WBAUnofficial
Our recruitment - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our recruitment (/showthread.php?tid=22975)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Our recruitment - Squid - 12-02-2021

(12-02-2021, 09:59 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(12-02-2021, 09:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-02-2021, 08:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-02-2021, 08:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Identifying players through stats is a very blunt tool. All seems rather one dimensional, players aren’t statistical data. I know it’s trendy, as is the pressing style of play but it seems like recruitment by numbers.

It was a big part of what we did under Ashworth. Of course the stats are very detailed and you also get full personality reports on players too.

Out of interest, how do you suggest doing it?

Do you really need a dossier full of analysis to work out if x, y, z player fits into the way you want to play? I don’t need to count how many passes Sawyers made to tell me he is good at passing, I don’t need to realise he was also a bit lightweight and wouldn’t fit into my plans if I wanted to play an aggressive, pressing style of play. I don’t need stats to tell me Gallagher would be a better fit for example. If I was looking for a natural goalscorer i would look for ahem a player that has scored lots of goals first and foremost. I doubt Lineker would have been signed by many clubs now because his stats would show a player with unbalanced stats. 

I would also trust myself and those I surround myself with opinion over any numbers presented to me via a trendy database. I would also want to talk to the player in person not rely on others to judge their characters and motivation. 

We signed plenty of poor players when Ashworth was at the club, his hit rate was no better than GM’s in fact probably worse and one relies on a laptop if what you say is true the other relied on the opinion of his Dad driving a Cortina Wink 

Stats should not be the driving force behind identifying players. I know it’s old fashioned but ultimately creating a team is an art form not a science. Otherwise the sport would become a glorified Championship Manager algorithm.

Surely you'd do a combination?.  Use the stats to identify a pool of players, then scout them, then meet them, then find out you can't afford them.

I'd just suggest that whoever/whatever formula was used to bring Harvey Barnes to the club they try that again.

That was Darren Moore's charm and persuasion. Brought in Johnstone, Barnes, Gayle, Townsend and yes, even the much-derided Tyrone Mears who actually did a decent job for us. Coupled with persuading JRod to stay, probably our best transfer window of recent times.


RE: Our recruitment - Big Daddy Cool - 12-02-2021

If Moore kept Shan as his assistant we'd have been promoted that season. Bringing in Jones to try and turn Bartley and Dawson into ball playing defenders was ridiculous.


RE: Our recruitment - Remi_Moses - 12-02-2021

Last time I checked the recruitment TEAM had 17; people.
Hard to blame any single individual, but far to many of our senior people walk away which tells you everything we need to know. Now Ken appears to have the final decision this indicates ignorance personification.


RE: Our recruitment - Hopalong - 12-02-2021

(12-02-2021, 08:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Identifying players through stats is a very blunt tool. All seems rather one dimensional, players aren’t statistical data. I know it’s trendy, as is the pressing style of play but it seems like recruitment by numbers.

Goals is a good one DH.

(12-02-2021, 09:34 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-02-2021, 08:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-02-2021, 08:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Identifying players through stats is a very blunt tool. All seems rather one dimensional, players aren’t statistical data. I know it’s trendy, as is the pressing style of play but it seems like recruitment by numbers.

It was a big part of what we did under Ashworth. Of course the stats are very detailed and you also get full personality reports on players too.

Out of interest, how do you suggest doing it?

Watching them? Sending out real people to give real views on them? Like we used to? Heck even getting Slav to watch VCRs in India...

Stats wise Hugill is almost a one goal every four game striker... In reality he's gash and scored most of his goals at low levels... The stats seem to ignore the latter part of that puzzle.


In the last 5 seasons he's scored 42 goals for PNE, Boro, QPR and Norwich in the Championship out of a career total of 61.  

16/17  PNE - 12 
17/18  PNE -   8 
18/19  Boro -  6
19/20  QPR  - 13 
20/21  Naagh - 3

So 70% of his career goals have been scored in Chump (including the one he's scored for us!)   Smile

(12-02-2021, 10:45 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: If Moore kept Shan as his assistant we'd have been promoted that season. Bringing in Jones to try and turn Bartley and Dawson into ball playing defenders was ridiculous.

Jones has gone very quiet at Newcastle...

(12-02-2021, 09:31 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-02-2021, 08:01 PM)Sliced Wrote: Do you honestly believe that every player Val wanted coincidentally happened to be on a free or a loanee?

He's talking about January transfer window targets. It doesn't say anything about summer budgets, top targets or anything of the sort.

Also, there's a very big difference between:
"I want Dike and Johansen"
"Sorry, you have to work only with frees and loanees, and we'll be selling your best players"
"...ok....well thats a limited pool but maybe Adam Reach could cover a few positions and Hugill is a target man"

and

"Get me Reach and Hugill. Top targets"

Seems like a desperate attempt to blame everything on Val to be honest. You're wilfully ignoring the very obvious restrictions that were put in place by our board on whoever happened to be our manager.

Hopefully these comments will put a bit of pressure on the board, lord knows they need it.

One could agree with that if Six had not made comments in the past saying we got who he wanted. Then comes out with this, where he is basically saying he tells Reach who (stats wise) to go after.

In pre-season(or early program notes)  Six made many comments about not caring too much about ability as long as the player runs so far during a game and that any player who does not run far enough gets binned (then it was bye bye Sawyers)...

I'm just giving my opinon on what Six is saying, if you choose to see it as a desperate attempt to blame him for everything then that is your prerogative. However, I would counter that you seem more desperate in trying to defend him, when HE is saying this and HE is saying we got his players etc...

(12-02-2021, 09:23 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: "Manager works closely with head of recruitment using statistics to help identify targets".   

Not sure there are any angles you can take on this, surely normal practise in modern football. Its then up to the recruitment team to contact the club's and find out who is fit, available and affordable.   I'm sure it's the affordable bit where it's starts to get sticky!

It's hardly like our extensive scouting network has been unearthing gem after gem over the last few years.

Pereira?

I take this as it being Six saying he tells Pearce who to go after not that he is working with him, sounds more like 'I'm his boss and he does what I say' to me.

I'm sure Pearce will have a view and there are 'old' targets on his list,  but in the absence of a DOF, Val has to call the shots surely, unless you want Ken to tell Pearce who to sign  Dodgy

(12-02-2021, 07:22 PM)MassDebater Wrote: https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/football/west-bromwich-albion/2021/12/01/valerien-ismael-has-his-list-of-west-brom-transfer-targets/

So based on Six's comments, it's down to him and his team and they tell this Ian Pearce fella (who now seems to be in charge or if) the sort of player they want, purely based on the stats.

Well that's worked marvellously with the recruitment we made in Summer... so don't worry people, more Hugills incoming?

For those who don't want to visit:

"It’s important to see the situation – we have identified the targets we want with Ian Pearce," Ismael said when asked about his plans for January window.
"We work behind the scenes and we know exactly what we need. We have prepared everything to be ready for the January window.
"It was important at the beginning that Ian understood the way to profile, that he understood the player we wanted and to give him some information to work on the transfer market.
“We have to find the right player with the numbers and we gave him that on all positions so that it’s easy to identify the right player through the numbers.
“He goes straight to the point."

I read that as they're working jointly on it together - with Ian having identified targets from the criteria Val and his team/analysts have given him to work to.  

At least it sounds like there's method in Val's madness as some might say,  rather than it being 'scatter-gun'.   ('I know let's sign three left wingers/forwards....'  Diang/Grant/Robinson -  (Not forgetting Grosicki and Pereira!!)


RE: Our recruitment - Bob Fossil - 12-03-2021

Sounds like a collaboration to me, which is exactly what we should expect. That's why this "xxx wasn't his player" is nonsense to me. Whilst Val may not get his first choice, he will have sanctioned every signing as did managers before him.

With our budget, every signing is a risk, however. I can think of many signings that were derided by fans who went on to be club legends (even the likes of Regis, Cunningham and Taylor had many, many doubters). There are also many that have been lauded as a coup, that went on to be complete dogs. Add in that it's January and it's all a bit of a lottery, I've just got everything crossed that we find a couple of gems, don't care if they cost £20m or are free as long as they are better than what we have and get us winning again.


RE: Our recruitment - ferencpuskas - 12-03-2021

(12-02-2021, 07:22 PM)MassDebater Wrote: https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/football/west-bromwich-albion/2021/12/01/valerien-ismael-has-his-list-of-west-brom-transfer-targets/

So based on Six's comments, it's down to him and his team and they tell this Ian Pearce fella (who now seems to be in charge or if) the sort of player they want, purely based on the stats.

Well that's worked marvellously with the recruitment we made in Summer... so don't worry people, more Hugills incoming?

For those who don't want to visit:

"It’s important to see the situation – we have identified the targets we want with Ian Pearce," Ismael said when asked about his plans for January window.
"We work behind the scenes and we know exactly what we need. We have prepared everything to be ready for the January window.
"It was important at the beginning that Ian understood the way to profile, that he understood the player we wanted and to give him some information to work on the transfer market.
“We have to find the right player with the numbers and we gave him that on all positions so that it’s easy to identify the right player through the numbers.
“He goes straight to the point."

               What a load of bollox ! I bet Pearce ay even got a dog and a flat cap !


RE: Our recruitment - Sliced - 12-03-2021

(12-03-2021, 09:40 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Sounds like a collaboration to me, which is exactly what we should expect. That's why this "xxx wasn't his player" is nonsense to me. Whilst Val may not get his first choice, he will have sanctioned every signing as did managers before him.

With our budget, every signing is a risk, however. I can think of many signings that were derided by fans who went on to be club legends (even the likes of Regis, Cunningham and Taylor had many, many doubters). There are also many that have been lauded as a coup, that went on to be complete dogs. Add in that it's January and it's all a bit of a lottery, I've just got everything crossed that we find a couple of gems, don't care if they cost £20m or are free as long as they are better than what we have and get us winning again.

I would argue that in recent years the "coups" turned out to be worse than the derided ones.

Burke, Kryckowiac, Sturridge.

Diangana was literally brilliant until we signed him


RE: Our recruitment - Gzbaggy - 12-03-2021

(12-03-2021, 09:40 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Sounds like a collaboration to me, which is exactly what we should expect. That's why this "xxx wasn't his player" is nonsense to me. Whilst Val may not get his first choice, he will have sanctioned every signing as did managers before him.

With our budget, every signing is a risk, however. I can think of many signings that were derided by fans who went on to be club legends (even the likes of Regis, Cunningham and Taylor had many, many doubters). There are also many that have been lauded as a coup, that went on to be complete dogs. Add in that it's January and it's all a bit of a lottery, I've just got everything crossed that we find a couple of gems, don't care if they cost £20m or are free as long as they are better than what we have and get us winning again.

many or most signings?

we have signed far too many players who have come for "one last payday" and whose career is in decline (these are usually labelled experienced) this is not difficult to predict in advance of signing them!

the better older players are those with something to prove and who we represent a step up (GMac) and those who are "very good pros"(Phillips and Taylor) Note that all of those started their professional career late and would have had a job outside football


RE: Our recruitment - Remi_Moses - 12-03-2021

(12-03-2021, 10:25 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(12-03-2021, 09:40 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Sounds like a collaboration to me, which is exactly what we should expect. That's why this "xxx wasn't his player" is nonsense to me. Whilst Val may not get his first choice, he will have sanctioned every signing as did managers before him.

With our budget, every signing is a risk, however. I can think of many signings that were derided by fans who went on to be club legends (even the likes of Regis, Cunningham and Taylor had many, many doubters). There are also many that have been lauded as a coup, that went on to be complete dogs. Add in that it's January and it's all a bit of a lottery, I've just got everything crossed that we find a couple of gems, don't care if they cost £20m or are free as long as they are better than what we have and get us winning again.

many or most signings?

we have signed far too many players who have come for "one last payday" and whose career is in decline (these are usually labelled experienced) this is not difficult to predict in advance of signing them!

the better older players are those with something to prove and who we represent a step up (GMac) and those who are "very good pros"(Phillips and Taylor) Note that all of those started their professional career late and would have had a job outside football

A very good point.
They appreciate the money and understand what's waiting for them if they don't bust a gut every time they pull the shirt on.


RE: Our recruitment - HLS - 12-03-2021

(12-02-2021, 08:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-02-2021, 08:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Identifying players through stats is a very blunt tool. All seems rather one dimensional, players aren’t statistical data. I know it’s trendy, as is the pressing style of play but it seems like recruitment by numbers.

It was a big part of what we did under Ashworth. Of course the stats are very detailed and you also get full personality reports on players too.

Out of interest, how do you suggest doing it?

By seeing if they come from a nice family and if they will play for England one day.