WBAUnofficial
The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... (/showthread.php?tid=23793)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Cunninghamismagic - 01-27-2022

(01-27-2022, 11:18 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I completely disagree with blaming the players. I remember some of our fans saying this when Pepe Mel came in and was completely useless but blamed the players for not adapting to his methods. That was when we had the likes of Foster, Reid, McAuley, Olsson, Brunt, Mozza.

The likes of Livermore, Phillips and Bartley have been here under quite a few managers however is there any evidence of them being a bad influence? Are we really blaming them for the clubs poor decision making over the last few years?

It just seems an excuse to defend the manager to call some of the players bad eggs. A good manager comes in and works with the players to get the best out of them. I don't believe for one minute that the players haven't tried to adapt to Val's methods. It just isn't working and hasn't worked for months now.

+1


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - WorcsWBA - 01-28-2022

(01-27-2022, 11:18 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I completely disagree with blaming the players. I remember some of our fans saying this when Pepe Mel came in and was completely useless but blamed the players for not adapting to his methods. That was when we had the likes of Foster, Reid, McAuley, Olsson, Brunt, Mozza.

I don't particularly want to turn it into a Pepe Mel debate, but we knew what style of play he was going to use when we brought him in and then failed to back him with suitable signings (or any signings actuallyh). He was also only able to bring in one coach of his choosing and that wasn't until after he'd been here for a month. Our play when we went 3-0 up against Spurs was exhilirating (yes I know we threw it away in the end). He never had a fair chance and was badly stitched up by some of the senior players.


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Birdman1811 - 01-28-2022

With Mel the senior players frustration was because they knew it wouldn't work, and Mel agreed having seen them. Then coaching was just, a mess, no tactical training on the opposition, just watching videos or practicing what Barcelona were doing...

The senior players decided to work with the coaches they knew and they just kept us up.

With Val it's simply some don't want to do the extra training he wants them to do. Add in his supposed arrogance and argumentative personality, it's a recipe for disaster. Thing us, when they DID do what ge wanted, we actually looked capable, but a few didn't like it so refused to do it. Val hasn't been strong enough with punishing them for it either it seems.


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Lurker#3 - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Mel the senior players frustration was because they knew it wouldn't work, and Mel agreed having seen them. Then coaching was just, a mess, no tactical training on the opposition, just watching videos or practicing what Barcelona were doing...

The senior players decided to work with the coaches they knew and they just kept us up.

With Val it's simply some don't want to do the extra training he wants them to do. Add in his supposed arrogance and argumentative personality, it's a recipe for disaster. Thing us, when they DID do what ge wanted, we actually looked capable, but a few didn't like it so refused to do it. Val hasn't been strong enough with punishing them for it either it seems.

Fozzie did a section on Pepe on his pod cast and said as much. 

He, Jonas and few other went to him and basically said. "We ay got the legs to do what you want, we want to do what Keith Downing says...".

In all fairness, in a relegation battle, mid season, with no recruitment or plan in place to follow through with that philosophy was madness.


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Derek Hardballs - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Mel the senior players frustration was because they knew it wouldn't work, and Mel agreed having seen them. Then coaching was just, a mess, no tactical training on the opposition, just watching videos or practicing what Barcelona were doing...

The senior players decided to work with the coaches they knew and they just kept us up.

With Val it's simply some don't want to do the extra training he wants them to do. Add in his supposed arrogance and argumentative personality, it's a recipe for disaster. Thing us, when they DID do what ge wanted, we actually looked capable, but a few didn't like it so refused to do it. Val hasn't been strong enough with punishing them for it either it seems.

I’ve seen these rumours on Twitter but there is no quotes attributed to anyone to back them up. Just some vague inference to sources close to the club. 

Val’s approach is stats driven and it shows. Get ball as fast as you can to areas on the pitch that are statistically the most effective to score goals from. So we shovel the ball out wide to our wing backs abs they are instructed to twat crosses into the box. Keep ball alive in 18yard box from long throws / set pieces as you’ve always got a chance, hit long ball into box, close down opposition in final third as a chance might occur. It’s formulaic, one dimensional and almost robotic in approach. It takes no account of what the opposition are doing, it means we don’t change the way we play and it takes almost all the creativity out of a team. 

If I was a creative player I would hate every minute of Val Ball it would be soul destroying. Mowatt is a perfect example of Val ball, he will run all day, will close down the opposition, will score the odd goal and repeat. It’s way too simplistic and far too easy to set-up to combat.


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - MassDebater - 01-28-2022

Everyone at the club is to blame, especially Doris, since she changed from PG to Yorkshire tea things have gone wrong, and Six complained she didn't push her trolley enough every day too, so there!


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Derek Hardballs - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:38 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Everyone at the club is to blame, especially Doris, since she changed from PG to Yorkshire tea things have gone wrong, and Six complained she didn't push her trolley enough every day too, so there!

She got the trolley forward quickly and into dangerous positions.


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Birdman1811 - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:38 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 10:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Mel the senior players frustration was because they knew it wouldn't work, and Mel agreed having seen them. Then coaching was just, a mess, no tactical training on the opposition, just watching videos or practicing what Barcelona were doing...

The senior players decided to work with the coaches they knew and they just kept us up.

With Val it's simply some don't want to do the extra training he wants them to do. Add in his supposed arrogance and argumentative personality, it's a recipe for disaster. Thing us, when they DID do what ge wanted, we actually looked capable, but a few didn't like it so refused to do it. Val hasn't been strong enough with punishing them for it either it seems.

I’ve seen these rumours on Twitter but there is no quotes attributed to anyone to back them up. Just some vague inference to sources close to the club. 

Val’s approach is stats driven and it shows. Get ball as fast as you can to areas on the pitch that are statistically the most effective to score goals from. So we shovel the ball out wide to our wing backs abs they are instructed to twat crosses into the box. Keep ball alive in 18yard box from long throws / set pieces as you’ve always got a chance, hit long ball into box, close down opposition in final third as a chance might occur. It’s formulaic, one dimensional and almost robotic in approach. It takes no account of what the opposition are doing, it means we don’t change the way we play and it takes almost all the creativity out of a team. 

If I was a creative player I would hate every minute of Val Ball it would be soul destroying. Mowatt is a perfect example of Val ball, he will run all day, will close down the opposition, will score the odd goal and repeat. It’s way too simplistic and far too easy to set-up to combat.

In essence, yes that is Val Ball.

You can be creative within it, but only in the final third, basically it's reliant on the front 3 and wing backs. Creative central midfielders aren't going to have much fun.


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - MassDebater - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 10:38 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Everyone at the club is to blame, especially Doris, since she changed from PG to Yorkshire tea things have gone wrong, and Six complained she didn't push her trolley enough every day too, so there!

She got the trolley forward quickly and into dangerous positions.

Her water had cooled down too much by the time Hugill got to it though...


RE: The revisionist pro Ismael theory... - Derek Hardballs - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 10:38 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 10:18 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: With Mel the senior players frustration was because they knew it wouldn't work, and Mel agreed having seen them. Then coaching was just, a mess, no tactical training on the opposition, just watching videos or practicing what Barcelona were doing...

The senior players decided to work with the coaches they knew and they just kept us up.

With Val it's simply some don't want to do the extra training he wants them to do. Add in his supposed arrogance and argumentative personality, it's a recipe for disaster. Thing us, when they DID do what ge wanted, we actually looked capable, but a few didn't like it so refused to do it. Val hasn't been strong enough with punishing them for it either it seems.

I’ve seen these rumours on Twitter but there is no quotes attributed to anyone to back them up. Just some vague inference to sources close to the club. 

Val’s approach is stats driven and it shows. Get ball as fast as you can to areas on the pitch that are statistically the most effective to score goals from. So we shovel the ball out wide to our wing backs abs they are instructed to twat crosses into the box. Keep ball alive in 18yard box from long throws / set pieces as you’ve always got a chance, hit long ball into box, close down opposition in final third as a chance might occur. It’s formulaic, one dimensional and almost robotic in approach. It takes no account of what the opposition are doing, it means we don’t change the way we play and it takes almost all the creativity out of a team. 

If I was a creative player I would hate every minute of Val Ball it would be soul destroying. Mowatt is a perfect example of Val ball, he will run all day, will close down the opposition, will score the odd goal and repeat. It’s way too simplistic and far too easy to set-up to combat.

In essence, yes that is Val Ball.

You can be creative within it, but only in the final third, basically it's reliant on the front 3 and wing backs. Creative central midfielders aren't going to have much fun.

Imo the system is straight jacket and over time will leave our club with a tiny pool of managers who can get a tune out of a squad built exclusively for one way of playing. We are entering a very worrying period for the club, I'm really not convinced this is the direction we should be taking. We may as well have an algorithm as a manager, such is the predictability of our play and the rigidity of thought that it requires.