WBAUnofficial
Name the squads - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Name the squads (/showthread.php?tid=23387)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Name the squads - Derek Hardballs - 01-05-2022

We don't have the luxury of having a squad built just for how our manager wants to play. So the manager has to be judged on results and resources afforded him. I don't particularly have a strong opinion on the manager, I just judge managers these days on what resources they have and what results they are getting. If he played silky smooth football but was 10th in the form guide I would still be questioning whether we got enough out of the squad. Ultimately the club will have earmarked promotion, the club needs promotion and the longer we stay in this division the less likely that objective will be met.

If league tables always reflected the quality of the squad then there would be no point in a manager, the players could just sort themselves out each game.


RE: Name the squads - Peachy - 01-05-2022

(01-05-2022, 04:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We don't have the luxury of having a squad built just for how our manager wants to play. So the manager has to be judged on results and resources afforded him. I don't particularly have a strong opinion on the manager, I just judge managers these days on what resources they have and what results they are getting. If he played silky smooth football but was 10th in the form guide I would still be questioning whether we got enough out of the squad. Ultimately the club will have earmarked promotion, the club needs promotion and the longer we stay in this division the less likely that objective will be met.

If league tables always reflected the quality of the squad then there would be no point in a manager, the players could just sort themselves out each game.

Bang on....


RE: Name the squads - Tom Joad - 01-05-2022

Shabby Russian Wrote:I would suggest waiting till the end of the season and then you can use the league table to find out who had the best squads.

I don't see enough of the other teams play to work out how good they are, but am happy to use the league tables to provide some insight.
This. It's easy to say us, Fulham and Bournemouth are the strongest squads, but as fans we simply don't get to see the other clubs regular 90 minute performances. What I can confidently say is that this is the poorest Albion squad in 20 years and looks very much like a mid table Championship side.  When I have criticized the strength of our squad I have based it on the following; We limped over the line last time we were at this level and we are considerably weaker now, the lopsided recruitment of last season, the non recruitment this season coupled with our loan signings being replaced by weaker players.
Further to that. Check out the appearances made by our squad and the level these appearances were at. Overwhelmingly Championship or lower. There is little Premier League pedigree among them and any there is was in struggling sides, which indicates they probably aren't good enough. How many of our squad were picked off by Prem clubs? Not one. Even the newly promoted 3 didn't bother coming to raid our lot, Bloody Hell, one of them even off loaded one of theirs onto us because he ain't all that.
The one upside to all this is that we are finally getting to see some of the academy products. These could yet be the trump card.