RE: How not to VAR... - cornishbaggie - 02-22-2019
(02-22-2019, 09:53 AM)steviedm Wrote: (02-22-2019, 09:23 AM)The Real PK Wrote: (02-20-2019, 09:13 PM)steviedm Wrote: I always find it hilarious when anyone in favour of it relentlessly trots out the line: "But it was the right decision in the end." That utterly misses the point
This truly baffles me. How can ensuring the correct decision is made be a fucking bad thing?!
Quite simply because it reduces the game to a technical absurdity. Where do we stop? If a player is 1mm offside then he is offside. This is "the correct decision". But it's "a fucking bad thing" when that decision comes in the last minute of a promotion or relegation battle when a team finally makes the breakthrough and the fans celebrate wildly and loudly only for "the correct decision" to be made eventually after an interminable wait. FOR THE SAKE OF ONE FUCKING MILLIMETRE. Offside was initially invented to stop people goal hanging. Simple as that. But now the game will eat itself and the whole sense of what it once was will be lost. It's blatantly obvious that ten years down the line, the refrain "is there any reason I can't award the goal?" will be heard from the referee after every single goal and the art of celebration will be lost.
So, yes, trotting out the line "VAR gets the right decision in the end" entirely misses the point. Danny Baker's Twitter feed is a good reflection of how I feel - here are his tweets from Wednesday night:
Fucking dreadful, cumbersome, interfering, boring VAR again. Football's own speed camera manages to drag another match to its knees. And they got it was WRONG too. Brilliant. Fuck VAR.
VAR is bureaucratic bullshit. Football with all its spontaneity, errors, chaos and controversy being tamed, airbrushed, burdened and bullied. Doubtless the legions of suits absolutely love it. People now talk about "getting the correct decision" like it's a fucking holy mission.
The spectre of VAR is now hanging over this game like a parent at a party. You sense the crowd feel the match is actually being controlled remotely, which it is. Football needs a punk rock revolution. Smash all the cameras.
All pro VAR people keep telling us it's the officials fault for not making VAR work efficiently. No. It's your fault for thinking it’s necessary. Don't try & lay it off on the ref. It's all down to you. It won't get better. You wanted it. You got it. It's your fault.
Why don't EUFA just play all their games behind closed doors and let us all know what they agreed the correct scores were the following morning.
Agree with every word.
RE: How not to VAR... - Dreamkiller - 02-22-2019
When Atkinson reffed our games I knew within 5 seconds or so whether he'd managed to find some reason to cancel out one of them goal things we used to score, and I could then celebrate to my hearts content. With him on the VAR screen, I wouldn't really feel safe to celebrate til I got home.
RE: How not to VAR... - Malcolm Tucker - 02-22-2019
(02-22-2019, 02:23 PM)The Real PK Wrote:
That's not VAR
|