WBAUnofficial
Another Yoof Departure - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Another Yoof Departure (/showthread.php?tid=23483)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Another Yoof Departure - SophLad - 01-12-2022

Loving the double standards on here.  Whinging like fuck that we've had a player (that nobody had even heard of) "stolen" from us at 17 years old when we've only had them on our books for 18 months.  Where do you think we get him from, the local park?

Graham Dorrans, Chris Wood and almost certainly a few others - we were the 'robbing bastards'.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Cuzer - 01-12-2022

Well I've heard of him, seen him and he's a talent

The only crumb of comfort is it's not those tossers from down the road

Played in our U18's cup run when we lost to Vile in the semi's and has also played for the 23's when 16/17

Left back come left winger, great talent but destined to leave unfortunately, Cleary contract talk gone quiet too, worrying

Cuzer


RE: Another Yoof Departure - SW4Baggie - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 07:34 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 07:23 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:50 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: According to what I have just read he is 17 next week I believe. Been playing for the U18's as a 16 year old. It says he had a game for the U23's as well.
I think we signed him about 18 months ago. He has played for England youth teams at U15's and U16's
I had heard he was very highly rated and was being sought by other Prem clubs.
No money mentioned and given that he is 17 very soon it would be peanuts anyway I suppose.

We can’t sign players on pro terms until their 17th birthday and the reality of the situation is that our top youngsters get poached when they go away to play in the England age group teams.  They get advised not to sign a pro contract for us which means the big clubs pick them up for peanuts in compensation. 

Until and unless we make a real song and dance about it with other “small” clubs with good Academies nothing is going to change.  Probably the easiest solution is to put in place a sliding scale of compensation based on what that player achieves by age 23, and with a minimum of £250k for a player who leaves before they’ve signed pro terms with us (provided that we prove we have offered them pro terms).  Poaching will always happen and we won’t ever stop that. It’s just the compensation side that urgently needs to be addressed.

Agree re the compo. Been saying the same for years. I've always said if a kid moves from an A cat academy to another A Cat academy then the flat compo should be £1m now.

Any top prem side has bilions to spunk but the current compo is pocket change to those sides and they can just stockpile these kids.

The kid is moving for money. Has to be as we are all yhe same standard academies so why else move? He'd also have a much better chance of first team football with us than he would at Arsenal. I'm sure his family have done well out of it so fair play to them.

Unfortunately the EFL clubs voted in the academy system knowing full well this would happen, it wasn’t enforced on them. The PL offered a larger, guaranteed share of the TV money but in return they had to agree to EPPP…

Lower league clubs needed cash there and then, and as a result they can have money up front but lose their kids for peanuts. Short sighted but not going to change any time soon…. There are plenty of Cat2-4 academies we could be poaching from (Blues, Cov, Walsall… even Wolves I think now)


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Shabby Russian - 01-12-2022

Someone further up the thread said that this lad would have a far better chance of getting first team with us than them.

But historically that's not true. Arsenal have a far better record of giving opportunities to their youth players than we have.

Saks was given his debut at a similar age to what this lad is now.  Clearly if he is good enough Arsenal will give him chances.

Circumstances may dictate that we now have to give more opportunity to our youth players, but previous reluctance may be a factor in determining whether a player stays with us or not.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Hopalong - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 07:14 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 12:51 AM)Hopalong Wrote: Happens every day.

Couldn't give  a  f***.  The mercenary will never play for the aresholes. 

No loss.

Mercenary? Get a fucking grip.

I was joking stalker. As i said couldn't give a f


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Duffers - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 10:53 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Someone further up the thread said that this lad would have a far better chance of getting first team with us than them.

But historically that's not true. Arsenal have a far better record of giving opportunities to their youth players than we have.

Saks was given his debut at a similar age to what this lad is now.  Clearly if he is good enough Arsenal will give him chances.

Circumstances may dictate that we now have to give more opportunity to our youth players, but previous reluctance may be a factor in determining whether a player stays with us or not.

Indeed, if you ask a 16 year old kid if they want to stay in the crumbling embers of our youth setup or go to a club like Arsenal with world class facilities, players and infrastructure what are they going to choose really?

The anger and Pearl clutching whenever one of our kids decides to go on to a bigger club is embarrassing. People still haven’t forgiven Izzy Brown and that was almost ten years ago.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Tom Joad - 01-12-2022

It's not just he compensation fees that need re-alignment. It also stifles the progress of the youngsters en route to playing regularly at the higher level. When talent is spread throughout the league clubs they have greater opportunities to progress than when all gathered at a few clubs. This, in turn has to affect the national side. Just look at England's progress since Southgate and his method of picking players on ability rather than just from Man U, Liverpool etc.
I don't see anyone pissing their pants about this, we all know it happens. It is in general, simply not a good way to run a sport. A more fairer compensation and a wider pool of resources is in everyone's best interests, except those clubs that stockpile youngsters. I don't see it happening though as long as the Premier League and the F.A and football leagues are all separate entities. It really requires a get together of all Academies-I mean the clubs that fund them- to agree reform.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - MrFizz - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 10:12 AM)SophLad Wrote: Loving the double standards on here.  Whinging like fuck that we've had a player (that nobody had even heard of) "stolen" from us at 17 years old when we've only had them on our books for 18 months.  Where do you think we get him from, the local park?

Graham Dorrans, Chris Wood and almost certainly a few others - we were the 'robbing bastards'.

Pretty sure we bought Dorrans (Partick?). But i get your point. Yoof will always move, it's the pitiful compo that really rankles.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Borin' Baggie - 01-12-2022

We're not privy to poaching down the ladder, Boruc was pinched from Stoke and Morton from Yeovil. Hell, Dara only joined at 16 as did Jak Delaney.

All I care about is building on the pathway to the first team that has seen O'Shea establish himself and Gardner-Hickman and Fellows break through, something we've failed out over the last 25 years.

Statutory compensation does need to be upped though, some academies have been enabled through it to become loan farms.

(01-12-2022, 11:06 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 10:12 AM)SophLad Wrote: Loving the double standards on here.  Whinging like fuck that we've had a player (that nobody had even heard of) "stolen" from us at 17 years old when we've only had them on our books for 18 months.  Where do you think we get him from, the local park?

Graham Dorrans, Chris Wood and almost certainly a few others - we were the 'robbing bastards'.

Pretty sure we bought Dorrans (Partick?). But i get your point. Yoof will always move, it's the pitiful compo that really rankles.

Dorrans was from Livingston, and he had 100 senior appearances at that point.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - SophLad - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 11:06 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 10:12 AM)SophLad Wrote: Loving the double standards on here.  Whinging like fuck that we've had a player (that nobody had even heard of) "stolen" from us at 17 years old when we've only had them on our books for 18 months.  Where do you think we get him from, the local park?

Graham Dorrans, Chris Wood and almost certainly a few others - we were the 'robbing bastards'.

Pretty sure we bought Dorrans (Partick?). But i get your point. Yoof will always move, it's the pitiful compo that really rankles.

I agree with the need to ramp it up to c£1m.  We also need to commit to a certain level of 'pay off' for players if we release them in their late academy years/1st years as pro.  If we offer them a reasonable safety net then they may not be tempted a la Izzy Brown, to jump for their one big pay packet.