WBAUnofficial
Massi's article on Val - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Massi's article on Val (/showthread.php?tid=23965)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Massi's article on Val - MassDebater - 02-03-2022

(02-03-2022, 09:27 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I have no doubt that Val could achieve a measure of success with young fit players who have no long term experience of different playing styles and are willing to accept a footballing philosophy that is aimed at forcing errors and turnovers high up the pitch in order to create 'chances'.

But at the higher levels of the game where is there a club with that player profile or fanbase willing to accept the sometimes unwatchable 'product' such a style requires? In the lower leagues it could very well work but invariably an incoming manager has to accept an age and experience range of players, many of whom have played under better (and worse) managers who have demanded at least a modicum of thoughtful, entertaining, passing football. Our players may not have been the most skilful and were I'm sure more than prepared to accept his methods, but his intransigence and inability to acknowledge the need to change horses for courses cannot have been easy to take.

I have spent 54 years watching the Albion and even in our darkest hours, when the football was truly dreadful, I have never felt so exasperated or miserable as I have this season. My daughter has only watched us for four years but the sight of her putting her hand over her eyes at a home game and trying not to watch through her fingers told me everything I need to know about the game we were at. Val is clearly likeable, intelligent and committed, but he is not a man manager or even a football manager, and until he learns those two basic requirements he is highly unlikely - in my opinion - ever to achieve success at anything approaching the higher levels of the game.

Totally agree. My mate's son started coming with us this season he's 11, within two games he had said 'Dad we play nothing don't we'. It stuck with me and I think it the best summation of Valball, it's nothing, zero entertainment and little reward at higher levels of the game.


RE: Massi's article on Val - WorcsWBA - 02-03-2022

(02-03-2022, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Pros
- We're far fitter and organised than we have been in previous seasons. Our excellent defensive record is testament to this and means you don't have to score as often to win games (but you do still have to score sometimes).
- The system and his principles I liked, whether you're a fan of the % football or not there is no questions that it created us enough (not loads) chances to have us 6-8 points better off providing he had someone capable of scoring from 6 yards, literally anyone but Hugill. Dike arriving and then getting injured straight away was the final nail in his coffin.
- The age group sides really seem to have taken to his style of football. From watching bits of the U23s some of the goals they've been scoring are peak Valball.
- Calling out are awful recruitment of the previous years. Signing ageing players with no resale value, he knew it had to change. It would have been interesting to see who he brought in. Mowatt started well and tailed off with the rest of the team, Clarke looks tidy enough and Dike comes highly thought of.

Cons
- Repeatedly shot himself in the foot by refusing to change and adapt. Every manager can stick to their principles but they have to change things up. Guardiola and Klopp do it, Mowbray has totally changed his MO with Blackburn this season and Val refused. As futile as it would have been he would have been given more slack for simply playing a different formation.
- Think his lack of experience cost him as well. Ultimately when things started going awry he wasn't able to stop, strip everything back to basis and build again. The last month or so from the Cardiff game onwards was particularly bleak as I think he completely lost his head. His antics post-Cardiff, the fall out with Johnstone, the supposed 'epiphany' after the Preston game. It all got too much for him I think.

I was pleased when we appointed him. We'd been urging the club to pick a younger manager with some potential and on the face of it he'd earned his chance. I was willing to give him a season as it was never going to be an easy job turning this squad over and into something that could master Valball. Especially when the resources provided restricted him to Adam Reach, Kean Bryan and Jordan Hugill. If I were Val I'd be wanting some time away from the game, but could also see him being a decent fit somewhere like Sunderland where he would have chance to bring them into the Championship, or even a return to Barnsley in L1. I'd also echo the thoughts of many on here in that he wont be really successful until he can adapt his methods to suit what is at his disposal better.

As for us we're now back to square one, appointing one of the old guard, how utterly depressing.

That's a fair and balanced view, which I mostly agree with. I wouldn't blame Val for what happened with Johnstone though. Although Johnstone's still here, regardless of what I think of his GK abilities, his attitude is tarnished for me now.


RE: Massi's article on Val - Tom Joad - 02-03-2022

(02-03-2022, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Pros
- We're far fitter and organised than we have been in previous seasons. Our excellent defensive record is testament to this and means you don't have to score as often to win games (but you do still have to score sometimes).
- The system and his principles I liked, whether you're a fan of the % football or not there is no questions that it created us enough (not loads) chances to have us 6-8 points better off providing he had someone capable of scoring from 6 yards, literally anyone but Hugill. Dike arriving and then getting injured straight away was the final nail in his coffin.
- The age group sides really seem to have taken to his style of football. From watching bits of the U23s some of the goals they've been scoring are peak Valball.
- Calling out are awful recruitment of the previous years. Signing ageing players with no resale value, he knew it had to change. It would have been interesting to see who he brought in. Mowatt started well and tailed off with the rest of the team, Clarke looks tidy enough and Dike comes highly thought of.

Cons
- Repeatedly shot himself in the foot by refusing to change and adapt. Every manager can stick to their principles but they have to change things up. Guardiola and Klopp do it, Mowbray has totally changed his MO with Blackburn this season and Val refused. As futile as it would have been he would have been given more slack for simply playing a different formation.
- Think his lack of experience cost him as well. Ultimately when things started going awry he wasn't able to stop, strip everything back to basis and build again. The last month or so from the Cardiff game onwards was particularly bleak as I think he completely lost his head. His antics post-Cardiff, the fall out with Johnstone, the supposed 'epiphany' after the Preston game. It all got too much for him I think.

I was pleased when we appointed him. We'd been urging the club to pick a younger manager with some potential and on the face of it he'd earned his chance. I was willing to give him a season as it was never going to be an easy job turning this squad over and into something that could master Valball. Especially when the resources provided restricted him to Adam Reach, Kean Bryan and Jordan Hugill. If I were Val I'd be wanting some time away from the game, but could also see him being a decent fit somewhere like Sunderland where he would have chance to bring them into the Championship, or even a return to Barnsley in L1. I'd also echo the thoughts of many on here in that he wont be really successful until he can adapt his methods to suit what is at his disposal better.

As for us we're now back to square one, appointing one of the old guard, how utterly depressing.

Good post, Ted. That's how I see it too. I also think Val will do better at a club with less expectation, the fact we didn't sign him any quality players and left him to try to fashion these bottle jobs couldn't have helped. Great fit for a Sunderland, Blues, Pompey type of situation.