![]() |
|
Green Agenda / Policies - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Green Agenda / Policies (/showthread.php?tid=23502) |
RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Fido - 01-16-2022 (01-16-2022, 08:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(01-15-2022, 04:21 PM)Sotv Wrote:(01-14-2022, 06:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(01-14-2022, 10:19 AM)Sotv Wrote: Until we understand that we need to consume less instead Bear in mind though that there are different cultures around the world. Some are happy to live in a shithole as long as they have the latest model of Merc on the drive. Maslow's hierarchy doesn't necessarily apply everywhere and we, historically, have been ahead of the curve of a lot of countries. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Protheroe - 01-17-2022 (01-16-2022, 08:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Falls off chair, I completely agree. The pursuit of wealth and material goods to bring happiness is a vacuous pursuit. Not surprised Proth thinks otherwise. The pursuit of wealth brings financial security and the the ability to make real choices. I'm pretty certain there's not a person on the planet who'd be less happy in those circumstances. Though as you appear to be one of the most terminally miserable people I've ever encountered I'm not surprised you think otherwise. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Ted Maul - 01-17-2022 Weirdly I think Proth has a point. It should not be up to individuals and their families to make drastic changes to their lives before the twenty firms that produce 55% of the worlds single use plastic are targeted with much stricter regulation. These companies have created such a huge market for their products, the onus should be on them to produce, package and transport their goods in a more environmentally friendly/sustainable manner. Don't persecute individuals for buying things that make their already miserable existence slightly more tolerable. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Borin' Baggie - 01-17-2022 (01-17-2022, 08:57 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Weirdly I think Proth has a point. It should not be up to individuals and their families to make drastic changes to their lives before the twenty firms that produce 55% of the worlds single use plastic are targeted with much stricter regulation. These companies have created such a huge market for their products, the onus should be on them to produce, package and transport their goods in a more environmentally friendly/sustainable manner. Don't persecute individuals for buying things that make their already miserable existence slightly more tolerable. Except that Proth thinks that the solutions should be driven by the market whereas you do not. So by opposing and measures to incentivise the market to drive those changes he is in turn opposing any changes whatsoever. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Derek Hardballs - 01-17-2022 (01-17-2022, 08:17 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(01-16-2022, 08:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Falls off chair, I completely agree. The pursuit of wealth and material goods to bring happiness is a vacuous pursuit. Not surprised Proth thinks otherwise. There is a difference between being comfortably off and just greedy and wasteful I appreciate that this might be confusing given the company you have kept whilst wearing that big blue rosette.
RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Protheroe - 01-17-2022 (01-17-2022, 10:18 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(01-17-2022, 08:57 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Weirdly I think Proth has a point. It should not be up to individuals and their families to make drastic changes to their lives before the twenty firms that produce 55% of the worlds single use plastic are targeted with much stricter regulation. These companies have created such a huge market for their products, the onus should be on them to produce, package and transport their goods in a more environmentally friendly/sustainable manner. Don't persecute individuals for buying things that make their already miserable existence slightly more tolerable. Erm, I don't oppose measures to incentivise the market that aren't ultimately damaging and self defeating like so many of those adopted over the past couple of decades. It's the same in housing BB. There hasn't been a single incentive to "help" First Time Buyers that hasn't ultimately made the situation worse for first time buyers. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Borin' Baggie - 01-17-2022 (01-17-2022, 12:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(01-17-2022, 10:18 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(01-17-2022, 08:57 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Weirdly I think Proth has a point. It should not be up to individuals and their families to make drastic changes to their lives before the twenty firms that produce 55% of the worlds single use plastic are targeted with much stricter regulation. These companies have created such a huge market for their products, the onus should be on them to produce, package and transport their goods in a more environmentally friendly/sustainable manner. Don't persecute individuals for buying things that make their already miserable existence slightly more tolerable. So do you support a carbon tax? Do you support infrastructure investment into public transport? Because I recall you objecting to both the implementation of a carbon tax and the extension of the Midlands tram network on the Hagley Road previously. Do you support the reintroduction of subsidises for solar? Do you support the relaxation of planning regulations for onshore wind? Do you support a nationally owned green infrastructure bank? These were three policies that were highly successful in their implementation during 2010-2015 that were scrapped subsequently resulting in stagnation in investment in those technologies. I mean fuck me there's only one new nuclear plant under construction and that was signed off by Ed Davey 9 years ago, that was the first signed off since David Howell was energy secretary and the reason for that is this nation's obsession with gas that you have shown extreme support for and the result is that Hinkley C is operational in 2026 (assuming no delays) there will be 4 operational plants left in the country and 2 of those are due for decommission by 2028. It's exactly like the first time buyers conundrum, meaningful incentives are being blocked as they effect the lifestyle choices of a group of powerful individuals. You've given the impression that you're opposed to renewables, opposed to battery electric vehicles, opposed to public transport, opposed to reducing meat consumption, opposed to any power generation that isn't gas. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Protheroe - 01-17-2022 I'm extremely supportive of using our own gas as a transitional fuel to a largely nuclear future. I tend to believe that wind, and in particular offshore wind should be an expensive minority sport and largely unsubsidised - particularly as it demands a huge amount of (repeated) "dirty" investment in carbon steel, carbon fibre and physical connectivity - as well as being bloody useless when the wind doesn't blow and killing countless birds every year. I'm not opposed to battery vehicles, they're just a crap technology completely lacking the convenience, agility and versatility of the ICE - as will become increasingly clear as we hurtle towards 2030. There's nothing wrong with lean burning small but powerful turbo petrol engines that chuck out virtually no CO2. I'm not opposed to public transport - just unnecessary and hugely expensive vanity projects like Street's Tram and HS2. HS2 in particular was for a pre-Covid world. I went to London on Friday for the second time in 2 years - rather than 2/3 days a week pre-Covid. Business travel has change forever and HS2 will end up being the UK's greatest white elephant. Oh, and the only meaningful incentive FTBs need is for the government to relax planning laws so we can build a few of cities the size of Coventry down the M40, M42, M3 & M20. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Borin' Baggie - 01-17-2022 So you're extremely supportive of doing the same thing that has resulted in our current mess of poor nuclear infrastructure and volatile energy prices, use gas. How much of our gas is sourced from outside the North Sea? A miniscule amount. Has this protected us from gas price volatility? No. When is it going to transition, Proth? It hasn't led to a transition over the last 40 years, do you expect the magic fairies to change something? Gas, along with Dear Margaret, is the reason we have no nuclear power infrastructure in this country, not changing tact and moving away from gas now will just ensure that we still won't build any nuclear plants and by the time our wells are too expensive to extract from we'll be reliant on the ME and Russia. Offshore wind is privately financed and the level of subsidies are nothing compared to oil and gas subsidises, it's also the leading reason for our drop in carbon output from the grid. It's also designed to compliment baseload generation which it has been extremely successful, can you imagine how much more expensive energy prices would be right now if more of the grid capacity was CCG? 10-15% more. The only reason it's seen as a "problem" is when those who don't want a diversified grid and just want us to use gas act like it's incapability to operate as a baseload is justifiable, when in fact it's not meant to act as a baseload it's meant to act as a supplementary through direct grid input and pumped storage (and in the future compressed storage and electrolysis). You can also recycle carbon fibre, steel and grid connections you know for when turbines are replaced, not everything has to be virgin material. Battery electric powertrain are the most efficient source of converting energy to drive wheels, they are not crap. They also suit the use-case of the vast majority of people in this country and for those it isn't FCEVs using the same powertrain will suffice. ICE is dying, going forward it will be a niche medium for hydrogen combustion and classic cars but that's it. Do you want to tell every single motor manufacturer both established and disruptive in the world that they are wrong? If you're building a new care the lifetime emissions of an ICE, even a turbocharged petrol one with undersquare cylinders, will be much higher than that of a battery electric car in countries like China, let alone in the UK or France. HS2 is about increasing railway capacity, Rugby-Wolverhampton is the most congested section of track in Europe and it crosses one of the busiest freight routes in the country. We cannot build more rail freight capacity without cutting passenger rail services on that section, that is why HS2 is being built. It also opens up capacity for passenger rail as more stopping services will be allowed to run due to not competing with intercity services. The same noise about high speed rail being a white elephant was levied at Italy, France, Germany and Japan and every single accusation has fallen flat on it's arse, there were the same arguments against HS1 and the people who made those look like massive idiots. If you don't want trams in the West Midlands then lobby your WhatsApp contacts on the government benches to release funding for the construction of S-Bahn/Underground MRTs instead as that's the only alternative. Will they do that? Will they fuck. Birmingham has tried to get an underground metro for decades but couldn't get funding so it is up to the trams which are a damn-sight better than nothing and when separated from the roads they are also pretty quick as they are MRTs. I reiterate, you are in favour of doing absolutely fuck all to address any of the issues. You do not care about solving the big issues or the smaller ones. As for housing, I think the bigger issue is land banking than planning. Right near me developers have bought up land in Warwick District to account as an extension for Coventry, Leamington and Kenilworth. It has planning permission for around about 35,000 houses. Are any of them being built? No. Why? Because the developers don't want them built yet. Punitive levies on land banking and inactive land earmarked for development is a greater incentive than relaxing planning permission. And then there's a LVT, something that would be a massive incentive to deliver high-density housing instead of the inefficient uses of space new build estates are in this country. RE: Green Agenda / Policies - Sotv - 01-18-2022 (01-17-2022, 10:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(01-17-2022, 08:17 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(01-16-2022, 08:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Falls off chair, I completely agree. The pursuit of wealth and material goods to bring happiness is a vacuous pursuit. Not surprised Proth thinks otherwise. Hold on, I can’t have you agreeing with me then me agreeing with the majority of your follow up, it will knock the bored equilibrium right out Protheroe kind of has a point about choices and security but the question is what’s is real security and what are the choices you want to make? It’s been shown by quite a bit of research that once you get beyond the basics of feeding, clothing, shelter and warmth, then increases in wealth produce diminishing levels of return on the satisfaction scale. If the choice is between eating or heating then obviously having the wealth to afford both makes a substantial difference to your sense of well-being. If however it’s merely a choice between a new Lexus or new Tesla then it’s pretty insignificant in terms of your well-being long term. Instead of thinking happiness is to be gained by having new, better, more of whatever, perhaps it’s more conducive to try and find satisfaction and happiness in the everyday and what is around us already. |