RE: Steve Bruce... - Sliced - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-16-2022, 10:59 AM)Sliced Wrote: I think people are reading what they want.
When we went on a bad run under Bruce half of us were primarily blaming the players and the other half primarily blaming Val for the first 3-4 games. When Bruce persisted with something that clearly wasn't working he rightly got criticised, as did Val; and they both deserved it. Anyone could see that TGH should have been played earlier but he was overlooked in favour of Reach at AM which absolutely wasn't working. That deserved criticism, just like Val deserved criticism for relentlessly sticking with something that wasn't working.
I think Bruce is a very good manager, at this level and I hope now we'll see how good he is. That doesn't change the fact that he should have picked up more than 1 point in our first 5 games or realised that Reach at AM wasn't working.......especially when pretty much all the fans could see that too.
I think the criticism of Bruce was completely ott and for the reasons CA has already pointed out. The idea he was going to come in and hit the ground running after months of poor results was an unfair expectation. How many matches has he been at the helm even now?
The league position argument is flawed given the points the teams below us had clawed back by the time Val left. It meant a win could see a team jump three or four places if things went their way. Likewise for months teams below us were so poor that even though our form was bad they still hadn’t gone above us, that changed and teams improved but it’s taken us time to turn around a complete mess. I really don’t think Bruce has anything to answer for other than perhaps underestimating the lack of confidence and rigidity of mindset instilled in the players after months of ‘non possession’ football.
Bruce got a free pass for a few games, the criticism was rightly towards the players.
In fact there were more posts about how criticism of Bruce was unfair than actual criticisms of Bruce, which is a theme continuing at the moment. With regards to the league position argument, over the course of the season Val had us in 5th; that's around where we probably should have been. It doesn't mean he would have kept us there, it means that initially he overperformed and towards the end he underperformed.
As pointed out by MD a couple of posts ago, Bruce's form in his first 8 games is equal to Val's worst form, which was his last 8 games, that lakcof points is partially due to Bruce, partially due to the lack of confidence that the players had when Val left and partially due to the lack of squad depth. You seem to be setting up positions that aren't being taken by hardly anyone. I don't think Val would have gotten us into the playoffs (I made one ironic post to this effect on a thread where arguments of other nature were taking place), nor do I think Val is a better manager than Bruce. However this idea that everything bad that happens now after Val is gone is still Val's fault is absolutely ridiculous.
And with regards to "non-possession football", we've averaged 51% posession under Bruce, under Val we were averaging 53% and arguably our best games this season have come without the ball (including yesterdays). As someone who was in favour of Pulis surely it's a bit late to be arguing possession = good.
RE: Steve Bruce... - baggie_ray - 03-16-2022
People are too quick to criticise football managers. It normally takes more than a few games to turn a team around. Whilst accepting that Bruce might have considered TGH in midfield a bit earlier than he did, his other midfield options were Mowatt, Molumby and Reach. He either had to find a way to make them effective or bring in players out of position or the kids.
With Livermore back, Bruce has landed on a system that not only covers Livermore's weaknesses, but also accentuates the qualities of the other players.
Mowatt has the freedom to push on, instead of standing around in front of the defence looking all at sea. The middle of the pitch is boosted by an extra body so is no longer a yawning chasm for the opposition to play through. We still have width so can spread the play. And we have two forwards who are mobile who play well together.
3-5-2 suits the players we have. I'm not sure that that was immediately obvious without trying a few other systems first.
RE: Steve Bruce... - SW4Baggie - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 12:24 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: People are too quick to criticise football managers. It normally takes more than a few games to turn a team around. Whilst accepting that Bruce might have considered TGH in midfield a bit earlier than he did, his other midfield options were Mowatt, Molumby and Reach. He either had to find a way to make them effective or bring in players out of position or the kids.
With Livermore back, Bruce has landed on a system that not only covers Livermore's weaknesses, but also accentuates the qualities of the other players.
Mowatt has the freedom to push on, instead of standing around in front of the defence looking all at sea. The middle of the pitch is boosted by an extra body so is no longer a yawning chasm for the opposition to play through. We still have width so can spread the play. And we have two forwards who are mobile who play well together.
3-5-2 suits the players we have. I'm not sure that that was immediately obvious without trying a few other systems first.
The only real thing Bruce deserves criticism for is playing Adam Reach as an AMC, and then persisting to do it more than once... but the absence of other options and the feedback from the coaching staff re TGH makes it understandable.
RE: Steve Bruce... - Sliced - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 11:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: My point was that the two sides will never agree, so best to just move on and focus on the positive uptick in form we've seen recently.
Those who felt some of stick Val got was OTT and in turn harshly laid into Bruce aren't going to change their position and neither are those who think Ismael was the devil reincarnate. Needs leaving now.
We had the big thread from Worcs the other week where all parties seemed to drop it, then for some reason we have to revisit after every decent performance. It's becoming like Brexit.
Corrected for you. Some just have to be right about these things.
It's fair to give Bruce credit rather than Val for yesterday's victory despite him basically reverting back to a high pressing Val-esque system, in the same way that Bruce deserved criticism rather than Val for persisting with Reach at AM and subsequently taking 1 point from 15. Definitely time to move on.
RE: Steve Bruce... - MassDebater - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 12:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-16-2022, 11:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: My point was that the two sides will never agree, so best to just move on and focus on the positive uptick in form we've seen recently.
Those who felt some of stick Val got was OTT and in turn harshly laid into Bruce aren't going to change their position and neither are those who think Ismael was the devil reincarnate. Needs leaving now.
We had the big thread from Worcs the other week where all parties seemed to drop it, then for some reason we have to revisit after every decent performance. It's becoming like Brexit.
Corrected for you. Some just have to be right about these things.
It's fair to give Bruce credit rather than Val for yesterday's victory despite him basically reverting back to a high pressing Val-esque system, in the same way that Bruce deserved criticism rather than Val for persisting with Reach at AM and subsequently taking 1 point from 15. Definitely time to move on.
Val-esque with the pressing, other than that there were no similarities.
RE: Steve Bruce... - Sliced - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 12:51 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (03-16-2022, 12:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-16-2022, 11:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: My point was that the two sides will never agree, so best to just move on and focus on the positive uptick in form we've seen recently.
Those who felt some of stick Val got was OTT and in turn harshly laid into Bruce aren't going to change their position and neither are those who think Ismael was the devil reincarnate. Needs leaving now.
We had the big thread from Worcs the other week where all parties seemed to drop it, then for some reason we have to revisit after every decent performance. It's becoming like Brexit.
Corrected for you. Some just have to be right about these things.
It's fair to give Bruce credit rather than Val for yesterday's victory despite him basically reverting back to a high pressing Val-esque system, in the same way that Bruce deserved criticism rather than Val for persisting with Reach at AM and subsequently taking 1 point from 15. Definitely time to move on.
Val-esque with the pressing, other than that there were no similarities.
5 at the back, Mowatt and Livermore in midfield, not be too concerned about having a lot of the ball and the goal came from a press. Textbook Val. Bruce has done well to recognise the things that Val got right and emulate them, and even moreso for instilling belief back into this team. Long may it continue!
RE: Steve Bruce... - Derek Hardballs - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 12:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-16-2022, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-16-2022, 10:59 AM)Sliced Wrote: I think people are reading what they want.
When we went on a bad run under Bruce half of us were primarily blaming the players and the other half primarily blaming Val for the first 3-4 games. When Bruce persisted with something that clearly wasn't working he rightly got criticised, as did Val; and they both deserved it. Anyone could see that TGH should have been played earlier but he was overlooked in favour of Reach at AM which absolutely wasn't working. That deserved criticism, just like Val deserved criticism for relentlessly sticking with something that wasn't working.
I think Bruce is a very good manager, at this level and I hope now we'll see how good he is. That doesn't change the fact that he should have picked up more than 1 point in our first 5 games or realised that Reach at AM wasn't working.......especially when pretty much all the fans could see that too.
I think the criticism of Bruce was completely ott and for the reasons CA has already pointed out. The idea he was going to come in and hit the ground running after months of poor results was an unfair expectation. How many matches has he been at the helm even now?
The league position argument is flawed given the points the teams below us had clawed back by the time Val left. It meant a win could see a team jump three or four places if things went their way. Likewise for months teams below us were so poor that even though our form was bad they still hadn’t gone above us, that changed and teams improved but it’s taken us time to turn around a complete mess. I really don’t think Bruce has anything to answer for other than perhaps underestimating the lack of confidence and rigidity of mindset instilled in the players after months of ‘non possession’ football.
Bruce got a free pass for a few games, the criticism was rightly towards the players.
In fact there were more posts about how criticism of Bruce was unfair than actual criticisms of Bruce, which is a theme continuing at the moment. With regards to the league position argument, over the course of the season Val had us in 5th; that's around where we probably should have been. It doesn't mean he would have kept us there, it means that initially he overperformed and towards the end he underperformed.
As pointed out by MD a couple of posts ago, Bruce's form in his first 8 games is equal to Val's worst form, which was his last 8 games, that lakcof points is partially due to Bruce, partially due to the lack of confidence that the players had when Val left and partially due to the lack of squad depth. You seem to be setting up positions that aren't being taken by hardly anyone. I don't think Val would have gotten us into the playoffs (I made one ironic post to this effect on a thread where arguments of other nature were taking place), nor do I think Val is a better manager than Bruce. However this idea that everything bad that happens now after Val is gone is still Val's fault is absolutely ridiculous.
And with regards to "non-possession football", we've averaged 51% posession under Bruce, under Val we were averaging 53% and arguably our best games this season have come without the ball (including yesterdays). As someone who was in favour of Pulis surely it's a bit late to be arguing possession = good.
I will reply later but one thing Val said we were an out of possession team not me. It failed and plan b (possession aots) also failed as it became a very weird hybrid due to the lack of flexibility on plan a.
Last thing it was nothing like Val ball yesterday.
RE: Steve Bruce... - Kit Kat Chunky - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 09:09 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: Bruce is no messiah, calm down guys
RE: Steve Bruce... - Borin' Baggie - 03-16-2022
(03-16-2022, 01:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-16-2022, 12:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: (03-16-2022, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-16-2022, 10:59 AM)Sliced Wrote: I think people are reading what they want.
When we went on a bad run under Bruce half of us were primarily blaming the players and the other half primarily blaming Val for the first 3-4 games. When Bruce persisted with something that clearly wasn't working he rightly got criticised, as did Val; and they both deserved it. Anyone could see that TGH should have been played earlier but he was overlooked in favour of Reach at AM which absolutely wasn't working. That deserved criticism, just like Val deserved criticism for relentlessly sticking with something that wasn't working.
I think Bruce is a very good manager, at this level and I hope now we'll see how good he is. That doesn't change the fact that he should have picked up more than 1 point in our first 5 games or realised that Reach at AM wasn't working.......especially when pretty much all the fans could see that too.
I think the criticism of Bruce was completely ott and for the reasons CA has already pointed out. The idea he was going to come in and hit the ground running after months of poor results was an unfair expectation. How many matches has he been at the helm even now?
The league position argument is flawed given the points the teams below us had clawed back by the time Val left. It meant a win could see a team jump three or four places if things went their way. Likewise for months teams below us were so poor that even though our form was bad they still hadn’t gone above us, that changed and teams improved but it’s taken us time to turn around a complete mess. I really don’t think Bruce has anything to answer for other than perhaps underestimating the lack of confidence and rigidity of mindset instilled in the players after months of ‘non possession’ football.
Bruce got a free pass for a few games, the criticism was rightly towards the players.
In fact there were more posts about how criticism of Bruce was unfair than actual criticisms of Bruce, which is a theme continuing at the moment. With regards to the league position argument, over the course of the season Val had us in 5th; that's around where we probably should have been. It doesn't mean he would have kept us there, it means that initially he overperformed and towards the end he underperformed.
As pointed out by MD a couple of posts ago, Bruce's form in his first 8 games is equal to Val's worst form, which was his last 8 games, that lakcof points is partially due to Bruce, partially due to the lack of confidence that the players had when Val left and partially due to the lack of squad depth. You seem to be setting up positions that aren't being taken by hardly anyone. I don't think Val would have gotten us into the playoffs (I made one ironic post to this effect on a thread where arguments of other nature were taking place), nor do I think Val is a better manager than Bruce. However this idea that everything bad that happens now after Val is gone is still Val's fault is absolutely ridiculous.
And with regards to "non-possession football", we've averaged 51% posession under Bruce, under Val we were averaging 53% and arguably our best games this season have come without the ball (including yesterdays). As someone who was in favour of Pulis surely it's a bit late to be arguing possession = good.
I will reply later but one thing Val said we were an out of possession team not me. It failed and plan b (possession aots) also failed as it became a very weird hybrid due to the lack of flexibility on plan a.
Last thing it was nothing like Val ball yesterday.
First half last night was pretty similar to what Valball was in August. Press high and in waves from the midfield, win the ball back up the pitch, high defensive line to condense space in the midfield, play the ball out wide to the full backs, get the wide centre halves to push into the midfield or create overloads down the wings.
RE: Steve Bruce... - CA Baggie - 03-16-2022
Out of possession it was no more Val-esque than Man City or Liverpool! They both press high up the pitch, it's the latest trend in football.
In possession it was nothing like Val Ball.
We also changed shape etc during the game, not dogmatically stick to 343 regardless of whether it was working or not.
Aside from the both, the OP wasn't a comparison of the 2, more a frustration that fans are moaning that Bruce didn't instantly get it right at a time when he picked up a shell-shocked side being abused by it's own fans (rightly so in some instances too), with no transfer window and 5 games in 19 days when he took over. In which his captain got sent off 20 odd minutes into the first game and was suspended for the next 4!!
Yes he played Adam Reach in a midfield instead of a youth player who's career amounts to 1 game in midfield at the start of December and is regarded as a RWB.
It does seem that those bemoaning the lack of time given to Val have then used it to instantly jump on Bruce. Pathetic really. In hindsight maybe Val was given too long (I'd say by about 29 league games)!
|