WBAUnofficial
Player marks - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Player marks (/showthread.php?tid=22513)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Player marks - ericlegrisly - 11-04-2021

Different game indeed.

All about opinions but Grant being DOUBLE the performance of Robinson is breathtaking.

Fair dues, no axe to grind, I just disagree with that 'rating' quite a lot.


RE: Player marks - Lurker#3 - 11-04-2021

(11-04-2021, 08:55 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Different game indeed.

All about opinions but Grant being DOUBLE the performance of Robinson is breathtaking.

Fair dues, no axe to grind, I just disagree with that 'rating' quite a lot.

Thats what its all about, polite disagreement! 

For me, Robbo offered nothing. No movement in behind. Didn't take anybody on. Didn't create. Didn't really put that much of a shift in. 

Where Grant is unassumingly efficient. He doesn't waste the ball very often, he never fails to graft and his off the ball movement causes trouble. 

I call it the "Jimmy Morrison effect", its easier to criticise somebody who's on the ball and involved in the game alot. Robbo hasn't been involved in our play at all recently.


RE: Player marks - ericlegrisly - 11-04-2021

(11-04-2021, 08:59 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-04-2021, 08:55 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Different game indeed.

All about opinions but Grant being DOUBLE the performance of Robinson is breathtaking.

Fair dues, no axe to grind, I just disagree with that 'rating' quite a lot.

Thats what its all about, polite disagreement! 

For me, Robbo offered nothing. No movement in behind. Didn't take anybody on. Didn't create. Didn't really put that much of a shift in. 

Where Grant is unassumingly efficient. He doesn't waste the ball very often, he never fails to graft and his off the ball movement causes trouble. 

I call it the "Jimmy Morrison effect", its easier to criticise somebody who's on the ball and involved in the game alot. Robbo hasn't been involved in our play at all recently.
Absolutely.

Understand the Mozza reference (though I loved the player).

I thought both were pretty bad last night and Grant wastes the ball an awful lot. 

Cest la vie. 

x


RE: Player marks - TartanRug - 11-04-2021

(11-03-2021, 11:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 6 Little to do,again could have commanded box better in last 5 when needed to take sting out of game

TGH 7 What a promising debut, full of confidence, despite obvious nerves, played like he does in the 23’s which is the biggest compliment Incan give him

Townsend 7 Started well and created plenty of attacks when switched to LCH

Bryan 6 Thought he started quite tidily before injury

Clarke 7 Solid and comfortable on the ball, one mistake late on when out of position v Eaves and his flick on gave Hull their only chance

Kipre 7 Presume Val brought him in as better on the ball than Semi and expected us to have all the ball, 69% possession in fact tonight, good passing, solid defensively and should start v Boro

Snodgrass 6 Tidy with the ball and drove us forward 2nd half and certainly played his part

Livermore 7* Clearly the new scrapgoat/scapegoat/crapgoat. Won the ball for the goal, worked tirelessly all night, took, the ball in tight areas and tried to play through the lines. Some of the stick he’s getting is absolutely disgusting

Phillips 5 Another poor one from  Matty, nothing happening for him currently

Robbo 5 Seems low on confidence currently and touch was off tonight, still a managed to set up goal though and should be in the team every week for me

Grant 6 Extra point for the goal but all round game was poor

Subs

Reach 7 Lively and always looking to get forward and played some excellent balls into midfield tonight to get attacks going

Hugill 6 As expected plenty of endeavor and much better coming off the bench to make an impact

Grady 6 Not on long enough but hope he starts Saturday, offers us something so different to what we have against these defensive sides

Struggling to get my head around the criticism tonight in all honesty, Hull defended deep and put bodies on the line, given the lack of a creative centre midfielder in our ranks we have to wear teams down

Cuzer

Can't argue with those marks. Hugill for all the criticism he gets did most things right, got into good positions but just can't finish!


RE: Player marks - MrFizz - 11-04-2021

(11-03-2021, 11:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 6 Little to do,again could have commanded box better in last 5 when needed to take sting out of game

TGH 7 What a promising debut, full of confidence, despite obvious nerves, played like he does in the 23’s which is the biggest compliment Incan give him

Townsend 7 Started well and created plenty of attacks when switched to LCH

Bryan 6 Thought he started quite tidily before injury

Clarke 7 Solid and comfortable on the ball, one mistake late on when out of position v Eaves and his flick on gave Hull their only chance

Kipre 7 Presume Val brought him in as better on the ball than Semi and expected us to have all the ball, 69% possession in fact tonight, good passing, solid defensively and should start v Boro

Snodgrass 6 Tidy with the ball and drove us forward 2nd half and certainly played his part

Livermore 7* Clearly the new scrapgoat/scapegoat/crapgoat. Won the ball for the goal, worked tirelessly all night, took, the ball in tight areas and tried to play through the lines. Some of the stick he’s getting is absolutely disgusting

Phillips 5 Another poor one from  Matty, nothing happening for him currently

Robbo 5 Seems low on confidence currently and touch was off tonight, still a managed to set up goal though and should be in the team every week for me

Grant 6 Extra point for the goal but all round game was poor

Subs

Reach 7 Lively and always looking to get forward and played some excellent balls into midfield tonight to get attacks going

Hugill 6 As expected plenty of endeavor and much better coming off the bench to make an impact

Grady 6 Not on long enough but hope he starts Saturday, offers us something so different to what we have against these defensive sides

Struggling to get my head around the criticism tonight in all honesty, Hull defended deep and put bodies on the line, given the lack of a creative centre midfielder in our ranks we have to wear teams down

Cuzer

Can't argue with that. Snodders needs a breather though i think. Molumby in on Sat for me.


RE: Player marks - Bear Town Baggie - 11-04-2021

(11-03-2021, 11:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 6 Little to do,again could have commanded box better in last 5 when needed to take sting out of game

TGH 7 What a promising debut, full of confidence, despite obvious nerves, played like he does in the 23’s which is the biggest compliment Incan give him

Townsend 7 Started well and created plenty of attacks when switched to LCH

Bryan 6 Thought he started quite tidily before injury

Clarke 7 Solid and comfortable on the ball, one mistake late on when out of position v Eaves and his flick on gave Hull their only chance

Kipre 7 Presume Val brought him in as better on the ball than Semi and expected us to have all the ball, 69% possession in fact tonight, good passing, solid defensively and should start v Boro

Snodgrass 6 Tidy with the ball and drove us forward 2nd half and certainly played his part

Livermore 7* Clearly the new scrapgoat/scapegoat/crapgoat. Won the ball for the goal, worked tirelessly all night, took, the ball in tight areas and tried to play through the lines. Some of the stick he’s getting is absolutely disgusting

Phillips 5 Another poor one from  Matty, nothing happening for him currently

Robbo 5 Seems low on confidence currently and touch was off tonight, still a managed to set up goal though and should be in the team every week for me

Grant 6 Extra point for the goal but all round game was poor

Subs

Reach 7 Lively and always looking to get forward and played some excellent balls into midfield tonight to get attacks going

Hugill 6 As expected plenty of endeavor and much better coming off the bench to make an impact

Grady 6 Not on long enough but hope he starts Saturday, offers us something so different to what we have against these defensive sides

Struggling to get my head around the criticism tonight in all honesty, Hull defended deep and put bodies on the line, given the lack of a creative centre midfielder in our ranks we have to wear teams down

Cuzer
I'd give Robbo a 6, for me he was better than Phillips and as good as Grant, otherwise a very good assessment.


RE: Player marks - Cuzer - 11-04-2021

Im glad a few are in agreement, some of the meltdown I read on here when I got home was off the charts

If we win Saturday, which I'm sure we will, then all is good going into the International break with Mowatt coming back after, keep the faith

Look, start of the season we were a hareem scarem side, in your face, pump it down the channels, launch long throws, now look at last night, 69% possession, all on the deck, is it perfect? No, is our squad as good as others? No, is Val trying to evolve us and approach differently to each game? Yes I'd say so, so keep the faith for now, meltdown not required

Cuzer


RE: Player marks - Bob Fossil - 11-04-2021

TGH, Kipre and Reach the picks for me all around the 7+ mark, none of whom are likely to start on Saturday.
Johnstone did everything he had to. - 7
Townsend was solid as ever. 7
Snodgrass was poor just looks angry and petulant - 5.
Livermore did a lot of stuff well, but him and Snodgrass don't get the ball forward quick enough so the front 3 are swamped. The only space we get is down the wings but when the ball goes into the box there's no-one there - 5.
Robinson was out of sorts but we just don't play to his strengths - 5.

Rest pretty much around the 6 mark

Always difficult against a park the bus team but, as we often saw with Pulis, they normally get breached in the end. Very disappointed with the capitulation at the end though, we have to be stronger than that.

All in all, it was good to see some new faces do well but, tactically, I am still not sure what it is we are trying to do.


RE: Player marks - coxy134 - 11-04-2021

I have to admit I never see it with Livermore, I really cant see what he brings, then he occasionally pops up like last night with a challenge that led to the goal. 

To slow for me and goes back and sidewards rather than going forward perphaps its highlighted more because he has players around him who are as slow.

I would love to be shown where I am wrong.