RE: 3 transfer windows required. - SW4Baggie - 12-08-2021
(12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Yes, but that was exceptional circumstances... we simply had to let Periera go for a knockdown price because we needed money to bring in quality early in the window and not be left faffing about relying on frees and loans.
(12-08-2021, 12:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: (12-08-2021, 11:02 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Huggy Bear has been a complete disaster, but wages wise was a straight swap for Hal who was obs ready to focus on Tumeric sales. Didn't expect goals but thought he would bring something to the team, as I imagine did our recruitment dept.
Clarke IMO has been a very good loan signing calm and assured. Molomby a punt who could still come good and Reach was undoubtedly from the existing west brom list of potential squad fillers offered to Val to cover LWB and ARM vs Cov. Add Mowatt and it wasn't a terrible window, just yet again lacking in addressing the two positions that need more quality in CF and CM.
We can't be sure if Hugil was identified by Val or was just one of a number of strikers that had been lined up for him at the time. We DO know that any future acquisitions will have been heavily influenced by Val. This is where it gets interesting. I'd certainly be happy to have a few more additions in the mould of Mowatt but it's the striker that is most anticipated and should give us an idea of where those next three windows could take us.
I admire your optimism. Maybe I'm focusing on the negatives and the fact that we seem reluctant to spend anything and sell our best players for peanuts rather than the fact that Clarke and Mowatt have been successful signings so far.
I'm also being a bit harsh on Reach. He's actually been pretty good, he's just not an improvement on our first 11.
Our incoming window wasn't as bad as is being made out really... Mowatt has proven an excellent bosman, but we would expect him to be given his wages.
Reach has been adequate, but I maintain for the wages he's commanding, we could have used the money better, and Molumby and Clarke have both been very good additions. I do hope we are able to find a way to make the latter permanent regardless of division next season (lol).
Hugill has been a complete disaster, but to give him his dues, I doubt Val wanted him as his only striker. We all know Dike was the prime target but we couldn't do a deal and were left with a shit recruitment department and very little time. Hugill would have been fine playing the role he played for Norwich last year, but to be relying on him as regularly as we are is damning. He's already played almost twice the minutes for us he did for Norwich last season and we're not even half way through the year.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Lillwall's left foot - 12-08-2021
(12-08-2021, 02:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Yes, but that was exceptional circumstances... we simply had to let Periera go for a knockdown price because we needed money to bring in quality early in the window and not be left faffing about relying on frees and loans.
(12-08-2021, 12:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: (12-08-2021, 11:02 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Huggy Bear has been a complete disaster, but wages wise was a straight swap for Hal who was obs ready to focus on Tumeric sales. Didn't expect goals but thought he would bring something to the team, as I imagine did our recruitment dept.
Clarke IMO has been a very good loan signing calm and assured. Molomby a punt who could still come good and Reach was undoubtedly from the existing west brom list of potential squad fillers offered to Val to cover LWB and ARM vs Cov. Add Mowatt and it wasn't a terrible window, just yet again lacking in addressing the two positions that need more quality in CF and CM.
We can't be sure if Hugil was identified by Val or was just one of a number of strikers that had been lined up for him at the time. We DO know that any future acquisitions will have been heavily influenced by Val. This is where it gets interesting. I'd certainly be happy to have a few more additions in the mould of Mowatt but it's the striker that is most anticipated and should give us an idea of where those next three windows could take us.
I admire your optimism. Maybe I'm focusing on the negatives and the fact that we seem reluctant to spend anything and sell our best players for peanuts rather than the fact that Clarke and Mowatt have been successful signings so far.
I'm also being a bit harsh on Reach. He's actually been pretty good, he's just not an improvement on our first 11.
Our incoming window wasn't as bad as is being made out really... Mowatt has proven an excellent bosman, but we would expect him to be given his wages.
Reach has been adequate, but I maintain for the wages he's commanding, we could have used the money better, and Molumby and Clarke have both been very good additions. I do hope we are able to find a way to make the latter permanent regardless of division next season (lol).
Hugill has been a complete disaster, but to give him his dues, I doubt Val wanted him as his only striker. We all know Dike was the prime target but we couldn't do a deal and were left with a shit recruitment department and very little time. Hugill would have been fine playing the role he played for Norwich last year, but to be relying on him as regularly as we are is damning. He's already played almost twice the minutes for us he did for Norwich last season and we're not even half way through the year.
Yep, I agree. An option to help see a game out, as he did against Cov but nothing more, and we need so much more. I was trying to be objective about who instigated the signing, but it does scream WBA recruitment dept.....
30 something forward required, PL experience an essential (regardless of how successful that experience was) and at least one season ( in your whole career) where you scored more than 10 goals. Ideally you will have had a serious injury that has now robbed you of any pace/sharpness you used to have. We may not match your PL salary but will certainly look to pay you well over the odds for what you can offer. Please send a CV and 30 second video clip of your best bits which we will apparently use as our only method of scouting/due diligence.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Birdman1811 - 12-08-2021
In defence of Reach, he is very versatile, and will do a decent, if not spectacular job almost anywhere, in this league that's worth a lot. Great attitude and still keen to develop as a player. No harm in his signing at all imo.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - MassDebater - 12-08-2021
Imagine the fun of his third window *if* we do not get promoted this season... Just imagine the amazing 'quality' of players we'll be getting then... <Shudder>
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Brandywell - 12-08-2021
He didn't need any transfer windows at Barnsley to massively transform them.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Lillwall's left foot - 12-08-2021
(12-08-2021, 05:19 PM)Brandywell Wrote: He didn't need any transfer windows at Barnsley to massively transform them. 
Struber, his predecessor at Barnsley, is also know for a counterpressing syle so Val was a continuity choice.
Interestingly the man who replaced Val tried to change to a more possesion based style and lasted 16 games.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Pragmatist - 12-08-2021
(12-08-2021, 10:54 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: We must get rid of the likes of Bartley, Phillips, Livermore, Hugill, Zohore etc. Then replace them with mobile players, that fit Val's philosophy, who actually want to fight and be here, and have at least some quality, ASAP. It must not take place over three windows.
Bartley? Agree with getting rid of the others but not Bartley. Very useful defender in this division.
(12-08-2021, 02:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Yes, but that was exceptional circumstances... we simply had to let Periera go for a knockdown price because we needed money to bring in quality early in the window and not be left faffing about relying on frees and loans.
(12-08-2021, 12:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: (12-08-2021, 11:02 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Huggy Bear has been a complete disaster, but wages wise was a straight swap for Hal who was obs ready to focus on Tumeric sales. Didn't expect goals but thought he would bring something to the team, as I imagine did our recruitment dept.
Clarke IMO has been a very good loan signing calm and assured. Molomby a punt who could still come good and Reach was undoubtedly from the existing west brom list of potential squad fillers offered to Val to cover LWB and ARM vs Cov. Add Mowatt and it wasn't a terrible window, just yet again lacking in addressing the two positions that need more quality in CF and CM.
We can't be sure if Hugil was identified by Val or was just one of a number of strikers that had been lined up for him at the time. We DO know that any future acquisitions will have been heavily influenced by Val. This is where it gets interesting. I'd certainly be happy to have a few more additions in the mould of Mowatt but it's the striker that is most anticipated and should give us an idea of where those next three windows could take us.
I admire your optimism. Maybe I'm focusing on the negatives and the fact that we seem reluctant to spend anything and sell our best players for peanuts rather than the fact that Clarke and Mowatt have been successful signings so far.
I'm also being a bit harsh on Reach. He's actually been pretty good, he's just not an improvement on our first 11.
Our incoming window wasn't as bad as is being made out really... Mowatt has proven an excellent bosman, but we would expect him to be given his wages.
Reach has been adequate, but I maintain for the wages he's commanding, we could have used the money better, and Molumby and Clarke have both been very good additions. I do hope we are able to find a way to make the latter permanent regardless of division next season (lol).
Hugill has been a complete disaster, but to give him his dues, I doubt Val wanted him as his only striker. We all know Dike was the prime target but we couldn't do a deal and were left with a shit recruitment department and very little time. Hugill would have been fine playing the role he played for Norwich last year, but to be relying on him as regularly as we are is damning. He's already played almost twice the minutes for us he did for Norwich last season and we're not even half way through the year.
How much is Reach earning?
(12-08-2021, 10:54 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: We must get rid of the likes of Bartley, Phillips, Livermore, Hugill, Zohore etc. Then replace them with mobile players, that fit Val's philosophy, who actually want to fight and be here, and have at least some quality, ASAP. It must not take place over three windows.
Bartley? Agree with getting rid of the others but not Bartley. Very useful defender in this division.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Remi_Moses - 12-08-2021
(12-08-2021, 11:37 AM)wba13 Wrote: From day one of the Ismael era we new he needed time to get the players he wanted to play the system he plays. I for one and a lot of us have jumped on his back because of the way he plays, but he has shown at times this system can be excellent and we have won and drew matches with good displays without having some of the correct players to play the Val way. Kipre is a prime example of this he’s a decent defender and a very good distributor of the ball and has played well in the last few games as his confidence rises. If we do go up this season Val will have done it without having some of the correct players which he knows he needs. Here’s hoping for a decent January window.
We have reached to the critical point, are we going to build confidence and go on a run? Fulham are nailed on for a return to the PL. Bournemouth however are catchable.
The January window must be used to bring in players to push the old school out. We don't need to chuck money at it. More solid hungry players would be best suited to fight for 2nd place. Our youngsters have not put a foot wrong and with Cleary, O'Brien and Palmer waiting we are not in a bad place.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - SW4Baggie - 12-08-2021
(12-08-2021, 07:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: How much is Reach earning?
By all accounts he was on £30k a week at Wednesday… whilst I doubt he’s at that level with us, I imagine we are paying him the kind of dough very few other clubs in this league would touch.
RE: 3 transfer windows required. - KRO - 12-08-2021
(12-08-2021, 02:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Yes, but that was exceptional circumstances... we simply had to let Periera go for a knockdown price because we needed money to bring in quality early in the window and not be left faffing about relying on frees and loans.
(12-08-2021, 12:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: (12-08-2021, 11:02 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.
Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows
Huggy Bear has been a complete disaster, but wages wise was a straight swap for Hal who was obs ready to focus on Tumeric sales. Didn't expect goals but thought he would bring something to the team, as I imagine did our recruitment dept.
Clarke IMO has been a very good loan signing calm and assured. Molomby a punt who could still come good and Reach was undoubtedly from the existing west brom list of potential squad fillers offered to Val to cover LWB and ARM vs Cov. Add Mowatt and it wasn't a terrible window, just yet again lacking in addressing the two positions that need more quality in CF and CM.
We can't be sure if Hugil was identified by Val or was just one of a number of strikers that had been lined up for him at the time. We DO know that any future acquisitions will have been heavily influenced by Val. This is where it gets interesting. I'd certainly be happy to have a few more additions in the mould of Mowatt but it's the striker that is most anticipated and should give us an idea of where those next three windows could take us.
I admire your optimism. Maybe I'm focusing on the negatives and the fact that we seem reluctant to spend anything and sell our best players for peanuts rather than the fact that Clarke and Mowatt have been successful signings so far.
I'm also being a bit harsh on Reach. He's actually been pretty good, he's just not an improvement on our first 11.
Our incoming window wasn't as bad as is being made out really... Mowatt has proven an excellent bosman, but we would expect him to be given his wages.
Reach has been adequate, but I maintain for the wages he's commanding, we could have used the money better, and Molumby and Clarke have both been very good additions. I do hope we are able to find a way to make the latter permanent regardless of division next season (lol).
Hugill has been a complete disaster, but to give him his dues, I doubt Val wanted him as his only striker. We all know Dike was the prime target but we couldn't do a deal and were left with a shit recruitment department and very little time. Hugill would have been fine playing the role he played for Norwich last year, but to be relying on him as regularly as we are is damning. He's already played almost twice the minutes for us he did for Norwich last season and we're not even half way through the year.
What is Mowatt rumoured to be earning a week?
|