WBAUnofficial
Button? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Button? (/showthread.php?tid=23450)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Button? - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-09-2022

I saw no cause for concern in Button's performance yesterday. But of course there are posters on here decrying his ability and the club's judgement in potentially letting Johnstone go. That's Albion fans for you.


RE: Button? - wba13 - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 02:12 PM)oldun Wrote:
(01-09-2022, 01:46 PM)wba13 Wrote: Button looked to me what he is a decent 2nd choice keeper, kicking woeful, made some decent saves but also beaten easily at the near post for 1st goal.
Not for me a championship first choice, if Sam goes we need a replacement.
Nothing against Button and I am happy for him to be a suspension or injury replacement for two or three matches, but our first choice not for me.

Perhaps we could persuade West Ham to give us a few mill and Fabianski?i   not a great fan of SJ I'm afraid, disappointed he doesn't  think enough of our club to sign a contract as Bellingham  did,  money is all I suppose

Each to our own in opinions, as for Bellingham big difference he is a blues supporter and didn’t want Blues to miss out on a substantial fee, a better comparison would have been Louis Barry who we bought up for ten years then we get nothing when he signed for Barcelona and ultimately Villa. Where as Johnstone owes us nothing.

(01-09-2022, 02:23 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I saw no cause for concern in Button's performance yesterday. But of course there are posters on here decrying his ability and the club's judgement in potentially letting Johnstone go. That's Albion fans for you.

I’m not having a go at Button a capable keeper as a number two for a lower championship club  but if we want promotion for in my opinion we need Johnstone or or a better option than Button. I think Button is like Myhill a good and capable stand in.

I have never seen him as a first choice at the Hawthorns.


RE: Button? - B36baggie - 01-09-2022

Button did some good things but seems to make an error for a goal every time he plays.

I liked both the Barnsley keeper Collins & especially the Reading keeper Southwood if SJ leaves & keep Button as number Two.

How tall was the Brighton keeper btw. Mossive


RE: Button? - MrFizz - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 02:43 PM)B36baggie Wrote: Button did some good things but seems to make an error for a goal every time he plays.

I liked both the Barnsley keeper Collins & especially the Reading keeper Southwood if SJ leaves & keep Button as number Two.

How tall was the Brighton keeper btw. Mossive

He was a biggun. His head must have permafrost.


RE: Button? - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 01-09-2022

Just get the Cambridge utd keeper in, was immense yesterday!


RE: Button? - Malcolm Tucker - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 11:42 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Very good I thought.

Saved two one on ones and made a racking save to tip an effort round the post. Thought kicking wise he was a step up from SJ. A few moments of me vs my lad on FIFA when I bring the keeper out and try and score with him but other than that, all good.

I’d be happy with him between the sticks and selling SJ to generate funds for area of more concern.

You must’ve been at a different game to me. He’s a prize clown - complete and utter liability. 

Appalling positioning for their equaliser - which should’ve been a routine save pretty much straight at him - and caused absolute mayhem at least twice by needlessly flying out the area. 

We absolutely will not go up with him in goal, so SJ must be kept at all costs. Keepers like that absolutely destroy defences.


RE: Button? - EastMidsBaggie - 01-09-2022

Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:I saw no cause for concern in Button's performance yesterday. But of course there are posters on here decrying his ability and the club's judgement in potentially letting Johnstone go. That's Albion fans for you.

I think folks just go on what they have seen AT THE GAME (not on a dodgy stream) vs. what SJ brought to the position maybe ?


RE: Button? - SW4Baggie - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 04:14 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(01-09-2022, 11:42 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Very good I thought.

Saved two one on ones and made a racking save to tip an effort round the post. Thought kicking wise he was a step up from SJ. A few moments of me vs my lad on FIFA when I bring the keeper out and try and score with him but other than that, all good.

I’d be happy with him between the sticks and selling SJ to generate funds for area of more concern.

You must’ve been at a different game to me. He’s a prize clown - complete and utter liability. 

Appalling positioning for their equaliser - which should’ve been a routine save pretty much straight at him - and caused absolute mayhem at least twice by needlessly flying out the area. 

We absolutely will not go up with him in goal, so SJ must be kept at all costs. Keepers like that absolutely destroy defences.

I think that’s incredibly harsh on Button… he made two excellent saves to stop Welbeck early on and to prevent McAllistair at the death. The first goal I can’t see how he can be faulted for, it’s entirely Bartley being caught flat footed and Townsend losing his runner and making a weak attempt for the ball after being caugt on the wrong side of his man (admittedly he’d have been off if he fouled him).

Brighton made the most of their additional man and ruthlessly exploited the gaps left over from Kipre’s red. The second goal potentially Button may have been a little slow to get down to but he saw it very late due to I think Taylor diving in front of him and the excellent step over from Trossard.


RE: Button? - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 04:21 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:I saw no cause for concern in Button's performance yesterday. But of course there are posters on here decrying his ability and the club's judgement in potentially letting Johnstone go. That's Albion fans for you.

I think folks just go on what they have seen AT THE GAME (not on a dodgy stream) vs. what SJ brought to the position maybe ?

Tired old argument that, East Mids. Nothing dodgy about the stream I watched on, didn't miss a moment. Of course I appreciate that only those who attend are allowed an opinion, now this bored has turned into Kazakhstan  Big Grin


RE: Button? - EastMidsBaggie - 01-09-2022

Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:I saw no cause for concern in Button's performance yesterday. But of course there are posters on here decrying his ability and the club's judgement in potentially letting Johnstone go. That's Albion fans for you.

I think folks just go on what they have seen AT THE GAME (not on a dodgy stream) vs. what SJ brought to the position maybe ?

Tired old argument that, East Mids. Nothing dodgy about the stream I watched on, didn't miss a moment. Of course I appreciate that only those who attend are allowed an opinion, now this bored has turned into Kazakhstan  Big Grin

Not at all but you do tend to gauge things differently at the actual match (out of shot moments/positioning/crowd reactions etc).

As an aside, nothing will ever match being there.