: Dial that G - Birdman1811 - 07-08-2022

Never have injury prone players as back up, because they won't be available when you need them, Gayle is injury prone, and rarely kicked a ball for 3 years now. All the Champ clubs around, only Birmingham wanted him.


RE: Dial that G - KratosBaggie - 07-08-2022

My comment about Bob Taylor was meant as today's Bob Taylor, not the 2000 Bob Taylor, in case that wasn't clear. And yes, it was overly sarcastic. But the point still stands, don't clamour for a signing, just because they were previously good. It's not that black and white. 

I don't think age has anything to do with it. The likes of Taylor, Gera or KP were into their 30's (the former two when they signing second time around l) when they signed for us, but were at the top of their games, and were exactly what we needed at the time.

I don't look at a number, as it's kinda irrelevant, especially in today's game with all the sports science, players can easily play 'till their mid 30's. Even late 30's if they look after themselves.

Gayle would potentially improve us, especially when comparing to someone like Zahore (I think I'd improve us if that's the case), but given Dwight's lack of recent game time, his recent AND past injury problems, and his relatively high wage, it's a no from me, and thankfully the club. It'd be a massive gamble. One we can't afford.

The budget can and should be better utilised.


RE: Dial that G - SophLad - 07-08-2022

(07-08-2022, 10:44 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: My comment about Bob Taylor was meant as today's Bob Taylor, not the 2000 Bob Taylor, in case that wasn't clear. And yes, it was overly sarcastic. But the point still stands, don't clamour for a signing, just because they were previously good. It's not that black and white. 

I don't think age has anything to do with it. The likes of Taylor, Gera or KP were into their 30's (the former two when they signing second time around l) when they signed for us, but were at the top of their games, and were exactly what we needed at the time.

I don't look at a number, as it's kinda irrelevant, especially in today's game with all the sports science, players can easily play 'till their mid 30's. Even late 30's if they look after themselves.

Gayle would potentially improve us, especially when comparing to someone like Zahore (I think I'd improve us if that's the case), but given Dwight's lack of recent game time, his recent AND past injury problems, and his relatively high wage, it's a no from me, and thankfully the club. It'd be a massive gamble. One we can't afford.

The budget can and should be better utilised.

Broken clocks