WBAUnofficial
Val assessed - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Val assessed (/showthread.php?tid=23268)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Val assessed - SW4Baggie - 12-29-2021

(12-29-2021, 01:32 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(12-29-2021, 10:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Agree with this.

Val was naive in believing the same tactics he employed with Barnsley would work here and has had to tweak them during competitive games. His failure to realise teams would deny our press and consider a point a good result was a massive underestimation, and for me, his biggest mistake to date but he has rectified it, but doesn’t have the personel to make it work yet.

As I’ve just posted on another thread, based on performances in the last 10 games, we ought to have 6 more points than we do… had we had a striker even remotely capable of scoring routine chances there would be absolutely no pressure on Val other than a few dissenting voices believing it’s still the 70s and we ought to be playing the type of sexy swashbuckling football that didn’t win us anything.

If this was our last 10 results, we’d practically be top.

Derby 0 - WBA 1
Barnsley 0 - WBA 2
WBA 3 - Reading 1
Coventry 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Forest 1
Blackpool 2 - WBA 3
Hudds 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Boro 1
WBA 2 - Hull 0
Fulham 3 - WBA 1

If you changed all of Blackburns results where they’ve dropped points they’d be top also. I don’t care how many shots we’ve had, we’ve been poor in far too many games. We’ve picked up wins where we haven’t deserved them also, so I think we are where we deserve to be. Hopefully a decent no9 will solve all of the issues but personally I have my doubts. Hopefully I’m wrong and you’re right. He deserves to be judged after we back him with a striker, but if we don’t see a big improvement, I’d be very worried about giving him the 3 windows he says he needs.

That’s not what I’m saying though is it?

In football results don’t always reflect the game, and when it comes to objectively assessing performances, the best way currently is to look at how many goals a team should have scored and how many they should have conceded… and there has been a very consistent theme this season in that we have created far more chances than we’ve taken and subsequently dropped for more points than we ought have. I think only Boro (who likewise lack a striker have dropped more points).


Val’s job is to put out a team which wins more games than it loses, and the side he has fashioned is creating as many chances as most teams in this division whilst limiting the opposition to little or no chances.

Goals we have conceded have generally been from terrible mistakes, and chances have been spurned due to poor finishing. Neither of these things are Val’s fault, he has crafted a system which is seeing us be the better side in pretty much every game we play.

I’m as frustrated as anyone with some of his recent selections, and I do think had we been a little more flexible we would have taken a few more points in recent weeks, however the squad we have have failed several managers under several systems consistently, so expecting him to work miracles with this group is one step too far. 

He deserves this season regardless, we need to get through January and hopefully with a striker on board we will get over the line come May. If January’s recruitment is as disappointing as Hugill and Reach, then there will be more questions to be asked of Val, but at the moment I’m happy to accept he’s doing as well as can be expected and being let down by a squad with physical and mental weaknesses.


RE: Val assessed - MassDebater - 12-29-2021

(12-29-2021, 02:26 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-29-2021, 01:32 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(12-29-2021, 10:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Agree with this.

Val was naive in believing the same tactics he employed with Barnsley would work here and has had to tweak them during competitive games. His failure to realise teams would deny our press and consider a point a good result was a massive underestimation, and for me, his biggest mistake to date but he has rectified it, but doesn’t have the personel to make it work yet.

As I’ve just posted on another thread, based on performances in the last 10 games, we ought to have 6 more points than we do… had we had a striker even remotely capable of scoring routine chances there would be absolutely no pressure on Val other than a few dissenting voices believing it’s still the 70s and we ought to be playing the type of sexy swashbuckling football that didn’t win us anything.

If this was our last 10 results, we’d practically be top.

Derby 0 - WBA 1
Barnsley 0 - WBA 2
WBA 3 - Reading 1
Coventry 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Forest 1
Blackpool 2 - WBA 3
Hudds 1 - WBA 1
WBA 1 - Boro 1
WBA 2 - Hull 0
Fulham 3 - WBA 1

If you changed all of Blackburns results where they’ve dropped points they’d be top also. I don’t care how many shots we’ve had, we’ve been poor in far too many games. We’ve picked up wins where we haven’t deserved them also, so I think we are where we deserve to be. Hopefully a decent no9 will solve all of the issues but personally I have my doubts. Hopefully I’m wrong and you’re right. He deserves to be judged after we back him with a striker, but if we don’t see a big improvement, I’d be very worried about giving him the 3 windows he says he needs.

That’s not what I’m saying though is it?

In football results don’t always reflect the game, and when it comes to objectively assessing performances, the best way currently is to look at how many goals a team should have scored and how many they should have conceded… and there has been a very consistent theme this season in that we have created far more chances than we’ve taken and subsequently dropped for more points than we ought have. I think only Boro (who likewise lack a striker have dropped more points).


Val’s job is to put out a team which wins more games than it loses, and the side he has fashioned is creating as many chances as most teams in this division whilst limiting the opposition to little or no chances.

Goals we have conceded have generally been from terrible mistakes, and chances have been spurned due to poor finishing. Neither of these things are Val’s fault, he has crafted a system which is seeing us be the better side in pretty much every game we play.

I’m as frustrated as anyone with some of his recent selections, and I do think had we been a little more flexible we would have taken a few more points in recent weeks, however the squad we have have failed several managers under several systems consistently, so expecting him to work miracles with this group is one step too far. 

He deserves this season regardless, we need to get through January and hopefully with a striker on board we will get over the line come May. If January’s recruitment is as disappointing as Hugill and Reach, then there will be more questions to be asked of Val, but at the moment I’m happy to accept he’s doing as well as can be expected and being let down by a squad with physical and mental weaknesses.

how do you actually gauge how many a team *should* have scored though? it completely negates a great save, a stunning block or tackle... Or in our case, are we saying we should have scored from a lot of the barely half chances we've had?

I didn't see the first half against Derby, but second half I would have said at absolute most we *could* not should, have scored maybe 1. What was this mystical xG in the second half vs Derby? it all seems a bit like saying *if* Linford Christie ran a bit faster then he'd be the fastest man ever...

Thing is, were we doing the job then not one person would even mention xG, it's all very straw clutchy.


RE: Val assessed - Hopalong - 12-29-2021

(12-29-2021, 02:07 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-29-2021, 02:02 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-29-2021, 01:58 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-29-2021, 12:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Yeah, think I'll start getting more concerned if changes aren't made next game.

I think this needs the caveat of if un-forced changes aren't made... After all it seems when we're forced to change due to COV or whatever the players who come in seem to have much more about them... It's when we stick with the players that haven't really worked that well all season that things go crap.

e.g. if Livermore gets Cov this week and misses the game, you can't really credit Six with making that change by choice.

We've not agreed on much when it comes to Val but this is pretty much where I'm at now. 

He will never change the system, I don't expect him to, it's creating enough to win games. But he's had more than long enough now to see that the players he thought were first choice are not very good at executing his plan. If doesn't make changes, he won't last the season.

Conversely, if he brings in some of his own targets and there is no improvement, he's toast. Which ever striker he brings in best be able to find the back of the net.

Have to go back to disagreeing as I still don't think the chances we are creating have been clear cut enough to win us the games that some have said they are.

Against Derby I'd say Hugill could have done better, but even that wasn't a clear cut chance. Bartley's header, why are our defenders getting our best chances?!

Also I disagree, I think his job's safe. Which is another reason I think he's a bit complacent about making changes. Cannot see us sacking him in say Feb/Mar when / if we're out of the play offs. I just don't think Lai will back down on this one, as he appears to be very much Lai's man.

You're right,  not too many clear cut chances but Robinson had a good one, that's all it would have needed (assuming Kipre/Johnstone didn't then screw up).   Teams are playing very deep against us so it's very difficult to create clear cut chances due to the lack of space and you could argue creativity.  Tom Fellows really opened them up though in the last 5 minutes with two great runs.  TF reminds me of Mike Summerbee very direct and no nonsense, could be a great find and could even play on the right of the four with TGH central in time.  

Hugill's was a very difficult chance and on his 'wrong' foot. It doesn't really matter who the chances are falling to as long as they go in. 

I doubt Val is feeling safe/complacent with the pressure he's under, quite the contrary.  I can't recall a more passionate or driven manager ever at WBA except maybe Megson.   I do think however that given his discussions with Lai and the apparent transfer plan we have he place I would imagine he'll be given this as a transition season but clearly with the objective of getting back first time.  

He's giving the senior players every chance to redeem themselves but it's clear even his patience has now expired. I don't know why fans and the media are getting so worked up about it though in terms of what he said, as he explained that he had said exactly the same thing to the players after the game.  If you listen to what he said - he said when we have the 'feeling' and you don't get the result there's not much you can do it's what it is, but he was clearly unhappy with the players preparation - too much turkey and booze? - desire - lack of from the first minute - given what was at stake.  I thought his comment about he is here to be top was very telling and woe betide anyone who tries to derail things.  

His comments after the match that TGH and Tom did exactly what they asked means to me that they should start against Cardiff with Grant and Mowatt back too and maybe Phillips up top - that's half a new team.  Even if we sign someone saturday there's no way they'll be prepared to play on Sunday - be QPR way on 15th for any early window signings. 

Keep the faith MD!


RE: Val assessed - SW4Baggie - 12-29-2021

(12-29-2021, 03:28 PM)MassDebater Wrote: how do you actually gauge how many a team *should* have scored though? it completely negates a great save, a stunning block or tackle... Or in our case, are we saying we should have scored from a lot of the barely half chances we've had?

I didn't see the first half against Derby, but second half I would have said at absolute most we *could* not should, have scored maybe 1. What was this mystical xG in the second half vs Derby? it all seems a bit like saying *if* Linford Christie ran a bit faster then he'd be the fastest man ever...

Thing is, were we doing the job then not one person would even mention xG, it's all very straw clutchy.

I take on board what you're saying here MD and maybe I am putting too much emphasis on xG as an instrument to determine how well we have played... 

One thing I will concede is that our xG per game is low considering how many chances we create, meaning we are creating a LOT of very poor chances... so maybe investigating individual chances in games is a better method of reviewing. 

Looking at the Derby and Barnsley games, whilst we "should" have scored in both of them, our best chance in terms of probability of scoring was Clark's attempt against Derby (38%) and against Barnsley it was Hugill at 42%.  Pretty much all the other chances we created were less than 10% hence why it seems we need to create 20 odd chances to win a game. 

Looking at a few other games - against Reading, Robinson's goal was 57%, but he missed 2 at 33% and 42%, and Hugill again missed a chance at 40%, against Coventry we missed our best chance through Robinson, and against Forest, Hugill again missed a chance at 35% with the remaining chances being around 10%.

Overall, we are creating enough chances to win games, but they' require a better finisher than what we have available. Strikers should be converting chances around the 30-50% mark roughly between 1 in 2 and 1 in 3 times... whereas our strikers just arent. In the last 5 games Hugill hasn't scored any, and Robinson has scored once, but the ease of those opportunities suggest Hugill should have buried at least 1 and Robinson ought to have had a couple more too. 

Signing a natural goal scorer wont fix all of our problems, we still need to create a better standard of chance, but if we can just convert another 1 in every 2-3 of the big chances we're creating, we will get better results, and allowing Robinson to play in his natural position and not playing Hugill will help this. 

Looking at a few Fulham and Bournemouth games for a comparison, whilst they have players like Solanke and Mitrovic greatly exceding their xG numbers they are creating better chances. Fulham in particular are missing 2-3 chances of >50% likelihood of scoring almost every week, and Bournemouth too are guilty of this to a lesser degree however they are also converting very low likelihood chances - which we just aren't doing.

There are 3 things we need to do as a team; firstly, sign a striker who can convert more marginal chances, as this will really help given how resolute we are defensively. Secondly, we need to create fewer, but better quality chances, and thirdly we need traditional non-scorers to chip in with a few goals to relieve the pressure on our forwards. Molumby, Reach, Townsend, Furlong and Livermore have all failed to score this season and at the half way point, that's just not acceptable.


RE: Val assessed - MassDebater - 12-29-2021

(12-29-2021, 04:04 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-29-2021, 03:28 PM)MassDebater Wrote: how do you actually gauge how many a team *should* have scored though? it completely negates a great save, a stunning block or tackle... Or in our case, are we saying we should have scored from a lot of the barely half chances we've had?

I didn't see the first half against Derby, but second half I would have said at absolute most we *could* not should, have scored maybe 1. What was this mystical xG in the second half vs Derby? it all seems a bit like saying *if* Linford Christie ran a bit faster then he'd be the fastest man ever...

Thing is, were we doing the job then not one person would even mention xG, it's all very straw clutchy.

I take on board what you're saying here MD and maybe I am putting too much emphasis on xG as an instrument to determine how well we have played... 

One thing I will concede is that our xG per game is low considering how many chances we create, meaning we are creating a LOT of very poor chances... so maybe investigating individual chances in games is a better method of reviewing. 

Looking at the Derby and Barnsley games, whilst we "should" have scored in both of them, our best chance in terms of probability of scoring was Clark's attempt against Derby (38%) and against Barnsley it was Hugill at 42%.  Pretty much all the other chances we created were less than 10% hence why it seems we need to create 20 odd chances to win a game. 

Looking at a few other games - against Reading, Robinson's goal was 57%, but he missed 2 at 33% and 42%, and Hugill again missed a chance at 40%, against Coventry we missed our best chance through Robinson, and against Forest, Hugill again missed a chance at 35% with the remaining chances being around 10%.

Overall, we are creating enough chances to win games, but they' require a better finisher than what we have available. Strikers should be converting chances around the 30-50% mark roughly between 1 in 2 and 1 in 3 times... whereas our strikers just arent. In the last 5 games Hugill hasn't scored any, and Robinson has scored once, but the ease of those opportunities suggest Hugill should have buried at least 1 and Robinson ought to have had a couple more too. 

Signing a natural goal scorer wont fix all of our problems, we still need to create a better standard of chance, but if we can just convert another 1 in every 2-3 of the big chances we're creating, we will get better results, and allowing Robinson to play in his natural position and not playing Hugill will help this. 

Looking at a few Fulham and Bournemouth games for a comparison, whilst they have players like Solanke and Mitrovic greatly exceding their xG numbers they are creating better chances. Fulham in particular are missing 2-3 chances of >50% likelihood of scoring almost every week, and Bournemouth too are guilty of this to a lesser degree however they are also converting very low likelihood chances - which we just aren't doing.

There are 3 things we need to do as a team; firstly, sign a striker who can convert more marginal chances, as this will really help given how resolute we are defensively. Secondly, we need to create fewer, but better quality chances, and thirdly we need traditional non-scorers to chip in with a few goals to relieve the pressure on our forwards. Molumby, Reach, Townsend, Furlong and Livermore have all failed to score this season and at the half way point, that's just not acceptable.

Must admit I've not seen any percentage chance of a player scoring stats, but that and xG combined does give the same picture that loads are saying, we simply do not look dangerous. For me, how dangerous a side looks usually is backed up by how well they are playing.

Good statting there though lad.

Your last paragraph I am in total agreement with. Just wish the club had done point one before the season started...


RE: Val assessed - Tom Joad - 12-29-2021

I would add, a better striker has better positioning and makes better chances.