WBAUnofficial
Manager quandary - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Manager quandary (/showthread.php?tid=23901)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Manager quandary - SophLad - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 12:38 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It's no secret that Megson was not popular with the players, a lot of the time, but he still managed to get them to buy into what he was doing, which is a skill that it appears Val is sadly lacking.
If the players are resisting, then it is Val's job to win them over and he just can't seem to do it. I would imagine every club in the league has players that disagree with tactics or formations etc. it's perfectly reasonable, it is, however, up to the manager to "manage" the situation. It's sort of in the job title.

In fairness though, we were Megson's "Barnsley". It was just a good fit at the right time and worked well for a while. He never replicated it elsewhere to the same degree, however.

To be fair to Val, Megson did it with (by and large) a load of cloggers who, until he came along, would have got a nosebleed just thinking about the play-off places.  Val is dealing with many who think they're better than they are or better than him.  The former is incorrect.


RE: Manager quandary - CA Baggie - 01-31-2022

Val to Barnsley is what Megson is to us..

Saved from relegation and into the playoffs. SGM did it from the end of the season and VI stepped in after a few games.

If we had the SGM of 2000 walk in I think we'd be sacking him about now. We're a different club now, thanks to him, with different pressures and the SKYTV money adds to this, along with a different level of expectation. Back then we just couldn't believe that we were winning games!


RE: Manager quandary - Remi_Moses - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 01:04 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Val to Barnsley is what Megson is to us..

Saved from relegation and into the playoffs.  SGM did it from the end of the season and VI stepped in after a few games. 

If we had the SGM of 2000 walk in I think we'd be sacking him about now.  We're a different club now, thanks to him, with different pressures and the SKYTV money adds to this, along with a different level of expectation.  Back then we just couldn't believe that we were winning games!

A good manager finds a way.


RE: Manager quandary - CA Baggie - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 01:18 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 01:04 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Val to Barnsley is what Megson is to us..

Saved from relegation and into the playoffs.  SGM did it from the end of the season and VI stepped in after a few games. 

If we had the SGM of 2000 walk in I think we'd be sacking him about now.  We're a different club now, thanks to him, with different pressures and the SKYTV money adds to this, along with a different level of expectation.  Back then we just couldn't believe that we were winning games!

A good manager finds a way.

And yet he couldn't replicate his success anywhere after us...

Right place, right time.


RE: Manager quandary - Remi_Moses - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 01:19 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 01:18 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 01:04 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Val to Barnsley is what Megson is to us..

Saved from relegation and into the playoffs.  SGM did it from the end of the season and VI stepped in after a few games. 

If we had the SGM of 2000 walk in I think we'd be sacking him about now.  We're a different club now, thanks to him, with different pressures and the SKYTV money adds to this, along with a different level of expectation.  Back then we just couldn't believe that we were winning games!

A good manager finds a way.

And yet he couldn't replicate his success anywhere after us...

Right place, right time.

I don't think he ever had the players, backing or time anywhere else. He always got basket cases after us.
It was always believed you needed fight to get out of the championship and SGM sides had that aplenty.


RE: Manager quandary - backsidebaggie - 01-31-2022

Megson did well at Bolton for a good while. They went downhill his last few months but he’s the only manager they’ve had after Sam to do any good at all.

Having said this, he’s been out the game way too long for us to go back there IMO.


RE: Manager quandary - Remi_Moses - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 01:43 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Megson did well at Bolton for a good while. They went downhill his last few months but he’s the only manager they’ve had after Sam to do any good at all.

Having said this, he’s been out the game way too long for us to go back there IMO.

We only need a manager to get us promoted, whoever it is will almost be guaranteed the sack in a years time. 
I wouldn't want Mozza or Brunty put in the hot seat and then dumped I'd rather they stay coaching the kids for a few years.


RE: Manager quandary - Gzbaggy - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 01:43 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Megson did well at Bolton for a good while. They went downhill his last few months but he’s the only manager they’ve had after Sam to do any good at all.

Having said this, he’s been out the game way too long for us to go back there IMO.

His % win rate at Sheff Weds is higher than at WBA, they have not improved much since he went!


RE: Manager quandary - clem4england - 01-31-2022

(01-31-2022, 12:38 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It's no secret that Megson was not popular with the players, a lot of the time, but he still managed to get them to buy into what he was doing, which is a skill that it appears Val is sadly lacking.
If the players are resisting, then it is Val's job to win them over and he just can't seem to do it. I would imagine every club in the league has players that disagree with tactics or formations etc. it's perfectly reasonable, it is, however, up to the manager to "manage" the situation. It's sort of in the job title.

In fairness though, we were Megson's "Barnsley". It was just a good fit at the right time and worked well for a while. He never replicated it elsewhere to the same degree, however.
Same with all managers really. I guess it is up to the DoFs to maximise the chance of that happening.


RE: Manager quandary - Lillwall's left foot - 01-31-2022

On Saturday we saw what Valball really is. After the compromise, and promise, of playing it out and between the lines at times over the last few months, he told the players to stop fucking about and stick to plan A = Get it forward into the oppos third and press and fight for it. Seems simple as.

It worked for ten minutes and again we should have scored BUT as soon as the intensity dropped it was just awful clogging football. Terrible to watch and zero end product.

Now i bought into the project idea initially but now i'm just not sure how much time, and how many players would need to be turned over before we have a team that can at minimum play like Barnsley! Or what would theoretically be Barnsley PLUS with better players?

More importantly I'm not sure I WANT a team that can develop into a better version of Barnsley. Despite the tenuous links i was making myself to other high press managers its obvious that pure Valball is NOT Bielsaball or anything like what Klipperty offers.

I didn't have a lot of time for Dowling!! Zahore appeared under his watch ffs but he also made some solid decisions. However, in removing him they removed some balance/counterargument from within the management team. He wanted Wilder, who is having some success at Boro, and was open in his assessment that Val's footballing philosophy would just not be accepted here. Maybe he had a point?!

Val has got a lot right! Putting a system in place throughout the age groups, creating a pathway from the academy to the first team and criticising our recent transfer activity in purchasing mediocre players with no resale value. However, this should be a given for any new manager coming in and it's not enough for us to endure a spell of management that is becoming torturous.

When it doesn't feel like even a win on Saturday would be enough to appease fans you question if it can be retrieved. But who knows in this ridiculous game? Three wins on the bounce and Andy Carroll rampaging through the division........he gets more time from the owners and the fans climb off his back a bit?? That just seems very unlikely as of today.