![]() |
|
Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living (/showthread.php?tid=25351) |
RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Borin' Baggie - 06-14-2022 1. All free school meals should be expanded to all students to relieve the cost of living, reduce the stigma against it and promote healthy eating habits. Removing that is an absolutely stupid idea. 2. Tesla's weren't eligible for the ev subsidy in the first place RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Protheroe - 06-14-2022 1. I don't need the state to feed my kids. Direct the help to where it's needed. 2. Insert whatever soulless milk float you want then. RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Borin' Baggie - 06-14-2022 1. It isn't the state feeding kids, it is the schools - state-run, academies and independent. Given that we need to focus on preventative care and childhood nutrition is a major general problem in this country I'm sorry but there needs to be major intervention to reinforce healthy eating habits and improving nutritional standards for young children. The market has completely shit the bed and so therefore there needs to be intervention to address that, Finland has shown such a policy to be successful and has disconnected childhood obesity rates from adult obesity rates through nutritional policies similar to that and active lifestyle funding. 2. Milk floats don't go 0-60 in 7 seconds. RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Protheroe - 06-14-2022 1. You can count the obese kids on one hand at A-minor's (big) primary school. Go to Inner City Brum and you can count the thin kids on one hand. Spend the money where it is needed. 2. Arf. A Nissan Leaf does 0-60 (soullessly, rather like vacuuming the stairs) in 7.4 seconds. Amazing. Wouldn't be seen dead in one, but amazing nevertheless. RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Borin' Baggie - 06-14-2022 Spend the money where it's needed how? The current childhood nutrition plan simply isn't good enough, Finland has had success with rolling out free school meals to all children in education as has Sweden. I'm surprised that a liberal, as you profess yourself to be, wouldn't support a simple and cost-effective correction to the market to address the shortcomings in policy which could help prevent deeper interventions by the state being necessary later. One meal a day, free to all kids in school, nutritional and balanced. It also reduces the bureaucracy around applying it, stigmatisation and reluctance to engage with the scheme and reduces the risk of people who should be eligible slipping through the cracks. Also, thinness doesn't mean they're eating healthy and it doesn't mean they're learning healthy eating habits, it means they're eating to a calorie deficit. RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Protheroe - 06-14-2022 (06-14-2022, 03:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Also, thinness doesn't necessarily mean they're eating healthy and it doesn't necessarily mean they're learning healthy eating habits, it means they're eating to a calorie deficit. I've inserted a very important word there. The fact is that many kids don't require any intervention at all. A large minority do. "The market" doesn't feed my kids. I do (or rather Mrs P does) . As parents we see that as an absolutely core part of our responsibility; as a liberal it's none of the state's business if I'm not harming them. I can't for the life of me understand this point about "stigma". How on Earth would you know if kids were on free meals these days anyway? It's not like those who do pay send their kids in with a little brown envelope anymore. It's not like kids care about it, or in the case of my two (I've asked) whether it ever crosses their mind. RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Fido - 06-14-2022 My kids get packed lunches most days because 1) it’s cheaper but more importantly 2) cantines seem to have reverted to carb-overload as they were 30 years ago. Pizza/calzone/panini is not really any better than fish fingers, chips and beans yet if they did serve just quinoa with roasted veg most kids wouldn’t touch it anyway. No idea why we waste time on religious education when we could be at least teaching kids to cook a proper meal instead of just baking scones or soda bread. RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Borin' Baggie - 06-14-2022 The word you have described as "very important" is entirely redundant and doesn't in any way change either the direct meaning nor the inference of what I put. So no, it isn't "very important. The fact is that we have a serious issue in this country with ensuring children in general learn and follow healthy eating habits. Passing the duty of care to schools to address that has been successful in other European countries, it is the exact thing we and many other countries did to tackle illiteracy and educational shortcomings. The market isn't some sacrosanct cosmic entity, it is the decisions and actions of people to exchange goods and information. The market has failed to ensure that enough of the younger generations in this country have general healthy eating habits, a correction needs to be made to address the shortcomings and their societal ramifications. You're argument about the responsibilities of parents is akin to the Victorian fuckwits opposed to universal education mandates because "their kids were being looked after properly", note that your position is in direct contradiction to the actions taken by liberals and is in direct contradiction to the core liberal concept of utilitarianism. And are you seriously unaware of the concept of self-stigma? Both for children and parents being too proud to take up help available, even with digitial transactions in schools too many kids eligible for free school meals aren't using them and too many parents eligible aren't applying, to the tune of 20% and 25% of all kids eligible for free school meals. That's not even accounting for people who should be eligible but aren't and therefore slip through the gap, that's just people not using what they're eligible. This doesn't extend to just free school meals either, one of my mates got himself into a financial mess and lived off savings during the financial crisis instead of asking for financial relief while looking for a job. (06-14-2022, 05:02 PM)Fido Wrote: My kids get packed lunches most days because 1) it’s cheaper but more importantly 2) cantines seem to have reverted to carb-overload as they were 30 years ago. Pizza/calzone/panini is not really any better than fish fingers, chips and beans yet if they did serve just quinoa with roasted veg most kids wouldn’t touch it anyway. No idea why we waste time on religious education when we could be at least teaching kids to cook a proper meal instead of just baking scones or soda bread. Literally one of the recommendations that Proth is celebrating being dropped is the school food standards plan Another thing is cooking in the curriculum RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Protheroe - 06-15-2022 (06-14-2022, 05:04 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The word you have described as "very important" is entirely redundant and doesn't in any way change either the direct meaning nor the inference of what I put. So no, it isn't "very important. For a "liberal" you sound very authoritarian. We have the greatest array of food choices ever in our history. It is not for the government to mandate what I stuff down my neck or down my kids' necks. Education is one thing, diet by diktat is quite another. Until just now yes, I was seriously unaware of the concept of self-stigma. Now I am aware of it I care even less. My policy solution would be to get the fuck over yourself - particularly in your mate's situation. I fully expect he'll be sending his £400 off his energy bill back to the state. FFS. RE: Targeted Help With Cost Of Living - Borin' Baggie - 06-15-2022 Piss off, I'm no authoritarian. I'm a utilitarian, I'm a liberal. I want a utilitarian approach to stave off authoritarian solutions that we both know will come in when the horse has bolted because that's how this country works, you sticking your fingers in your ears isn't a solution. Utilitarianism isn't authoritarianism, it's core to the entire premise of liberalism, you outright can't be a liberal and be opposed to utilitarianism. You've now gone off on a tangent talking as though the state would be dictating what you feed your children when that isn't in any way relevant, the state providing free school meals for all children doesn't mandate you can't feed your children, you can't provide a packed lunch nor does it state they have to eat it. All it does is mean schools would have to provide a free school meal that is healthy and balanced to every primary aged child under their duty of care. That is not authoritarian. Rising childhood obesity rates, rising levels of childhood obesity, rising levels of malnutrition, rising strain on the NHS. 25% underutilisation of those eligible for free school meals, 40% of those in relative poverty not eligible. Means testing free school meals hasn't worked and our children are as unhealthy as they've ever been. |